Gaming with your daughter is good for her

Nevyn

http://ingame.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/02/01/5962255-gaming-with-your-daughter-is-good-for-her

By Winda Benedetti

Listen up parents: If you're not a video game player and your child is, now might be a good time to pick up a game controller and pick up a new pastime.

While many parents worry that letting their children play video games will have a negative impact on them, a new study from Brigham Young University has found that when parents play games with their children — specifically their daughters — it can actually be good for them.

Researchers from BYU's School of Family Life in Provo, Utah, found that girls who played age-appropriate video games with a parent felt more connected to their families, had fewer mental health issues and fewer problems with aggressive behavior.

And the researchers say this is the first study to show that gaming with an adult can be good for a girl.

For the study, published in Tuesday's issue of the Journal of Adolescent Health, researchers Sarah Coyne and Laura Padilla-Walker had 287 families with children between 11 and 16 years old complete video game-, behavioral-, and family-related questionnaires. They report:

We found an association between co-playing of video games and lowered internalizing (e.g., depression/anxiety) and aggressive behavior. Furthermore, girls who co-played with their parents reported more prosocial behavior toward family members, which may be a function of higher relationship quality between daughters and parents who co-play. These findings certainly confirm parents' own views of co-playing, who believe that co-playing would result in positive social and emotional outcomes. Furthermore, they allay fears that co-playing video games results in negative outcomes, at least for girls.

So why the positive impact? According to the article published in the Journal of Adolescent Health, the researchers surmise:

When parents play video games with their daughters, they may be sending a myriad of messages. First, parents may show that they are willing to engage in an activity that is important to daughters. Second, playing video games can represent quality time between a daughter and a parent, especially when such play involves conversation between parent–child.

As a gamer and parent myself, this all simply makes good sense to me. After all, parents and their children have been playing games together since the dawn of time. Just because a game now appears on a TV, via a sophisticated machine, doesn't mean it has to be any less of a healthy, positive experience for a family.

But there are a couple of interesting twists in the study's findings.


The researchers found that playing games with a parent did not have an impact on the behavior or family connection for boys. Compare that to girls, for whom playing with a parent accounted for as much as 20 percent of the variation on the measured outcomes.

The researchers said it’s possible that the time boys play with parents doesn't stand out as much because they spend much more time playing with friends. The researchers said they plan to explore the reasons behind the gender differences as they continue working on the project.

Something else worth noting: The BYU researchers found that 31 percent of the children reported playing age-inappropriate games with their parents (42 percent of boys, 15 percent of girls) and they report that "heightened parent–child connection was not found for girls who played these age-inappropriate games with their parents."

"It is possible that exposure to such inappropriate content may influence both parent and daughter mood and ability to respond to each other," the researchers write. "Additionally, such games are often very intense and may interfere with conversation or interaction that may lead to heightened levels of connection."

And finally, the researchers point out that few of the mothers surveyed played games. So it was really the father/daughter time that was having an impact on the girls.

To that I say: Kudos to dads who play games with their daughters. And to the moms who don't: Give it a try. It's a lot of fun and your daughters and sons will love you for caring enough to give gaming a go.

In case you're wondering, "Mario Kart," "Super Mario Brothers," "Wii Sports," "Rock Band" and "Guitar Hero" were the games played most often by the girls in the study. Meanwhile, boys reported "Call of Duty," "Wii Sports" and "Halo" as their most-played games.

All of which makes me wonder ... parents, which games do you like to play with your sons and daughters? And which games do you think do the best job helping you connect with your kids?

Being a gamer myself I may be sligthly biased but I do think playing with your kids is awesome, for me and mind it's co op games on the xbox like castlecrashers or being each other's henchmen in Fable or cardgames like Munchkin or boardgames.

My parents played with us when I was growing up from the atari system to boggle, scrabble, card games endless games of ludo and chess. Some of my best memories are of time spent sitting about playing games and I try to make that happen for my two.

metrovelvet

Is this just video games or any kind of games from twister to scrabble to volleyball?

Nevyn

The study looked at playing video games with kids.

FoxT

That's interesting. My wife & I have found video games useful in 2 ways

1/ teaching kids to share / negotiate. They had a Video/DVD, Playstation, & TV channels - but just one TV. They soon learned to agree between themselves which activity they were going to do. This worked really well when they were aged 4-8, and has paid off long term as well

2/ We both have spent a good deal of time playing video games with our kids, because it is something they enjoy & they use the time to talk. We have had some great conversations with our kids whilst playing games, that we probably would not have had, otherwise.

-FoxT

cynder

My lady never plays video games, she never had any interest, however my boys love them and always ask me to play, i have great fun with them. The boys learn to take turns, wait , share an cooperate with each other.

BostonB

Might depend on the specific game though.

liliq

At least the report does say "age appropriate" and gives a few examples of games that girls might play most- Mario Kart, Rock Band etc.!
Can't imagine something like Dead Space would be entirely appropriate... :rolleyes:

padr81

Just for a bit of fun, when im down at my ex's. the 4 of us take turns messing on the wii fit. my kids are only 3 and 4 but its a great craic. Seeing who can run the farthest, etc... My daughter hasn't a clue what shes doing as shes 3 but its funny teaching her to do the balance things. its good fun and its suprising watching how much fun they have via exercise they'd never do when its on a game.

Another good side to it is my son and I play fifa on my ps. Hes the kind of child who has to be first at everything, first into school, first finished his work, first out the door and he cheats like hell at Ludo and snakes and ladders. if he makes a mistake doing his homework he demands i rub the lot out so he can start again. If he tries to draw a picture and its not perfect he used to throw the colours away. He's the most competitive child Ive ever seen so its great for him to start accepting that he can't win everything.

I let him win the odd game but mainly whoop him (im an addict haha). I don't let him win because I think learning to lose is a big thing for him and he has to learn as close to perfect and all as he is he's not perfect. Plus he has to learn how to react when he's not perfect. Hes slowly mellowing out. So yeah as a games addict myself I think its great for him.

BostonB

liliq wrote: »

At least the report does say "age appropriate" and gives a few examples of games that girls might play most- Mario Kart, Rock Band etc.!
Can't imagine something like Dead Space would be entirely appropriate... :rolleyes:

Looking beyond the obvious age rating. Which incidentally on some games is an indication of difficulty not just the maturity of the content. But some games are just mindless key bashing, and some games require a bit of thought, lateral problem solving.

Morag

Ratings on games and all other media are guide lines not gospel.
Different kids are able for different stories/effects.
Both mine are under 15 and play fable 3 and I have played it with them.
Kids are well able for complex games, many people would be surprised at the complexities they can grasp, Viva pinjata is a wonderfully complex gardening game and the management of the resoruces in it is hard enough but kids are well able for it, the same with the Sims.

BostonB

Thats why I said its an indication of difficulty. Not that its accurate. TBH I was thinking of younger kids when padr81 mentioned it.

cnocbui

Bioshock with my daughter is pure win.