[Resolved] artanevilla

CMcsporty

got a ban would like to discuss if comments deserve or constitute ban. Thank you

ShamoBuc

Hi CMcsporty, can you confirm that you have engaged with the Mod in question already and if so, please post the messages here or via PM.

CMcsporty

• You are being warned for the following post:Disparaging nicknames is abuse per charter
  https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122762104#Comment_122762104
• 

  CMcsporty  October 25

  I respect the warning and would like to add it was said in a context; whereby I think he is 'bluffing'. it just so happens its also a moniker that has been applied to him.

• 

  artanevilla  October 25

  Have a read of this post in the charter, it's pretty clear on this sort of thing:

  https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/73160775#Comment_73160775

• 

  CMcsporty  October 25

  with respect I had read the charter already 

  Reread and let’s be fair. Bluffer v fat Spanish waiter….

  And a ban I see! 

• 

  artanevilla  October 25

  The ban is for accumulated warnings, again as per charter.

  You can dispute here:

  https://www.boards.ie/categories/dispute-resolution

• 

  CMcsporty  October 26

  thanks for the dispute link 

  I do think it’s worthwhile pursuing it considering context, subject and subsequent ban

  Esp when it was in direct response to your response about “real” people.

  It’s all subjective

CMcsporty

thanks for the opportunity to review

ShamoBuc

Hi CMcsporty, I have taken a look at this and your post warranted a 1 point Warning. From the Charter - You may consider certain terms to be a bit of banter, but any nickname or phrase that is even vaguely derogatory may be considered as abuse for the purpose of the charter. - calling him Bluffer instead of his actual name does come under the above.

You may have been given some leeway - as you say - considering context, subject and subsequent ban - but it is fairly clear and you have previous with this style of posting.

Leeway was given to you last month when you received a 0 point Warning for your 'man child' comment, so it is something you need to consider more in your posting.

The Ban was indeed due to it being your second 1 point Warning - your pevious Warning was for name calling too as it happens.

The Ban will remain.

If you would like an Admin to further review please let me know.

CMcsporty

thanks for detailed response And review

I don’t want to drag this on

How long is a 1 point ban for btw?

As I said I don’t want to go on….I’m 6 year’s contributing to this platform….2 warnings….

ShamoBuc

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122772035#Comment_122772035

Warnings in the Soccer Forum are counted back 2 years and you have two 1 point warnings in that period and a 2 week ban was therefore given.

CMcsporty

I thought ‘leeway’ not granted for the first warning? And it It was a 0 point warning.

So it’s a 1 point warning. No?

I know mod must be a thankless job. Just think context is important to note and consider.

ShamoBuc

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122772350#Comment_122772350

Your first 1 point warning was when you decided to call Carvajal a 'prick' - never going to be any leeway there.

You then got a 0 point warning - a reminder that certain posts are not going to be allowed again.

You then got a 1 point warning for 'Bluffer'.

Over the past 2 years, you have two 1 point warnings in the Soccer Forum and hence a 2 week ban.

0 point warnings do not count towards Bans.

CMcsporty

I completely forgot about the statement about of Carvajal been a prick. Fair enough. Sorry that you had to search back.

Will leave it at that.

Thanks for taking the time.

ShamoBuc

No problem.

Thread can be marked as resolved,