Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:14AM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Post your info before you get pilled Conor!!!

Would be very odd if they didn't Pill Conor wouldn't it ?

That list raises many questions .

Gertrude WW · 20-09-2018 10:14AM

Conor WW wrote: »

Jesus...expected some reaction! Everyone plotting?

We haven't hit one wolf??

What was holly?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:15AM

Conor WW wrote: »

I figure I'm screwed either way today hence the wall of text with the info (doing stupid group bonding sheet in this meeting I wouldn't mind being munched)

Post the dessie and Doris roles so. Although unless they are secret roles its easy to figure out who the both of them were, but not who they were individually.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:16AM

6 minutes until wini 'dies' if im evil.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:16AM

Wini swings tonight. Has to be.

Winifred WW · 20-09-2018 10:16AM

Orla WW wrote: »

God dammit. I think we've been had by Winnie.

How are you had, I just got sent the pills.

I survived by picking the Mork pill

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:17AM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Drink more coffee Riona. He is saying he is withholding that info until consensus from village that he should tell us it.

What about the non rolled goodies ? Most of the names on Conors list say "possibly, probabley or I think" . . Why would Conor have to hypothesise on roles he got ?

What benefit to the village of us not having all on rolled positions ? PArticuarly if he might be poisoned at any stage . . I call bullsh*t

Orla WW · 20-09-2018 10:18AM

Winifred WW wrote: »

How are you had, I just got sent the pills.

I survived by picking the Mork pill

:rolleyes: Of course.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:19AM

Winifred WW wrote: »

How are you had, I just got sent the pills.

I survived by picking the Mork pill

If this is true why didn't the wolves go for Conor ?

Also Gabriels disappearance pre munch and serious offence against Winnie is very suspect . .

Conors list is a pile of sh*t as far as I am concerned. Hes actually not really confirmed anybody dead .

Orla WW · 20-09-2018 10:19AM

Riona WW wrote: »

What about the non rolled goodies ? Most of the names on Conors list say "possibly, probabley or I think" . . Why would Conor have to hypothesise on roles he got ?

What benefit to the village of us not having all on rolled positions ? PArticuarly if he might be poisoned at any stage . . I call bullsh*t

Nah, that means if Irene was lynched or killed whilst out of the wolf room she'd show as NRV

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:21AM

If nothing else happened today Gabriel, Orla and Conor would be my FFA . .

Conors confirmed nothing in his reveal . . Look at the amount of dead roles he has actually confirmed . And with Jeffs pill hanging over him, what good is it to the village to have a RV confirm very little of the information they have ?

Winifred WW · 20-09-2018 10:22AM

Riona WW wrote: »

If nothing else happened today Gabriel, Orla and Conor would be my FFA . .

Conors confirmed nothing in his reveal . . Look at the amount of dead roles he has actually confirmed . And with Jeffs pill hanging over him, what good is it to the village to have a RV confirm very little of the information they have ?

Are you Irene?

WerewolfGM · 20-09-2018 10:22AM

Lynch is open

https://goo.gl/kVy9yj

Gertrude WW · 20-09-2018 10:22AM

Riona WW wrote: »

If this is true why didn't the wolves go for Conor ?

Also Gabriels disappearance pre munch and serious offence against Winnie is very suspect . .

Conors list is a pile of sh*t as far as I am concerned. Hes actually not really confirmed anybody dead .

O look. We're back to questioning a role reveal again. How interesting.

Can you counter it? Can you disprove it?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:22AM

Riona WW wrote: »

What about the non rolled goodies ? Most of the names on Conors list say "possibly, probabley or I think" . . Why would Conor have to hypothesise on roles he got ?

What benefit to the village of us not having all on rolled positions ? PArticuarly if he might be poisoned at any stage . . I call bullsh*t

All the possibles or probables have to do with the fact that any of the NRVs could be Irene. Which is accurate.

Riona WW wrote: »

If this is true why didn't the wolves go for Conor ?

Also Gabriels disappearance pre munch and serious offence against Winnie is very suspect . .

Conors list is a pile of sh*t as far as I am concerned. Hes actually not really confirmed anybody dead .

He revealed at 10am.....after the usual munch order deadline.

Riona WW wrote: »

If nothing else happened today Gabriel, Orla and Conor would be my FFA . .

Conors confirmed nothing in his reveal . . Look at the amount of dead roles he has actually confirmed . And with Jeffs pill hanging over him, what good is it to the village to have a RV confirm very little of the information they have ?

Jesus Riona take a step back there......you need to calm down. And thats coming from me like.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:23AM

Winifred WW wrote: »

How are you had, I just got sent the pills.

I survived by picking the Mork pill

This is very good news. If anyone else gets pilled, we have a wolf.

If noone else gets pilled, we keep our priest.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:24AM

Orla WW wrote: »

Nah, that means if Irene was lynched or killed whilst out of the wolf room she'd show as NRV

Desmond WW - was roled. Not saying which one without village consensus.
Doris WW - was roled. Same as Des.
The worse news is that Barbara WW was Sherlock.
Clodagh WW was indeed Dr. John Watson.
Mary WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Munched
Frank WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – SKd so possibly Irene but I have my own theories on that.
Katie WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.
Wendy WW - Scotland Yard Officer - NRV – Attempted poisoning and munched. I don’t know what this was, they can’t have peeked her.
Oisín WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Modkilled, unlikely Irene.
Liam WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.

Who ut of this list exactly has Conor told us an exact role ? sherlock and Watson . . The wolves get two peaks and Watson came out on thread . .

You guys accepting this so quickly is as dodgy as a Tipperary FF politician . .

Too quick for my liking .

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 10:24AM

Riona WW wrote: »

What about the non rolled goodies ? Most of the names on Conors list say "possibly, probabley or I think" . . Why would Conor have to hypothesise on roles he got ?

What benefit to the village of us not having all on rolled positions ? PArticuarly if he might be poisoned at any stage . . I call bullsh*t

Read it properly Riona. I gave the roles with my thoughts added.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:25AM

Riona WW wrote: »

If this is true why didn't the wolves go for Conor ?

Also Gabriels disappearance pre munch and serious offence against Winnie is very suspect . .

Conors list is a pile of sh*t as far as I am concerned. Hes actually not really confirmed anybody dead .

Hold on a second. My disappearance? What? I was posting with you before munch!

Serious offence against Wini? How the feck couldnt i go after her!

Oh and by the way, the 12 hours has passed. So either wini is FOS or im good. Make your choice.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:26AM

Riona WW wrote: »

Desmond WW - was roled. Not saying which one without village consensus.
Doris WW - was roled. Same as Des.
The worse news is that Barbara WW was Sherlock.
Clodagh WW was indeed Dr. John Watson.
Mary WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Munched
Frank WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – SKd so possibly Irene but I have my own theories on that.
Katie WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.
Wendy WW - Scotland Yard Officer - NRV – Attempted poisoning and munched. I don’t know what this was, they can’t have peeked her.
Oisín WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Modkilled, unlikely Irene.
Liam WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.

Who ut of this list exactly has Conor told us an exact role ? sherlock and Watson . . The wolves get two peaks and Watson came out on thread . .

You guys accepting this so quickly is as dodgy as a Tipperary FF politician . .

Too quick for my liking .

Thats a fair point actually.

Winifred WW · 20-09-2018 10:26AM

Riona is Irene

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:27AM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

All the possibles or probables have to do with the fact that any of the NRVs could be Irene. Which is accurate..

Irene cant be several roles Gabriel .. .

So it would make sense that if she was killed she would show as some random NRV.

That doesn't explain several "potential Irenes" in Conors list . .

Gertrude WW · 20-09-2018 10:28AM

Riona WW wrote: »

Irene cant be several roles Gabriel .. .

So it would make sense that if she was killed she would show as some random NRV.

That doesn't explain several "potential Irenes" in Conors list . .

If an nrv died by lynch or sk he highghted that it could have been irene, no?

Orla WW · 20-09-2018 10:28AM

Riona WW wrote: »

Irene cant be several roles Gabriel .. .

So it would make sense that if she was killed she would show as some random NRV.

That doesn't explain several "potential Irenes" in Conors list . .

But Riona, stop for a second - read the OP surrounding Irene.

If Irene was dead, she'd show as NRV, so there's no way to tell even via priest if an NRV is what they claim or in fact Irene.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 10:28AM

Winifred WW wrote: »

Riona is Irene

Ah the veil falls . . Please do explain . .

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:29AM

Riona WW wrote: »

Irene cant be several roles Gabriel .. .

So it would make sense that if she was killed she would show as some random NRV.

That doesn't explain several "potential Irenes" in Conors list . .

Conor pointed out that any of those NRVs could be Irene....and that we dont know which it is, if any.

Its shrodingers role. They are all NRV and Irene until we can identify (if we can identify) which was Irene.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 10:29AM

Riona WW wrote: »

Irene cant be several roles Gabriel .. .

So it would make sense that if she was killed she would show as some random NRV.

That doesn't explain several "potential Irenes" in Conors list . .

Are you that dim? Of course there are several potential Irenes...there are several NRVs so any of them could be Irene FFS.

Orla WW · 20-09-2018 10:29AM

Orla WW wrote: »

But Riona, stop for a second - read the OP surrounding Irene.

If Irene was dead, she'd show as NRV, so there's no way to tell even via priest if an NRV is what they claim or in fact Irene.

That is, presuming of course she wasn't in the wolf room when killed.

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 10:30AM

I'm locking in my vote for Wini.

At the very least, since revealing as someone with de facto seer powers, the wolves have opted not to kill him TWICE. They chose to role hunt with Holly and leave Wini to fate with the pills?

The chances Wini is Eurus is too high to ignore, and given their double parity, that needs to be our main target, especially if all the wolves are dead.

Riona's reaction this morning makes me put her solidly into the wolf camp now too tbh. Doubting a priest reveal with zero evidence or anything to back up said concern? Its doubting for the sake of doubting.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 10:30AM

I think you are wrong on the NRV/Irene thing Riona but i agree with you that with only 2 roles revealed, Conors list is suss as feck.

It could be a ploy to get the seer out (or any other role) to counter claim.

Conor we need those 2 roles you have withheld, imo.

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments