Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

M9 Motorway Could face Additional toll

  • 26-07-2010 10:40am
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,517 ✭✭✭


    Waterford motorists could be facing another toll according to reports this morning

    The Irish Times quotes Department of Transport sources that the Waterford to Dublin motorway jumps
    off the page as an obvious route to toll.

    Drivers in Waterford already face a toll to use the Second River crossing, however motorist can use the new motorway without charge.

    The M9 is to be the only one of the State’s inter-urban motorways that has just one toll and this can be avoiding by using Rice Bridge.

    Other possibilities include tolling stretches of the Limerick to Cork route, the Jack Lynch tunnel and a range of bypasses such as Youghal and Ballincollig in Co Cork.


Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,818 ✭✭✭Minstrel27


    The second river crossing isn't a part of the M9.


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    Minstrel27 wrote: »
    The second river crossing isn't a part of the M9.

    Its great when journalists don't do proper research eh? :)
    The motorway is the M9 the second river crossing is the N25, so infact the M9 has no tolls what so ever at present :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,641 ✭✭✭gscully


    Pedantry aside, isn't it just a bit ridiculous that anyone driving from Waterford, using the Suir Bridge, to get to Dublin Airport would have to pay three tolls?

    Could someone explain to me where our extortionate road tax goes?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 222 ✭✭mecco


    I'm no fan of road tax or in particular, what we get for our money, but I dont think anyone driving from waterford would go over the new bridge in this case.

    And it seems to me the example you gave is one toll for the N25/city by pass, one for the M9 (if/when it happens) and one for the M50. Whether or not you think those roads should be tolled is a different situation. Personally I'd make my peace with the tolls for the ease of using dual-carraigeways and motorways.


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    gscully wrote: »
    Pedantry aside, isn't it just a bit ridiculous that anyone driving from Waterford, using the Suir Bridge, to get to Dublin Airport would have to pay three tolls?

    Is it any different for somebody going from Galway to Dublin?
    Three tolls
    Could someone explain to me where our extortionate road tax goes?

    We don't pay road tax, you pay motor tax.
    Motor tax goes into a big pot and is used for all sorts of things....not just road or transport related.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,081 ✭✭✭ziedth


    ^ I agree,

    I mean SOMETHING has to be done to generate a bit of money correct? In my view if you can afford the trip to Dublin you can afford the maybe €5 you might pay in tolls. Bit lousy on people who travel it daily granted.


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    ziedth wrote: »
    ^ I agree,

    I mean SOMETHING has to be done to generate a bit of money correct? In my view if you can afford the trip to Dublin you can afford the maybe €5 you might pay in tolls. Bit lousy on people who travel it daily granted.

    You have to look at reality,
    If you get yourself a car you know its going to cost money, tax, insurance, petrol, maintance etc we all know it costs money.

    This is yet another running cost and reality is that the gov needs more money, doesn't matter who is in power money needs to be raised, I'm not saying I agree with it but how is Waterford anymore special then Galway when it comes to putting tolls on roads?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,818 ✭✭✭Minstrel27


    Cabaal wrote: »
    Is it any different for somebody going from Galway to Dublin?
    Three tolls

    It is three from Cork to dublin also now that Abbeyleix section has been completed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,790 ✭✭✭Benimar


    Cabaal wrote: »
    You have to look at reality,
    If you get yourself a car you know its going to cost money, tax, insurance, petrol, maintance etc we all know it costs money.

    This is yet another running cost and reality is that the gov needs more money, doesn't matter who is in power money needs to be raised, I'm not saying I agree with it but how is Waterford anymore special then Galway when it comes to putting tolls on roads?

    It isn't, but just because Galway people are getting shafted on this doesn't mean that we have to. I have to say, the argument that others do it, therefore we should, really annoys me. The cost of tolls from Galway to Dublin Airport is crazy and should be reduced, rather than screwing everybody else to 'bring them in line' with the Galway road.

    It's easy to say that if you can afford to go to Dublin, you can afford the tolls. The toll doesn't distinguish between people who can afford it and those who can't. Some people will have to go to Dublin out of necessity (hospitals etc), do they stick to the old 'death trap' road? I've always thought that the M9 should not be tolled because there isn't a viable alternative given the state of the old N9.

    Also, remember we will be paying more than our own tolls. Businesses will have no option but to pass on the toll charges which will increase the cost of everything we buy.

    I'm not saying I have the solution to the countrys ills (and if I did I certainly wouldn't trust our politicians with it), but this needs to be looked at a bit more carefully than 'ah, it's only a few quid'


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,081 ✭✭✭fricatus


    Tolls are a stupid idea. All they do is discourage use of the tolled road.

    I'm not against road pricing when it's in an effort to reduce congestion (like what they have in London), but it seems completely stupid to discourage people from using a safer, less congested, high quality road.

    Our new bridge has tons of excess capacity just going to waste because a toll is being charged. Meanwhile people are sitting in jams all along the Quay every evening, reducing their quality of life, and that of people using the city centre.

    When the new bridge was opened, it was claimed that traffic on the Quay would drop by 30%. However it has fallen by 6% judging by the year-on-year figures for April of this year and last.

    If they toll the M9, sure, people just going occasionally to Dublin will use it, but people commuting between the likes of KK and Waterford, KK and Carlow, Naas and Carlow, etc., will just go back to using the old road, while the new one sits, neither generating toll revenue, nor doing anything economically useful with its excess capacity.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,790 ✭✭✭Benimar


    fricatus wrote: »
    Tolls are a stupid idea. All they do is discourage use of the tolled road.

    I'm not against road pricing when it's in an effort to reduce congestion (like what they have in London), but it seems completely stupid to discourage people from using a safer, less congested, high quality road.

    Our new bridge has tons of excess capacity just going to waste because a toll is being charged. Meanwhile people are sitting in jams all along the Quay every evening, reducing their quality of life, and that of people using the city centre.

    When the new bridge was opened, it was claimed that traffic on the Quay would drop by 30%. However it has fallen by 6% judging by the year-on-year figures for April of this year and last.

    If they toll the M9, sure, people just going occasionally to Dublin will use it, but people commuting between the likes of KK and Waterford, KK and Carlow, Naas and Carlow, etc., will just go back to using the old road, while the new one sits, neither generating toll revenue, nor doing anything economically useful with its excess capacity.

    Thank you sir! You just saved me a lot of typing. I could not agree with you more.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 88,968 ✭✭✭✭mike65


    Usual brain fart stuff from our masters (and their hired consultants).


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 182 ✭✭Joey leBlanc


    You are always gonna get skinflints no matter what the economic climate is. Miserable bitter ol' sods would rather put themselves thru the misery of driving an extra 15miles & add an extra 30mins on their journeys just to avoid paying a 1.80euro toll;
    The same miserable b'strds who take naggins into a pub & just buy a couple of glasses of Coke all nite;
    The same tight fisted ppl who rather than get subscribe to a wheelie bin, go around town disposing of their waste in the litter bins;

    Most ordinary, laid-back sane people will pay the toll for a better class of road, a safer journey, no chance of getting stuck behind a Sunday driver as there is ample opportunity to overtake & the bonus of the journey being much quicker.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 957 ✭✭✭comeraghs


    I thought there was going to be a toll somewhere between Kilkenny & Carlow once the road is completed!? No?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,790 ✭✭✭Benimar


    You are always gonna get skinflints no matter what the economic climate is. Miserable bitter ol' sods would rather put themselves thru the misery of driving an extra 15miles & add an extra 30mins on their journeys just to avoid paying a 1.80euro toll;
    The same miserable b'strds who take naggins into a pub & just buy a couple of glasses of Coke all nite;
    The same tight fisted ppl who rather than get subscribe to a wheelie bin, go around town disposing of their waste in the litter bins;

    Most ordinary, laid-back sane people will pay the toll for a better class of road, a safer journey, no chance of getting stuck behind a Sunday driver as there is ample opportunity to overtake & the bonus of the journey being much quicker.

    I object to tolls.
    I have NEVER brought drink into a pub
    I pay my bin charges and do not dump illegally

    Oh, and the toll is €1.90..each way..for a car. Sounds like you don't use it too often?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,336 ✭✭✭tonc76


    comeraghs wrote: »
    I thought there was going to be a toll somewhere between Kilkenny & Carlow once the road is completed!? No?

    Nope! There were no plans to toll this section as current traffic figures and projected future traffic figures would not have made it a viable business for the operator.

    Whether the road is tolled by the government is yet to be seen? A government toll would mean all monies collected would go into the government coffers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,510 ✭✭✭Max Powers


    I cant agree with tolling the M9, we pay a toll on our bypass(N25). Limerick, Cork and Galway dont pay tolls on their bypasses.
    Where does our road tax go? Ans= to fund quangos and handy numbers for the seanad and dail members to fill their pockets.
    Lets face it, a toll is just another stealth tax like your tv licence fee, bin charges etc. At this stage we are handing over 50% of your earnings to the govt. to waste most of it. PAYE, PRSI, VAT on all goods and services, levy, health levy, tv licence, extra taxes on booze and smokes, bin charges, tolls, NCT etc etc.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,081 ✭✭✭fricatus


    Miserable bitter ol' sods would rather put themselves thru the misery of driving an extra 15miles & add an extra 30mins on their journeys just to avoid paying a 1.80euro toll;

    I work in Kilkenny and use the M9.

    Approximately 20 working days in a month...
    That makes 240 in a year.
    Travelling to and fro, that makes 480 trips.
    Assuming a toll of €1.90, that makes €912 a year. Skinflint, you say?

    Before you ask, public transport doesn't serve my workplace, unless you consider a 25-minute walk acceptable.
    In any event, I often start before the first Waterford-KK train gets to KK, and at other times I finish after the last train leaves.

    And like Benimar, I have NEVER brought drink into a pub, I pay my bin charges and do not dump illegally.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 222 ✭✭mecco


    fricatus wrote: »
    Tolls are a stupid idea. All they do is discourage use of the tolled road.

    I'm not against road pricing when it's in an effort to reduce congestion (like what they have in London), but it seems completely stupid to discourage people from using a safer, less congested, high quality road.

    Our new bridge has tons of excess capacity just going to waste because a toll is being charged. Meanwhile people are sitting in jams all along the Quay every evening, reducing their quality of life, and that of people using the city centre.

    When the new bridge was opened, it was claimed that traffic on the Quay would drop by 30%. However it has fallen by 6% judging by the year-on-year figures for April of this year and last.

    If they toll the M9, sure, people just going occasionally to Dublin will use it, but people commuting between the likes of KK and Waterford, KK and Carlow, Naas and Carlow, etc., will just go back to using the old road, while the new one sits, neither generating toll revenue, nor doing anything economically useful with its excess capacity.

    It seems to me that people are going to weigh it up and decide whether or not they think a toll is worth it. A toll on a road such as the M9 is not stupid in my opinion as I'm sure a lot of people would take a toll for the extra ease the motorway adds to their journey in comparison to a single lane road.

    This is where the toll on the new bridge suffers. Its only of use to people who are going around the city, and I imagine that, with the exception of trucks, there is a relatively limited amount of vehicles going from cork and west waterford to wexford area.

    On the subject of trucks, they would probably be most likely to avoid a toll because its a much higher cost for them. I wonder has the NRA figure of 6% increased since the HGV ban in the city centre, but i guess im drifting off topic now:)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,542 ✭✭✭dayshah


    gscully wrote: »
    Pedantry aside, isn't it just a bit ridiculous that anyone driving from Waterford, using the Suir Bridge, to get to Dublin Airport would have to pay three tolls?

    Could someone explain to me where our extortionate road tax goes?

    It pays for the roads.
    The amount of revenue generated from motor tax and taxes on petrol/diesel is less than what is spent on roads. Roads are subsidised from general taxation.

    That said, I think tolls are inefficient. If you want to make people pay for the amount they use roads it would be easier to just increase excise duty. All the infrastructure for that already exists, and it wouldn't divert people into city centres.


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    Benimar wrote: »
    I have to say, the argument that others do it, therefore we should, really annoys me.

    Ironic that people on this forum have been complaining about Waterford not having a M&S yet other citys do, so now we have a city with a nice new motorway that actually has no toll on it.

    All other motorways to citys have them so why not Waterford ;)
    The cost of tolls from Galway to Dublin Airport is crazy and should be reduced, rather than screwing everybody else to 'bring them in line' with the Galway road.

    Fair enough, but thats a different discussion
    I've always thought that the M9 should not be tolled because there isn't a viable alternative given the state of the old N9.

    Could Galway people not argue the same for the road from Dublin to Galway, or Cork people to argue the same for Dublin to Cork


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,542 ✭✭✭dayshah


    Cabaal wrote: »


    Could Galway people not argue the same for the road from Dublin to Galway, or Cork people to argue the same for Dublin to Cork
    The difference with the toll of on the new bridge is that its a reverse congestion charge. It actually funnels traffic into the city centre, not away. I think its fair to compare the new bridge to the J Lynch tunnel, which has no road.

    I think it would be fair to get rid of the bridge toll and put more tolls on the motorway instead. Or better still, scrap all tolls and just increase excise duty on petrol and diesel.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,072 ✭✭✭sunnysoutheast


    dayshah wrote: »
    The difference with the toll of on the new bridge is that its a reverse congestion charge. It actually funnels traffic into the city centre, not away. I think its fair to compare the new bridge to the J Lynch tunnel, which has no road.

    I think it would be fair to get rid of the bridge toll and put more tolls on the motorway instead. Or better still, scrap all tolls and just increase excise duty on petrol and diesel.

    The Jack Lynch tunnel has a road in it, unless there was an apocalyptic event after I got the red eye LHR flight this morning :D

    Does anyone know - how much is the HGV toll on the new bridge and how does this compare to the fuel cost of routing down through Gracedieu (presumably), over the bridge and up through Ferrybank or past the station back to the N9/N25?

    On a personal note we happily pay the €1.90 to access the bypass to get home if we're coming back from the Dublin direction, I just can't be bothered getting caught up on the quay.

    SSE


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,536 ✭✭✭JohnC.


    Does anyone know - how much is the HGV toll on the new bridge and how does this compare to the fuel cost of routing down through Gracedieu (presumably), over the bridge and up through Ferrybank or past the station back to the N9/N25?

    Toll%20Rate%20Table%202.JPG

    I have no idea what the fuel consumption of an HGV would be, but hardly €6 in that distance?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,072 ✭✭✭sunnysoutheast


    Kahless wrote: »
    Toll%20Rate%20Table%202.JPG

    I have no idea what the fuel consumption of an HGV would be, but hardly €6 in that distance?

    HGVs are around 5-10 MPG aren't they?

    Maybe someone in the know can work out the comparatives, but I've noticed a few more lorries using the bridge recently.

    SSE


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 222 ✭✭mecco


    HGVs are around 5-10 MPG aren't they?

    Maybe someone in the know can work out the comparatives, but I've noticed a few more lorries using the bridge recently.

    SSE

    A few months ago they blocked off the centre of town to lorries with 3.5tonne limits once you get past the industrial estate


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 119 ✭✭Sikie


    Well up to a few weeks ago I thought it my own private toll bridge there was been mornings recently where queues were up to 2 deep at the manual pay station.


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    Sikie wrote: »
    Well up to a few weeks ago I thought it my own private toll bridge there was been mornings recently where queues were up to 2 deep at the manual pay station.

    No idea why people use the manual pay station, you can use the self serve one's and there's normally one or two open


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 119 ✭✭Sikie


    Its a question of change using it daily it cost 10c extra to drop in 2 euro.
    Setting up an account I would use it the whole time, time is a valuable item itself. Using real money keeps me in control.:o


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    Sikie wrote: »
    Its a question of change using it daily it cost 10c extra to drop in 2 euro.

    But it doesn't, it still costs 1.90


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,029 ✭✭✭shedweller


    You are always gonna get skinflints no matter what the economic climate is. Miserable bitter ol' sods would rather put themselves thru the misery of driving an extra 15miles & add an extra 30mins on their journeys just to avoid paying a 1.80euro toll;
    As somebody else pointed out, it's 1.90. If i were to use it daily to get to work i would pay 950 per year, excluding two weeks where i may not due to holidays etc.
    Thats some pay cut.

    I laugh when i hear this nonsense about turning off the standby on various electrical appliances to save a few euro per year. Or when i'm told to shop around for car insurance to save (admittedly more) euro. But it's never much is it? Well, it's not 950 euro anyway!
    And here we are being bullied into throwing up to a grand per year to this crowd. I'll not have a part of it.
    Put a much smaller levy onto the fuel and we will ALL pay for the roads.
    I thought we were anyway but it turns out we weren't paying for the roads at all!:rolleyes:
    This thing of "if you can afford....." etc. is pure bull.

    When does it stop?

    When we are on our knees? I nearly am as it is.


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    shedweller wrote: »
    I laugh when i hear this nonsense about turning off the standby on various electrical appliances to save a few euro per year.
    <SNIP> But it's never much is it?

    hmm I don't know now,
    If I have my PC and all the additions to it plugged in but not switched on it costs 30e a year just to have them plugged in. Thats just my PC, the likes of TV, Microwave etc also obviously cost money.

    So yes it does add up to a fair bit, I guess its a case of penny wise £ foolish :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,790 ✭✭✭Benimar


    Cabaal wrote: »
    Ironic that people on this forum have been complaining about Waterford not having a M&S yet other citys do, so now we have a city with a nice new motorway that actually has no toll on it.
    All other motorways to citys have them so why not Waterford ;)

    I used the word 'I'. I never claimed we should have a M&S just because other cities do. Others have made that argument, I haven't and I was expressing my opinion about something.
    Cabaal wrote: »
    Fair enough, but thats a different discussion

    It's not a different discussion. If you remove the toll on the Galway road, then the argument for one on the M9 disappears with it.

    Cabaal wrote: »
    Could Galway people not argue the same for the road from Dublin to Galway, or Cork people to argue the same for Dublin to Cork


    Having driven the Waterford-Dublin and Galway-Dublin routes using the old roads there is no comparison. The N9 is actually a disgrace.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,388 ✭✭✭gbee


    fricatus wrote: »
    Tolls are a stupid idea. All they do is discourage use of the tolled road.
    but it seems completely stupid to discourage people from using a safer, less congested, high quality road..

    I hate M-Ways. Apart from the novelty of a bit of speed, or the necessity to make a deadline .... they are boring and mind numbing and IMO are in fact MORE dangerous because we still can go from 130KM to 100KM to 50KM and I find I'm speeding even more than ever.

    I like the older more scenic routes, traffic and all ~ obviously it can get excessive at times too, but generally its a nicer dive.

    On my last Dublin trip I deliberately avoided all M roads as much as I could and deliberately went through the towns and villages ... stopping for coffee and dinner ... lovely actually.

    Now, I know I have the M-Ways to thanks for that as there is a lot of people using them and by-passing everything ...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,818 ✭✭✭Minstrel27


    gbee wrote: »
    I hate M-Ways. Apart from the novelty of a bit of speed, or the necessity to make a deadline .... they are boring and mind numbing and IMO are in fact MORE dangerous because we still can go from 130KM to 100KM to 50KM and I find I'm speeding even more than ever.

    I like the older more scenic routes, traffic and all ~ obviously it can get excessive at times too, but generally its a nicer dive.

    On my last Dublin trip I deliberately avoided all M roads as much as I could and deliberately went through the towns and villages ... stopping for coffee and dinner ... lovely actually.

    Now, I know I have the M-Ways to thanks for that as there is a lot of people using them and by-passing everything ...

    I wish they would put a motorway between my house and the shop. They are a God send. Driving on narrow twisting N roads is not my idea of a nice drive.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 182 ✭✭Joey leBlanc


    Benimar wrote: »
    I object to tolls.
    I have NEVER brought drink into a pub
    I pay my bin charges and do not dump illegally

    Oh, and the toll is €1.90..each way..for a car. Sounds like you don't use it too often?

    What's an extra 10 cent gotta do with it? €1.80/€1.90 Who Cares??
    No, I don't use it too often coz I don't need to. But I happily toss my
    coins into the basket when I have too.
    I can't understand why people object to paying tolls on roads. Roads
    across Europe are heavilly tolled (try driving from the North of France right down to the South & then u will realise how cheap Irish tolls are in comparison).
    If u object to the tolls stick to the ol national regional bohereen's that criss-cross & wind thru the land. I'll be at Dublin Airport in under 2 hrs whilst u are stuck behind some tractor in Co. Kilkenny!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 182 ✭✭Joey leBlanc


    fricatus wrote: »
    I work in Kilkenny and use the M9.

    Approximately 20 working days in a month...
    That makes 240 in a year.
    Travelling to and fro, that makes 480 trips.
    Assuming a toll of €1.90, that makes €912 a year. Skinflint, you say?

    Before you ask, public transport doesn't serve my workplace, unless you consider a 25-minute walk acceptable.
    In any event, I often start before the first Waterford-KK train gets to KK, and at other times I finish after the last train leaves.

    And like Benimar, I have NEVER brought drink into a pub, I pay my bin charges and do not dump illegally.

    In monetary terms if you were to purchase a Trip Card you receive a 10% discount on all tolls which reduces your figure of €912 by €91.12 to €820.80 p/a. Savings can be made if you do your research!

    Further, if you are working in Kilkenny, I estimate that you are spending at least €65.00 per week on petrol which equates to €3,200.00 per annum when you deduct 4wks for annual leave. If your travel expenses are at that level what's a extra €3.41(€1.70 each way) per day for a bit of comfort? Yes, it may not matter in the summer months when the schools are out but in deepest winter driving a high quality road in priceless!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,790 ✭✭✭Benimar


    In monetary terms if you were to purchase a Trip Card you receive a 10% discount on all tolls which reduces your figure of €912 by €91.12 to €820.80 p/a. Savings can be made if you do your research!

    Further, if you are working in Kilkenny, I estimate that you are spending at least €65.00 per week on petrol which equates to €3,200.00 per annum when you deduct 4wks for annual leave. If your travel expenses are at that level what's a extra €3.41(€1.70 each way) per day for a bit of comfort? Yes, it may not matter in the summer months when the schools are out but in deepest winter driving a high quality road in priceless!

    An increase in yearly transport charges of €820.80 if hardly a saving unless we follow the Dougal Maguire principal that if you expect a kick in the you-know-whats but get a slap in the face its a victory! Yes, its less than €912 but its a hell of a lot more than the current cost of €0.

    Also, €820.80 is a 26% increase in travel costs based on your assumptions, which is significant in the best of times but with the other forms of taxes we already pay (direct and stealth), and throw in the inevitable Property Tax we will have to pay after the budget, it could really cause financial difficulties for some.

    It's not the one charge in itself that causes difficulties, its the combined effect of all the charges. Say, for example, that the proposed toll is 'only' €1.70, and Motor Tax might 'only' go up €10 and duty might 'only' increase by 5c in the budget, but add it all together and it would come to a very large increase. It's easy to see every increase as a small amount, but add them all up and it looks completely different.

    Also, in the current climate of wage cuts (for those lucky enough to work), to pay €820.80 would require you to earn a gross of close to €1,600.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,081 ✭✭✭fricatus


    gbee wrote: »
    I hate M-Ways. Apart from the novelty of a bit of speed, or the necessity to make a deadline .... they are boring and mind numbing and IMO are in fact MORE dangerous because we still can go from 130KM to 100KM to 50KM and I find I'm speeding even more than ever.

    I like the older more scenic routes, traffic and all ~ obviously it can get excessive at times too, but generally its a nicer dive.

    On my last Dublin trip I deliberately avoided all M roads as much as I could and deliberately went through the towns and villages ... stopping for coffee and dinner ... lovely actually.

    Now, I know I have the M-Ways to thanks for that as there is a lot of people using them and by-passing everything ...

    You're entitled to your preferences of course, and more power to you if you want to take your time and stop to enjoy the view.

    One thing I will take issue with is your contention that motorways are more dangerous than the old national roads. I read somewhere that the M1 has one-seventh the accident rate (or death? injury? rate - sorry since I don't have the link to hand) of the old N1 road, and that's not taking account of the increase in traffic that has occurred since the M1 started being built.

    I'm sure there are plenty more statistics to back up this point, because I've read enough of them. If you have a look at any NRA or Transport21 report, you'll probably see this mentioned there.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 478 ✭✭wellbutty


    What's an extra 10 cent gotta do with it? €1.80/€1.90 Who Cares??
    No, I don't use it too often coz I don't need to. But I happily toss my
    coins into the basket when I have too.
    I can't understand why people object to paying tolls on roads. Roads
    across Europe are heavilly tolled (try driving from the North of France right down to the South & then u will realise how cheap Irish tolls are in comparison).
    If u object to the tolls stick to the ol national regional bohereen's that criss-cross & wind thru the land. I'll be at Dublin Airport in under 2 hrs whilst u are stuck behind some tractor in Co. Kilkenny!

    Some bridges in the UK are almost €10 to cross, one way, as are some bridges in France. In France I've paid €18 upwards, one way, to cover the distance of Waterford to Dublin. Yes we have high motor tax here but we now have amazing roads for a such a small country, €1.90 is not too much to ask to use them.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,081 ✭✭✭fricatus


    In monetary terms if you were to purchase a Trip Card you receive a 10% discount on all tolls which reduces your figure of €912 by €91.12 to €820.80 p/a. Savings can be made if you do your research!

    Don't patronise me with this Eddie Hobbs rubbish. I'm well aware of the trip card. Believe me I would buy one if I had to use a tolled road on a regular basis. It's still eight hundred and twenty bloody quid though! Nearly a whole mortgage payment!

    Further, if you are working in Kilkenny, I estimate that you are spending at least €65.00 per week on petrol which equates to €3,200.00 per annum when you deduct 4wks for annual leave. If your travel expenses are at that level what's a extra €3.41(€1.70 each way) per day for a bit of comfort? Yes, it may not matter in the summer months when the schools are out but in deepest winter driving a high quality road in priceless!

    I spend €50 p/w on diesel, and yes, I would probably be well able to afford another €17 p/w in tolls, but you're ignoring my argument, which is not what it costs me or any other guy, but the cumulative effect of tolls pushing motorists off the good, new, safe! roads and on to the crappy tractor boreens of yore.

    What do you think the good people of Thomastown or Mullinavat would think about the M9 being tolled, just as they're getting their villages back after many years of HGV traffic?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,849 ✭✭✭Bards


    its not goint to happen - the M9 was built using taxpayuers and EU money. We are not going to end up paying twice for something we (Taxpayers) have already paid

    'tis about time this Govt were kicked out of office for pure incompetance of the highest order and then sued by the taxpayer for blowing €22bn down the dark bog of Anglo without asking for our permission/REFERENDUM


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Regional South East Moderators Posts: 28,552 Mod ✭✭✭✭Cabaal


    Bards wrote: »
    its not goint to happen - the M9 was built using taxpayuers and EU money.

    I could be wrong but many many roads throughout the EU have been built with EU funds and have tolls


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,081 ✭✭✭wellboytoo


    Just for a bit of perspective... If you drive a forty foot reefer from here Waterford to Milan , tolls on motorways/tunnels= €1195.00 , get over it


Advertisement