Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Nigel WW wrote: »

Yeah, Priest or Seer would tells us on Winnie. The former of course would require her death first. TBH, I think in Wendy and Barbara one or both of those roles are probably gone.

What does Mrs Hudson do? Anything in her powers that can unravel this riddle for us?

I was convinced this was Winnies role . . That's why I find her chosen character as odd . .

Orla WW wrote: »

FFAs Day 3, Final List



Player Name Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Winifred WW Derry Gabriel Liam
Liam WW Abigail Holly Steve
Gabriel WW Holly Liam Steve
Brendan WW Isla Nigel Liam
Nigel WW Gabriel Holly Steve
Abigail WW Liam Steve Isla
Orla WW Liam Nigel Gabriel
Conor WW Isla Steve Riona
Holly WW Gabriel Liam Nigel
Eva WW Gabriel Steve Isla
Steve WW LIam Gabriel Holly
Gertrude WW Riona Liam Steve
Derry WW Liam Steve Holly
Isla WW Holly Nigel Liam

Results:

Liam WW 10
Steve WW 8
Gabriel WW 6
Holly WW 6
Isla WW 5
Nigel WW 3
Riona WW 2
Abigail WW 1
Derry WW 1


Ok, here's what I had from last night.

Be back after the school run.

Sorry folks.

Orla WW wrote: »

We run that risk anyways

Not necessarily - Jeff could try to pill someone and they could get the 50/50 choice correct, thereby negating him for 24 hours.

Lads, if i die shortly, please please please please please dont assume the fab 4/5 are all cleared. We dont know that. For all we know Dessie got a message and Riona (or whoever got the message the day dessie/wendy/katie etc etc etc died) is a wolf claiming they got that message. Thats nothing against you Riona - im making the point for any of us.

We are close to clearing our 'core' but its not there yet.

Orla WW wrote: »

Rule 4 - BG and Jailer protections must be entered before the lynch.

So a seer revealing at 9.59am could be marked for kill.

Has nothing to do with this morning, I'm saying in general reveals should be happening at a different time.

Apologies, I misred your post. I thought you meant reveal before the munch, not lynch . . . We need Dessie to come back to us, presuming the wolves don't target him .

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Dessie?

I meant Brendan . . Ive had my coffee so no excuse for the mistakes .

Wendy WW wrote: »

I think this is an important point. It makes sense for the wolves to take part in puzzle solving. A wolf solving one of them would be the perfect cover to hide behind when accusations come flying.

If I was on team wolf I'd be solving the puzzles as a group, then having Irene Adler announce the answer. If she comes up a winner, have her disconnect from the group so she peeks as a NVR. She's have two things pointing to her as clearly villager. Definitely worth it.

I'm not saying its what happened but its something to keep in mind.

Post 602 - Wendy suggesting a wolf strategy - Wolves went for her twice

Derry WW wrote: »

This goes out to a specific someone.

If you're given a choice soon....don't.

(I'll see about expanding in a while. I'm hoping I've read something right and that the relevant person will understand).

Derry had been put on the hospital list. I remember now thinking it was like a wolf giving a message to the SK not to kill them before the wolves get their kill in at 10 . . I found this very odd and Derry never explained it. This was why I always had my eye on Derry and one of the reasons I voted for him Last night...

Mary WW wrote: »

So as I said last night Irene Adler will have left the room and be communicating on thread
While I don’t think you are a wolf I do think that stuff like this is going to provide cover.

This was Mary responding directly to Derrys above Quote just before she died . . She posted it way to close to the munch for the wolves to change their mind (if Derry is a wolf and didn't want to cast shade on himself). .

Something about Derry has been bugging me all game. Getting 2 of the 3 quiz answers suggests either hes really clever or had help answering the questions. But would people say his play for the last 3 days has been super helpful clever play ?

I would like Derry to be propery analysed by people, particularly if I am killed. . Derry, Gabriel, Clodagh and Desmond have been the people who I have clashed with most here . . I am not saying they are wolves but its a decent heads up if I am killed . .

Very quiet here pre munch . . Wolves frantically trying to work out a strategy after my Derry post ?

I don’t know how I’ve managed it but I’m alive and have info for the village.

So first, the good news which you’ve all already figured out. The Serial Killer is dead.

Tegan WW was Culverton Smith. His abilities were to write his own kill story and send up to 4 people to hospital each day, who’d remain hospitalized unless healed. SK could only kill hospitalized players.

This is why I was pushing Tegan as SK and why I suspected her and FFAd her. She was rambling about Molly maybe protecting people in the hospital and I knew I didn’t have that power. I thought she had me sussed as a roled villager when she made a mistake between me and Brendan. I now think she deliberately made a ‘mistake’ to provide herself with cover.

Now the bad news:

Desmond WW - was roled. Not saying which one without village consensus.

Doris WW - was roled. Same as Des.

I debated revealing these or claiming NRV but I have my suspicions that one or both were peeked by Moriarty and I don’t want to lead the village down the wrong path.

The worse news is that Barbara WW was Sherlock. His powers were as per the op PLUS Foresight - he had the ability to find out if he was being targeted for a munch and this was a one-time power. Look at her post when she was munched and my ‘reads’ yesterday. She said:

“I’ve reviewed 1 to 6 as promised and they’re clear” referencing the list of remaining players posted by Nigel. In my reads list I effectively cleared Abigail and Derry but offered no real reason for it. This was based on Barbara’s last post and I was amazed nobody pulled me up on it. To be clear, this absolutely does NOT clear them 100%. Derry voted for Katie and Abigail for Wendy on night one…both of whom are apparently NRVs.

Clodagh WW was indeed Dr. John Watson. Again, as per OP but was limited to healing one person daily which removed their hospitalized status and she shared a room with Mary. This obviously made me believe Brendan despite being suspicious of him to the point of including him on an FFA. Soz Brendan!

As for the rest of them:

Mary WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Munched
Frank WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – SKd so possibly Irene but I have my own theories on that.
Katie WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.
Wendy WW - Scotland Yard Officer - NRV – Attempted poisoning and munched. I don’t know what this was, they can’t have peeked her.
Oisín WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Modkilled, unlikely Irene.
Liam WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.

Now for my theories which are less theories and more fears and I’m hoping are totally bananas. Part of me wanted to push to lynch Winnie last night so we could confirm her one way or another but if Winnie is good, she’d be dead, the wolves would have another munch and we might still have Irene safe-listed. Winnie could also be Irene as someone pointed out.

My biggest fear is that Winnie’s Eurus AND one of the 4 note getters are Irene. Winnie = Eurus means a scenario with 3 villagers against 3 wolves because Eurus counts as 2 wolves. Unfortunately, I can’t single out which one. Orla referenced Winnie being crazy and Eurus is crazy and that could be a fun little in-joke for the wolves. Eva spoke up to defend Winnie which is understandable if a villager but also very convenient timing if Winnie is a wolf. Riona I’m just suspicious of and even Gabriel who I was inclined to believe could also be Irene. Send him the final note and activate the recall button on Irene and cruise to wolfy win. Unlikely but possible.

Now, I sincerely hope I’m totally wrong and kind of think that this scenario would mean an overpowered wolf team but as I reckon I’ll soon be dead I needed to get all my thoughts out there.

All that said the village still has a chance. I’ve painted a worst-case scenario here. Best case is Winnie is truthful and only 1 of that ‘core’ is a wolf. I’m hoping I stayed far enough under the radar that I’m not munched but if I’m dead, best of luck village and sorry I couldn’t be more helpful.

Molly Hooper.

Holly NRV

Jesus...expected some reaction! Everyone plotting?

Riona WW wrote: »

Everybody has been gone since I dropped a post about Derry . .

You posted a lot of Information there Conor. .

I had a lot to share Riona

We have lost 4 roles? And havent hit one wolf (maybe).....sh!t.

God dammit. I think we've been had by Winnie.

Riona WW wrote: »

Now the bad news:

Desmond WW - was roled. Not saying which one without village consensus.
Doris WW - was roled. Same as Des.
The worse news is that Barbara WW was Sherlock.
Clodagh WW was indeed Dr. John Watson.
Mary WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Munched
Frank WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – SKd so possibly Irene but I have my own theories on that.
Katie WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.
Wendy WW - Scotland Yard Officer - NRV – Attempted poisoning and munched. I don’t know what this was, they can’t have peeked her.
Oisín WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Modkilled, unlikely Irene.
Liam WW - Scotland Yard Officer – NRV – Lynched so possibly Irene.

What exactly is your role ? You don't seem to have all the information of the dead .

Molly Hooper – Molly putting her love life on hold in her pursuit for justice is making practical use of her medical skills in the morgue.

Priest: Molly receives the roles of the dead.

Also, is your post suggesting that only the BG (Brendan) is left out of the rolled players?

Drink more coffee Riona. He is saying he is withholding that info until consensus from village that he should tell us it.