Which of these brown shoes do you prefer?

bret69

I'm considering one of the following three pairs of shoes for wearing with dark navy & grey suits. I have black shoes already so I want to mix it up!

Which of these do you prefer?

http://www.schuh.co.uk/mens-brown-schuh-andix-aysm-lace/3104976020

http://www.schuh.co.uk/mens-tan-ted-baker-greco-3/3106846220

http://www.schuh.co.uk/mens-brown-schuh-banter-derby-shoe/3104796020

Please don't judge on price!

anniehoo

Under a suit the second is perfect all round,not too formal or informal...its "casual dressy". The first is nice too but more informal and not for a suit imho, unless its a beach wedding/casual chino open shirt look.I would basically put that shoe with jeans or a relaxed trouser look.

The 3rd is nice, but its edging on the "very formal" for me. The suit would want to be very "sharp" and tailored to make it work. All shoes are very nice though!

What style are you going for?

bret69

anniehoo wrote: »

Under a suit the second is perfect all round,not too formal or informal...its "casual dressy". The first is nice too but more informal and not for a suit imho, unless its a beach wedding/casual chino open shirt look.I would basically put that shoe with jeans or a relaxed trouser look.

The 3rd is nice, but its edging on the "very formal" for me. The suit would want to be very "sharp" and tailored to make it work. All shoes are very nice though!

What style are you going for?

Thanks! They will be for work in an office environment but stylish office wear is what I try for!

They'd be worn with tailored Ted Baker and Paul Smith suits.

ladypip

Id go for the second pair

Shhh

Either 2 or 3, 1 is trying too hard.

DebDynamite

I prefer 3. It's a simple and classic shoe.

Mr. Presentable

First one for me, but I hate wearing a suit so it'd be my way of "breaking" the formality. The second shoe is a bit Oul fella-ish, and the third just dull.

Have you considered an ox-blood, or a grey shoe?