Clarkson's Farm Werewolf - Where everyone does Diddly Squat

When reading your interaction with Frank I was under the impression that you were asking him why he WASNT going to vote for Oisin out of the 3.

I’ll have to read over it again.

OK, I'm finally caught up. Wow, that was a lot. As will this post be, sorry

Initial obvious thoughts, Fiona village, Conor very likely

Admin on me, post #408 was the previous player "Evening all, more reading than expected. Vernon accusing everyone was interesting but distracting I liked Frank's questions better as a way of generating discussion." - just pointing that out as I don't like Frank's game and don't want to look like I'm contradicting myself

I have ignored Fiona, Doris and Mary in my read back, but I'll go over Mary's posts in the morning

I agree with those who said we can't trust the Mary wagon, especially with Holly's vote blocked. But I'd probably trust the first few, Patrick, Frank, Gabriel. I did have a bad lean on Frank and Patrick though, which I'll still include for completeness

Before my word soup, here's my summary

Village

• Fiona
• Conor
• Lucy
• Clodagh

Neutral

• Brendan (yes, I voted here for two early posts but since then he's seemed useful.
• Phil (sub, little to go on)
• Holly (I had very little, felt the FFA may have been copying Fiona a bit, biggest flag is that a roled villager blocked ehr vote, so they obviously suspect her. I don't really see it though, and don't expect them to explain)
• Orla (I think her posts have been very good but the focus on Mary came after several declared votes, so I'm hesitant to have too much faith)
• Oisin (just got nothing)
• Gabriel (few posts I really like, though I hate the "policy lynch" statement for Vernon. Lynch wolf targets)
• Isla (I get what other people are saying about calling out Gerald but it seems to open to be wolfy to me. I don't have much of an opinion here)
• Liam (not got much but post #889 "Unsure about Mary, Oisin, Brendan, Isla, et al" seems odd to me. Why highlight them but omit so many others from an unsure list?)

Wolfy

• Patrick (was lower pre-vote but I'm inclined towards neutral now)
• Frank (was lower pre-vote but I'm inclined towards neutral now)
• Vernon
• Angus
• Katie
• Emily

Reasons for village and wolfy leans

Fiona and Conor from Fiona's claim

Lucy - I disagree with a lot of these posts, but think they're very villagery…

• #415 "Also the wifom of something that is ""always"" wolfing is absurd... To me it's the convoluted first posts that scream ""i have to make sure i don't look wolfie""... Village don't give a fcuk"
  
• #784 "I believe Vernon is Village, Like how could a wolf be that loud and shouty.
  
• #833 I hate but it's not wolfy ""Vernon is a villager but he was mean to Jezzer so we are gonna kill him… Doris had two votes so the village idiot shot her - she was a vanilliger… Fiona is Clarkson… Mary like cock… Oisin is being wagoner… Gabrielle is a wolf"
  
• #871 at Gabriel, I don't think a wolf calls heat like this "I feel left out… Ignore the whole i think you are a wolf and should be lynched thing. Just set that aside for a minute… What's your read on me ?"
  
• #880 I think she's wrong but it's a villagery call "Trying to control the vote ? There is no need to do a poll right now other that to see how many of ye if any have to vote on poor vern to save your fur"
  
• #976 not protecting Mary but not following "I really don't see where people are getting g Mary like they are being cross with Fiona but it's all a bit village on village action... I'd be thinking Clodagh, brendan and orla... AnyAnyways Looks like ye aren't policy lynching Vernon and have moved onto Mary... It's all a bit crazy guys"
  
• #989 "Wonder if conor could be the alpha wolf now."

Clodagh Lots of posts I really liked. I won't quote them, but #395 and #815 for example, well thought out arguments

Patrick I'm backtracking from a bit post vote, but reading through he tried to clear Fiona in #585 after she'd role claimed before, and #586 confirms he'd read that. Indeed in #752 he claims to have got her soft reveal. Feel like pocketing to me

Frank I'm also backtracking from post vote, but I thought the numbers game was a charade and these posts stood out:

• #555 Lean list, but no reasons at all. I'm also always suspicious when someone includes themselves!
• #788 at Mary "If it was a race between Oisin and Isla where would your vote go and why?" for two reasons, she'd mention Gabriel too, plus a soft suggestion of a race feels wolfy to me. If Frank were to flip wolf later I'd look straight at Gabriel in case he was being protected here
• Mary #792 at Frank "I did have you for a lean towards wolf before you mentioned me later in the day so I’d like to ask @Frank WW why are you definitely a villager. The reason I was leaning towards you was the level and type of engagement I think there’s a lot of wolfs and your posts made me think you were fairly confident and it’s hard to go on concrete stuff very early so like you asked me to respond here’s your opportunity albeit a lot later" - this feels fake to me. Wolf saying "I did have a lean, tell me why not to…, I dunno, feels off

Vernon I'd have said noisy village early on but it was always bugging me, is it a play? What swings it bad for me is following Fiona's vote onto Katie, it's hiding, especially after #715 "I think Katie is town FWIW". But… I think Katie is a wolf, so that makes me waver on Vernon

Angus - the pushing on Fiona, even after a role claim is just weird. As someone said, you let a role claim play out. Though now that I type this I feel it implicates Vernon more

• #527 Folks who have suddenly pushed for a lynch on him [Vernon] are well suss- Fi, you’re a bad un
  
• #602: because I’m trying to figure out why an experienced villager would role claim on day0... experienced wolf yes, experienced villager not so much
  
• #733 "seriously though- do you think vern is a wolf? We may need to lynch him to find out at some point tbh but.. if he isn’t then he’s the easiest mislynch target in the game. Would you agree that folks piling on to him is a bit suss IF he’s village?"

Katie - some bad posts here…

• #680 terrible call "vernon has come out strongly against fiona and conor. i say we lynch one of those and see where it ends up."
  
• #681 "maybe not fiona due to her role claim."
  
  #770 "so vernon's tactic earlier has resulted in our team leader having to reveal themselves. not very villagery play it must be said."
  ^ this comes after Fiona and Conor said Vernon should go. Smacks of bandwagoning, but then…
• #831 "i know some want to policy lynch him, but i just dont think he is a wolf"
  
• #838 "i dont think his behavior is that of a wolf. prob a NRV trying to start chaos and it just ended unfortunately."
  
• #1060 don't like this either "for the moment i'd be happy to clear the voters on mary. was too tight i think for a wolf to vote there." If Katie was to flip wolf I'd want to look at Orla and Liam, the last Mary voters

Emily - arriving late and hitting these random questions feels like a wolf trying to sow a bit a chaos. Though she doesn't actually mention Mary, that was probably too high risk

• #834 "What has he done to make you think they aren't a wolf? I'm literally just arrived, but I read this and thought its early doors to have that opinion. I usually think either someone's a suss or unknown on the first day."
  
• #835 "Why Oisin over the other two? What makes him stand out?"
  Second is a misread, but overall weird early posts
  
• #839 "Why is Gabs a wolf?"
  
• #910 "If it's nothing, could I sway you to vote for one of the other 2 or are you set on Oisin?"
  
• #955 "The day has gotten away with me and I haven't read back. I will vote for someone but I have no idea who."
  
• #964 "Could be an attempt to get low posters more involved than actually be wolfy."
  
• #966 "I'm going to vote Isla."
  ^ seems a weak vote as Isla was on other FFAs, but it's avoiding the wagon

So there's me for now. Apologies again for being so late, I will be on it from here on in!

i am disappointed in myself. is it worth of a self-elim? No, never is. But yeah i messed up. Here is what is going to happen. You and i will watch any s. i mean wolf who votes me. Slim pickings over here.

Mary was a membver of the s.. i mean wolf team.

I know that i played poorly d1, but i am a man who is willing to admit his mistakes.

@Fiona WW I made a mistake. You will either forgive me or make a mistake. I was confident you were the evil faction. Evidently, i was wrong. We learn and move on.

Morning All,

Amongst Ver's late night ramblings of nothingness once again, thankfully there is Brendan's post to deconstruct.

@Vernon WW never answered my question overnight?

Any reason?

Actually maybe remove Clodagh and add in Vernon into the "if i had a bullet" conversation . Forgot about him

@Fiona WW

I'd shoot Isla. Still is not helpful despite being active.

I give Vernon a pass for the moment, as he is a newbie here and I think we mislynched a newbie early last game.

I would agree and I think they will have to be resolved sooner rather than later.

Sorry Nigel, it was your big post, not Brendan's. Same offer still stands, ask me anything

If this is a wolf postbuts the best wolf post in the history of wolf posts 📫 😍

Ok so let's collate who responded to my late night request which we shall refer to as #bulletffa for now…

Vernon. An absolute nothing-burger of a response. Pretty much like their entire play since yesterday tbh.

Gabriel wants Vernon or Clodagh dead. Was hoping for more reasoning but it's erm… better than Vernon's effort at least

Orla - initially goes Emily, Oisin, Clodagh but changes Clodagh out for Vernon. Reasoning provided is definitely the best so far.

Frank - wants Isla shot and to give Vernon a pass for now.

Nigel - Pretty confident in ordering the shot on Emily based on their big post.

So where does that leave us with input from 4 players, it's not great tbh.

Anyone else want to weigh in on the question?

If there was a bullet to fire off at 10am who would you shoot, and why?

I'd shoot phill or oisin but for mechanical reasons

I believe that the wolves had a no show that's why they couldn't save Mary mechanically

Both didn't vote

I'm also waiting on Holly's answer