Colour V B&W C&C

Ricky91t

It's been a while,

Anyway, looking for some comments on this photos, Mainly the B&W vs the Colour one, But I'll accept comments on anything, except the messy window :pac:





I prefer the B&W but others prefer the colour...

sineadw

I prefer the colour, if nothing more than to inform the brain of what's outside the window. If that makes sense.

jpb1974

Thinking I prefer the B+W... but the mess on the glass towards the RHS is really, really distracting.

Ballyman

B&W as there isn't much colour in the pic in the first place. I'd take about an inch off the rhs as well if it was mine(in to the hair and then clone that out).

magicbastarder

how about removing all colour except on the dog? and photoshop the dirt on the glass out, replacing it with a swan, so it draws the eye from the dog's gaze.

zdooldreb

Colour for me. Don't think there is enough contrast in the B&W one.

CabanSail

magicbastarder wrote: »

how about removing all colour except on the dog? and photoshop the dirt on the glass out, replacing it with a swan, so it draws the eye from the dog's gaze.

Selective colour and Swans, how about doing some HDR and adding a vignette as well while you're there. :eek:

Very small screen here but I prefer the mono as the reflection stands out more. Definitely needs some of the dirt cloned out though.

kelly1

Would you just look at the state of that window!!? :pac:

AnCatDubh

Colour. I like that its not overly satuuated. Nice pic.

squareballoon

Black and white for me. I love the texture on the glass and would remove the four biggest white spots only. I really like the scratches/smears. The composition is great with the reflection ending up in the centre and the dog looking into frame.
Great shot

Morrisseeee

B&W, color just looks ordinary, whereas the B&W has a character/ambience/mood to it.