resistence 2 v halo 3 v Gears of wars 2

Vampireskiss

What order would you put these best to worst?

Gears of Wars 2
Halo 3
Resistence 2

Captain Chaos

Same

GoW 2
Halo 3
Res 2

humanji

Personally, I think none of them are anything special and wouldn't really rate them, but the above order is how I'd put them if cornered.

FreeOSCAR

Gears 2
Killzone 2
Halo 3
Resistance 2

davrho

Gears 2 by miles at the top.

Dont rate either of the other 2. I can only see this debate going down the fan boy route

noodler

Gears is way too repetitive for me. Halo 2 was better than 3. and Resistance 1 was better than 2 (Single-player anyway).

Gummy Panda

Killzone 2 > all in OP imo

Seifer

noodler wrote: »

Gears is way too repetitive for me. Halo 2 was better than 3. and Resistance 1 was better than 2 (Single-player anyway).

That's actual crazy talk. Halo 2 is universally agreed as a rushed job and the weakest of the series. The only thing that saved it was the mulitplayer.

I'd go Halo 3, GoW2 and Resistance 2.
Saying that, I haven't played Resistance and I despise GoW2's cover system and its stay dead til the end of the round multiplayer. Thinks it's counter-strike does it?

Fol20

Gow2(although multiplayer waiting times is fair)
halo3(good multiplayer fun)
Uncharted 2(i know its not out but cant wait for multiplayer)
Killzone 2(good enough shooter but id prefer if i had the xbox triggers for firing)
res 2 (not my type of game)

Retr0gamer

PC with mouse and keyboard >>>>>>> Than all 3

My vote goes to System Shock 2.

Podge2k7

Call of Duty >>>>>>>>>> resistance,gow and halo!!

pablomakaveli

I have'nt played halo 3 so it's Gears of war 2 over resistance 2.

I played Killzone 2 as well but i never really got into it. It really irritated me when i found i could'nt swap the pistol for another weapon.

mcrdotcom

Never played Gears 2...so

Ris 2, Halo 3, Gears 2

And CoD is better than them all!

smooch71

Gears of War 2

Resistance 2
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.Halo 3 (With about 100 PS3 and XBox 360 games in between)

sarumite

Personally it depends on what you mean by better. In terms of singler player, multi player or the whole package. For me, gears is top for singler player, halo 2 for mutliplayer and resistence two for the whole package (it had a solid and fleshed out, but not fantastic, single player as well as an indepth coop and competitive online game play).

Otacon

Retr0gamer wrote: »

PC with mouse and keyboard >>>>>>> Than all 3

My vote goes to System Shock 2.

Hey, you can't do that!

/looks at Mod status

...OK

System Shock 2
Killzone 2
GOW2
Halo 3
Resistance 2

NunianVonFuch

Gears of War 2
Halo 3
Haven't played Resistence 2. Tried a demo of the first one and it didn't seem to be my cup of tea, enemies being the almighty bullet sponges that they are. They should have more demos up on PSN!