the best seth mcfarlene show

hi guys and girls im a huge seth mcfarlene fan and i was wondering which show do ye guys think is the better one i personally think american dad is the best(mainly due to roger):D

Minto

American Dad for me. Not a huge Roger fan, but I think Stan is the best of the three dads across the shows.

Diabhal Beag

Family Guy from season 3 to season 5 was great stuff. Everything he has touched since then has been awful. Really thought South Park even in the worst season (last one) put McFarlane's work to shame.

Mark Hamill

At its best, Family Guy outshines the rest no problem, but its very variable, some episodes are absolute crap. American Dad is more reliable, never really bad but not funnier than Family Guys best. Plus its been getting stale, nearly every episode is about Stan not appreciating Roger, Steve or Francine, rinse repeat, they need something new. Cleveland show is just awful.

Riddle101

Family Guy for me. Never could get into American Dad, and Cleveland Show is a load of rubbish?

youcancallmeal

I remember watching the first season of American Dad years ago and thought meh. Went back to it there recently and I now think its far superior to Family Guy.

matthew8

The Cleveland show is absolutely awful, one of the worst spinoffs ever (and the bar isn't set very high).

Family guy was taken out of the top drawer seasons 3-5, but recently it has really gone south. Brian has become too serious and they seem to be bringing in more of those godawful awkward silence scenes when they all just look at eachother for 5-15 seconds.

American Dad has never been great but it's been consistently average.

goose2005

youcancallmeal wrote: »

I remember watching the first season of American Dad years ago and thought meh. Went back to it there recently and I now think its far superior to Family Guy.

Not to mention that the first series of AD is by far the worst.

K.O.Kiki

Missing option:

[*]None, they're all shíte