Berbatov vs Ibrahimovic

timetogetfit · 18-09-2010 11:17pm #1

This probably doesn't deserve its own thread but because there so similar I have to ask ,who has more natural talent?

Peyton Manning · 18-09-2010 11:21pm

timetogetfit wrote: »

This probably doesn't deserve its own thread

You're right there, Ted.

orourkeda · 18-09-2010 11:23pm

Talent matched and often blunted by even bigger egos

3hn2givr7mx1sc · 18-09-2010 11:25pm

orourkeda wrote: »

Talent matched and often blunted by even bigger egos

Berba doesn't have that mych if an ego..?

Nemanja91 · 18-09-2010 11:28pm

Berbatov doesn't go around kicking his team mates.

CR 7 · 18-09-2010 11:28pm

Let's create a list of players that are the exact same players.

Ibrahimovic
Berbatov
Aquilani

eZe^ · 18-09-2010 11:41pm

Ibrahimovic is far superior in every aspect of the game imo. Still though, no real need for this thread.

Pinturicchio · 18-09-2010 11:55pm

Definitely Ibrahimovic.

Park Ji Sung wrote: »

Let's create a list of players that are the exact same players.
Ibrahimovic

Berbatov

Aquilani

Aquilani doesn't even play the same position as the other two.

mink_man · 18-09-2010 11:58pm

ibrah, but in a team berba is better.

CR 7 · 18-09-2010 11:58pm

Pinturicchio wrote: »

Definitely Ibrahimovic.

Aquilani doesn't even play the same position as the other two.

But he wears the same type of headband. Is that not what this thread is about?

Le King · 18-09-2010 11:59pm

On coolness alone it has to be Berbatov

Rob113 · 19-09-2010 12:03am

Le King wrote: »

On coolness alone it has to be Berbatov

+1

Ibra's a dick. Berba is going to show his true worth this year.

Pinturicchio · 19-09-2010 12:10am

2007–08 Berbatov: 52 appearances 23 goals.
2007–08 Ibrahimović: 34 appearances 22 goals.

2008–09 Berbatov: 44 apps. 14gls.
2008–09 Ibrahimović: 29 apps 10 gls.

2009–10 Berbatov: 43 apps. 12 gls.
2009–10 Ibrahimović: 41 apps. 21 gls. (When he was supposedly awful for Barca).

LuckyLloyd · 19-09-2010 12:11am

I really couldn't give a ****.

Le King · 19-09-2010 12:14am

Pinturicchio wrote: »

2007–08 Berbatov 52 appearances 23 goals.
2007–08 Ibrahimović 34 appearances 22 goals.

2008–09 Berbatov 44 apps. 14gls.
2008–09 Ibrahimović 29 apps 10 gls.

2009–10 Berbatov 43 apps. 12 gls.
2009–10 Ibrahimović 41 apps. 21 gls. (When he was supposedly awful for Barca).

Natural Talent≠Goals in Apps

2 + 2 = 5

stovelid · 19-09-2010 12:16am

Dour Proddy 80s Ferguson Aberdeen trefoil Adidas bench coat vs stylish new-generation continental Mourinho cashmere overcoat?

DISCUSS

Degag · 19-09-2010 2:47am

Berbatov for me. Suppremely talented player. Some of the things he does (or often tries to do) leave me gobsmacked at times. He's playing well at the moment and scoring goals which is a plus of course:)

Saying that, Ibra is a great player too. 16 League goals in 29 games and 22 overall is not to be sneezed at and is not a failure by any definition of the word.