Werewolf I - The Beginning | Completed - Villagers Win

Digital Solitude · 25-08-2016 10:42AM

I think if we have two wolves that could be enough, posting patterns etc May help us figure out another one, hopefully both.

tritium · 25-08-2016 10:46AM

Tigger wrote: »

How many checks has the seer done now 4?
How many a round do we lose 2 and we gain a check
If the seer has checked they should say so in their posts but all I see is people posting lists of loads of people that is too many to be a seer
We need the seer to say I have checked these 4 people they are all wolves

Should the seer come out if there are no wolves checked though

Digital Solitude · 25-08-2016 10:47AM

I'm a quasi sleeper?

My tactic would be, unless the seer has two/three definite wolves or gets to 5 confirmed surviving villagers, stay quiet

Tigger · 25-08-2016 10:56AM

tritium wrote: »

Should the seer come out if there are no wolves checked though

Depends if they have four living villagers that's huge but four dead ones is pointless assuming they checked Sulli they have three probably living names
Plus themselv s is 4 villagers which is a voting block the size of the wolves

Tigger · 25-08-2016 10:57AM

Digital Solitude wrote: »

I'm a quasi sleeper?

My tactic would be, unless the seer has two/three definite wolves or gets to 5 confirmed surviving villagers, stay quiet

That will be too late

Tigger · 25-08-2016 10:59AM

I propose we vote out daz we should have done it yesterday
If you want to defend him and you are a villager then only do so if you think I'm a wolf and am leading you astray (or if you are a wolf)

tritium · 25-08-2016 11:03AM

Tigger wrote: »

Depends if they have four living villagers that's huge but four dead ones is pointless assuming they checked Sulli they have three probably living names
Plus themselv s is 4 villagers which is a voting block the size of the wolves

So probably need a couple more or a wolf to start doing damage?

tritium · 25-08-2016 11:04AM

Tigger wrote: »

I propose we vote out daz we should have done it yesterday
If you want to defend him and you are a villager then only do so if you think I'm a wolf and am leading you astray (or if you are a wolf)

Im good with that as a start point for today. I trust you more than i trust daz at this point

mahamageehad · 25-08-2016 11:11AM

Who would we run Daz against though? Maybe Digi or Flash? Or El Hombre as he wants to go anyway?

If we lynch someone tonight, we have a almost a 50/50 chance of getting a wolf. If we do, happy days. Without a priest though we would need to assume we've killed a villager. That leaves 4 wolves and 9 villagers at end of round 4. Round 5 starts with another villager kill- that's 8 villagers v 4 wolves. Let's say we lynch another villager (because we have no way of knowing unless apprentice comes out), that leaves 7 villagers against 4 wolves, then one gets eaten leaving 6 v 4. If it gets that far we can't win as wolves control the vote.

I think we should vote as normal tonight. There should be consensus on who the seer should check out and either way, wolf or not, they come out tomorrow before 10.

tritium · 25-08-2016 11:19AM

mahamageehad wrote: »

Who would we run Daz against though? Maybe Digi or Flash? Or El Hombre as he wants to go anyway?

If we lynch someone tonight, we have a almost a 50/50 chance of getting a wolf. If we do, happy days. Without a priest though we would need to assume we've killed a villager. That leaves 4 wolves and 9 villagers at end of round 4. Round 5 starts with another villager kill- that's 8 villagers v 4 wolves. Let's say we lynch another villager (because we have no way of knowing unless apprentice comes out), that leaves 7 villagers against 4 wolves, then one gets eaten leaving 6 v 4. If it gets that far we can't win as wolves control the vote.

I think we should vote as normal tonight. There should be consensus on who the seer should check out and either way, wolf or not, they come out tomorrow before 10.

I see where youre coming from but im worried that taking a normal vote is a bit of a gamble. We really need to start nailing wolves and two of our votes have been a mess.

Tigger · 25-08-2016 11:20AM

mahamageehad wrote: »

Who would we run Daz against though? Maybe Digi or Flash? Or El Hombre as he wants to go anyway?

If we lynch someone tonight, we have a almost a 50/50 chance of getting a wolf. If we do, happy days. Without a priest though we would need to assume we've killed a villager. That leaves 4 wolves and 9 villagers at end of round 4. Round 5 starts with another villager kill- that's 8 villagers v 4 wolves. Let's say we lynch another villager (because we have no way of knowing unless apprentice comes out), that leaves 7 villagers against 4 wolves, then one gets eaten leaving 6 v 4. If it gets that far we can't win as wolves control the vote.

I think we should vote as normal tonight. There should be consensus on who the seer should check out and either way, wolf or not, they come out tomorrow before 10.

Before 10 pm I assume

Digital Solitude · 25-08-2016 11:21AM

I'm not trusting of Daz at all, as can be seen yesterday I voted for him yday before VY and Kylo became the centre of attention.

Who are our top 4 or 5 suspects?

Daz
Pp
VY
El Hombre are mine
I know I'm in a lot of people's too.

If VY isn't a wolf, I would almost guarantee mahamageehad is a wolf, however I think the chances of that are quite low.

My logic with the seer is that they're already one, if they have 4 more villagers that pretty much our odds halved. We'll have 9 suspects, if tomorrow we'll have 7. Even if the seer can have three villagers tomorrow that'll still leave us with 9 suspects. Going off history and the guesses we already have, which I think are close to the mark with two wolves, we will be in a strong place going forward.

Tigger · 25-08-2016 11:23AM

tritium wrote: »

I see where youre coming from but im worried that taking a normal vote is a bit of a gamble. We really need to start nailing wolves and two of our votes have been a mess.

I agree why have multiple candidates have one and if there has to be a second I'll be the second
Me vs daz
wolves and those not following vote me
Villagers vote daz
I'm going to leave this play out till 2145 and anyone who argues for me better have a good reason

mahamageehad · 25-08-2016 11:29AM

Digital Solitude wrote: »

I'm not trusting of Daz at all, as can be seen yesterday I voted for him yday before VY and Kylo became the centre of attention.

Who are our top 4 or 5 suspects?

Daz
Pp
VY
El Hombre are mine
I know I'm in a lot of people's too.

If VY isn't a wolf, I would almost guarantee mahamageehad is a wolf, however I think the chances of that are quite low.

My logic with the seer is that they're already one, if they have 4 more villagers that pretty much our odds halved. We'll have 9 suspects, if tomorrow we'll have 7. Even if the seer can have three villagers tomorrow that'll still leave us with 9 suspects. Going off history and the guesses we already have, which I think are close to the mark with two wolves, we will be in a strong place going forward.

We have Daz and el hombre in common on our lists. That's a good start. Vale I'm not sure of. PP I have a feeling is a villager. I'd include Flush as a potential.

MrsFlushdraw · 25-08-2016 11:29AM

Sorry about yesterday guys, a day trip ended up a long night in the pub and had a dead phone so no way to post, also I could hardly see!

Poochie and Perseyp have a hard on for me. I think both of them are wolves.

Villagers for me now would be Andy and Tigger.

Will be more active today, spent the last while catching up from late Tuesday and there were a lot of posts.

I don't think the Seer should come out unless they have 2 wolves under their belt. Once they have a list of alive villagers then it will be useful but until then stay hiddden.
Shame Suli thought they had trained a wolf and we have no way now of knowing until the endgame if they did.

Ficheall · 25-08-2016 11:32AM

Tigger wrote: »

I agree why have multiple candidates have one and if there has to be a second I'll be the second
Me vs daz
wolves and those not following vote me
Villagers vote daz
I'm going to leave this play out till 2145 and anyone who argues for me better have a good reason

You proposed this yesterday and then at the very end you switched to Kylo for no real reason. It's good to have a strategy, but you're hardly inspiring confidence in your convictions by flip-flopping all over the shop.

Also possibly worth noting that MrsFlush has been reading this thread all morning (or at least has been logged into this forum) and still not posted, despite not voting yesterday.

mahamageehad · 25-08-2016 11:33AM

Tigger wrote: »

I agree why have multiple candidates have one and if there has to be a second I'll be the second
Me vs daz
wolves and those not following vote me
Villagers vote daz
I'm going to leave this play out till 2145 and anyone who argues for me better have a good reason

If you say you're a villager, and I believe you are, then why risk putting you in a race?

I agree with you, I just think you're phrasing it in a roundabout way. What you're saying is lets lynch Daz. I'm with you on that and you can count me as a vote. Any villager that doesn't vote Daz or doesn't come up with a good reason as to why they voted someone else should be treated with suspicion. (Obvious exception being Daz of course)

tritium · 25-08-2016 11:33AM

Tigger wrote: »

I agree why have multiple candidates have one and if there has to be a second I'll be the second
Me vs daz
wolves and those not following vote me
Villagers vote daz
I'm going to leave this play out till 2145 and anyone who argues for me better have a good reason

Im good with this. No surprise if i say ill be voting daz

Ficheall · 25-08-2016 11:33AM

Ha - speak of the divil. Sorry

mahamageehad · 25-08-2016 11:34AM

Ficheall wrote: »

Ha - speak of the divil. Sorry

You Probo couldn't have timed that worse! :P

Ficheall · 25-08-2016 11:37AM

mahamageehad wrote: »

You Probo couldn't have timed that worse! :P

I dunno - had it come in just before Flush's post instead, it would have cast perhaps undue suspicion on her when she did post.

Tigger · 25-08-2016 11:39AM

Ficheall wrote: »

You proposed this yesterday and then at the very end you switched to Kylo for no real reason. It's good to have a strategy, but you're hardly inspiring confidence in your convictions by flip-flopping all over the shop.

Also possibly worth noting that MrsFlush has been reading this thread all morning (or at least has been logged into this forum) and still not posted, despite not voting yesterday.

I don't have convictions I have watching who is looking to push me off a voter
Look it's simples me or daz every vote I e made so far has been on the successful lynch of an innocent
Statically I'm playing a blinder as a wolf so it's an easy vote to point out my flaws
Well if I go tonight we are all dead so I'll not be missing much but if we get a wolf we are back in the game
So unless you think I'm a wolf or you don't suspect daz then vote daz
And yes I switched I said at this point yesterday I would switch if you read back but today I'm sticking
Vote me or daz

Tigger · 25-08-2016 11:44AM

mahamageehad wrote: »

If you say you're a villager, and I believe you are, then why risk putting you in a race?

I agree with you, I just think you're phrasing it in a roundabout way. What you're saying is lets lynch Daz. I'm with you on that and you can count me as a vote. Any villager that doesn't vote Daz or doesn't come up with a good reason as to why they voted someone else should be treated with suspicion. (Obvious exception being Daz of course)

Last post cos it was a direct question
Because I've successfully voted every time for an innocent villager
So I deserve to be put up
I'm the only person I'm 100% sure is not a wolf so if I survive and we find out later daz was a wolf the people that tried to push it on me or the people that voted me are wolves

crosstownk · 25-08-2016 11:49AM

mahamageehad wrote: »

If you say you're a villager, and I believe you are, then why risk putting you in a race?

Agreed. No point in risking the loss of a villager. It's wolves we need to kill.

Although if Tigger was a wolf then the idea of putting himself up for a vote wouldn't make much sense. Even if there was some strategy to it, it seems too much of gamble.

crosstownk · 25-08-2016 11:50AM

Tigger wrote: »

Because I've successfully voted every time for an innocent villager
So I deserve to be put up

While contrite and noble, if you are a villager then it's not helping the cause.

mahamageehad · 25-08-2016 11:52AM

Tigger wrote: »

Last post cos it was a direct question
Because I've successfully voted every time for an innocent villager
So I deserve to be put up
I'm the only person I'm 100% sure is not a wolf so if I survive and we find out later daz was a wolf the people that tried to push it on me or the people that voted me are wolves

So has tritium and so have I. I think it makes you more likely to be a villager. Either way, no point arguing semantics. I'm in for Daz, as is Tig. I'm not changing without seriously compelling evidence. I won't be here again until close to the vote but I've said my piece.

Digital Solitude · 25-08-2016 12:04PM

You've given that plan away I think, I'm not sure it's as watertight as you think but I may be missing something there. If it will realistically work how you think then we're golden, I can see all the wolves voting Daz though.

I want to put myself forward for a seer check, if I do though I'll likely be killed off as soon as I'm confirmed villager, I'm pretty much protected from the wolves for now because I'm buffing out suspect lists, as soon as I'm off them I'm no good to them.

Digital Solitude · 25-08-2016 12:06PM

Also up for putting Daz in the race, not sure who with, I think it definitely needs to be a strong suspect though.

Poochie05 · 25-08-2016 12:11PM

I'm happy to put Daz up.
I notice Flush thinks I have a hard on for him.
I only mentioned him this morning, he's voted for me twice...
I won't be back on until later today, but as it stands, I will be voting for Daz.

MrsFlushdraw · 25-08-2016 12:40PM

Poochie05 wrote: »

I'm happy to put Daz up.
I notice Flush thinks I have a hard on for him.
I only mentioned him this morning, he's voted for me twice...
I won't be back on until later today, but as it stands, I will be voting for Daz.

What part of Mrs is it that makes you think I am a man!

My usual nickname is MrsFD which should be easier for you all to write

Werewolf I - The Beginning | Completed - Villagers Win

Comments