Your combined Liverpool and United team

bamboozling

This often comes up in conversation between me and my mates and the results are generally very different depending on the fan.

My combined team between players of United and Liverpool would be;

---

Reina

---

Smalling--Vidic---Agger----Enrique

---

Lucas---Gerrard
Nani---Suarez----Young

---

Rooney----

Very balanced team and I think the best players combined. What's yours?

NukaCola

Uh-oh.....

GavRedKing

I predict a short thread with the potential for bans high.

On another note, I reckon only Reina, Suarez and Gerrard would get into a Utd/Liverpool combined team.

whatawaster

---

Reina

---

Rafael

---

Vidic

---

Jones

---

Enrique

---

Lucas

---

Gerrard

---

Nani

---

Downing

---

Suarez

---

Rooney

---

tough decisions were: Downing/Young/Valencia, Jones/Smalling and Rafael/Fabio/Kelly/Johnson

MagicMarker

De Gea
Smalling Rio Vida Fabio
Nani Cleverley Ando Young
Wellbeck Rooney

bamboozling

gavredking wrote: »

I predict a short thread with the potential for bans high.

On another note, I reckon only Reina, Suarez and Gerrard would get into a Utd/Liverpool combined team.

Enrique and Lucas surely would. Lucas is the best defensive midfielder in the league at the moment. Evra has been píss poor the last 18 months whereas Enrique has shined the last 18 months.

bamboozling

MagicMarker wrote: »

De Gea
Smalling Rio Vida Fabio
Nani Cleverley Ando Young
Wellbeck Rooney

I don't think your understanding the concept here.

The_Kew_Tour

bamboozling wrote: »

I don't think your understanding the concept here.

he does:p

Paul Tergat

Already seeing plenty of bias. This thread is heading for a cluster****


I think the only guarantees ought to be Reina, Vidic, Suarez and Rooney possibly Lucas too. The rest are just a case of who you prefer

Nalz

---

Reina

---

Rafael

---

Vidic

---

Jones

---

Evra

---

Anderson

---

Gerrard

---

---

Adam

---

---

Suarez

---

Rooney

---

Young---

MagicMarker

bamboozling wrote: »

I don't think your understanding the concept here.

Au contraire.

The_Kew_Tour

MagicMarker wrote: »

De Gea
Smalling Rio Vida Fabio
Nani Cleverley Ando Young
Wellbeck Rooney

i have Chico over Wellbeck, but otherwise its spot on.;)

Nalz

bamboozling wrote: »

Evra....píss poor

a fair bit below his high standards maybe, piss poor I think is harsh.

bamboozling

I know you 'fans' think you're being funny but we're trying to have a discussion here, try and put your bias and superiority complex away for at least one day lads.

Brian?

bamboozling wrote: »

Lucas is the best defensive midfielder in the league at the moment.

That statement burns my eyes.

adox

I have a policy of not even considering Liverpool players when picking my fantasty football teams so theres no way I`m putting a team up here, unless you want the same as Magic Markers. :pac:

bamboozling

briankeating wrote: »

That statement burns my eyes.

Why who would you say is better. Song?

adox wrote: »

I have a policy of not even considering Liverpool players when picking my fantasty football teams so theres no way I`m putting a team up here, unless you want the same as Magic Markers. :pac:

That's an awfully narrow minded view you have there.

Wile E. Coyote

gavredking wrote: »

I predict a short thread with the potential for bans high.

On another note, I reckon only Reina, Suarez and Gerrard would get into a Utd/Liverpool combined team.

I wouldn't have Gerrard anywhere near the team.

GavRedKing

bamboozling wrote: »

Enrique and Lucas surely would. Lucas is the best defensive midfielder in the league at the moment. Evra has been píss poor the last 18 months whereas Enrique has shined the last 18 months.

Going on form or ability?

My team would be,

Reina

Smalling Vidic Ferdinand Evra

Fletcher Gerrard

Nani Suarez Young

Rooney

Yakult

Reina
Johnson Carra Agger Enrique
lucas Adam
Kuyt Suarez Downing
Carroll

The_Kew_Tour

bamboozling wrote: »

I know you 'fans' think you're being funny but we're trying to have a discussion here, try and put your bias and superiority complex away for at least one day lads.

you have 6 liverpool players to united 5

ya your not biased at all:rolleyes:

Nalz

Paul Tergat wrote: »

I think the only guarantees ought to be Reina, Vidic, Suarez and Rooney possibly Lucas too. The rest are just a case of who you prefer

Young should be up there...he's going to be an amazing player for United this season in my opinion. Definetly ahead of Lucas in terms of "guarantees" , different player or not. Put it to you this way if you were captain back in the playground days and they were the last two players left you'd be crazy to go for Lucas!

mike65

---

Reina
Kelly--Rio--Agger--Enrique

---

Lucas
Nani

---

Downing
-Hernandez-Young-Suarez

De Gea, Vidic, Carra, Valencia, Gerrard, Kuyt, Rooney

bamboozling

The_Kew_Tour wrote: »

you have 6 liverpool players to united 5

ya your not biased at all:rolleyes:

I'm not being biased. Some are close calls but I don't think it's an outagreous thought to have 6 Liverpool players.

Considering that United's strength has always been there squad rather than their starting 11 its not an outlanish statement.

Le King

I'd rather keep what we have. K? Thanks

CSF

Why are all these crazy people picking Enrique over Evra? They're a class apart even if Evra hasn't been at the top of his game of late.

Nalz

mike65 wrote: »

---

Reina
Kelly--Rio--Agger--Enrique

---

Lucas
Nani

---

Downing
-Hernandez-Young-Suarez

De Gea, Vidic, Carra, Valencia, Gerrard, Kuyt, Rooney

OMG i mean OMMFG!!!!!!

A team that contains Lucas and not Rooney when they are both available for selection! I'd play Rooney CM before him.....seen it all now

Peyton Manning

bamboozling wrote: »

Why who would you say is better. Song?

Dozens of times better than Lucas, and I quite like the Brazilian.

PHB

I always love threads like these because you can see how little some people know about football.

tommyhaas

MagicMarker wrote: »

De Gea
Smalling Rio Vida Fabio
Nani Cleverley Ando Young
Wellbeck Rooney

As soon as I saw the thread title, I knew this would be inevitable. It was just a question of whether it would be a Utd fan to post a full Utd team first, or a Liverpool fan to post a full Liverpool team first

Regardless of who people think, anyone contemplating leaving out Rooney, Suarez, Vidic or Reina is simply wrong

bamboozling

Tom_Brady wrote: »

Dozens of times better than Lucas, and I quite like the Brazilian.

Yeah he's up there. It's between himself and Lucas at the moment. I think Lucas just shades it at the moment.

SlickRic

not a fúcking hope.

it's enough having a match between the 2 at least twice a year.

you can fúck off with this.

Peyton Manning

bamboozling wrote: »

I think Lucas just shades it at the moment.

:eek: