Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Rumor has the irish army are recruiting ?

  • 03-05-2010 8:40am
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 202 ✭✭


    Hi everyone i heard off a source that the army are recruiting soon hope its true as its something i would love to do as it runs in the family.

    Any help would be great hope its true

    Thanks again


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,267 ✭✭✭concussion


    There is still no confirmation. The Minister has said he intends to recruit ~200 by the end of the year but there's been no announcement as of yet.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 202 ✭✭Dannyboy1987


    concussion wrote: »
    There is still no confirmation. The Minister has said he intends to recruit ~200 by the end of the year but there's been no announcement as of yet.

    hope they sort something out soon

    Thanks


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,072 ✭✭✭PeterIanStaker


    Email the press officer, or check www.military.ie for updates.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,025 ✭✭✭muboop1


    When was the last time the air corps recruited?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 155 ✭✭ODriscoll


    Be patient and good luck.
    The Irish Military are one of the few forces in the world, that you can be proud of as a institution.
    Worth the wait.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,497 ✭✭✭Poccington


    ODriscoll wrote: »
    Be patient and good luck.
    The Irish Military are one of the few forces in the world, that you can be proud of as a institution.
    Worth the wait.

    How many other armed forces have you served in?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 37 Gilligan.Mark


    Are they gonna be recruiting for officers in that 200?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 66 ✭✭echo.lima


    muboop1 wrote: »
    When was the last time the air corps recruited?

    I think the last time the air corps took recruits directly was 2006.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 66 ✭✭echo.lima


    Are they gonna be recruiting for officers in that 200?

    There`ll probably be very few positions for cadets within that 200.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    A recruitment competition is being run for the Naval Service. It is starting on Friday and only recruiting 40 people.

    on Friday,

    Go to www.military.ie - there will be a link that you click, the appication process is being done online now.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,497 ✭✭✭Poccington


    echo.lima wrote: »
    There`ll probably be very few positions for cadets within that 200.

    Cadets don't fall under the same umbrella as general recruiting.

    If they did, there wouldn't be a Cadet class in training right now. You can almost guarantee there'll be a Cadet competition run this year.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4 pete_cork


    Poccington, as someone who intends to apply for an Irish Army Cadeship this year, how can you be sos ure? I have heard conflicting reports as to whether there will be a cadet class or not...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,798 ✭✭✭Local-womanizer


    pete_cork wrote: »
    Poccington, as someone who intends to apply for an Irish Army Cadeship this year, how can you be sos ure? I have heard conflicting reports as to whether there will be a cadet class or not...

    There has never not been a Cadet class run. And last year when it seemed lke it wasent going to run it did.

    On current form,chances are there will be one. Stay positive ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 202 ✭✭Dannyboy1987


    anyone know what the Irish navy is like


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 675 ✭✭✭Dr.Sanchez


    benwavner wrote: »
    A recruitment competition is being run for the Naval Service. It is starting on Friday and only recruiting 40 people.

    on Friday,

    Go to www.military.ie - there will be a link that you click, the appication process is being done online now.

    Where does it say their only taking on 40?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,798 ✭✭✭Local-womanizer


    00Blaine00 wrote: »
    Where does it say their only taking on 40?

    It said it on the Facebook site,1 platoon of 40.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭theirishguy


    all i see is this

    Naval Service Start Recruitment

    Friday 14 May, 2010



    The Naval Service will start a recruitment competition on Friday 14 May 2010 and will close on June 4th, 2010.
    For more information on the Naval Service and how to apply follow this link Naval Service Recruitment


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,798 ✭✭✭Local-womanizer


    I was doubting meself there but I knew I read it somewhere!

    http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1013334026#!/IrishDefenceForces?ref=sgm

    Go to one of Pats post on the 14th of May about the recruitment,a few comments into that post he says its 40 places or 1 platoon.

    "Pat O'Connor 17 to 27 before 1 August 2010. There are 40 places, that's one recruit platoon, there are no updates on Army or AC."
    14 May at 12:46


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 510 ✭✭✭serjical_strike


    anyone know what the Irish navy is like

    ****e i just left after serving 5 years in there.!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 675 ✭✭✭Dr.Sanchez


    ****e i just left after serving 5 years in there.!

    Care to give us some insight into the job and day-to-day life?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,333 ✭✭✭Tones69


    ****e i just left after serving 5 years in there.!

    That bad really? What didnt you like about it, the sea time or what?
    Thanks


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,252 ✭✭✭Sterling Archer


    Just out of curiosity is there a maximum age to apply to the army, air corps, Navy for general service


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,639 ✭✭✭Sugar Free


    Shane_ef wrote: »
    Just out of curiosity is there a maximum age to apply to the army, air corps, Navy for general service

    27 for the Naval Service, from the application form, "Are you over 17 years of age and under 27 years of age on August 1st 2010?"

    25 for the Army, http://www.military.ie/careers/booklets/genservice-eng.pdf


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 pollars4


    ODriscoll wrote: »
    Be patient and good luck.
    The Irish Military are one of the few forces in the world, that you can be proud of as a institution.
    Worth the wait.

    Nonscence I spent 5 years in their 1999 - 2004 and got bullied out of the place. NCO's with position power too ignorant to realise they are in a small impotent defense force and they behave like they are in the American special forces. Officers are a different story I would emplore anybody not to go in as a recruit where you will be subjected to some monkey pushing you round for the fun of it or whatever narrow minded reason he/she may have. I did enjoy recruits but as soon as that ended and I went into operation I met some complete tools. Made good friends in their also but normal objective people are thin on the ground. It is a cushy job though. When I was in there you start at 08.45 and finish at 16.20, 5 days a week, half days all over the place, 28 days leave a year plus army and bank holidays, public holidays, the odd duty, you didn't have to go over seas if you didn't want to, 7 days uncertified sick days a year plus if you don't want to use them just go to the base doctor and tell him your sick and away home you go. People need to know facts before they make decisions based on whatever romantic notions they may have. The pay for a recruit is very good and with bench marking I can only imagine how good it has become. The personnel turnover when I was in their of people fleeing the stupidity was enormous and if they are recruiting again it must be still going on, but in a recession they have the upper hand. If it's changed - and I doubt it - then it is a good job based on job security, a pension, cheap booze, cheap loans and cheap accommodation and payment whether you work or not - whats wrong with that - but it's not a military in any sense of the word, after recruits and training courses its just a cushy job. And if you want to get anywhere you need to lick some serious hole, and its seniority and not ability for the most part that will push you up the ranks. If you have a brain in your head, a half decent leaving cert or a degree then go in as a cadet, you will be shown how to lead, educated and given a sword, and can go about with some self respect, if your not bothered about your mental health, you left school early or with little to no education and doesn't mind being pushed around then go in as a recruit and pucker up.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,688 Mod ✭✭✭✭Morpheus


    pollars4 wrote: »
    Nonscence I spent 5 years in their 1999 - 2004 and got bullied out of the place. if your not bothered about your mental health, you left school early or with little to no education and doesn't mind being pushed around then go in as a recruit and pucker up.

    So you are saying that the majority of irish soldiers (enlisted) are retarded lazy bullies?

    Sorry you had such a bad experience with your own unit, but as regards the above sweeping statement, I completely disagree. Bullying is not tolerated today. That was 8 years ago and much has changed. The force is far more professional. As regards choosing to go / not go overseas, im not so sure its that simple anymore.
    :(


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,460 ✭✭✭DipStick McSwindler


    This post has been deleted.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    pollars4 wrote: »
    Nonscence I spent 5 years in their 1999 - 2004 and got bullied out of the place. NCO's with position power too ignorant to realise they are in a small impotent defense force and they behave like they are in the American special forces. Officers are a different story I would emplore anybody not to go in as a recruit where you will be subjected to some monkey pushing you round for the fun of it or whatever narrow minded reason he/she may have. I did enjoy recruits but as soon as that ended and I went into operation I met some complete tools. Made good friends in their also but normal objective people are thin on the ground. It is a cushy job though. When I was in there you start at 08.45 and finish at 16.20, 5 days a week, half days all over the place, 28 days leave a year plus army and bank holidays, public holidays, the odd duty, you didn't have to go over seas if you didn't want to, 7 days uncertified sick days a year plus if you don't want to use them just go to the base doctor and tell him your sick and away home you go. People need to know facts before they make decisions based on whatever romantic notions they may have. The pay for a recruit is very good and with bench marking I can only imagine how good it has become. The personnel turnover when I was in their of people fleeing the stupidity was enormous and if they are recruiting again it must be still going on, but in a recession they have the upper hand. If it's changed - and I doubt it - then it is a good job based on job security, a pension, cheap booze, cheap loans and cheap accommodation and payment whether you work or not - whats wrong with that - but it's not a military in any sense of the word, after recruits and training courses its just a cushy job. And if you want to get anywhere you need to lick some serious hole, and its seniority and not ability for the most part that will push you up the ranks. If you have a brain in your head, a half decent leaving cert or a degree then go in as a cadet, you will be shown how to lead, educated and given a sword, and can go about with some self respect, if your not bothered about your mental health, you left school early or with little to no education and doesn't mind being pushed around then go in as a recruit and pucker up.


    Man, there is so much wrong with this post that I dont know where to start. I wont bother pulling it all apart but It actually doesnt sound like you served for all that time, in fact I doubt you served at all.

    "People need to know facts before they make decisions", its a pity that you didnt post any facts.

    Feel free to PM me your ex number, rank and name, and maybe what unit you served in. I could hold your argument with much more weight.

    You served 5 years, were you not signed back on? I find it hard that you were bullied out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 311 ✭✭KickstartHeart



    Cadets are due to begin training this october. The applicants for that class have already been whittled down to the last few hundred and the competition is still on-going. There won't be another competition this year.
    Minister of Defence Alan Shatter said in an interview with a local Offaly news paper that there is a disproportionate amount of officers to other ranks in the defence forces and he intends to rectify that. I can say with 100% certainty because of that that there won't be ANOTHER cadetship competition this year. There's usually only one a year anyway. The DF also hasn't even finished its competition to fill the 600 vacancies of other ranks accross the Army and the Navy so don't hold too much hope for another competition to be run this year for general recruits. If they do decide to fill more vacancies amongst other ranks AFTER that 600 have been inducted, they'll probably take those new recruits from the succesful but unselected candidates of the competition currently being run.


    In short, don't expect to be able to apply until well in 2013. Thats just my opinion though. People that are actually in the DF might be able to give you better advice.


    EDIT: Disregard my post here, I didn't realise how old this thread was


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,827 ✭✭✭ex_infantry man


    i kinda agree with the bullying part!! our platoon commander who may i add was fresh out of cadet school had a major chip on his shoulder, he was a year younger than myself who also thought he was **** hot walking around as if he was massive when in fact he was a scrawny fecker, he used often take the platoon out of eyeshot of anyone senior and beast the feck outta us just cos he could and one night he had us in rain gear and cefo, gave us all pick axes and spade marched us over to waste ground at the back of the barracks had us dig out and area 20 foot by 20 foot then split the platoon in half one half was filling sand bags the other half still digging out the area carefully removing the sods and placing them in one pile and any stones we found in another!!! may i also add that the heavens were falling that night, but anyway he called the platoon altogether and screamed grenade and had us leper crawl through the area making sure we were all destroyed and told us to have every single bit of gear we had on us spotless that we would be inspected in them the next day!!! his reason for doin this was that he claimed that we made a show of him, i'm sorry now but what he did there to us was an impossible task and is classed as bullying!!!!this was only in 2005 may i add


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 159 ✭✭Burdock


    i kinda agree with the bullying part!! our platoon commander who may i add was fresh out of cadet school had a major chip on his shoulder, he was a year younger than myself who also thought he was **** hot walking around as if he was massive when in fact he was a scrawny fecker, he used often take the platoon out of eyeshot of anyone senior and beast the feck outta us just cos he could and one night he had us in rain gear and cefo, gave us all pick axes and spade marched us over to waste ground at the back of the barracks had us dig out and area 20 foot by 20 foot then split the platoon in half one half was filling sand bags the other half still digging out the area carefully removing the sods and placing them in one pile and any stones we found in another!!! may i also add that the heavens were falling that night, but anyway he called the platoon altogether and screamed grenade and had us leper crawl through the area making sure we were all destroyed and told us to have every single bit of gear we had on us spotless that we would be inspected in them the next day!!! his reason for doin this was that he claimed that we made a show of him, i'm sorry now but what he did there to us was an impossible task and is classed as bullying!!!!this was only in 2005 may i add


    Any platoon commander I've worked with, and I've been involved with 5 recruit platoons, was a full lieutenant, 'fresh out of cadet school' I think not.

    Where'd you train ?? What was your army number ??

    I joined in 2000 and call BS on these posts BTW, no enlisted man talks like this.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,195 ✭✭✭goldie fish


    A baby lieutenant "fresh out of cadet school" will go noplace other than to college.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 114 ✭✭dodgydes


    What colour is the boathouse in Coolmooney Camp? :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 311 ✭✭KickstartHeart


    Its actually hilarious to read the stuff that people who weren't suited to the Army spout online about their bad experiences.


    I find it particularly hilarious because they go on about the downsides of military training/service as if it only happens in the Irish Army. I have friends in the British Army and they have the exact same quams about it. Infact, the statements of the above two posters whinging about their time in the Army are somewhat near identical to the things that people I know have said about their times in the BRITISH ARMY.

    So if the Irish Army isn't a military in any sense then neither is the British Army ;)

    If you didn't like your time in the Army then there's an enormous abundance of people who served who will counter what you say and that can admit that the hardship of military training isn't bullying, it has a purpose. If your'e the kind of person who will come online on and be-little the Defence Forces and your time in it, then the training just very simply didn't work on you, or you weren't suited to it.

    I'm not targetting any ONE person in particular here, rather a few posters on this site, but if you want to come on here and whine about your time in the Army and maintain the chip on the shoulder about it, then you should think about the fact that if you haven't served in any other military, then you don't GET to say whether the Irish military is 'real' 'not real' 'impotent' or anything along those lines. These are the same gripes that people have about most armies if they weren't suited to their service.

    For anyone reading this, when you see the complaints of the previous posters and you ponder whether the Irish Defence Forces is a real military or not, remember too that people who have served in the British Army, which seams to be the grand daddy of all online fanboy idolization, have had the exact same issues as the above posters have had.

    Army training is hard, and can seam like your'e being bullied, and hell the instructors may even enjoy it, but it has its purpose, and if it wasn't suited to you, or if you think too much of yourself, then it will seam rediculous, but it is not. Military life when not on operations can seam like boring monotonous hell, but thats military life... in any army..on either side of the Irish Sea, on any contenant, no matter how much of a war fighting army your'e in and no matter what flag you have on your shoulder.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,539 ✭✭✭John_D80


    A baby lieutenant "fresh out of cadet school" will go noplace other than to college.

    Incorrect. I know of a few instances where young officers have deferred college for a few years. And there are plenty officers out there who have been recruit platoon commanders as one-pippers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,539 ✭✭✭John_D80


    Burdock wrote: »
    Any platoon commander I've worked with, and I've been involved with 5 recruit platoons, was a full lieutenant, 'fresh out of cadet school' I think not.

    Where'd you train ?? What was your army number ??

    I joined in 2000 and call BS on these posts BTW, no enlisted man talks like this.

    I'm not in anyway agreeing with the people who have posted gripes here about bullying but you're quite wrong (see my above reply to goldie fish's post).

    And dude, do you seriously think he would post his army number for a random stranger to check up on him? Would you? Very silly move if anyone did this.

    Oh and what exactly does an enlisted man talk like? Thats the most sweeping generalisation i've ever read.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,739 ✭✭✭✭minidazzler


    dodgydes wrote: »
    What colour is the boathouse in Coolmooney Camp? :D

    Where is the easiest place to go for a sneaky shag in Coolmoney will get out the ex-RDF lads at least :pac:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 pollars4


    benwavner wrote: »
    Man, there is so much wrong with this post that I dont know where to start. I wont bother pulling it all apart but It actually doesnt sound like you served for all that time, in fact I doubt you served at all.

    "People need to know facts before they make decisions", its a pity that you didnt post any facts.

    Feel free to PM me your ex number, rank and name, and maybe what unit you served in. I could hold your argument with much more weight.

    You served 5 years, were you not signed back on? I find it hard that you were bullied out.


    My personal details are not going up on a public forum for anyone to check out. I'm given my experience in the military, my five years of experience and the reason I didn't sign back on after my five year contract ended was because of my experience throughout my five years, why would I?

    From reading the posts of others I'm sure the majority of people enjoy or endure military life and I never thought otherwise, but I certainly didn't, my experience was miserable. I loved recruits, and I got best kit, for my trouble, and the reason I didn't get best recruit because I didn't shout as loud as the guy who did get it.

    After recruit training things got overly complicated with way to much politics, and 'playing the game' and 'moving the goalposts' as they called it. I was good at my job, enthusiastic and better than most including a lot of the NCO's and that singled me out. I was confident but but not cocky, and it happened all too often that some NCO took a dislike to me because of my ability or enthusiasm. They were like children or a group of gossiping women at times. There was very little you could do not to attract negative attention from dip**** NCO's who on a whim thought I and others were fair game for their behaviour that wasn't the expected robust military type behaviour, it was bullying and nothing else.

    I'm no push over I'm 6ft in height and 14 stone, and I'm not intimidated by someone telling me off for doing something stupid which is necessary, - as I said I loved that - in recruits you knew what you had to do and you did it and when you ****ed it up you got thorn apart, but it was part of it, it was preparing you for the service. But what I'm talking about a lot of enlisted men and women have experienced and it has caused a lot of good and capable people to leave after five years. And if your not aware that bullying has been a problem in the Irish army, navy and aircore then google it, and read the reports, the commissioned research and all the other stuff you can find.

    You and the others who read these post know all this yourself, and if you don't your in denial. There are enlisted men, and officers too, who have major chips on their shoulders, who don't want to do more than they should, and they can't stand it when others do, it makes them angry and devious, and their are lots of them. They just want to do the 21 and get the pension and burn away the hours in the base. Its these ****s I'm talking about, and when they get position power - rank - then they can do a lot of damage and have done a lot of damage to people. I had depression and anxiety disorder for most of my time since I came out, and I went in a confident intelligent young man and came out a wreck. So I'm entitled to my severe opinion, and I'm entitled to hold a grudge with the military.

    In all seriousness though why in Gods name would I make the statements I did if I never served. And it was immature of me to offend which I can't deny that part of my intention was to, but I'm still very bitter over it because all I wanted to do since I was a child was to be in the military, and because of the actions of tools who are of no benefit to the organisation, that was taken away from me. boo hoo right but **** them.

    Robust and necessary military training is completely different to bullying, and is immediately apparent when it goes on.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    I appreciate that you had a hard time while you "served" but there is just something about your choice of words that dont ring true with being ex military.

    I personally have never heard anyone use the term "moving the goalpost" or "burn away the hours in the base", what base? Were you AC or NS maybe? You also spelt Air Corps like this "aircore". :confused:

    Yes in the past people were victimised and bullied, but that was the old DF. A lot of measures have been put in place since you left, and it is just NOT tolerated anymore. In fact in my opinion, these measures have made the DF a worse environment for soldiers to work in. You have to be very very careful if you have to discipline anyone, or even to pull them aside to have a cautionary word, even if it is to benefit them.

    I would like you to PM me the unit you served in, or even what Brigade. It would solidify your case somewhat. Where I have served, your desciption of power mad NCO's and Officers is just not right. I find it extremely hard to believe that you suffered because of your enthusiasm and abilities, if anything, you should be an asset to a unit not a target for bullying.

    I dont think you are telling the whole truth here at all. It shouldnt be an issue to PM me those details.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,195 ✭✭✭goldie fish


    Yup. The basic terminology someone who served, even for a short time, would use is absent from any of your posts.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,539 ✭✭✭John_D80


    The chap (pollars4) is obviously a knob with a seriously over inflated opinion of himself if he believes that the reason he was singled out repeatedly was for being enthusiastic and having ability. The circumstances of what actually happened and what he chose to believe happened are probably very different in this case I reckon. Have seen countless guys like this come and go through the army in my time. And when they leave they generally have a serious chip on their shoulder towards the Defence Forces when a serious self examination is whats really needed.

    But gents, to dismiss someones posts as trolling or lying because they dont use the same terminology or phrases as someone in the military is rather unfair. There are people from a very broad spectrum of backgrounds among the enlisted ranks. In my recruit platoon, the only guy who had a degree was buddied with one of the guys who couldn't read. I know officers who are from the roughest/toughest parts of cork and limerick cities and walk and talk the part as well. Basically guys what i'm getting at is that we are as much a product of our background as we are of our current surroundings.

    And its certainly worth noting that pollars4 has been out of the defence forces for 8 years now and was only in it for 5 so i'm pretty sure he's not keeping up to date with the lingo and terminology, in his current civilian life.

    I in no way shape or form agree with his post but I certainly cant dismiss them for the same reasons as some. Just because someone puts forward a negative opinion of the DF on this board is no reason to call 'troll' or whatever.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    I understand your points John_D80 and you may be right about the guy. I personally think he is a multiple account holder who opened this one to troll.

    I know guys who left 10 years ago and only lasted a few weeks of recruit training, they refer to where they served as a "barracks" etc. If he spent 5 hard years in the DF, im sure he knew he spent that time in a Barracks.


    "But gents, to dismiss someones posts as trolling or lying because they dont use the same terminology or phrases as someone in the military is rather unfair. There are people from a very broad spectrum of backgrounds among the enlisted ranks. In my recruit platoon, the only guy who had a degree was buddied with one of the guys who couldn't read. I know officers who are from the roughest/toughest parts of cork and limerick cities and walk and talk the part as well. Basically guys what i'm getting at is that we are as much a product of our background as we are of our current surroundings"

    ^^^I dont know what the above has anything to do with anything^^^:confused:

    I have no problem with someone posting negative comments about the DF in here, but I would like them to come from someone with experience in the DF, who gave it a good crack and did not leave for an obscure reason.

    I find it unlikely that this guy served, if he PM'd me any of the following I would believe him and engage with him properly on here:

    • Unit(s) served in
    • Exercises completed
    • Overseas missions he went on, or could have volunteered for
    • What is A7..........The Glen of Imaal kind :cool:
    • Courses completed, and where they were held
    • What weapon would you find a "Pre-notched, spiral wound, steel wire sleeve" to be part of.
    If he cant answer any of these, then he either did not last recruit training or else he is a Walt, just posting to defame the DF.


    If he did serve, then I am saddend that such a quality soldier was forced to leave because of bullying and intimidation and would like to converse with the guy and get into the nitty gritty.


    But


    If he is a Walt, he is spredding an untrue experience and further damaging the reputation of the DF and all who serve(d), without due cause. I feel he should answer one of the above in the interest of transparency.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 pollars4


    benwavner wrote: »
    I understand your points John_D80 and you may be right about the guy. I personally think he is a multiple account holder who opened this one to troll.

    I know guys who left 10 years ago and only lasted a few weeks of recruit training, they refer to where they served as a "barracks" etc. If he spent 5 hard years in the DF, im sure he knew he spent that time in a Barracks.


    "But gents, to dismiss someones posts as trolling or lying because they dont use the same terminology or phrases as someone in the military is rather unfair. There are people from a very broad spectrum of backgrounds among the enlisted ranks. In my recruit platoon, the only guy who had a degree was buddied with one of the guys who couldn't read. I know officers who are from the roughest/toughest parts of cork and limerick cities and walk and talk the part as well. Basically guys what i'm getting at is that we are as much a product of our background as we are of our current surroundings"

    ^^^I dont know what the above has anything to do with anything^^^:confused:

    I have no problem with someone posting negative comments about the DF in here, but I would like them to come from someone with experience in the DF, who gave it a good crack and did not leave for an obscure reason.

    I find it unlikely that this guy served, if he PM'd me any of the following I would believe him and engage with him properly on here:

    • Unit(s) served in
    • Exercises completed
    • Overseas missions he went on, or could have volunteered for
    • What is A7..........The Glen of Imaal kind :cool:
    • Courses completed, and where they were held
    • What weapon would you find a "Pre-notched, spiral wound, steel wire sleeve" to be part of.
    If he cant answer any of these, then he either did not last recruit training or else he is a Walt, just posting to defame the DF.


    If he did serve, then I am saddend that such a quality soldier was forced to leave because of bullying and intimidation and would like to converse with the guy and get into the nitty gritty.


    But


    If he is a Walt, he is spredding an untrue experience and further damaging the reputation of the DF and all who serve(d), without due cause. I feel he should answer one of the above in the interest of transparency.


    I'm very wary of someone currently in the DF looking for my personal information and to PM you does not ensure my anonymity. And I have no interest in getting into this in a public forum or by email just to satisfy your ego as again after five years I'm entitled to my opinion. I'm being obscure in my use of military so not to draw to much attention to myself or my unit, obviously I'm not in the 'Air Corps' and I know nothing about the place but the other two, I know plenty, and I'm entitled to say what I like about the DF as it did me enough damage. Read between the lines and get over the idea that someone would go to all this effort just to troll, sure how could anyone think like that about the beloved defense forces. And in the eight years I have forgotten most of the terminology except the stuff thats burned into my brain like how to strip and clean a Styer, a GPMG, how the action works, and crap like that. I don't remember anything about the myriad of forms that I had to full out, or what kind of wounds weapons caused. And what the **** is a 'walt' I never heard of that. And if I'm "further damaging the reputation of the DF" who has already damaged it, and for what reason. I've got a gripe, and your a cheerleader lets agree to disagree.

    John D80 if you want to make this personal, then go ahead but remember their are consequences to everything and to dismiss me as a knob is in itself a bullying tactic. Just because I know myself and my capabilities does that indicate an over inflated opinion of myself. I thought I was a piece of **** with a really low opinion of myself for eight years what does that say about my character. You sound very familiar to the type of character that I would have experienced, dismissing all my behavior with a quick insult for your own end. Below is a publication implemented into the defense forces in 2001, 3 years into my time, now ask yourself why? Was their a problem?

    SECTION 6 BULLYING

    130. Definition of Bullying Bullying is defined as repeated inappropriate behavior, direct or indirect, whether verbal, physical or otherwise, conducted by one or more persons against another or others, at the place of work and/or in the course of employment, which could reasonably be regarded as undermining the individual's right to dignity at work. An isolated incident of the behavior described in this definition may be an affront to dignity at work but as a once-off incident is not considered to be bullying. (Government Task Force on the Prevention of Workplace Bullying,2001)

    131. Behaviour falling within the scope of para 130 above constitutes unacceptable behavior in the Defence Forces.

    132. Bullying can be perpetrated not only by a superior on a subordinate, but also by a peer on another peer, or by a subordinate on a superior, or by a group to constitute unacceptable behavior.

    133. Bullying must be distinguished from the proper use of rank and authority which is necessary to achieve legitimate military objectives. Bullying is, in fact, the misuse of rank and authority. Operational effectiveness requires the Defence Forces to be physically strong and robust and, when needed, to display controlled aggression. This is not achieved by bullying. It is the responsibility of commanders at all levels to protect individuals from both physical and mental intimidation by peers or persons in positions of authority. Initiation ceremonies involving assault, humiliation, intimidation, or the abuse of alcohol are unacceptable.

    134. The monitoring, review and evaluation of performance is an essential part of the command function. All superiors are required to effectively monitor the performance of their subordinates. It is the duty of superiors to be open with subordinates about performance, attendance or general conduct. Effective supervision may require critical comments to individuals about issues relevant to their official duties. However, such criticism should not be personalised but directed against the conduct or performance of a subordinate. Bullying does not arise, where critical comments are made in an honest and constructive manner.

    135. Examples The list of examples, below, should be regarded as illustrative rather than exhaustive:

    Intimidation.
    Eyeballing or shouting into a person’s face.
    Preventing the victim from speaking by using aggressive and/or obscene language.
    Subjecting an individual to unreasonable scrutiny.
    Swearing or other forms of demeaning name-calling.
    Physical abuse or threats of abuse.
    Physically attacking, threatening to attack or acting in a menacing way towards another person.
    Gratuitous commenting on the appearance of another person
    Setting unreasonable or impossible deadlines or impossible or meaningless tasks.
    Unwarranted or disproportionate criticism unsupported by facts of an individual's work performance.
    Manipulation of the victim's reputation by rumour, gossip, ridicule and/or innuendo.
    Making an individual, his or her beliefs or opinions, the butt of jokes or uncomplimentary remarks which are likely to cause offence.
    Social exclusion or isolation; deliberately ignoring or excluding an individual on a persistent basis.
    Undermining the authority of a colleague in the workplace.
    Manipulating the nature of the work or the ability of the victim to perform the work, for example by withholding information in order to undermine a colleague.


    The first lot of these I would consider normal robust military training even if they are now classed as bullying and it never bothered me and in most cases amused me, as the individuals who confront you to your face are the ones you can trust and the ones just doing their job its the latter of these that caused most of the problems. If I had a problem the former I would have left in recruits, its the latter that drove me out after 5 years.




  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,968 ✭✭✭✭Praetorian Saighdiuir


    Look man, this has nothing to do with my "ego". It has everything to do with transparency. You cant just come on here and post what you have posted without satisfying the people who are going to read it. You could be some civvy living in a fantasy world posting rubbish for a reaction.

    Once again you wont name something specific to confirm that you were a serving member of the PDF. If you are big and bold enough to come on here and tell us all that you were bullied out of the DF, then you could at least answer one of my questions!

    It would put an end to all this "tit for tat", and we can get on with the process of discussing what happened to you. The following questions do NOT affect opsec or your anonymity in the slightest!

    • What type of boot were you issued?
    • What accessories go on your Service Dress No1's?
    • What is an L.A 30 Admin?

    "I'm being obscure in my use of military so not to draw to much attention to myself or my unit"


    ^^^^This makes NO sense^^^^


    Im looking forward to a proper discussion with you, once I get an answer to these questions.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,195 ✭✭✭goldie fish


    What's a styer?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 634 ✭✭✭Maoltuile


    What's a styer?

    A question someone should ask the DFTC some time!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 31 grasncov


    Maoltuile wrote: »
    What's a styer?

    A question someone should ask the DFTC some time!

    And what would u know about it?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,497 ✭✭✭Poccington


    Tone down the language.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 31 grasncov


    Poccington wrote: »
    Tone down the language.

    There was no language in the last post, but I took it down so I wouldn't keep getting warned off. Best of luck


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 634 ✭✭✭Maoltuile


    grasncov wrote: »
    And what would u know about it?

    More than you apparently, sport.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 31 grasncov


    Maoltuile wrote: »
    grasncov wrote: »
    And what would u know about it?

    More than you apparently, sport.

    ;-) ok


  • Advertisement
Advertisement