Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Christening..?

  • 15-09-2015 8:43pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 748 ✭✭✭


    Hi, neither myself nor my fiancee are religious and don't go to mass. However we're hoping to have put little fella (3 months) christened more out of tradition than anything else and to help get into schools if necessary etc. Some might call me a hypocrite - but there ya go! Anyway, how do I go about arranging a christening with a priest? Do I need to make my face known at mass beforehand??!

    Thanks - sorry I'm just totally clueless here!


Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,449 ✭✭✭✭pwurple


    Congratulations on your new baby!

    To answer your question, you just have a chat with the priest about it. After mass they usually are around, or drop into the parish office.

    Some of the big churches put the info on their weekly newsletter, maybe pick one of those up from the church door and have a read.

    The priest will tell you what you need to bring along, it's usually a baptism candle, a white shawl or garment to put over the baby during the ceremony... And godparents.


  • Hosted Moderators Posts: 10,661 ✭✭✭✭John Mason


    You will probably need to do some sort of preparation class and be seen to attend the services for a couple of month previous. but first talk to the priest.

    It will depend on how fed up he is of this kind of thing


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,214 ✭✭✭cbyrd


    Call your parochial house, the housekeeper will give you the details of when the registration night is, they call it a baptismal course, you get a form to fill on the night and you get details of what to bring on the day.
    I've done 4... Struggling to find the interest to do the fifth.. I could give the course at this stage... 

    Google baptisms for your parish, should find the information there too.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,919 ✭✭✭dori_dormer


    Hi, neither myself nor my fiancee are religious and don't go to mass. However we're hoping to have put little fella (3 months) christened more out of tradition than anything else and to help get into schools if necessary etc. Some might call me a hypocrite - but there ya go! Anyway, how do I go about arranging a christening with a priest? Do I need to make my face known at mass beforehand??!

    Thanks - sorry I'm just totally clueless here!

    Just in case it might change your mind if you hadn't thought or heard about other options ( but likely not lol!) lots of people have welcoming ceremonies in their homes or hotel/pub event rooms, and have someone say nice things about the child and assign people to look out for the child. We ourselves just had a party!

    Also there is a movement happening at the moment to remove the Catholic bias on entry to primary schools. It's doing pretty well!

    Enjoy the christening! My sister had to go to mass every week for a month before the event and swear she lived with my mum, in the hope to get her son into my mums local primary. Lovely day though!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    Jeez people seem to be jumping through hoops here to get their kids christened!? My son was christened 2 years ago and my daughter christened 1 year ago. Both times I just rang the parish priest who arranged a date that suited. Met up with him for about 15 minutes in his house a couple days before the ceremony. Them turned up to the ceremony with the godparents etc. he did tell me they are introducing an information evening which may become mandatory but one year ago it wasn't so we didn't go. Very easy and straight forward altogether. Our parish priest is a Monsignor aswell as wouldn't be the easy going type. But he made this very straight forward for us. And we don't go to mass! Perhaps it depends which priest you get....


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,171 ✭✭✭Ms2011


    Sligo1 wrote: »
    Jeez people seem to be jumping through hoops here to get their kids christened!? My son was christened 2 years ago and my daughter christened 1 year ago. Both times I just rang the parish priest who arranged a date that suited. Met up with him for about 15 minutes in his house a couple days before the ceremony. Them turned up to the ceremony with the godparents etc. he did tell me they are introducing an information evening which may become mandatory but one year ago it wasn't so we didn't go. Very easy and straight forward altogether. Our parish priest is a Monsignor aswell as wouldn't be the easy going type. But he made this very straight forward for us. And we don't go to mass! Perhaps it depends which priest you get....

    We were the same pretty much.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 750 ✭✭✭Ashbx


    I wouldn't quite say people are jumping through hoops! If you want your child christened in a church you should pay a bit of respect and at least attend a couple of masses before expecting the priest to christen your baby.

    I was recently a godparent at my nephews christening and the priest made the parents attend for a couple of sundays prior to the christening date. Then the parents and the godparents had to have a meeting the day before but it was quite relaxed and felt more like a chat to get to know us!

    I think it would be very unreasonable to expect a church to hold your christening without putting any effort into that church whatsoever. A bit of respect will go a long way IMO.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,909 ✭✭✭greenman09


    We had our christening last year. Had to go to a christening meeting with someone from the community with the priest.
    We had the christening in 2 masses. First was our welcome into be community and the second was the sacrament part of it. No requirement to go to mass every week or anything.
    We aren't mass goers ourselves but we knew we had to do these things in order for baby to be christened


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    Ashbx wrote: »
    I wouldn't quite say people are jumping through hoops!

    If you want your child christened in A bit of respect will go a long way IMO.

    A previous poster said that she knows someone who had to go to mass every Sunday for a month and swear she lived with her mother before the event. I most certainly would call that jumping through hoops tbh.

    There are different ways people may pay respect to the Catholic Church and I don't necessarily think that means going to mass two times before a christening if the couple have no intention to go after the event or don't go regularly anyway. We pay our respects differently. The children will have a catholic upbringing and may go to church if they wish. They will take religion class. I pray regularly even if I don't go to church regularly. And I try my best to treat others with kindness and be as giving as I can. And various other things....

    I don't think by going to church twice before a christening means you have paid more respect to the Catholic Church than those who haven't done the same.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 750 ✭✭✭Ashbx


    Sligo1 wrote: »
    A previous poster said that she knows someone who had to go to mass every Sunday for a month and swear she lived with her mother before the event. I most certainly would call that jumping through hoops tbh.

    There are different ways people may pay respect to the Catholic Church and I don't necessarily think that means going to mass two times before a christening if the couple have no intention to go after the event or don't go regularly anyway. We pay our respects differently. The children will have a catholic upbringing and may go to church if they wish. They will take religion class. I pray regularly even if I don't go to church regularly. And I try my best to treat others with kindness and be as giving as I can. And various other things....

    I don't think by going to church twice before a christening means you have paid more respect to the Catholic Church than those who haven't done the same.

    Going to mass four times in your childs lifetime is jumping through hoops...really?

    Im not saying by just going twice means is the only way you respect the catholic church but if you want the priest to make the effort to christen your child, why cant you make the effort with them too? I agree, we all pay our respects in our own way, but its the only thing the church want the parents to do so why not just do it?!


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    Ashbx wrote: »
    Going to mass four times in your childs lifetime is jumping through hoops...really?

    Im not saying by just going twice means is the only way you respect the catholic church but if you want the priest to make the effort to christen your child, why cant you make the effort with them too? I agree, we all pay our respects in our own way, but its the only thing the church want the parents to do so why not just do it?!

    In your previous post you stated that if people want their children to be christened they should "pay a bit of respect and at least attend a couple of masses" and "a bit of respect will go a long way". Those were your direct quotes and I was simply stating that going to mass is not the only way to show respect. IMHO, for example, doing the things I do and will teach my children about their faith, far far far outweigh the benefits of going to mass only twice before the child's christening. And imho, that pays far far greater respect to the Catholic Church then going to mass 2 or 4 times as you state "in the child's entire life". You appear to be quite hung up on this notion of attending a couple of masses.

    If our priest requested our presence at a couple of masses prior to the christening of our children then of course we would have attended. But he did not. I have heard many stories of people having to yes... wait for it... "jump through hoops" in order to have their child christened. That is my opinion which I am quite entitled to. And all I am merely saying here in response to your initial post is that people do and can pay respect in different ways. Your initial post seemed to say that the only way people can pay respect is to go to mass a couple of times. That is not true. That is just what the priest wants as a prior recommendation. Which is fine aswell.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 499 ✭✭greenflash


    We have three kids. We're not religious and don't go to mass so we decided not to be hypocritical and have not had our kids christened. I want the best education and prospects for our children and that means not contributing to the perpetuation of farcical superstitious cults presiding over the education of Ireland 's young citizens.

    Have a party for friends and family, welcome your kids into your lives and raise them in a caring and loving environment.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 396 ✭✭barneyrub


    I think there should be more 'hoops to jump through'. Might stop people doing it just because and in turn push it further down the requirements for getting into certain schools. If everyone is baptised they won't change the enrollment policy


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 750 ✭✭✭Ashbx


    barneyrub wrote: »
    I think there should be more 'hoops to jump through'. Might stop people doing it just because and in turn push it further down the requirements for getting into certain schools. If everyone is baptised they won't change the enrollment policy

    The fact that in this day and age it is a requirement to get into certain schools is ridiculous!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,708 ✭✭✭BeardySi


    greenflash wrote: »
    Have a party for friends and family, welcome your kids into your lives and raise them in a caring and loving environment.

    We tried to do this, the MOL wouldn't invite anyone - it wouldn't be right if there wasn't a christening apparently - Uncle soandso would take offence etc...

    Was tempted to tell them all to go take a running jump and do it anyway, but that would have made it all about scoring points on them and not about the baby. In the end we spend a lovely weekend with my family instead.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,436 ✭✭✭✭Pawwed Rig


    Ms2011 wrote: »
    We were the same pretty much.

    Us too. Call them to arrange, turn up on the day with some kind of donation and never darken their door again. Simples. Pity it is a necessity to get educational options in this country but that is another conversation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,023 ✭✭✭testaccount123


    Pawwed Rig wrote: »
    Pity it is a necessity to get educational options in this country but that is another conversation.
    Its the same conversation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 750 ✭✭✭Ashbx


    Pawwed Rig wrote: »
    Us too. Call them to arrange, turn up on the day with some kind of donation and never darken their door again. Simples. Pity it is a necessity to get educational options in this country but that is another conversation.

    Id be quite curious to get into this conversation....

    Can I ask does it come up regularly that schools do not accept children because they are not christened or whats the issue? Does this issue just arise in catholic schools? I just never knew it was even a problem.

    I didn't get baptised until I was 9 years old and was baptised with the Church of Ireland. And my parents had absolutely no problems sending me to a primary school or secondary school. Although I did go to multi denominational schools so I presume that's the difference?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    Ashbx wrote: »
    Id be quite curious to get into this conversation....

    Can I ask does it come up regularly that schools do not accept children because they are not christened or whats the issue? Does this issue just arise in catholic schools? I just never knew it was even a problem.

    I didn't get baptised until I was 9 years old and was baptised with the Church of Ireland. And my parents had absolutely no problems sending me to a primary school or secondary school. Although I did go to multi denominational schools so I presume that's the difference?

    I think it depends really where you live and also the numbers of people applying for specific schools. For example, I went to secondary school in Sligo and having your child christened was not a massive issue to get into a school as the schools did not have massive numbers applying or numbers higher than the school may take.

    In Dublin however, the numbers applying for a particular school may be far in excess of the actual intake. Therefore, the schools may make have a policy or a list of which students will have priority for entry. For example... Sons/daughters of past pupils, siblings, teachers sons/daughters, and in the case of a catholic school... Well they may prefer to give priority to those students who have been christened as opposed to those who haven't.

    I'm a catholic and my kids will be brought up Catholic. But I don't really agree with school policies that dictate that those who haven't been christened are not eligible for enrollement in a particular school. But again, I think this is usually because the catholic schools gives priority to Catholics when numbers are in excess of intake. I "think" you will only really see this in the cities those as opposed to the smaller country towns? I could be wrong?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 750 ✭✭✭Ashbx


    Sligo1 wrote: »
    I think it depends really where you live and also the numbers of people applying for specific schools. For example, I went to secondary school in Sligo and having your child christened was not a massive issue to get into a school as the schools did not have massive numbers applying or numbers higher than the school may take.

    In Dublin however, the numbers applying for a particular school may be far in excess of the actual intake. Therefore, the schools may make have a policy or a list of which students will have priority for entry. For example... Sons/daughters of past pupils, siblings, teachers sons/daughters, and in the case of a catholic school... Well they may prefer to give priority to those students who have been christened as opposed to those who haven't.

    I'm a catholic and my kids will be brought up Catholic. But I don't really agree with school policies that dictate that those who haven't been christened are not eligible for enrollement in a particular school. But again, I think this is usually because the catholic schools gives priority to Catholics when numbers are in excess of intake. I "think" you will only really see this in the cities those as opposed to the smaller country towns? I could be wrong?

    I do see where the catholic schools are coming from on this point and I suppose its their prerogative. I live in Dublin and am yet to have kids so I suppose I really haven't put much thought into the school requirements. I didn't think in this day and age this would be an issue though. Especially as we have so many races/religions in Ireland these days.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    Ashbx wrote: »
    I do see where the catholic schools are coming from on this point and I suppose its their prerogative. I live in Dublin and am yet to have kids so I suppose I really haven't put much thought into the school requirements. I didn't think in this day and age this would be an issue though. Especially as we have so many races/religions in Ireland these days.

    Yea well that's the thing you see. If it is a catholic school they will usually give priority to Catholics which is understandable. In Sligo there was a Protestant Private school which gave priority to Protestants (back in the day but they might still I'm not sure). So it's the same thing really.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,770 ✭✭✭The Randy Riverbeast


    Ashbx wrote: »
    Id be quite curious to get into this conversation....

    Can I ask does it come up regularly that schools do not accept children because they are not christened or whats the issue? Does this issue just arise in catholic schools? I just never knew it was even a problem.

    I didn't get baptised until I was 9 years old and was baptised with the Church of Ireland. And my parents had absolutely no problems sending me to a primary school or secondary school. Although I did go to multi denominational schools so I presume that's the difference?

    I dont think a child can be refused a place purely due to religion but if there are too many people applying for a place not being the right religion for the school allows them to put you at the bottom of the list. Some people would say that is fair enough but the problem is that about 90% of schools are one denomination.

    Multi denominational dont tend to put you in order on the list due to religion so a Catholic and a non Catholic would be competing and a Catholic could get the place over another religion despite the only other options in the area being Catholic. I think there was mentions of prioritizing non Catholics but it kind of went against the whole everyone is equal thing they have going.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,436 ✭✭✭✭Pawwed Rig


    Multi denominational dont tend to put you in order on the list due to religion so a Catholic and a non Catholic would be competing and a Catholic could get the place over another religion despite the only other options in the area being Catholic. I think there was mentions of prioritizing non Catholics but it kind of went against the whole everyone is equal thing they have going.

    Also the non Catholic is often forced to participate in the Catholic ethos of the school


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,919 ✭✭✭dori_dormer


    The other point is also that most admissions go like this
    1- Catholics
    2- other religions
    3- no religion

    So you actually usually get a few kids of other religions in, and rarely unbaptised kids in high demand areas.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,449 ✭✭✭✭pwurple


    The other point is also that most admissions go like this
    1- Catholics
    2- other religions
    3- no religion

    So you actually usually get a few kids of other religions in, and rarely unbaptised kids in high demand areas.

    Most admissions? Where?

    All of the 8 Cork schools I applied to gave me their admissions policies, and not one of them looked anything like that.

    They generally went in this order:
    1) Siblings of children already attending
    2) Children within x area
    3) Children of past pupils
    4) Grandchildren of past pupils
    5) children of larger area y.

    1 of the 8 also had religion at the very bottom of their admission policies, it was a COI school, not Catholic.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,708 ✭✭✭BeardySi


    Ashbx wrote: »
    I do see where the catholic schools are coming from on this point and I suppose its their prerogative. I live in Dublin and am yet to have kids so I suppose I really haven't put much thought into the school requirements. I didn't think in this day and age this would be an issue though. Especially as we have so many races/religions in Ireland these days.

    Not as long as they're funded by the state it isn't. If they want to fund themselves, then by all means let them set admission policies that proiritise catholics. If they're funded by the state (as nearly all of them are) then they shouldn't be allowed to discriminate on any grounds - or do they only take tax money that came from catholics?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,449 ✭✭✭✭pwurple


    Ashbx wrote: »
    Id be quite curious to get into this conversation....

    Can I ask does it come up regularly that schools do not accept children because they are not christened or whats the issue? Does this issue just arise in catholic schools? I just never knew it was even a problem.

    I didn't get baptised until I was 9 years old and was baptised with the Church of Ireland. And my parents had absolutely no problems sending me to a primary school or secondary school. Although I did go to multi denominational schools so I presume that's the difference?

    I think it's a problem for a very small and vocal part of Dublin where they must be under served for schools in general, and that's about it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    pwurple wrote: »
    Most admissions? Where?

    All of the 8 Cork schools I applied to gave me their admissions policies, and not one of them looked anything like that.

    They generally went in this order:
    1) Siblings of children already attending
    2) Children within x area
    3) Children of past pupils
    4) Grandchildren of past pupils
    5) children of larger area y.

    1 of the 8 also had religion at the very bottom of their admission policies, it was a COI school, not Catholic.

    All faith schools, and there's lots of them where we live, have siblings first and then those of the faith in the area, those of the faith outside the area, and then any other faiths. All have applied this policy more strictly in recent years. I've known people all over Dublin apply to up to 20 schools to be sure of a place and one person has been refused from 13 schools because the child isn't baptised. It's a major issue with our friends and wider circles who have children.

    And the CofI schools are the most restrictive. Priority goes to active church members after siblings. There's no non CofI children in the two schools nearest to us with CorI patronage. I was told there was zero chance of even baptised Catholic children getting a place, never mind my heathens.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    lazygal wrote: »
    All faith schools, and there's lots of them where we live, have siblings first and then those of the faith in the area, those of the faith outside the area, and then any other faiths. All have applied this policy more strictly in recent years. I've known people all over Dublin apply to up to 20 schools to be sure of a place and one person has been refused from 13 schools because the child isn't baptised. It's a major issue with our friends and wider circles who have children.

    And the CofI schools are the most restrictive. Priority goes to active church members after siblings. There's no non CofI children in the two schools nearest to us with CorI patronage. I was told there was zero chance of even baptised Catholic children getting a place, never mind my heathens.

    Lol... Yes can be difficult to get into the COI schools. Even the one in Sligo!

    Being christened is a major factor in the majority of catholic schools in Dublin. However, every school we've looked at (and that's A LOT), their admissions policy are nothing like that or how dori described. They are more along the lines of what Pwurple has said and then the faith stuff comes in at the end. It's usually all about siblings/relatives/past pupils etc etc first in all the schools we've looked at. And that's public and private. They are all catholic schools.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Only one school within a reasonable distance of us doesn't limit enrolment on faith within the first three categories. And it's a school I would not consider great which is why it's able to let anyone who applies in. We're currently considering our school options and its depressing reading over and over that Catholic or protestant children from other areas in the country can get a place before our children are even considered for a place. That's before the indoctrination is taken into account.

    Eta the school closest to us, which I attended, changed its policy recently. It used to be based on living within the area and we live two minutes from it. Now it's siblings, followed by Catholic children in the area, Catholic children from any other areas, then all other Christian faiths, then others. This was in the past couple of years, and apparently because too many non Catholic children were getting in according to a teacher I know in the school. They now look for a baptism cert which was not the case when I was there.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    lazygal wrote: »
    Only one school within a reasonable distance of us doesn't limit enrolment on faith within the first three categories. And it's a school I would not consider great which is why it's able to let anyone who applies in. We're currently considering our school options and its depressing reading over and over that Catholic or protestant children from other areas in the country can get a place before our children are even considered for a place. That's before the indoctrination is taken into account.

    Eta the school closest to us, which I attended, changed its policy recently. It used to be based on living within the area and we live two minutes from it. Now it's siblings, followed by Catholic children in the area, Catholic children from any other areas, then all other Christian faiths, then others. This was in the past couple of years, and apparently because too many non Catholic children were getting in according to a teacher I know in the school. They now look for a baptism cert which was not the case when I was there.

    That sucks for you guys. It does seem very unfair. Hope you find a school that ye like. Must be pretty stressful :(.


  • Moderators, Education Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 12,527 Mod ✭✭✭✭byhookorbycrook


    lazygal wrote: »
    All faith schools, and there's lots of them where we live, have siblings first and then those of the faith in the area, those of the faith outside the area, and then any other faiths. .
    Our school is Catholic and there is a huge demand for places, but religion is not part of our admission policy. We have children of many different faiths and none.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Thanks, its really stressful. Friends of ours had their child down for a school at a few weeks old and only got a place a week before the child was due to start. All other schools had places only for baptised children. But the school hasn't a siblings policy so they'll go through the same again.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Our school is Catholic and there is a huge demand for places, but religion is not part of our admission policy. We have children of many different faiths and none.

    Is the school in Dublin? I know it's not an issue in all areas but as I've said I'm familiar with the enrolment policies in schools in several areas we're looking into moving too and only educate together schools don't prioritise faith after siblings. And from communication with schools many have tightened up on looking for baptism certs. Including the closest one to us that I can see from my house.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭Sligo1


    lazygal wrote: »
    Is the school in Dublin? I know it's not an issue in all areas but as I've said I'm familiar with the enrolment policies in schools in several areas we're looking into moving too and only educate together schools don't prioritise faith after siblings. And from communication with schools many have tightened up on looking for baptism certs. Including the closest one to us that I can see from my house.

    Lazygal, There's a new educate together school opening in Dublin 14 next year. They started taking names only a few months ago I think! You could consider putting your names down for that school if you are near that area?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Sligo1 wrote: »
    Lazygal, There's a new educate together school opening in Dublin 14 next year. They started taking names only a few months ago I think! You could consider putting your names down for that school?

    We have names down in a few places. It's just difficult to plan for anything when you can't be sure your children will have a place in school! We're seriously tempted to move abroad for a few years to avoid the system here.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,919 ✭✭✭dori_dormer


    pwurple wrote: »
    Most admissions? Where?

    All of the 8 Cork schools I applied to gave me their admissions policies, and not one of them looked anything like that.

    They generally went in this order:
    1) Siblings of children already attending
    2) Children within x area
    3) Children of past pupils
    4) Grandchildren of past pupils
    5) children of larger area y.

    1 of the 8 also had religion at the very bottom of their admission policies, it was a COI school, not Catholic.

    I meant from a religios stand point as that was the topic we were talking about. all the schools I've looked at for my son in South dublin, and North kildare other than educate together have pretty much followed that formula. I don't know about other areas obviously.

    Very few actually had a catchment area also.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,268 ✭✭✭✭uck51js9zml2yt


    We're not RC. My son started in the the local RC school this year without issue in Dublin.
    We were given 3 options on RE.
    Let him participate, let him do drawing during the class or take him out of class.
    We've decided to let him participate. Communion year will be different.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Very few actually had a catchment area also.

    Same here. Our local RC school refers to Catholic children in 'the area' followed by all other Catholic children outside 'the area'. The school can't tell me what 'the area' involves. The Dept of Ed refers to all schools in 'an area' catering for all children in 'the area' but hasn't clarified how 'areas' are defined.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 482 ✭✭Mac0783


    I've been reading this thread with interest, my child hasn't been baptised. I would like for her to go to the local Gaelscoil but they're a Catholic school, the only other option bar English speaking Catholic schools is a Church of Ireland school.

    I really want her to go to an Irish school but am concerned about the amount of time devoted to religion. I've nothing against Catholicism but from what I hear from friends, it's all the masses. Then Christmas and Easter nativity plays and practicing for I don't know hymms and choirs and masses etc.. If my daughter wont be going to mass, even if she sits out the stuff in class she'll feel like she's missing out on something her friends get to do.

    For example, a friends daughter is in senior infants, there was a "blessing of the school bags" at the local mass one of the first Sundays back at school, and they all learnt a prayer and went up and said it at the front of the Church. All the kids sat together at the front of the Church with their bags. Sounds lovely and great for the kids to meet outside school and good for them to practice public speaking. But if my child was there, she would have known all about it, heard the kids talking about it on Monday and wondered why she wasn't allowed go.

    Is any one else concerned that even if they get their child into a Catholic school that they'll feel like they're missing out, plus missing out on learning about other religions and frankly loosing time that could be devoted to learning other things?

    Sorry for the long post.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Mac0783 wrote: »
    Is any one else concerned that even if they get their child into a Catholic school that they'll feel like they're missing out, plus missing out on learning about other religions and frankly loosing time that could be devoted to learning other things?

    Sorry for the long post.

    Yes. And the plan for indoctrination through the new Grow in Love programme seems very focused on infusing the entire school day with religion. Nature programmes thanking god for making the world and stuff like that. It can often be down to a teacher and/or principle as to how religion is handled. I've heard good and bad about how those who don't participate in indoctrination are dealt with.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 482 ✭✭Mac0783


    The Gaelscoil I'm looking at don't even ask the child's religion on the enrolment form and they all seem relatively young teachers, which I think are both positive signs. But I need to find out more.

    I haven't heard about this Grow with love, I must look into it more. Thanking god for making the plants?? :(


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,436 ✭✭✭✭Pawwed Rig


    The entire day has religion. From prayers the morning and home time and break times to the x amount of hours a week focused on indoctrination to the greetings that they have to use, forced mass attendance, learning religious songs etc etc. It is not cosy love one another stuff they teach either - it is hard scary stuff. Kids just internalise these things as fact. My nephew (who was born out of wedlock) was upset after his teacher told the class that this was inherently wrong.
    We also had to tell him that Noah's ark et al were probably not true stories.
    The most dangerous part is the teaching that questioning is wrong. I don't know how often I heard the phrase 'doubting Thomas' in my school days to silence someone who dared to think for themselves.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,644 ✭✭✭✭lazygal


    Mac0783 wrote: »
    The Gaelscoil I'm looking at don't even ask the child's religion on the enrolment form and they all seem relatively young teachers, which I think are both positive signs. But I need to find out more.

    I haven't heard about this Grow with love, I must look into it more. Thanking god for making the plants?? :(
    http://www.ippn.ie/index.php?option=com_mtree&task=att_download&link_id=4939&cf_id=24

    This is the outline of the new curriculum.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12,449 ✭✭✭✭pwurple


    Mac0783 wrote: »
    Is any one else concerned that even if they get their child into a Catholic school that they'll feel like they're missing out, plus missing out on learning about other religions and frankly loosing time that could be devoted to learning other things?

    Depends on what you make of it really. Ours goes to COI. There are hymns and prayers that I'm not familiar with. It's in the homework, I'm sticking them on youtube to learn them myself.

    I don't perceive much difference between learning hymns and prayers and learning songs and poems. We don't practice it, so it's just more "learning" in general to me. Music, participation in a group, memory. All useful skills.

    When I say we don't practice, we'll go along to the church fundraising bake sale, probably some of the easter events, mainly to meet the other parents (so I know their friends parents) and be involved with the local community.

    I don't think she misses out on learning about other religions either by learning about one. We go to the Hiwala celebrations, do some jewish bits, and go to catholic mass from time to time.

    School isn't the beginning, middle and end of their education. Parents are educators, so I take responsibility for any extra education we want them to get.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,501 ✭✭✭lonestargirl


    My son is in school in South Dublin and is the only non-Catholic child in 60 junior infants. He got his place being the child of a past pupil. The enrolment policy has now been amended to specify that children of past pupils must be baptised to fit that category of enrolment.


Advertisement