TJ Reid - The Ronaldo (R7 version) of hurling….?

What do you think yourself ?

Wasnt that DJ?

TJ is a phenomenal hurler with an absolutely rock solid career with great longevity but for me there are many standout hurlers over the years.

You could argue there are a few Messi's ahead of him even in his own county.

No

In my mind anyway TJ Reid is ahead of R7 because his greatness is rooted in collective achievement rather than individualism.

His medal haul, his consistency and leadership across three different eras show a player who adapts to systems instead of demanding them be built around him as Ronaldo has done.

TJ's work rate without the ball, aerial dominance and unselfish distribution really does characterise the holistic skill set demanded by hurling, which we all know, is a sport less forgiving of passengers than elite football.

I think that R7’s legacy is increasingly entangled with personal brand, Reid’s is defined by elevating teammates and sustaining a competitive standard deep beyond himself.

Not sure Tony is in that bracket. He disappeared into Paddy Butler's pocket once too often

A great hurler but honestly wouldn't make top 5 in his own county let alone top 10 all time.

I hate the fact that in 100% of the frees he takes he fouls the ball and is never called out on it

Is that a foul? I just had a quick look online, and I see references to "lifting the ball" and then striking. This is what TJ does. But maybe there is something more specific in the rule book.

And TJ disappeared into Matt O'Hanlon's too often for him to be considered the GOAT