Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Tracker mortgage

  • 23-03-2017 1:26pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 76 ✭✭


    Here goes a question of the back of something I saw on the news this hour...
    I bought my house in January 2007 on a 100% mortgage (I know....not my finest moment!!!!) through EBS. I don't recall them offering me a tracker mortgage. Should they have done, or was a tracker retained solely for those on a 92% loan?
    Do I have any grounds for complaint, and if so, to whom?


Comments

  • Moderators Posts: 6,916 ✭✭✭Spocker


    There was no obligation on EBS (or any mortgage provider) to offer any of their clients a tracker rate at that time, so you have no grounds for a complaint.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 751 ✭✭✭dozy doctor


    Apologies for hijacking this thread....

    We bought our home in February 2005 with PTSB through a broker on the East Coast.

    We are on a variable rate but my wife went in an inquired about changing our mortgage from Variable to a Tracker,
    and was told at the time by the broker that there was no difference in the mortgages and that we should just stay as we are...

    Can we protest this and do you think that we have grounds for a complaint..
    The Broker in question is no longer providing mortgages for PTSB


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,443 ✭✭✭phormium


    You can try but I doubt you have any case, do you have all of this in writing or can somehow prove the conversation too place?

    The broker in 2005 did not have a crystal ball and could not have known how valuable a tracker would become, the rates may have been the same at the time so there would have been no obvious benefit to switching over but ultimately it was your decision.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 491 ✭✭brendan86


    Apologies for hijacking this thread....

    We bought our home in February 2005 with PTSB through a broker on the East Coast.

    We are on a variable rate but my wife went in an inquired about changing our mortgage from Variable to a Tracker,
    and was told at the time by the broker that there was no difference in the mortgages and that we should just stay as we are...

    Can we protest this and do you think that we have grounds for a complaint..
    The Broker in question is no longer providing mortgages for PTSB

    No you can't, the whole thing about the tracker cases is that they we're on a tracker mortgage then fixed there mortgage for a certain length of time and when the fixed period was over the bank put them on varable rate when in fact they should have reverted back to there tracker (or at least been offered it)

    If you never signed up to a tracker at any stage how can you expect to be put on one?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 751 ✭✭✭dozy doctor


    phormium wrote: »
    The broker in 2005 did not have a crystal ball and could not have known how valuable a tracker would become, the rates may have been the same at the time so there would have been no obvious benefit to switching over but ultimately it was your decision.

    I went in to speak with them today and it turns out that the rates at the time were more favourable to have a variable as tracker rates were slightly more expensive then...

    Gotta be worth the try, right...


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,443 ✭✭✭phormium


    I think you haven't a hope, you were never on a tracker so can't get back what you were never done out of unlike other tracker holders.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 491 ✭✭brendan86


    I went in to speak with them today and it turns out that the rates at the time were more favourable to have a variable as tracker rates were slightly more expensive then...

    Gotta be worth the try, right...

    I'm in the exact same boat as you, although I had a tracker but switched my mortgage. Went to a broker for switchinh, broker advised me go variable as it was cheaper at time. I agreed, could have saved tens of thousands to this day had I not taken his advice but such is life.

    I never had a tracker with my new mortgage company, how could one expect just because a tracker it so valuable now we should be entitled to it cause we took what turns out to be bad advice from a broker.

    But it's a disgrace Irish mortgage companies are aloud to extortionate us with such high variable rate when the ECB is so low! They got there bailout, there now starting see profits again and still screw us.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,404 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    I went in to speak with them today and it turns out that the rates at the time were more favourable to have a variable as tracker rates were slightly more expensive then...

    Gotta be worth the try, right...

    You were given advice at the time by a broker, which at the time offered you a more favourable deal. You accepted that advice, but now you think you're entitled to a tracker you were never on? Ah here.

    As banks will very clearly tell you, rates can go up as well as down.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,499 ✭✭✭jarvis


    Apologies also for hijacking but seems to be good responses here.

    In Feb 2008 I took a mortgage with Ptsb and they gave me a tracker mortgage.
    Their tracker at the time was ecb +0.75

    I was given a 12 month discounted tracker rathe of ecb +0.5

    When 12 months Discount ended I wanted the original ecb +0.75

    But the only tracker option they would give was ecb +2.25

    They gave that option and a lower variable along with a lower fixed rate.

    I chose the tracker of ecb +2.25

    I complained again in 2015 and they made a final decision that I chose ecb +2.25 so they did nothing wrong even though I pointed out I would be on ecb +0.75 if they hadn't applied their "Special Offer" and that I chose that option because they refused any other tracker option.

    I have sent it off this week to the financial ombudsman but I'm inside if I do actually have a case and if I would be classed as one of the people who're part of the tracker mortgage scandal.

    Anyone got an opinion?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10 davesull


    Hi Jarvis

    I am very interested to hear how you get on as I am in a similar situation.

    I too got a tracker in early 2008 with 1% above ECB. It was discounted to .75 for 12 months and then after 12 months jumped to 3.25% above ECB or else I could go to a fixed rate.

    Did you contact Permanent TSB directly in recent times?

    Cheers
    David


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,499 ✭✭✭jarvis


    davesull wrote: »
    Hi Jarvis

    I am very interested to hear how you get on as I am in a similar situation.

    I too got a tracker in early 2008 with 1% above ECB. It was discounted to .75 for 12 months and then after 12 months jumped to 3.25% above ECB or else I could go to a fixed rate.

    Did you contact Permanent TSB directly in recent times?

    Cheers
    David

    I had a sit down meeting with them in 2015. Their response was "computer says no".

    I wrote a formal complaint in 2015 after that meeting and they replied saying "computer says no".


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,724 ✭✭✭Apiarist


    jarvis wrote: »
    Apologies also for hijacking but seems to be good responses here.

    In Feb 2008 I took a mortgage with Ptsb and they gave me a tracker mortgage.
    Their tracker at the time was ecb +0.75
    I am in a bit of a similar situation, had the original tracker ecb+1% in 2008, then went with a discount fixed rate. After that PTSB (in 2009) have offered me a choice of variable, more expensive tracker (probably ecb+3.5%) or fixed. I chose the variable as I hoped to switch the mortgage to another bank :ermm: So now I wonder if they had an obligation to offer me the original tracker deal in 2009?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 46 herlihyd


    Hi guys, looking for advise, myself and my partner had a tracker mortgage in 2006 we split up in 2007 and I wanted to buy him out, so I went to my bank and handed payslips etc, they came back and saidvi could afford to repayments on my own but would need a new mortgage number, which I thought ok, weeks later I went in to sign the paperwork, and realised I wouldn't have my tracker it was a new fixed rate, if course I was upset and was just told either sign for the new fixed rate or loose my home because they knew I was under pressure from my ex to pay him off . I asked could I continue with my tracker on my outstanding balance and go on a fixed rate on the extra cash I needed to pay off my ex, they Said no, but later on as in years later, I heard stories of people buying out their ex partners and held onto their tracker.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,095 ✭✭✭ANXIOUS


    herlihyd wrote: »
    Hi guys, looking for advise, myself and my partner had a tracker mortgage in 2006 we split up in 2007 and I wanted to buy him out, so I went to my bank and handed payslips etc, they came back and saidvi could afford to repayments on my own but would need a new mortgage number, which I thought ok, weeks later I went in to sign the paperwork, and realised I wouldn't have my tracker it was a new fixed rate, if course I was upset and was just told either sign for the new fixed rate or loose my home because they knew I was under pressure from my ex to pay him off . I asked could I continue with my tracker on my outstanding balance and go on a fixed rate on the extra cash I needed to pay off my ex, they Said no, but later on as in years later, I heard stories of people buying out their ex partners and held onto their tracker.

    So you took out a new mortgage and they explained to you the terms and conditions of the new mortgage and you went ahead with it?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 46 herlihyd


    It wasn't explained to me until the day I went into sign, I noticed my tracker was been taken from me, and with them telling me I'd loose my home unless I agreed to the new terms, sure I was 25 yrs old, they knew I hassle and pressure I was under to pay my ex partner off, so of course I panicked and signed, but they were still offering tracker mortgages, why was I not offered even with it being a new mortgage, I feel they knew exactly what they were doing and took advantage of my situation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,443 ✭✭✭phormium


    Some banks allowed couples to remove one from the existing mortgage, whatever the type, and continue on with it in one name if they had sufficient income. Some did not and insisted on a brand new mortgage.

    If you actually borrowed extra money that makes it much likely that it would have to be a brand new mortgage in your own name only rather than just the removing of a name.

    But in 2007 trackers were still available so should in theory have been available on the new mortgage, unless you only qualified for the higher mortgage based on taking a fixed rate, some fixed rate mortgages were not stress tested for repayments meaning that customers could borrow more if the chose a fixed rate than they could on a variable rate.

    No obvious reason why you couldn't have gone for a tracker at that time as they were still available unless it was a question of affordability. You could have applied to another lender for one.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,095 ✭✭✭ANXIOUS


    herlihyd wrote: »
    It wasn't explained to me until the day I went into sign, I noticed my tracker was been taken from me, and with them telling me I'd loose my home unless I agreed to the new terms, sure I was 25 yrs old, they knew I hassle and pressure I was under to pay my ex partner off, so of course I panicked and signed, but they were still offering tracker mortgages, why was I not offered even with it being a new mortgage, I feel they knew exactly what they were doing and took advantage of my situation.

    You could've went to any bank in the country, you didn't need to stay with your existing bank. Also It was around that time banks stopped tracker mortgages all together.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 46 herlihyd


    Trackers were still been given out a year later, to apply to another bank would have taken longer, like I said I was under pressure from my ex.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,443 ✭✭✭phormium


    Well unfortunately that was not going to be of concern to the bank, they don't appear to have done anything wrong in your case.

    Trackers finished from around mid 2008


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,404 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    herlihyd wrote: »
    Trackers were still been given out a year later, to apply to another bank would have taken longer, like I said I was under pressure from my ex.

    You were taking out a new mortgage, the bank was under no obligation to offer you a tracker on a new mortgage. One of the main issues with trackers was that customers that were initially offered a tracker and went onto a fixed rate at some time during the course of the mortgage and then came off the fixed rate were no longer offered the tracker and they should have been.

    A bank is not ever obliged to offer a tracker mortgage on a new mortgage, it's entirely at their discretion, and even if they were offering them to customers a year later, they chose not to offer one to you. Being under pressure from your ex is not their fault. An application to another bank might have taken longer, but not forever, your ex would have had to wait, what else could they have done.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    herlihyd wrote: »
    Hi guys, looking for advise, myself and my partner had a tracker mortgage in 2006 we split up in 2007 and I wanted to buy him out, so I went to my bank and handed payslips etc, they came back and saidvi could afford to repayments on my own but would need a new mortgage number, which I thought ok, weeks later I went in to sign the paperwork, and realised I wouldn't have my tracker it was a new fixed rate, if course I was upset and was just told either sign for the new fixed rate or loose my home because they knew I was under pressure from my ex to pay him off . I asked could I continue with my tracker on my outstanding balance and go on a fixed rate on the extra cash I needed to pay off my ex, they Said no, but later on as in years later, I heard stories of people buying out their ex partners and held onto their tracker.

    Banks were obliged under the consumer protection code which was in force from August 2006 to offer ALL suitable options.

    I reckon you have a case.

    Possibly go onto the specialist site askaboutmoney.com and post the same query.

    A lot of experienced mortgage / tracker posters there and some may have similar story


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,443 ✭✭✭phormium


    But it may not have been a suitable option if affordability criteria only allowed for a fixed.

    Worth a try I suppose, everyone is jumping on the tracker bandwagon these days but it doesn't sound like a good case to me.

    I would agree it's worth posting on askaboutmoney to get more opinions.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 849 ✭✭✭Tenigate


    victor8600 wrote: »
    I am in a bit of a similar situation, had the original tracker ecb+1% in 2008, then went with a discount fixed rate. After that PTSB (in 2009) have offered me a choice of variable, more expensive tracker (probably ecb+3.5%) or fixed. I chose the variable as I hoped to switch the mortgage to another bank :ermm: So now I wonder if they had an obligation to offer me the original tracker deal in 2009?

    There is a high chance that you'd be entitled to the original rate.. they currently have a team of people dealing with these cases, though they generally wait until you are selling your house or change provider before they offer to investigate for you- by which time, they'll hope you tell them you don't want to investigate (and hold up the sale).
    A very, very despicable bank and imo treated their customers the worst during the downturn.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,189 ✭✭✭DANNY2014


    Have you to write to the bank first to get them to investigate your case... Tracker was an option in original contract and again on another document in 06 but disappears from 08...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 146 ✭✭charleville


    Hi,

    Seems a lot of people are disgruntled with the banks (and rightly so in many cases).

    Myself and my buddy bought a house in 2006 through Ics and was advised to fix at the time for 2 years even though we could have opted for the tracker, we done this just for a bit of stability to get on our feet etc and get things going.

    After this 2 years was up (06-08), we fixed again for 2 more years as the fix rate was considerably lower than the tracker rate at the time.

    Then In 2010 the Bank sent us out an offer letter, but this time it only gave options of fixing for either 2, 3 or 5 years!! No tracker available, no variable even available... we Just went with what we thought was the bet option we had and fixed for 3 years.

    However after the 3 years we received a letter stating that keeping in line with the central bank etc we were being reverted to a tracker mortgage and we didn’t need to do anymore etc, was delighted at the time, but was also very pee’d off that it wasn’t offered to us in 2010 and we genuinely struggled to keep up those repayments at the time.

    My question is, what are my options or rights here or what should I do now about not being offered the low tracker rate when I should have ?

    Tks for your time


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,240 ✭✭✭Oral Surgeon


    A very gray area IMO

    When the first fixed rate term was up, you should have been offered the tracker again and it sounds like you were offered the tracker and choose the fixed....
    I'm a little uncertain if you should have been offered the tracker after the second fixed rate term as you rejected the tracker option when given the chance but I may well be wrong. Odd that you were only offered fixed terms!!

    Anyway, the fact that they came back and put you on the tracker 3 years later is them essentially admitting that they neglected to offer you what you were entitled to.

    I'd say that you have a case.

    What bank is it??
    Hi,

    Seems a lot of people are disgruntled with the banks (and rightly so in many cases).

    Myself and my buddy bought a house in 2006 through Ics and was advised to fix at the time for 2 years even though we could have opted for the tracker, we done this just for a bit of stability to get on our feet etc and get things going.

    After this 2 years was up (06-08), we fixed again for 2 more years as the fix rate was considerably lower than the tracker rate at the time.

    Then In 2010 the Bank sent us out an offer letter, but this time it only gave options of fixing for either 2, 3 or 5 years!! No tracker available, no variable even available... we Just went with what we thought was the bet option we had and fixed for 3 years.

    However after the 3 years we received a letter stating that keeping in line with the central bank etc we were being reverted to a tracker mortgage and we didn’t need to do anymore etc, was delighted at the time, but was also very pee’d off that it wasn’t offered to us in 2010 and we genuinely struggled to keep up those repayments at the time.

    My question is, what are my options or rights here or what should I do now about not being offered the low tracker rate when I should have ?

    Tks for your time


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 146 ✭✭charleville


    Hi there,

    Yes that is what I think too, not just jumping the band wagon here but it seems to be black and white in my case ?
    I’m not sure though which is why I’m asking advice.

    The bank was ICS which is now Bank of Ireland
    A very gray area IMO

    When the first fixed rate term was up, you should have been offered the tracker again and it sounds like you were offered the tracker and choose the fixed....
    I'm a little uncertain if you should have been offered the tracker after the second fixed rate term as you rejected the tracker option when given the chance but I may well be wrong. Odd that you were only offered fixed terms!!

    Anyway, the fact that they came back and put you on the tracker 3 years later is them essentially admitting that they neglected to offer you what you were entitled to.

    I'd say that you have a case.

    What bank is it??


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,240 ✭✭✭Oral Surgeon


    Hi there,

    Yes that is what I think too, not just jumping the band wagon here but it seems to be black and white in my case ?
    I’m not sure though which is why I’m asking advice.

    The bank was ICS which is now Bank of Ireland


    Call them

    This is the dedicated line for BoI
    1890882722


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 146 ✭✭charleville


    Thanks oral surgeon, I’ll try call them tomorrow.

    Hope they don’t try and fob me off though.
    Call them

    This is the dedicated line for BoI
    1890882722


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭Eire Go Brach


    Could someone tell me the dates that this applies to?

    I got my mortgage in 2006. Fixed for 2 years. Offered and took tracker in 2008. 1.25 over the ECB. I’m probably fine. But might as well jump on the bandwagon. Tracker to high etc.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 532 ✭✭✭beechwood55


    Could someone tell me the dates that this applies to?

    I got my mortgage in 2006. Fixed for 2 years. Offered and took tracker in 2008. 1.25 over the ECB. I’m probably fine. But might as well jump on the bandwagon. Tracker to high etc.

    So are you saying that you have been on a tracker since 2008 at a rate of ECB + 1.25%.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    Could someone tell me the dates that this applies to?

    I got my mortgage in 2006. Fixed for 2 years. Offered and took tracker in 2008. 1.25 over the ECB. I’m probably fine. But might as well jump on the bandwagon. Tracker to high etc.

    Standard tracker rate was 0.95% to 1.25% depending on bank and loan to value.

    Thank your lucky stars you have a 1.25% tracker


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭Eire Go Brach


    So are you saying that you have been on a tracker since 2008 at a rate of ECB + 1.25%.
    Yes. After posting I done some research. Looks like I’m in in the clear. Sure was worth looking into.

    Thank my luck star I was not conned by the bankers more like it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,724 ✭✭✭Apiarist


    jarvis wrote: »
    I have sent it off this week to the financial ombudsman but I'm inside if I do actually have a case and if I would be classed as one of the people who're part of the tracker mortgage scandal.
    In the news today, "[All ]Permanent TSB customers returned to correct tracker mortgage". Have you received a reply from PTSB or the financial ombudsman?
    I called PTSB a week ago and they said that that my original tracker was "a promotion to attract new customers" and they had no obligation to return my mortgage to it after a period on the fixed rate. I need to look into this in more detail, and get the original contract from them or the broker.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11 Superniamh


    Can anyone tell me the meaning of a "variable annuity"? Our mortgage documentation from
    Aib from 2008 states that once our fixed rate ends our mortgage will revert to a variable annuity. Could this be either the standard variable rate or a tracker? It's all very confusing!!


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    Superniamh wrote: »
    Can anyone tell me the meaning of a "variable annuity"? Our mortgage documentation from
    Aib from 2008 states that once our fixed rate ends our mortgage will revert to a variable annuity. Could this be either the standard variable rate or a tracker? It's all very confusing!!

    That's a standard variable rate.

    Only if you originally had a tracker or an entitlement written in a contract would you possibly be entitled to one back.

    By mid 2008, trackers were effectively gone from the market (some banks ended them earlier). So if your mortgage started in 2008 it is higly unlikely that you could be entitled to a tracker as the options was not there.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11 Superniamh


    CeilingFly wrote: »
    That's a standard variable rate.

    Only if you originally had a tracker or an entitlement written in a contract would you possibly be entitled to one back.

    By mid 2008, trackers were effectively gone from the market (some banks ended them earlier). So if your mortgage started in 2008 it is higly unlikely that you could be entitled to a tracker as the options was not there.

    Thanks ceilingfly, I've just noticed form an earlier mortgage letter of offer on the first page that we were offered the following:-

    Loan Type Interest rate/description
    Variable annuity Trackerhome LTV >80%<€500k

    Rate Margin
    3.5% 1.1%

    I would attach a photo if I knew how!!

    This is our original mortgage offer! However shortly after, we realised we required additional funds to build and when those letters of offer arrived in 2008 the wording is different!

    It states that at the end of our fixed period of 3 years our mortgage will revert to a
    Variable Annuity 5.25%.

    Even more confused now!!

    I think I'll ask for my docs from AIB!!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 849 ✭✭✭Tenigate


    Superniamh wrote: »
    Thanks ceilingfly, I've just noticed form an earlier mortgage letter of offer on the first page that we were offered the following <snip>

    It may have been your original offer, but you did not accept it.

    Simply by allowing the offer to lapse, or by rejecting the offer, or by changing the terms (as in your case), that offer is gone forever. so that letter means very little.

    Your only hope is to say you were lead to believe by the bank representative that you were taking out a product with the same terms as the original "offer" prior to asking for the increased amount - and the bank sold you a completely different product.
    (The bank may argue that since your original "offer", the tracker product was discontinued or did not apply due to the amount you were looking for, or the term)

    If you went through a broker, you have even less of a leg to stand on with the bank - you'd need to argue that your broker made a mistake or mis-sold you the product.

    Anyway, there is no harm in phoning AIB, ask them if you are on a tracker and is the rate ECB+1.1%. If not, ask them for copies of all documents on your file.
    Superniamh wrote: »
    Also, in our T&Cs attached to the later 2008 letter it states that at the end of any fixed rate period we can choose between another fixed rate, a variable interest rate, or a tracker rate!!

    OK just saw this.. trying to piece together snippets of information you're scattering across two different threads....

    Variable annuity just means you pay interest and capital and the rate can vary. It doesn't mean it's not a tracker.

    The bit in bold is the relevant bit. If your new contract says you were allowed to revert to a tracker, the bank should have offered it. It appears they did not, or if they did you decided not to accept it.

    Phone your bank and find out what rate you're currently paying, and whether they offered you a tracker at the end of the fixed period.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    Superniamh wrote: »
    Thanks ceilingfly, I've just noticed form an earlier mortgage letter of offer on the first page that we were offered the following:-

    Loan Type Interest rate/description
    Variable annuity Trackerhome LTV >80%<€500k

    Rate Margin
    3.5% 1.1%

    I would attach a photo if I knew how!!

    This is our original mortgage offer! However shortly after, we realised we required additional funds to build and when those letters of offer arrived in 2008 the wording is different!

    It states that at the end of our fixed period of 3 years our mortgage will revert to a
    Variable Annuity 5.25%.

    Even more confused now!!

    I think I'll ask for my docs from AIB!!

    Looks like you had an offer of a tracker and then you made a new application (an increased amount would require a new application) and at the time of that application, the trackers were no longer offered.

    No harm in chekcing all the paperwork, but I'd assume that an increeased amount would entail a new application. Pity they didnlt point it out to you that trackers were gone - but back then the trackers were a similar rate to standard variable.

    edit - in the post in the other thread you say that the fixed rate instruction claims you will got to variable, fixed or tracker.

    That could be avaluable piece of paper.

    You need to contcat a financial specialist. Padraic Kissane of Kissane Financial Services is the specialist in this - google him and send him details. It may take a few days for response as he's very busy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11 Superniamh


    CeilingFly wrote: »
    Looks like you had an offer of a tracker and then you made a new application (an increased amount would require a new application) and at the time of that application, the trackers were no longer offered.

    No harm in chekcing all the paperwork, but I'd assume that an increeased amount would entail a new application. Pity they didnlt point it out to you that trackers were gone - but back then the trackers were a similar rate to standard variable.

    edit - in the post in the other thread you say that the fixed rate instruction claims you will got to variable, fixed or tracker.

    That could be avaluable piece of paper.

    You need to contcat a financial specialist. Padraic Kissane of Kissane Financial Services is the specialist in this - google him and send him details. It may take a few days for response as he's very busy.


    Thanks Ceilngfly and Tenigate!!

    I have requested the whole file from AIB and have been in touch with Padraic Kissane, who has been really helpful!! They felt we might have a case based on clause 3.2 in our terms and conditions which states that at the and of any fixed rate period we can choose between the three options as stated above. They want us to forward our whole mortgage file when it arrives.

    I also sent aib a query on Tuesday about it and we have just received a letter today from them stating we are included in their review!!

    I'm still thinking there's something very peculiar in the wording of both 2007 and 2008 offer letters in that variable annuity seemed to have actually meant tracker in 2007. Then the 2008 contract letter on which we drew down the loan states that we will revert to this "variable annuity".

    I guess I can't really be certain until we get the signed copies from the bank as we only kept the unsigned copies ourselves.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,057 ✭✭✭irish bloke


    Folks,

    Does anyone know if any of the banks are permitting you to transfer your remaining current tracker mortgage in full over to a new property?

    They all seem to offer this service with different penalties etc..

    Also do you think they will be forced to allow this to happen especially in light of the current scandal.

    Thanks..


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    Folks,

    Does anyone know if any of the banks are permitting you to transfer your remaining current tracker mortgage in full over to a new property?

    They all seem to offer this service with different penalties etc..

    Also do you think they will be forced to allow this to happen especially in light of the current scandal.

    Thanks..

    Why?

    You'd be ending one agreement and starting a completely new one.

    Some will allow you transfer remaining tracker balance at a premium. But that's their own offers and there is and there will be no direction ftom central bank to make them transfer a rate.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,057 ✭✭✭irish bloke


    CeilingFly wrote: »
    Why?

    You'd be ending one agreement and starting a completely new one.

    Some will allow you transfer remaining tracker balance at a premium. But that's their own offers and there is and there will be no direction ftom central bank to make them transfer a rate.

    I was referring to keeping the existing balance of the current tracker.

    Example:
    • €300,000 left on current tracker
    • New house €400,000
    • keep existing tracker agreement of €300,000 and have new agreement on the €100,000

    I don't see why I cant move the tracker without penalty.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭CeilingFly


    I was referring to keeping the existing balance of the current tracker.

    Example:
    • €300,000 left on current tracker
    • New house €400,000
    • keep existing tracker agreement of €300,000 and have new agreement on the €100,000

    I don't see why I cant move the tracker without penalty.

    A mortgage loan is attached to a specific property. Once that property is sold / transferred to a different person or entity the mortgage is expunged. Effectively it no longer exists.

    Think the otehr way.

    You have 300k left on a mortgage at 4.25% and wish to sell and move to a new property and take a new mortagge out at a "new borrower" rate of 2.99% - thankfully the bank can't force you to stay at 4.25% as its a new loan under new conditions and for a new term.

    Some bank have "tracker mover products" but that's a marketing name. Its still a new loan, but would have different terms to the balance of the new purchase price.

    e.g. Bank of Ireland will allow you 5 years on the transfer amount at your tracker rate + an extra 1%. Not a great deal

    AIB do similar but for the full remaining tracker term. KBC will discuss options. Not sure about Ulster or PTSB.


Advertisement