Your Fav versus Someone Elses Fav: Merge

I Need The Sun

Hey!

I thought of a greeeat idea! Why not merge all the "Whos' Better Than Who" threads into one monster one and then we could all meet up and have a big debate.

Blur v Oasis
Beatles v Stones
Punk v Metal
Heavy Metal v Hard Rock
Ziggy Stradust v David Bowie
Bowie v The Thin White Duke
Spice Girls v Oasis
Beach Boys v Beatles
Stone Roses v The Stones
Rock v Classical
Beethoven v Debussy
The blonde one from Abba v The One with the Beard from Abba
The Electric Picnic v Tea In The Park

Sinfonia

I Need The Sun wrote: »

Blur v Oasis
Beatles v Stones
Punk v Metal
Heavy Metal v Hard Rock
Ziggy Stradust v David Bowie
Bowie v The Thin White Duke
Spice Girls v Oasis
Beach Boys v Beatles
Stone Roses v The Stones
Rock v Classical
Beethoven v Debussy
The blonde one from Abba v The One with the Beard from Abba
The Electric Picnic v Tea In The Park

For the record:
Blur, Beatles, Metal, Hard Rock, Equal, Equal, Equal, Beatles, Stones, Classical, Debussy, Blonde one, never been.

:pac:

I Need The Sun

Sinfonia wrote: »

For the record:
Blur, Beatles, Metal, Hard Rock, Equal, Equal, Equal, Beatles, Stones, Classical, Debussy, Blonde one, never been.

:pac:

Excellent: No faffing involved...

Oasis, Stones, Punk, Hard Rock, Equal, Equal, Equal:D,Beatles, Stones, Rock, Debussy, Blonde one, never been.

4zn76tysfajdxp

What's the point?

Oasis, Beatles, Metal, Hard rock, Equal, Equal, Oasis, Beatles, Stones, Rock, Beethoven, T'blonde one, Equal to me.

karaokeman

My take on that list is as follows;

Equal
Beatles
Metal
Hard Rock
Stradust
White Thin Duke
Oasis
Beach Boys
Stone Roses
Classical
Beethoven
Blonde one
Never been to either

Out of interest, my I ask how the Oasis v Spice Girls comparison is fair?

smokedeels

Blur
Beatles
Punk
Heavy Metal
David Bowie
Bowie
Spice Girls
Beach Boys
Stone Roses
Rock
No idea
The Blonde girl
Electric Picnic

rcaz

Blur
Beatles
Punk
Heavy Metal
omg they're like the same person
Spice Girls
Wings
The Stones
oranges
Debussy
The blonde one from Abba
The Electric Picnic

I Need The Sun wrote: »

Is there a valid reason for such polls. Seems pointless to me.

Washington Irving

Blur
The Beatles
Punk
Hard Rock
Equal
Equal
Oasis
The Beatles
The Rolling Stones
Rock
Beethoven
The blonde one
Electric Picnic

I Need The Sun

Tongue in cheek Rcaz. Bit of fun turned out to be. (Sinfonia's reply made me fall off me chair with appreciative laughter):D

I do think, in music and other arts, comparison as to who excels who, is missing the point. Anyways cheers all.:)

dhmusic

Oasis
Beatles
Punk
Hard Rock
Bowie
Bowie
Oasis
Beatles
Stone Roses
Rock
Beethoven
Blonde
Electric Picnic

I Need The Sun

My intention of this thread is to cast a light on the futility of comparisons...enjoy the music whatever shape or fashion its presented to you...do not judge yourself by the work of others, if they are true to the love of music, that would be the last thing they would want...do it, whatever it is you do, and dont be hoodwinked or misled by feeling the need, or having the lack of vision to have to live in someone elses shadow. There is nothing to offer on that road.

The link is to a song called "A Song For Rory Gallagher" by John Spillane. John is not a guitar head, but he relates the inspiration that was Rory.


http://youtu.be/uUBhJQv7UnQ