Irish Aris's Walrus: The Reveal

RasTa · 31-07-2020 8:36pm

Ah I thought I'd sent Suite Judy Blue Eyes by CSNY. Yeah I've only heard the live version, tis a whopper.

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:36pm

mustang shelly wrote: »

Oh boy!

I know it isn't much of a consolation, but without the male vocals this song would have placed higher - it was just that I was splitting hairs to finalise rankings and I found an easy excuse. . .

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:39pm

In 3rd place, submitted by

Necro

, Robbie Williams-Bodies

One of the very few pop songs in this list and it gave it a competitive advantage – the song would have placed high anyway. I like Robbie Williams, I think that he made the most interesting things outside of Take That. This is a great pop song, I like the strings and how the song changes arrangements between verses and chorus.

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:44pm

In 20th place, submitted by

Electric Nitwit

, Fight Like Apes-Pull Off Your Arms and Let’s Play in Your Blood.

I was impressed to discover that Fight Like Apes were both popular and critically acclaimed. Another band that they weren’t very active after I moved to Ireland so I never registered them. I found this rather noisy. The instruments felt like they were trying to get on top of each other and the voices for the most part were getting lost in the mix – not sure if this was on purpose or a result of too much production, but I didn’t like the end result

Zaph · 31-07-2020 8:46pm

I can see where this is going at the bottom of the table and I'm not feeling good about it...

Electric Nitwit · 31-07-2020 8:47pm

Yeah...

Fight Like Apes wrote:

Well, I detest your fücking stories
I'd love to have a shot at your chest

I mean who else gave you a song featuring self-removing genitals?!

Ah well, I genuinely think some people would love this. Not today though. Luckily I know I've nailed the last two rounds :pac:

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:50pm

Electric Nitwit wrote: »

Yeah...

I mean who else gave you a song featuring self-removing genitals?!

Ah well, I genuinely think some people would love this. Not today though. Luckily I know I've nailed the last two rounds :pac:

Can't commend at the moment. I'm doing this thing that I only check who submitted what as I do the reveal, so I can have a bit of suspense for myself too

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:52pm

In 2nd place, submitted by

phatkev

, Explosions in the Sky-Your Hand in Mine

My connection with post rock started with the discovery of Sigur Ros (with the self-titled/untitled album). Explosions In The Sky was one of the bands that draw my attention and I think their first 3 albums are amongst the most interesting of the post rock sound. Your Hand in Mine is an epic 9 minute song that captures the essence of post rock: quite guitar passages leading to powerful drums crescendos, the mood changes throughout the song in such a natural way. It feels like the music really tells a story. An excellent choice and a good reminder of a very good band.

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 8:56pm

Zaph wrote: »

I can see where this is going at the bottom of the table and I'm not feeling good about it...

sorry Zaph, just an unlucky selection. . .

In 21st place, submitted by

Zaph

, Radiohead-My Iron Lung

I don’t like 90s Radiohead at all. I found Thom Yorke’s voice annoying and only got interested when they introduced electronic elements on Kid A and Amnesiac, mainly because I find the experimental electronic sound suits his voice better. That song didn’t catch my attention that much. Standard Radiohead sound with some grunge elements and Yorke’s voice the way I don’t like. Only natural so that it ended up in the last spot.

Electric Nitwit · 31-07-2020 9:00pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

sorry Zaph, just an unlucky selection. . .

In 21st place, submitted by
Zaph
, Radiohead-My Iron Lung

I was OK with me being second last but I will not accept this! This is a cracking song!

Zaph · 31-07-2020 9:00pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

sorry Zaph, just an unlucky selection. . .

In 21st place, submitted by
Zaph
, Radiohead-My Iron Lung

I don’t like 90s Radiohead at all. I found Thom Yorke’s voice annoying and only got interested when they introduced electronic elements on Kid A and Amnesiac, mainly because I find the experimental electronic sound suits his voice better. That song didn’t catch my attention that much. Standard Radiohead sound with some grunge elements and Yorke’s voice the way I don’t like. Only natural so that it ended up in the last spot.

That's fair enough, there's a natural split between those who prefer early Radiohead and those who prefer later. I'm definitely in the former camp, electronic noodling just doesn't interest me at all, but I will say that some of their later songs sound incredible live when they have to dial back the electronic sounds a bit.

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 9:01pm

Electric Nitwit wrote: »

I was OK with me being second last but I will not accept this! This is a cracking song!

I told you there would be a riot!!!!

[Deleted User] · 31-07-2020 9:01pm

Ah here now! :eek:

Far from my favourite Radiohead song.....but last?!

ShaneU · 31-07-2020 9:02pm

Zaph wrote: »

That's fair enough, there's a natural split between those who prefer early Radiohead and those who prefer later.

I'm in the don't like any Radiohead camp, so make another split :pac:

Electric Nitwit · 31-07-2020 9:03pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

I told you there would be a riot!!!!

I mean, my take away could be that I placed one above the best band in the world... :cool:

Zaph · 31-07-2020 9:03pm

ShaneU wrote: »

I'm in the don't like any Radiohead camp, so make another split :pac:

I'm afraid there's just no hope for you at all Shane

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 9:04pm

Zaph wrote: »

That's fair enough, there's a natural split between those who prefer early Radiohead and those who prefer later. I'm definitely in the former camp, electronic noodling just doesn't interest me at all, but I will say that some of their later songs sound incredible live when they have to dial back the electronic sounds a bit.

I really think Yorke's voice plays a big part on my dislike of early Radiohead - because I rather like this cover that Tears for Fears have done

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 9:06pm

In 1st place, submitted by

Also Starring LeVar Burton

, Tears For Fears-Head Over Heels

No other song came close to challenging Head Over Heels for the top spot. This is another classic 80s song. Roland’s vocals are usually powerful – but here there is a softness and vulnerability in the way he sings and that’s why I consider this one of his most interesting (if not the best) vocal performance of his career.

Zaph · 31-07-2020 9:07pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

I really think Yorke's voice plays a big part on my dislike of early Radiohead - because I rather like this cover that Tears for Fears have done

Never heard that before. Better than I would have expected tbh, especially given my pathological dislike of Tears For Fears. :pac:

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 9:14pm

LeVar increases his lead, but 4 players are still in "shouting" distance.
A second consecutive good placing gets RasTa of the last place which is now occupied by JohnGreenFan

Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Round 5 Round 6 Round 7 Total Points
Also Starring LeVar Burton 14 20 11 19 21 85
phatkev 18 6 21 9 20 74
s1ippy 16 19 10 16 12 73
beakerjoe 15 21 17 10 9 72
JP Liz V1 12 17 16 12 10 67
Necro 21 12 5 4 19 61
fixXxer 4 18 15 5 17 59
Homer J. Fong 20 10 6 17 5 58
Shane U 11 11 9 14 13 58
Kolido 5 15 8 13 16 57
Zaph 19 9 14 11 1 54
lassykk 1 14 4 21 14 54
Gru 17 5 20 2 4 48
the purple tin 10 2 18 6 11 47
Mustang Shelly 6 4 13 20 3 46
Sawduck 7 16 1 7 15 46
Osh 9 8 19 1 8 45
Electric Nitwit 8 3 12 18 2 43
Green&Red 13 7 7 8 6 41
RasTa 3 1 2 15 18 39
JohnGreenFan 2 13 3 3 7 28

Electric Nitwit · 31-07-2020 9:16pm

Zaph wrote: »

That's fair enough, there's a natural split between those who prefer early Radiohead and those who prefer later

Irish Aris · 31-07-2020 9:16pm

and the YouTube playlist:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUaRXycpvvkHhFD9Hcvpp6l9ZpM8b3S8b

next reveal is probably gonna be Monday, I will let you know guys anyway.

Hope you all have a great long weekend!!

quickbeam · 31-07-2020 9:17pm

What about people who don't like either?

quickbeam · 31-07-2020 9:17pm

Oh, never mind, I see them outside the Venn.

Electric Nitwit · 31-07-2020 9:18pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Oh, never mind, I see them outside the Venn.

I'm a mathematician, my Venn diagrams have to be complete

Green&Red · 31-07-2020 10:29pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

In 8th place, submitted by
lassykk
, Goo Goo Dolls-Iris

The second appearance of the Goo Goo Dolls classic in this Walrus ends a place higher than the first attempt. I was intrigued when I saw the song in 2 different categories. I read the story behind the lyrics and it appears that the song has been inspired by singer Iris DeMent. Since iris is also in the human body I allowed it in both categories. This is definitely a song that benefits from repeated listening and I expect to listen to it more in the future as contrary to the majority I wasn't familiar with it.

God I hate that song

I think (and I seem to be alone) that its the most overplayed, over-rated song in the last 20 years

osh · 31-07-2020 10:31pm

No I hate it too

Tauriel · 31-07-2020 10:37pm

Irish Aris wrote: »

I know it isn't much of a consolation, but without the male vocals this song would have placed higher - it was just that I was splitting hairs to finalise rankings and I found an easy excuse. . .

In fairness, I have always thought that this song would benefit without Marco's vocals.

Necro · 31-07-2020 10:42pm

Irish Aris wrote:

One of the very few pop songs in this list and it gave it a competitive advantage â€“ the song would have placed high anyway. I like Robbie Williams, I think that he made the most interesting things outside of Take That. This is a great pop song, I like the strings and how the song changes arrangements between verses and chorus.

Woo hoo! Always the danger with pop that you will get a judge who doesn't like any at all. Glad I took the risk because I think Bodies is a cracking tune. Not his best, but it's quite different from his normal stuff imo which makes it stand out a bit.

ShaneU wrote:

I'm in the don't like any Radiohead camp, so make another split

Add another one to that camp, don't get them at all at all.

beakerjoe · 01-08-2020 12:04am

Green&Red wrote: »

God I hate that song

I think (and I seem to be alone) that its the most overplayed, over-rated song in the last 20 years

Youre not alone. A fine sing but played to death. It now hurts my ears.

Irish Aris's Walrus: The Reveal

Comments