Can I get a second opinion on this!

jigsawmurderer

I play in a band called the jigsaw murders and we're looking for a female singer. We've done all the usual stuff (posts, posters, endless networking etc.) but one thing that we've done that I haven't seen other bands do is make videos to advertise the position. What I'm asking is do you think these videos are a good idea or are they likely to scare off any potential singers. And if they are likely to help, which one is better?

Thanks for your time. It is muchos appreciated.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZhmDUfgSek

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWhMiK-Qtks

ham_n_mustard

Howya Lad.
its unique, i'll give you that!
im neither female nor a singer so that wont help you, but think of this as a free bump
best of luck with the search

jigsawmurderer

Why thank you kind sir.

Yillan

Only listened the first one there, but I think it's great. Very QOTSA/Kaizer Chiefs...

Don't know why you're looking for a female singer. I'd prefer a male voice behind those melodies, but that's just me.

The way you're going about finding a singer though I like. Don't see why it would put anyone off and if they are put off, then you don't want them fronting your band really.

jigsawmurderer

Well thats very true too. Theres a few reasons why I want a girl to sing but you do make much sense friend.