The Most Ultimate of "Ultimate" Questions

My "friend" thinkins that a certain player of his side is better than one of mine. Just so there's no bias to me on this... I'm not going to say who this other person is... *cough* Mac Masters *cough* would insert his name here, but he was being a bitch.

He's admitted my player is better now after threatening to delete what I write...

"Stop Please!"

Anyway, ultimate question time!!!!11!

Who is better....

Michael Carrick or the mighty Denilson [of Arsenal]

eZe^

Carrick, by a mile, Denilson is still raw potential...

bUILDERtHEbOB

Denilson is quite good, and at 21 has shown a lot of potential, and could possibly be a top class midfielder in the future, tbf, though Carrick is obviously better.

CHD

Essien.

/thread.

Xavi6

Stephen Ireland

Pepe LeFrits

Denilson has been better so far this season.

Redzer7

Not going to get a right answer here, too many united fans on boards :P.

MementoMori

On the basis of what I've seen so far this season Dennilson is having a much better season than Carrick, so if I was picked a team tomorrow and had to choose between the two I would go for Denilson.

I think the poll here might be affected by the relative number of Utd fans compared to Arsenal fans.

There's also the fact that Dennilson is only 21 compared to Carrick who is 28 so given they are at such different stages of their career it's hard to compare.

MementoMori

MementoMori wrote: »

There's also the fact that Dennilson is only 21 compared to Carrick who is 28 so given they are at such different stages of their career it's hard to compare.

I'm talking about the now, not the future.

Glico Man

From what I've seen so far this season I would have to pick Denilson. He has added being a goal threat to his game and his goal against Everton was a peach.

3hn2givr7mx1sc

Deleted User wrote: »

I'm talking about the now, not the future.

Denílson's having a better season so far but as the season goes on I think Carrick will hit some sort of decent form, and if there both on form it's Carrick any day.

Sorry, I'm just a bit tense because of his insistence, I guess it was a bit rash.:o

Frisbee

Carrick - by a mile

liamygunner29

denilson

curry-muff

Redzer7 wrote: »

Not going to get a right answer here, too many united fans on boards :P.

To be honest i think the United v Arsenal match thread highlighted the abundance of anti United fans around here.

LuckyLloyd

Deleted User wrote: »

Sorry, I'm just a bit tense because of his insistence, I guess it was a bit rash.:o

Cool. Though remember to use your words.

Shall do captain

SlickRic

carrick.

not even close yet.

a couple of good games does not a great player make.

although carrick can be ineffectual, he very rarely makes a bad mistake. denilson is forever giving the ball away.

give it a couple of years and it might be a better contest.

hughes2558

Liam Brady

Nalz

Carrick

Xavi6 wrote: »

Stephen Ireland

lads I got warnings off Mods for posting similar things like this when it had nothing got to do with the thread!

Dave!

Fletcher