Questions to Val Andrews

celt262

Val i know that you read boards.ie because you mentioned in a radio interview.

If you could come out and answer these questions it would be great.

1. Why were 2 sweepers played against Donegal a team that play with 1 or 2 forwards.
2. Why did the team not play a similar system that the U-21's played against Donegal in the U-21 Semi Final which beat the blanket defence.
3. Why did a player who did not show any commitment to the team by going drinking several times throughout the year get a pivitol starting postion in the Ulster Championship team even though he hadnt the same training done as others.
4. You seem to blame the success off the U-21's as a reason for the poor performances by the senior team. Can you explain.
5. Why did Mickey Brennan not get a start against Donegal, a player with experience and power was surely required that day.

The list of questions could go on.

sgarvan

he may read here but I hardly think he is going to answer the above questions on a public board to an unknown person

Alaska1

That is the most ridiculous post I have ever seen.

Bluetonic

Alaska1 wrote: »

That is the most ridiculous post I have ever seen.

I disagree.

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=74907474&postcount=2

Alaska1

Bluetonic wrote: »

I disagree.

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=74907474&postcount=2

Oh, I am sorry, I seemed to have forgotton to have put a smiley in that post.

Lemlin

celt262 wrote: »

Val i know that you read boards.ie because you mentioned in a radio interview.

If you could come out and answer these questions it would be great.

1. Why were 2 sweepers played against Donegal a team that play with 1 or 2 forwards.
2. Why did the team not play a similar system that the U-21's played against Donegal in the U-21 Semi Final which beat the blanket defence.
3. Why did a player who did not show any commitment to the team by going drinking several times throughout the year get a pivitol starting postion in the Ulster Championship team even though he hadnt the same training done as others.
4. You seem to blame the success off the U-21's as a reason for the poor performances by the senior team. Can you explain.
5. Why did Mickey Brennan not get a start against Donegal, a player with experience and power was surely required that day.

The list of questions could go on.

I'm intrigued. Where did he mention Boards? And I'm sure you are more likely to get a response in the Cavan GAA thread.

celt262

Lemlin wrote: »

I'm intrigued. Where did he mention Boards? And I'm sure you are more likely to get a response in the Cavan GAA thread.

I just want him to know that people in Cavan are not happy with him.

He mentioned boards on a radio interview a while back, he was on about calling to peoples houses to confront them.

Paddyontherun

celt262 wrote: »

I just want him to know that people in Cavan are not happy with him.

He mentioned boards on a radio interview a while back, he was on about calling to peoples houses to confront them.

If Cavan people are unhappy with him why did they bring him back for a second stint?

Do you really expect a co. manager to come onto boards and answer questions to any supporter who asks?

You are obviously disgruntled with his tactics as mentioned. Why not give your opinion on what he should/shouldn't have done. Thats what we all do.
Incidently feedback from Dublin minor panelists last year was quite positive.

Clareman

Why not use the Cavan thread for this? Also, I assume if the real Val posts on here that he'd like to keep somewhat anonymous so I don't think he'd post on an open thread, I would invite him to PM the Op with the answers to the questions posted.

Closing thread