Received an infraction

celticbest

:(:(
I received the below infraction for answering a question posed to me in a Thread which does not state no discussion apart from no R/A talk.

I cannot see how the Mod could do this as I broke no rules of the thread, if there was to be no discussion then the thread should state this. Yes the Mod said the following, which is only a question not a statement:

'That vid isn't even all that interesting...can we just drop the chat on that one, and get more vids? '

However the Mod found fit to hand out infractions when the conversation continued.....

I have given the Mod alternatives today & before when this issue previously raised it head as you can see below,

Can the infraction against me please be rescinded as it is not valid.



You have received an infraction
________________________________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Dear celticbest,

You have been infracted for ignoring a moderator's instructions.

Discussion can become heated, we don't object to that, but when a moderator issues a warning on a thread to reign things in, it stops a heated discussion from turning into a mess.

For more information please refer to the Boards.ie FAQ.

If you wish to appeal this infraction you can see details on how to do so here.

Alanstrainor

Your post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jesus.
Are you serious?
Yes what they did was illegal

Why can I not answer someone question?
__________________


Re: You have received an infraction
________________________________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Dear celticbest,

You have been infracted for ignoring a moderator's instructions.

Discussion can become heated, we don't object to that, but when a moderator issues a warning on a thread to reign things in, it stops a heated discussion from turning into a mess.

For more information please refer to the Boards.ie FAQ.

If you wish to appeal this infraction you can see details on how to do so here.

Alanstrainor

Your post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jesus.
Are you serious?
Yes what they did was illegal

Why can I not answer someone question?
This is after I requested that conversation to stop. Both received infractions, and both posts deleted.
__________________
2001-325ci-Silver



Re: You have received an infraction
________________________________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Dear celticbest,

You have been infracted for ignoring a moderator's instructions.

Discussion can become heated, we don't object to that, but when a moderator issues a warning on a thread to reign things in, it stops a heated discussion from turning into a mess.

For more information please refer to the Boards.ie FAQ.

If you wish to appeal this infraction you can see details on how to do so here.

Alanstrainor

Your post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jesus.
Are you serious?
Yes what they did was illegal

I answered a question put to me, as previously mentioned there is no side thread to answer through
The point is that after i asked for the discussion to stop, you did so. Reporting the post would have solved this....and not responding.
__________________
2001-325ci-Silver

Re: You have received an infraction
________________________________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Dear celticbest,

You have been infracted for ignoring a moderator's instructions.

Discussion can become heated, we don't object to that, but when a moderator issues a warning on a thread to reign things in, it stops a heated discussion from turning into a mess.

For more information please refer to the Boards.ie FAQ.

If you wish to appeal this infraction you can see details on how to do so here.

Alanstrainor

Your post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jesus.
Are you serious?
Yes what they did was illegal

I answered a question put to me, as previously mentioned there is no side thread to answer through
__________________


Re: You have received an infraction
________________________________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alanstrainor
Dear celticbest,

You have been infracted for ignoring a moderator's instructions.

Discussion can become heated, we don't object to that, but when a moderator issues a warning on a thread to reign things in, it stops a heated discussion from turning into a mess.

For more information please refer to the Boards.ie FAQ.

If you wish to appeal this infraction you can see details on how to do so here.

Alanstrainor

Your post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by celticbest
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jesus.
Are you serious?
Yes what they did was illegal

I answered a question put to me, as previously mentioned there is no side thread to answer through
The point is that after i asked for the discussion to stop, you did so. Reporting the post would have solved this....and not responding.
You still haven't answered my question, how you are meant to discuss videos on this thread if when 'you' feel it is boring you, you tell people to stop.

As stated before there is nowhere else to discuss videos and you have not come up with an alternative.

I would happily never post anything but videos to this thread if there was an alternative place for discussions, as there is not then discussions have to be held on this thread.

Hence the infraction you gave is a bit heavy handed considering the circumstances.
__________________


See people want to carry on the discussion but there is nowhere to do it,

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showp...postcount=6036

BTW, I won't be reporting this post as it is perfectly legitimate on the posters behalf re the rules of the thread, no talk of r/a's....
__________________

Penn

Hi celticbest,

The Mod gave a clear instruction to drop the line of discussion, and you and another poster continued posting about it. Regardless of whether or not you believe there should be a separate discussion thread or if discussion should be allowed in that thread, that doesn't justify ignoring the mod's instruction.

As such, the infraction is upheld. You may ask for an Admin to review this decision if you wish.

celticbest

Penn wrote: »

Hi celticbest,

The Mod gave a clear instruction to drop the line of discussion, and you and another poster continued posting about it. Regardless of whether or not you believe there should be a separate discussion thread or if discussion should be allowed in that thread, that doesn't justify ignoring the mod's instruction.

As such, the infraction is upheld. You may ask for an Admin to review this decision if you wish.

As I already pointed out he did not give a clear instruction to stop, he asked 'can we just drop it' another poster asked a question which in turn I answered as it was not specifically stated to stop.

That vid isn't even all that interesting...can we just drop the chat on that one, and get more vids?

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=92921153&postcount=6035
As requested I would like this infraction to be rescinded.

Penn

It was a moderator of the forum posting in bold text (commonly used to signify that the moderator is posting in their capacity as a moderator as opposed to a normal poster) and giving an instruction. Arguing semantics over the terminology used doesn't negate that fact.

Again, you may ask for an Admin to review this decision, or allow this dispute to be marked as resolved.

celticbest

Penn wrote: »

It was a moderator of the forum posting in bold text (commonly used to signify that the moderator is posting in their capacity as a moderator as opposed to a normal poster) and giving an instruction. Arguing semantics over the terminology used doesn't negate that fact.

Again, you may ask for an Admin to review this decision, or allow this dispute to be marked as resolved.

Terminology is what defines how a statement is read, again I state that it did not stay' stop' it said 'can we' this was a question not an instruction.

Again I ask for this infraction to be lifted.

Gordon

celticbest wrote: »

As I already pointed out he did not give a clear instruction to stop, he asked 'can we just drop it'

What did you expect, that the discussion would then turn into a discussion about whether or not you all could just drop that topic? If so, would you not technically be posting off topic if you weren't discussing that particular topic? That's rhetorical questions incidentally.

celticbest wrote: »

Terminology is what defines how a statement is read, again I state that it did not stay' stop' it said 'can we' this was a question not an instruction.

No, sorry, that was a clear instruction, a gentle but clear instruction from the Mod.

Boards Mods (and Mods in general) get grief sometimes for being too harsh, for being power trippers, Nazis etc etc. And when someone tries to steer the tiller with a warm hand, they get grief for not being too harsh.

I agree with the infraction so don't agree that it should be lifted.