equivariant wrote: » I don't believe that you have stated the question correctly. Have you included all the information given in the question? As you have stated it, the proposition is false. For example, if x=0 and p=q=r=1 then (x-p-q-r) = -3 and (x-4)(x+2)(x+1)-(q+r)(r+p)(p+q) = -16. Now -3 does not divide into -16, so your statement about factors must be false. Please check that you have stated the entire problem *exactly* as it was given to you.