MultiTool recommendations

Lex Luthor · 25-10-2020 05:37PM #1

Looking for one for DIY, think I would prefer corded, looking at this
https://www.diy.com/departments/erbauer-220-240v-300w-corded-multi-tool-emt300-qc/3663602795100_BQ.prd

Any suggestions thanks

The Continental Op · 25-10-2020 05:43PM

Looks good enough. I have the DeWalt battery one after having a cheap Lidl one for years. The Lidl one was slow but did the job. I'd recommend the DeWalt for anyone that is already into their battery system.

What are you cutting? Fine for wood but I found nearly all the blades including the expensive blades for cutting metal useless on modern hardened screws which seem to turn up whenever I have a use for a multitool.

Also beware the blade fitting. There are many types but most blades you buy have two distinct fittings. I had a load of blades for the Lidl Parkside MultiTool but none of them fitted the DeWalt.

okidoki987 · 25-10-2020 06:50PM

Bought a cordless one in Lidl a few months ago for a couple of odds jobs (cutting wood, removing grouting and some sanding) and it managed it all without any major hassle and was cheap as chips.
Very impressed with it especially as it came with a few attachments, other attachments depending on what you were using it for were cheap enough to buy as well.
Easy enough to recharge and the battery also can be used in any other cordless Lidl tool.
Saw a cordless one in Woodies and the attachments were nearly the same price as the unit from Lidl!
Never had one before but would recommend the Lidl one based on the jobs I had to do with it but you would have to wait for it to come back in again.

Lex Luthor · 25-10-2020 07:18PM

Mostly cutting wood
Remove grout
If they can cut tiles aswell all the better

I used a Dewalt corded one yesterday and it was great

The Continental Op · 25-10-2020 08:23PM

Loads of Youtube videos comparing them and this webpage compares 25 and has a few good points but tbh the difference between the better ones isn't huge https://www.protoolreviews.com/buying-guides/best-oscillating-tool-review-and-shootout/37382/ - sorry mainly American tools but shows what to look for.

Dr_Colossus · 25-10-2020 09:38PM

Never seen that B&Q brand before but 300W should be pretty decent.
I bought this 350W Worx version a few years ago when it was on sale for £55 and it's done a lot of work and going strong. Never mind the accessories as most of them are sandpaper, you'll have to get a carbide attachment for removing grout but otherwise you should be good to go.
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00MYZHWAK/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
If you're not in a rush set an alert on CamelCamel with a desired price and you'll get an email whenever it drops before that set price.

You'll need a 4" grinder for cutting tiles, found these blades very good and a lot cheaper than what you'll find in stores here
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Prodiamant-Premium-Diamond-Porcelain-Stoneware/dp/B07VNMGYN1/ref=sr_1_3?dchild=1&keywords=PRODIAMANT+premium+diamond+cutting+disc+tile%2Ffine+stoneware+PDX93.936+-+115+x+22.23mm&qid=1603658598&sr=8-3

listermint · 26-10-2020 09:49AM

If you can get cordless within your budget do. I have a corded and a cordless one. And always only ever reach for the cordless. Batteries never let me down yet and it's just easier to grab and use. They are only used in short stints but having freedom of movement is vital. Whatever battery system you are in go for that.

But I found the Ryobi one to be great I have that one because I've a few units Ryobi and value for money it's excellent.

Have a couple of dewalt flexvolt batteries too but the Ryobi unit was much cheaper to buy for the same outcome.

Lex Luthor · 26-10-2020 02:26PM

I see Aldi have one coming soon
https://www.aldi.ie/ferrex-300w-multifunction-tool/p/802084390872900

Not familiar with the Ferex range but I have a Parkside detailed sander I've had for years and is just as good if not better than any Bosch one that came before it

CJhaughey · 26-10-2020 06:26PM

I bought a Bosch GOP 55-36 110v corded multitool and its a beast, 550w is well able for most things that I would want to cut.
It has Starlock Max fitment so will accept all the previous Starlock iterations before the Max variant which means a lot of tool choice and a wide selection of tools available as well.

tiredcity · 26-10-2020 06:30PM

I've this Erbauer one - https://www.screwfix.ie/p/erbauer-emt300-qc-300w-electric-multi-tool-220-240v/622fx

Not used it loads yet but love it so far.

The Continental Op · 26-10-2020 06:47PM

tiredcity wrote: »

I've this Erbauer one - https://www.screwfix.ie/p/erbauer-emt300-qc-300w-electric-multi-tool-220-240v/622fx

Not used it loads yet but love it so far.

When you start analyzing the reviews there isn't a whole lot that separates the best from the not as good tools.

Just having any multitool is better than not having one. When you need one its probably the only tool that will do the job.

The only real decision users need to make is whether to stay corded or go cordless. I feel this is one tool where its worth spending the extra on a cordless battery tool because you get more use out of it but for very occasional use corded is going to be a more sensible option. If you are already in debt to a brand with their batteries then probably best getting a bare tool that uses the same batteries.

Lex Luthor · 26-10-2020 08:55PM

I’m not stuck on a brand because of batteries
A corded unit wouldn’t bother me

Forgot about screw fix
Must have a look at what they have

Fine Cheers · 26-10-2020 09:20PM

I see Aldi have this one for sale from Thurs 29th for €29.50.
https://www.aldi.co.uk/ferrex-300w-multifunction-tool/p/099148298051500

Bawnmore · 28-10-2020 03:20PM

listermint wrote: »

If you can get cordless within your budget do. I have a corded and a cordless one. And always only ever reach for the cordless. Batteries never let me down yet and it's just easier to grab and use. They are only used in short stints but having freedom of movement is vital. Whatever battery system you are in go for that.

But I found the Ryobi one to be great I have that one because I've a few units Ryobi and value for money it's excellent.

Have a couple of dewalt flexvolt batteries too but the Ryobi unit was much cheaper to buy for the same outcome.

I've mostly corded tools and a few odd cordless Black and Decker tools at the moment. Looking to stick with one battery system. Bouncing between Dewalt and Ryobi at the moment. Leaning towards Dewalt, but the price difference is significant alright.

listermint · 28-10-2020 08:34PM

Bawnmore wrote: »

I've mostly corded tools and a few odd cordless Black and Decker tools at the moment. Looking to stick with one battery system. Bouncing between Dewalt and Ryobi at the moment. Leaning towards Dewalt, but the price difference is significant alright.

I do believe too much emphasis is put on the one battery system stuff. Fine if your a tradesperson. But as an average user i think going for the best value quality tool for a given job makes more sense. No use having tools out there that require 100 Euro + batteries and tools to match.

Example of this is, I currently own a mix of Dewalt, Bosch, Ryobi, WORX battery gear and other corded equipment.

I buy based on value for money and quality for a given task. individual manufacturers can make some absymal tools within their range where another manufacturer can have a better version of the same tool.

The battery thing is obviously put out their by manufacturers to scare you into staying inside their eco system. Charging each marque makes no ends to me. They are all charged in the garage at a charging station.

listermint · 03-11-2020 10:33AM

listermint wrote: »

If you can get cordless within your budget do. I have a corded and a cordless one. And always only ever reach for the cordless. Batteries never let me down yet and it's just easier to grab and use. They are only used in short stints but having freedom of movement is vital. Whatever battery system you are in go for that.

But I found the Ryobi one to be great I have that one because I've a few units Ryobi and value for money it's excellent.

Have a couple of dewalt flexvolt batteries too but the Ryobi unit was much cheaper to buy for the same outcome.

Coming back to this, the Ryobi one i own died a death. no reason just stopped working. Its had a relatively sedate life and i do mean that very little work through it. Perhaps 60 mins over the last few months max. All my other ryobi stuff has been perfect over the last few years. but i guess their multitool is not good quality. As i say all marques have bad apples in them.

Ive put in order for DeWalt DCS355N this morning. Ryobi is going back for refund. Will see how the DeWalt stacks up.

Lex Luthor · 03-11-2020 11:00AM

I picked up one of the Aldi ones last week....will be taking it out of the box in the next couple days and give it a test run and will update

irishbuzz · 03-11-2020 11:10AM

Lex Luthor wrote: »

I picked up one of the Aldi ones last week....will be taking it out of the box in the next couple days and give it a test run and will update

I thought the Aldi special buy stuff was cancelled? Was looking at picking up one of those myself

Lex Luthor · 03-11-2020 12:00PM

irishbuzz wrote: »

I thought the Aldi special buy stuff was cancelled? Was looking at picking up one of those myself

i think it depends on the product

03-11-2020 12:12PM

listermint wrote: »

Coming back to this, the Ryobi one i own died a death. no reason just stopped working.

Mine too, I was absolutely raging as I needed it badly.
They replaced it but that was the end of me buying Ryobi.
I also killed a one+ SDS and they repaired it but it died again.
I had given that a hard but short life to be honest.

Bluefoam · 03-11-2020 01:56PM

If you are in the market for a multi-tool, you are probaly inclined to do a bit of DIY & buy more tools... you should consider investing in a battery system so that you can add tools as you need.

That can be Lidl, Ryobi, DeWalt... whatever. Just chose a system that allows to to buy the tools and not just one item at a time. Although, I wouldn't be confident in Lidl or Aldi being loyal to a particular battery type & you may have difficulty getting tools for the same system in the future.

I have a Makita drill that I bought a few years ago in the Middle East when I lived there... I recently added a jigsaw and lawn mower, but didn't have to buy anymore batteries because I had the original set from the drill... Now I just keep those two batteries charged and can use them with any of my tools. Makita tools are easily available as 'tool only' so you don't have to spend money on batteries.

Only one charger in the shed, no feckin around and I know that if I need more tools or batteries in the future, they'll all work off the same system...

03-11-2020 03:19PM

Withe the risk of going OT ,
I bought two 5ah generic 18v makita batteries off amazon for 50e last week.
Have ran them through the 36v chainsaw a few times and so far so good.
time will tell!

Bluefoam · 03-11-2020 03:39PM

BrownFinger wrote: »

Withe the risk of going OT ,
I bought two 5ah generic 18v makita batteries off amazon for 50e last week.
Have ran them through the 36v chainsaw a few times and so far so good.
time will tell!

Keep us posted... I'm interested to find out how they go...

03-11-2020 03:41PM

Bluefoam wrote: »

Keep us posted... I'm interested to find out how they go...

Will do.
Its not something I would usually do but Amazon wouldn't ship me the genuine ones

ozmo · 05-11-2020 01:26PM

I had a varient of one of these multitools - came with lots of great looking attachments, diamond saws etc - used it once to carve a small bit out of some soft skirting board - and the pins that lock the blade from twisting around all sheared off.

Poor power tool that relies on 1mm Tiny pins to do the work... Very unimpressed.

listermint · 05-11-2020 03:36PM

ozmo wrote: »

I had a varient of one of these multitools - came with lots of great looking attachments, diamond saws etc - used it once to carve a small bit out of some soft skirting board - and the pins that lock the blade from twisting around all sheared off.

Poor power tool that relies on 1mm Tiny pins to do the work... Very unimpressed.

Sounds like a cheap one. I've had two so far none of done this . Also sounds like the retention nut wasnt on properly you can't sheer the heads if the nut is tightened properly

Bluefoam · 05-11-2020 03:48PM

ozmo wrote: »

I had a varient of one of these multitools - came with lots of great looking attachments, diamond saws etc - used it once to carve a small bit out of some soft skirting board - and the pins that lock the blade from twisting around all sheared off.

Poor power tool that relies on 1mm Tiny pins to do the work... Very unimpressed.

Buying cheap tools is a false economy in some cases

CJhaughey · 06-11-2020 12:05PM

ozmo wrote: »

I had a varient of one of these multitools - came with lots of great looking attachments, diamond saws etc - used it once to carve a small bit out of some soft skirting board - and the pins that lock the blade from twisting around all sheared off.

Poor power tool that relies on 1mm Tiny pins to do the work... Very unimpressed.

There are various different methods of tool attachment and availability and cross fitment is a big selling point for me, that is one of the main reasons I opted for the Bosch system, Starlock Max can use all the previous versions of Starlock and OIS as well.
https://www.kelvinpowertools.com/blog/blog/new-bosch-fein-starlock-system

bladespin · 06-11-2020 12:09PM

Bought the Lidl multi on special offer a while back (cordless type) for some small jobs around the house (well just one but don't tell the mrs), great bit of kit tbh, far better than I thought it would be

Lumen · 06-11-2020 01:28PM

My 2c.

I have a Makita 18V LXT multi tool. It's not useless, but it goes through blades like nothing else.

I can get months and hundreds of cuts out of a circular saw blade, but it seems like I need a fresh multi tool blade for every small job.

I've tried expensive blades, cheap blades, fine teeth, coarse teeth, blades for "wood and nails", blades for wood only, blades for multi materials, blades with yellow carbide coatings, straight blades, narrow blades, wide blades, semi-circular blades. Doesn't really make much of a difference, they all end up in the bin in short order.

Basically, I'll only use it as a tool of last resort for flush cutting. It's usually better to figure out how to remove the thing I need to cut and do it properly, rather than trying to do a flush cut in situ.

Am I alone in this?

Romer · 06-11-2020 01:37PM

Lumen wrote: »

My 2c.

I have a Makita 18V LXT multi tool. It's not useless, but it goes through blades like nothing else.

I can get months and hundreds of cuts out of a circular saw blade, but it seems like I need a fresh multi tool blade for every small job.

I've tried expensive blades, cheap blades, fine teeth, coarse teeth, blades for "wood and nails", blades for wood only, blades for multi materials, blades with yellow carbide coatings, straight blades, narrow blades, wide blades, semi-circular blades. Doesn't really make much of a difference, they all end up in the bin in short order.

Basically, I'll only use it as a tool of last resort for flush cutting. It's usually better to figure out how to remove the thing I need to cut and do it properly, rather than trying to do a flush cut in situ.

Am I alone in this?

Not just you. Whilst I've not gone the full spectrum of price points, the cheap ones last about as long as the more expensive ones. I'm not gonna even bother buying the truly dear ones. I've started considering them as consumables. I get a pack of 20 or whatever for cheap, use one once, bin it.

MultiTool recommendations

Comments