The eBike thread

Magzire · 27-03-2021 3:46pm

Not to bad i guess, still waiting for the 1t4 cable.

The batteries are cheap (5P13S Li-ion 2.5Ah 65 pcs 18650 battery cells (china battery cells)
After seeing some cheap batteries go up in flames my next priority is to upgrade.
I saw a guy some selling a 48v 24.5ah jumbo LG battery for €599 in Dublin.
Anyone know some good deals or manufacture?

DaveyDave · 27-03-2021 3:51pm

Are you using the bike on the road at all? If so I'd be putting on a tyre suited to the road for better rolling resistance and weight.

unkel · 27-03-2021 4:09pm

Nice bike!

Magzire wrote: »

The batteries are cheap (5P13S Li-ion 2.5Ah 65 pcs 18650 battery cells (china battery cells)
After seeing some cheap batteries go up in flames my next priority is to upgrade.

All li-ion are as dangerous as each other and the invariably cheap BMS used don't help either. All of this stuff is made in China BTW, as is your iPhone

The only way to have a safe eBike battery, is to use LiFePo4 cells...

Magzire · 27-03-2021 4:27pm

DaveyDave wrote: »

Are you using the bike on the road at all? If so I'd be putting on a tyre suited to the road for better rolling resistance and weight.

Well I bought it last year for exercise during the lock down and cycle only on my local roads and royal canal. Now I want to cycle to work when weather gets better. I managed to lose 8 kilos and plan to lose more so I don't mind the extra resistance and weight.

Magzire · 27-03-2021 4:28pm

unkel wrote: »

Nice bike!

All li-ion are as dangerous as each other and the invariably cheap BMS used don't help either. All of this stuff is made in China BTW, as is your iPhone

The only way to have a safe eBike battery, is to use LiFePo4 cells...

Thanks for that info

benjy1000 · 27-03-2021 4:37pm

https://shop.independent.ie/?gclid=CjwKCAjwr_uCBhAFEiwAX8YJgSjUUQhwVTmczNcphlu7YEloX22eeKkZKE8_6a_G2I9bxLMcl0eXpxoCO7gQAvD_BwE

Hi,

Came across this veloci ebike link on b.ie.
Seems interesting just curious if anybody has bought from it or has any feedback on veloci ebike in general ?

Cheers
B

Thargor · 27-03-2021 6:14pm

Magzire wrote: »

Not to bad i guess, still waiting for the 1t4 cable.
[img]https://i.imgur.com/ct3piZl.jpg[mg] The batteries are cheap (5P13S Li-ion 2.5Ah 65 pcs 18650 battery cells (china battery cells) After seeing some cheap batteries go up in flames my next priority is to upgrade. I saw a guy some selling a 48v 24.5ah jumbo LG battery for €599 in Dublin. Anyone know some good deals or manufacture?[/img]

That looks great there, underneath the downtube was a bit dodgy looking.

the_amazing_raisin · 27-03-2021 11:19pm

the_amazing_raisin wrote: »

Just wondering if anyone here has tried the Rockrider E-ST100 or 500? Decalthon are selling them and they seem to be some of the cheapest e-bikes out there while still being high quality

I'm toying with the idea of getting an e-bike next year, partly for commuting so the electric motor would be handy for the long uphill ride home. I used to have a trail bike and I really like being able to take it offroad a bit which is something I feel commuter and road bikes really aren't capable of

I wouldn't be covering huge distances (20-30km max), so I feel for me the extra weight and bulk of an eMTB are worth it for what I'm looking for.

Bumping as I got no responses the first time

Magzire · 28-03-2021 12:10am

Since i have rivet nuts under the frame i was thinking it be a good spot to have a spare tube and tools. Anyone know something like a bag holder that will go into a drink holder mount?

Magzire · 28-03-2021 1:25am

Thargor wrote: »

That looks great there, underneath the downtube was a bit dodgy looking.

The power controller is right there were the tire would hit, that would end in disaster

SCOL · 29-03-2021 9:34am

Magzire wrote: »

Since i have rivet nuts under the frame i was thinking it be a good spot to have a spare tube and tools. Anyone know something like a bag holder that will go into a drink holder mount?

you could use a actual drink container, fill it with the tools you need.

Skill Magill · 29-03-2021 9:22pm

This will do the job, cheap and has good reviews too :

https://www.wiggle.co.uk/lifeline-tool-storage-bottle

Magzire · 29-03-2021 10:13pm

Skill Magill wrote: »

This will do the job, cheap and has good reviews too :

https://www.wiggle.co.uk/lifeline-tool-storage-bottle

great idea, thanks

yousifm · 30-03-2021 3:17pm

jc bamford wrote: »

Just wondering if you got the Kuma and how it worked out. I am looking at the R1 myself but the the battery looks a bit small at 8.7 AH

If you're planning to use it quite a lot, I would definitely look at a battery size of at least 12Ah.
You should be able to find an ebike with a decent sized battery for about 1400 or 1500 or, if you already have a bike, you can make it electric with a conversion kit (they usually come with decent sized batteries).

unkel · 30-03-2021 6:00pm

yousifm wrote: »

If you're planning to use it quite a lot, I would definitely look at a battery size of at least 12Ah.
You should be able to find an ebike with a decent sized battery for about 1400 or 1500 or, if you already have a bike, you can make it electric with a conversion kit (they usually come with decent sized batteries).

Depends completely on what you want with the bike. Sure if you have a huge commute and need a (very) long range and / or use it as a "motorbike" without wanting to do much in the way of pedaling yourself, sure get a big battery

For a lot of people a smaller battery would be a better option. It is substantially cheaper and lighter.

Magzire · 30-03-2021 8:32pm

I managed to get a cable and got it all working, got it up to 54km/h. Ridiculously fast, that's only the 750watt version. That's plenty enough for me. A lot smoother than i expected. Overall definitely worth it.

Padre_Pio · 30-03-2021 10:19pm

Magzire wrote: »

I managed to get a cable and got it all working, got it up to 54km/h. Ridiculously fast, that's only the 750watt version. That's plenty enough for me. A lot smoother than i expected. Overall definitely worth it.

54km/h is a dangerous speed for anyone wearing cycling gear.
Take care of yourself.

Where are people getting batteries from nowadays?
I want to build one from scratch with a BMS.

Any reputable sources for 18650?

Mousewar · 03-04-2021 8:40pm

Absolutely burned past a couple of those rental ebikes on a big hill today so my kuma must be half decent at least.

What's the deal with charging ebike batteries? I always try to run it down before charging. Should I do that or can I just top it up as needed?
Or does it not really matter at all?

WoollyRedHat · 03-04-2021 9:08pm

Can anyone recommend a good cover for battery port, to prevent water damage?

Skill Magill · 03-04-2021 9:26pm

I never let the battery run down to zero if I can help it and always charge when the battery is cooled down and indoors. Once charged, I unlug the battery from the charger (rather than leaving it attached to the charger and unplugging that from the wall)
Think thats best practice, but I'm open to correction

Actually this paraphrases what they say on the Brompton site

Worth a quick look through

unkel · 03-04-2021 9:49pm

Skill Magill wrote: »

always charge when the battery is cooled down and indoors. Once charged, I unlug the battery from the charger (rather than leaving it attached to the charger and unplugging that from the wall)
Think thats best practice, but I'm open to correction

You will need some correction. There is no need to unplug the charger when charging is finished. Unlike lead acid, lithium chargers only charge up to the full voltage and never any more. When the batteries are full, there is simply zero current from the charger to the batteries. Same as it not being connected at all

I wouldn't charge indoors though, if you mean inside your house. Lithium ion 18650 battery cells are pretty unsafe things that can cause fires. I charge mine in the shed.

unkel · 03-04-2021 9:53pm

Mousewar wrote: »

What's the deal with charging ebike batteries? I always try to run it down before charging. Should I do that or can I just top it up as needed?

Top up as needed is theoretically better. Lithium ion battery cell only ever charged between 25% and 75% SOC at a constant ambient temp of 21C will last 50-100 years and still have near half the original capacity

Mousewar wrote: »

Or does it not really matter at all?

See my answer above, it matters very little really unless you want your battery to last 20 years

the_amazing_raisin · 03-04-2021 9:56pm

Mousewar wrote: »

Absolutely burned past a couple of those rental ebikes on a big hill today so my kuma must be half decent at least.

What's the deal with charging ebike batteries? I always try to run it down before charging. Should I do that or can I just top it up as needed?
Or does it not really matter at all?

I'm assuming you're using lithium batteries, if not then you should probably disregard what I'm about to tell you

This is based on best practices for using and charging an electric vehicle but the principles should be the same

Lithium batteries have a certain cycle count before they begin to lose a significant amount of capacity.

Depleting the battery and charging to full will give you something like 600 cycles before it's badly degraded. This should sound familiar if you've ever had a smartphone where the battery is wrecked after 2-3 years

Depending on how you use the battery, you can dramatically extend the lifetime of it. For example electric vehicle batteries can last 8 years without significant degredation now

The two best things you can do would be to not deplete the battery to zero before charging, and not leave the battery fully charged

If possible, try to recharge the battery when it's still not 20% left to avoid a deep discharge

Also, if you can stop the charge at 80% that will increase the lifetime. If you need to charge to 100%, then try to do it just before you use the bike so the battery isn't sitting at full charge for a long time. Don't leave the battery connected to the charger after it's charged

Similar to people, batteries don't like being too hot or cold. I'd recommend bringing the battery inside if the bike is kept outdoors or in a shed. Makes it less likely to be stolen as well

Discharge rate can also affect battery lifetime, especially in cold weather. How much power you can safely draw from a battery depends on the cell type, but to be conservative you should probably not try to draw more power than the battery capacity.

So if you have a 100Wh battery, then you'll want to try and avoid drawing more than 100W for an extended period of time

In other words, try to back off the assistance levels as much as you can. It'll be good for your health as well as your battery health

EDIT: One last thing, if you're ever leaving the battery for a while unused (a week or more) it's probably best to get it to 50% charge. This is how they're stored in warehouses for long periods of time

Mousewar · 03-04-2021 10:00pm

Thanks for the posts. Very useful.
I don't have a shed though so I'll have to carry on charging in the house. Won't leave it over night though anymore.

the_amazing_raisin · 03-04-2021 10:09pm

Mousewar wrote: »

Thanks for the posts. Very useful.
I don't have a shed though so I'll have to carry on charging in the house. Won't leave it over night though anymore.

I guess as Unkel said, top up as you need to, if you're using the bike for commuting then it'll probably need a charge every day or so

There's not much point in not charging one evening because you've 40% battery and running out of battery the next day

If the bike is for weekend spins, then probably best to try and get the battery to 50% after the weekend cycle and then top it up before the next cycle. This'll avoid it sitting too high or low during the week

So how you charge depends a lot on how you use the bike

unkel · 03-04-2021 10:13pm

@the_amazing_raisin - you have some general logic right, but I disagree with a lot of what you are saying there.

Don't charge inside your house if you can avoid it. Not very safe. Also all shop bought batteries have a BMS. It will not let you discharge the battery to dangerously low levels causing harm. And even if you didn't have a BMS, the bike's controller also has a fairly safe low voltage cut off. It's also no problem to charge a lithium battery to 100% and leave it sit for a bit, a few days is no problem at all

And the story about the phone batteries is that you usually have only one cell, it's a numbers game, a lot of phones have multiple cycles per day, so after 3 years they would have had 1000-2000 cycles, which means a severe reduction in capacity. Does that matter? Of course not, the phone is pretty much obsolete after 3 years and most people would have upgraded well before then

Same with bike batteries, but for most people even daily commuters, 1000 cycles (pardon the punch) would mean 4-5 years or even way more. Do you really want them to last 20 years? Waste of your efforts really. And in particular I find that with discharging. Do you really want to carry a 1kW battery with you if you want 1000W power out of your bike regularly? Of course not. The battery will be toast anyway after 4-5 years, much better to buy a 500Wh battery and discharge the hell out of it, and just buy another 500Wh battery after 2-3 years. Cheaper this way and lighter too...

the_amazing_raisin · 03-04-2021 10:31pm

@unkel, yeah fair enough, no need to agonise over whether you charged the battery when it's at 20% or 40%. If you need to charge then charge.

I wouldn't fully trust the BMS to protect the batteries longevity, it's more designed to stop immediate damage.

I wouldn't want to regularly run the bike down to 0% if I can avoid it, but at the same time I'm not going to lose any sleep over it

Good point about charging indoors, it should be safe if the battery and charger is from a reputable company, but given some of the garbage that's going around these days better to play it safe if you can. Definitely wouldn't leave it charging while I'm asleep, too much energy stored in that battery

I guess I'm trying to get the idea that if you get into some good habits then you'll get 5 years easily and maybe more. I think that's a reasonable lifetime for an ebike battery

I suspect there's a few ebikes that are regularly put on charge on Sunday and left until the following Saturday. Do that for a couple of years and you'll definitely see some battery degredation

unkel · 03-04-2021 10:35pm

the_amazing_raisin wrote: »

I suspect there's a few ebikes that are regularly put on charge on Sunday and left until the following Saturday. Do that for a couple of years and you'll definitely see some battery degredation

Oh of course, no argument there. My point is that if you spend huge money on a big expensive battery from say a shop, you'd want to treat it well to make it last 4-5 years. Personally I'd rather spend 75% less, don't care about the battery, abuse it, and still get 2-3 years out of it

WoollyRedHat · 04-04-2021 12:10pm

WoollyRedHat wrote: »

Can anyone recommend a good cover for battery port, to prevent water damage?

Does anyone know?

Skill Magill · 04-04-2021 3:19pm

WoollyRedHat wrote: »

Does anyone know?

Could you expand a little? Perhaps a photo of the battery port? Mine is detacheable and has a cover that you just press over the charging port to stop water ingress. This is what mine looks like

The eBike thread

Comments