which eoin kelly, tipp/waterford????

28-02-2003 9:53am #1

eoin for tipp, the deluxe model

Yavvy · 28-02-2003 2:36pm

there should be a third option for Faughes + Dublin

Dont Ban Me · 20-03-2003 3:49pm

Eoin Kelly for Sion is good, but he is a wanker!! Played with and against him a few times, he is a complete wanker!

But although I am a waterford man I would have to say that Eoin Kelly (Tipp) is probably better!

It pains me to say that

31-03-2003 3:01pm

seen the game the other day in semple against Cork. fu<king cracker of a game. pity we lost but the result didnt affect us in anyway. the man in question eoin from tipp got 3-5. a truly magnificent player.

Waylander · 04-04-2003 1:01pm

Tipp Eoin is class, definitely the better of the two

pretty-in-pink · 28-04-2003 9:50pm

TIPP TIPP TIPP!

Let the cats watch their backs cause we are a coming!

Deise Tom · 28-09-2009 4:58pm

Not really a contest is it.

suitcasepink · 28-09-2009 7:32pm

Loyalty made me go with the blaa.
But I think his story of why hes with Passage not Mount Sion now sums up what a *insert word here* he is!

Daysha · 28-09-2009 7:45pm

Tipp Eoin Kelly. No contest.

Deise Tom · 28-09-2009 8:42pm

Daysha wrote: »

Tipp Eoin Kelly. No contest.

Same here, the man is one of the best around in recent years.

Pride Fighter · 28-09-2009 9:45pm

Tipp Eoin is the best, voted the other way though as the Tipp one has been injury ravaged this year. This year Waterford Eoin was best due to the fact he played more.

Deise Tom · 28-09-2009 10:11pm

Pride Fighter wrote: »

Tipp Eoin is the best, voted the other way though as the Tipp one has been injury ravaged this year. This year Waterford Eoin was best due to the fact he played more.

I would think the thread is on the overall performances of the two and not just for this year as it was started six years ago. I found it this evening looking for a few other things and commented. Guess that is why it has come up near the top of the list when you log on.

Diabhal Beag · 29-09-2009 7:17pm

Overall Tipp Eoin but I prefer Waterford Eoin because he has been better over the last 2 years IMO

Deise Tom · 29-09-2009 7:29pm

Diabhal Beag wrote: »

Overall Tipp Eoin but I prefer Waterford Eoin because he has been better over the last 2 years IMO

Injuries have not been kind to the tipp man in the last year or so.

BnA · 01-10-2009 2:51pm

I cannot believe that anyone would think the Waterford Eoin Kelly is better that the Tipp one. Nothing against the fella, but he's not even in the same league. Eoin Kelly Waterford is a good striker of a ball. Good free taker. But he won't ever be the one to win hard ball for you and make his own scores.

Eoin Kelly Tipp is a class act. Definately one of the top 5 forwards in hurling in the 00's. He has struggled a bit in the last year or two with injury but he showed in the AIF that he is close to regaining his full form. I have a feeling we could see a big year from him next year

Eoin Kelly Tipp Vs John Mullane would be a closer call for me.

Deise Tom · 01-10-2009 4:46pm

BnA wrote: »

I cannot believe that anyone would think the Waterford Eoin Kelly is better that the Tipp one. Nothing against the fella, but he's not even in the same league. Eoin Kelly Waterford is a good striker of a ball. Good free taker. But he won't ever be the one to win hard ball for you and make his own scores.

Eoin Kelly Tipp is a class act. Definately one of the top 5 forwards in hurling in the 00's. He has struggled a bit in the last year or two with injury but he showed in the AIF that he is close to regaining his full form. I have a feeling we could see a big year from him next year

Agree 100%. The Passage East club mna has lots of ability but seldom if ever uses it.