Monument to recognize our hurling tradition

holyhead

I would love to see some physical representation our of love for hurling. It would stand as a recognition for our great hurling tradition and as a permanent memorial to all those who represent our city and county with such distinction down the years. My idea would be a tasteful sculpture of two black and amber coloured giant cats in a vertical pose gripping hurleys which meet in the middle with a sliotar between the bosses. A possible location is the Parade near the Castle.

Raze_them_all

ugh. No.

Ravage1616

Raze_them_all wrote: »

ugh. No.

^^^^ +1

Plug

Raze_them_all wrote: »

ugh. No.

+1

fabbydabby

Raze_them_all wrote: »

ugh. No.

+1

In fact:

∞
∑ n
n=1

Daemos

An utterly cringeworthy idea

Rather like changing the Kilkenny crest instead of having a normal one like everyone else

Captain Havoc

Don't hold back, say what ye really think. I imagined two Matt the Cats on the parade.

catbear

Not gone on the idea, it's not like people have short memories and need to be reminded. Infact it would suggest that there may be insecurities regarding the future of hurling in kilkenny if there's a need to remind everyone.

Generally monuments are of things passed. However thurles has a hurling heritage shop I think just of the main square for those locals who need their fix. Maybe GAA followers could set up their own kilkenny hurling appreciation centre. There seems to be growing trends with two pubs competing against eachother on the parade for the hurling fans.

ft9

I fully agree there should be a monument.

However I do not agree with your idea of 2 black and amber cats, I think it would be horrible. Maybe something with a little more class.

The little square by the river opposite Xtravision is an ideal spot, best keep away from the castle, leave well enough alone and all that.

If a monument is erected, don't you just know its going to be a big chrome monstrosity.

Dozen Wicked Words

Sports teams generally, no matter how big or successful, and associated with their town/city, don't have statues or monuments in the middle of their town centres (or do they?). They have the statues or monuments outside their sports grounds, or Michael Jackson outside their ground if you are Fulham.

I suppose a fountain based monument would be a nice draw for the drinkers and druggies though.

holyhead

It doesn't have to be my exact idea of two cats or whatever or even in the location I suggested. Its just that hurling is a central part of life in KK. It allows us to be represented on the national stage and is an opportunity to show ourselves in a great light as a city and county. Hurling is a wonderful switch off from lifes various hassles be it financial, physical, emotional or psychological. It allows us to be engrossed for 70 minutes on a Sunday. I really think the contribution hurlers have made to our enjoyment of life deserves to be recognised and an appreciation of their brilliance on the field and for how well the represent the city and county as sports people. You will always have people who begrudge others being recognized for their positive contribution to society and life as we live it.

Raze_them_all

i don't like hurling. It has done nothing to enhance my life. I consider hurling to be the same as religion. Grand if others like it but i don't need to see constant reminders of it. Oh and where will the money to pay for it come from

holyhead

Maybe Glanbia might sponsor you never know. As for not liking hurling that's your entitlement. It may not have enhanced your life but I know it has been a nice added dimension to mine and I'm sure many others in the county. Money has been spent in far worse ways in this country, e-voting machines spring to mind.

ft9

holyhead wrote: »

It doesn't have to be my exact idea of two cats or whatever or even in the location I suggested. Its just that hurling is a central part of life in KK. It allows us to be represented on the national stage and is an opportunity to show ourselves in a great light as a city and county. Hurling is a wonderful switch off from lifes various hassles be it financial, physical, emotional or psychological. It allows us to be engrossed for 70 minutes on a Sunday. I really think the contribution hurlers have made to our enjoyment of life deserves to be recognised and an appreciation of their brilliance on the field and for how well the represent the city and county as sports people. You will always have people who begrudge others being recognized for their positive contribution to society and life as we live it.

^ This I agree with.

fabbydabby

The town is full of stupid, pointless, ugly architecture. Sure what harm is there in having another example I suppose?

1984baby

The monument is a good idea, but a hurling museum/exhibition should be opened in the city. It'd be great. They should have integrated one into Nowlan Park when they built the new stand behind the goal a couple of years ago.

Captain Havoc

We have the Lory Meagher centre only a few miles out, I don't think we really need another one.

catbear

Nolan Park would be the place for it.

Sky King

Captain Havoc wrote: »

We have the Lory Meagher centre only a few miles out, I don't think we really need another one.

Ah, here!

Captain Havoc

Sky King wrote: »

Ah, here!

It's not even ten miles, half an hour on my bicycle, fifteen in the car.

riffmongous

I'd be in favour of some kind of tasteful monument alright, hurling is a big part of the culture of the county, it's not for everyone of course, but enough I think.

Irishswede

I think this is so f**king sad that this is all KK has to offer. Yes I am from KK but luckily dont live there any more.

Dozen Wicked Words

Irishswede wrote: »

I think this is so f**king sad that this is all KK has to offer. Yes I am from KK but luckily dont live there any more.

Fairly sure no luck is required. Winning the lottery would be considered lucky, finding the right road out of a city, a basic skill.

ft9

Irishswede wrote: »

I think this is so f**king sad that this is all KK has to offer. Yes I am from KK but luckily dont live there any more.

If another few with that attitude followed suit, KK would be much better for it!

Captain Havoc

ft9 wrote: »

If another few with that attitude followed suit, KK would be much better for it!

Some of us have "bad luck" and end up coming back

Badgermonkey

holyhead wrote: »

My idea would be a tasteful sculpture of two black and amber coloured giant cats in a vertical pose gripping hurleys

Does not compute

holyhead

That was probably why I didn't pursue art as a serious career option. On a serious note I hope a tasteful monument is put up to acknowledge the contribution hurling has made to life in the county and to acknowledge the brilliance of Kilkenny hurling no better displayed than in the last decade.

catbear

How about something like this from Iraq, hurlies instead of swords over all the major roads in.
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/files/images/01CrossedSwordsMakiya400_1.jpg
Like Iraq, Kilkenny could display its symbolic tribalistic medieval show of arms.
Glorify the past when the future dries up.

fabbydabby

Irishswede wrote: »

I think this is so f**king sad that this is all KK has to offer. Yes I am from KK but luckily dont live there any more.

Which is probably why you are of the opinion that hurling is all Kilkenny has to offer.

anyone_local

catbear wrote: »

Not gone on the idea, it's not like people have short memories and need to be reminded.

maybe a monument in memory of Kilkenny football so?!

catbear

Farmball? No, it would have to be cricket, it was the most popular sport in Kilkenny before hurling.

He saw a hurling match in the town with no spectators present, ‘a fact which proves conclusively what little hold the GAA has taken on Kilkenny’. He went on to deplore the quality on offer: ‘The hurling of both teams was, we believe, the worst and most spiritless ever witnessed on an Irish hillside . . . It would break the heart of a Moycarkey or Galway Gael to witness such a contemptible perversion of the grand old dashing game of hurling’.

http://www.historyireland.com/volumes/volume15/issue2/reviews/?id=113943

Perhaps a monument to cricket would bring back to centre the socially uniting manner of sport rather than the socially divisive rules of the GAA.

misterdeeds

IMO I think any money spent on a monument to reconise kilkenny hurling would be better put to use to help local charaties at this terrible time for many needy families. just my opinoin so i will go now .

catbear

misterdeeds wrote: »

IMO I think any money spent on a monument to reconise kilkenny hurling would be better put to use to help local charaties at this terrible time for many needy families. just my opinoin so i will go now .

I agree, the cost of any GAA monument must come from the pockets of GAA fans themselves.

fabbydabby

That's a hellova lot of bags packed in Eurospar.

S28382

i think what kilkenny needs is a big poster of john mullane on every road into the city........:p