Noel leaving oasis

byrner88

just seen on sky news . Breaking news : noel gallagher is to leave oasis. he cant work with liam anymore . such a shame. him and liam are the life and soul of the band . even though in my opinion i think noel is better than liam

Famous45

:eek:

Bandit12

Most over rated band ever....fact. Thank god for this news

A Primal Nut

This about the 100th time Noel has left Oasis...and he cites the same reason everytime. They'll be back together soon enough....nice publicity for the band.

laoisforliam

I reckon this is really it, Liam and Noel really seem to hate each other. Not in a public way, they dont talk at all, only see each other on stage etc.

Mossy Monk

Luckily I saw them live this summer for the first time.

MooseJam

It's rumoured Lady GaGa will be replacing him

deadhead13

They haven't really done much of merit since "(What's the story) morning glory?". And that was a long time ago.

craiginireland

It's hardly John leaving the beatles, no wait...........

SlipperyPeople

NNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

aDeener

sickened:(

thomond2006

In fairness, Oasis' moment in the sun has passed imho.

cjmcork

while I've always been 'aware' of Oasis, I didn't pay them much heed (since Definitely Maybe) until recently when I used to listen to the Russell Brand Radio 2 show, where Noel was a constant fixture and the stuff since (and including) the Importance of Being Idle, imho, was some of their best stuff......Falling Down etc are all excellent songs..........how long will Oasis last without Noely Noely.........I'm sure he has a very successful solo career ahead of him......in the past 2 or so years, they always reminded me of The Commitments (not the 'we're black and we're proud' side of things, but the fact that I imagined them kicking nine kinds of sh!te out of one another backstage!)

Rizzla King

deadhead13 wrote: »

They haven't really done much of merit since "(What's the story) morning glory?". And that was a long time ago.

Completely over the top statement, you've obviously never even heard The Masterplan or even Heathen Chemistry (featuring one of Oasis' best songs to date "Songbird").

Really hope this isn't the last straw, some people say Noel is better(which I would agree with) but Oasis needs him.

emergingstar

if he goes the band are finished

DaveH

I used to be a big Oasis fan, However Be Here Now and Standing on The Shoulder of Giants didnt cut it for me.
I did like the 2005 record. I hated their latest album thought it was absoulte puck!

However at the Slane Concert, Noel introduced their drummer as their 5th and final drummer. I thought that was a bit strange....I thought the end must be close, maybe they planning on wrapping up and just decided to call a halt early.

Fnergg

Yawn. Yet another desperate publicity stunt from the poor man's Beatles. Wait for the "reconciliation" and the "comeback" tour and album.

Why are people taken in by such rubbish?

Regards,

Fnergg

jazoo

They have run their course thats it....Noel will have huge solo career 5/10 years from now a lucrative reunion. The first two maybe 3 albums where class .A real rags to riches story (get rich become dickheads).I seen them in cork many years ago and later in Marley park great gigs. very few bands can match what they achieved. but in the latter years it was just oasis rehashed....I know its happened before but I really think this time its the end..the best quote goes to Noel describing Liam as "A man with a fork in a world of soup".

stovelid

I saw a picture of Lima wearing leopardskin loafers recently.

I support Noel and accept that there is only so much a man can take.

ArthurGuinness

People who say that this is a publicity stunt want their heads examined. Oasis don’t really need the publicity in fairness every date on their Dig Out Your Soul tour was a sell out 3 nights at Wembley a sell out Slane show, 3 nights at Heaten Park hardly seems like they need the publicity does it. They are also not going to give up the remanding sell out dates on their tour (Paris, Milan Germany etc etc) and loose all that cash and risk being sued by promoters for publicity are they. Mabe the band will get back together although this time I doubt it, but I still don’t think any of this was planned.

Whether or not you like oasis they have contributed dearly to the modern music scene, there would be a lot of bands and musicians that wouldn’t be around now if it wasn’t for them. For me the represent what rock n roll is all about 3 chords and the truth. Sure they have made some crappy records what band hasn’t but they have made some great ones too even excluding the first two.

Glassheart

Fnergg wrote: »

Yawn. Yet another desperate publicity stunt from the poor man's Beatles. Wait for the "reconciliation" and the "comeback" tour and album.

Why are people taken in by such rubbish?

Regards,

Fnergg

He has never actually left the band before.Thats the difference...

demanufactured

No loss to the world , anyone i have met who likes them knows sweet feck all about music , liam = worst vocalist ever, noel = most over rated guitarist and musician ever.

Chardee MacDennis

demanufactured wrote: »

anyone i have met who likes them knows sweet feck all about music

teach us o' wise one :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

ArthurGuinness

demanufactured wrote: »

No loss to the world , anyone i have met who likes them knows sweet feck all about music , liam = worst vocalist ever, noel = most over rated guitarist and musician ever.

Funny Paul McCartney ,Pete Townsend, Paul Weller have all expressed themselves as avid Oasis fans, but your right what the f*uck do any of them know about music

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUlUOvVSm5M

JerryHandbag

Fnergg wrote: »

the poor man's Beatles.

Absolute bull....

demanufactured wrote: »

liam = worst vocalist ever, noel = most over rated guitarist and musician ever.

More of it...

Mr. K

I saw them in 2005, they really are/were excellent live. I love Morning Glory and Champagne Supernova, the last two full tracks from (What's The Story) Morning Glory?. I haven't heard their latest album, which I doubt will be the last. Noel will be lured back!

demanufactured

ArthurGuinness wrote: »

Funny Paul McCartney ,Pete Townsend, Paul Weller have all expressed themselves as avid Oasis fans, but your right what the f*uck do any of them know about music

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUlUOvVSm5M

re-read my post , i said people i have met not famous people , anyone i have met when playing gigs that asked me to play oasis were all yobs without 2 brain cells to rub together.

Kalashnikov_Kid

I saw them at Cardiff Millennium Stadium in June for the first time and was really impressed (minus all the Valley chavs that they attracted). I did notice the lack of interaction between the band and between band and audience. They didnt disappoint though.

Not sure if Noel will go solo. He is on record in saying what he does (or did, rather) atm is the limit of his musical and creative capability. I dont think he can even read music. Fair enough they are no Floyd or Zepellin or whatever but they never claimed to be.

You cant deny that Definately Maybe is up there with the greatest debuts ever.

So why do people have a problem with them? There are plenty more bands out there with their heads truly shoved up their @rses but totally lacking in conviction.

BaZmO*

Kalashnikov_Kid wrote: »

Not sure if Noel will go solo. He is on record in saying what he does (or did, rather) atm is the limit of his musical and creative capability. I dont think he can even read music. Fair enough they are no Floyd or Zepellin or whatever but they never claimed to be.

What's that got to do with anything? An awful lot of bands/songwriters can't read music. I play the guitar but can't read music, you don't need to, not in the proper sense. Tabs are a simplified way to read music.

As for Oasis splitting up, is anybody really surprised? It's been a long time coming. They're past their best anyway so it's no loss really.

homerun_homer

I still like Noel G and am glad that he left the band. Liam is a right tool. Just look at the wee "interview" of him from the recent NME cover shoot on NME.com, he is an absolute knob and a bit of a scumbag.

Even when I fell out of love with Oasis I still liked reading Noel's interviews and seeing him talk on tv cause he is a very funny man, he should go into comedy if he thinks all his music capabilities are sapped. I hope he sticks to his guns with this walk out though I know they will definitely reunite at some point, he'll hardly have an Ian Brown ant-reformation attitude. He'll relax and have enough time away from his spanner of a brother and will take the money when the time comes.

mada999

have to laugh at everyone sayin oasis were cráp...what a joke...there's not too many bands left that have the rock and roll attitude and swagger (or songwriting skills) that Oasis had. There are too many novelty art student wannabie bands out there at the moment. Oasis were all about the music, not elaborate stage productions and baloons on stage. As for clowns in inferior bands giving oasis abuse are they for real???? they don't have the talent to even restring one of Noel's guitar FFS...

on the liam thing.. i cannot underestimate the importance of Liam Gallagher's influence on the band. I was/am an admirer of Liam. I thought he was funny, energetic and generally a great front man (he used to be a good singer also.)

I don;t think Oasis would be as big without him...who know's, Noel's songs might not have even seen the light of day had he not joined Liam's band...
Noel is the talented one in the band...he has wrote some classics...tbh some of his b sides are better than today's "bright young things" a-sides.....

i'll miss oasis... Noel and Liam always wore their heart on their sleeve in interviews etc unlike the new bands of today... I reckon Noel and Liam will have their own projects in the coming years... and i look forward to them...

mada999

demanufactured wrote: »

No loss to the world , anyone i have met who likes them knows sweet feck all about music , liam = worst vocalist ever, noel = most over rated guitarist and musician ever.

and what bands do you like???

BaZmO*

Love them or hate them you gotta love their interviews.

Saw this on a show the other day and thought it was class.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxqkEoLqJTk

Kalashnikov_Kid

mada999 wrote: »

There are too many novelty art student wannabie bands out there at the moment. Oasis were all about the music, not elaborate stage productions and baloons on stage. As for clowns in inferior bands giving oasis abuse are they for real???? they don't have the talent to even restring one of Noel's guitar FFS...

And lets see if any of these 'technically superior' bands will stand the test of time like Oasis will.

JP Liz

Oasis are over they havent been great the last few years and the last cd was terrible

Noel could do well as a songwriter and with a solo career maybe

am i bovvered

Oasis were a class act and will end up being placed with the best. However Liam would have never made it without the talent of Noel. When I have seen them Liam has not been a great front man, in Cork he sat on the edge of the stage and refused to sing !!!!. I feel Noel could have picked loads of frontmen to do as good a job as Liam has done for the band, however the last few years he has become a liability to the music, he is a asshole. Noel hopefully can carry on and create some great music again.

BornToRun88

Oasis splitting up is the worst thing to happen in music at the moment. One of the few great big bands left, and what are we left with, muck like kings of leon. Noel is the genius behind oasis, his songs provided the platform behind their success. They would still be a small Manchester band if he never joined the band. I don't blame Noel for getting fed up of Liam. Noel is a down to earth man whereas Liam is a up own his arse schoolboy.

A noel solo album post-oasis is going to have great expectations, hope it can live up to the expectations

demanufactured

mada999 wrote: »

and what bands do you like???

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

Glassheart

demanufactured wrote: »

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

Let's just hope Noel's solo career doesn't end up like Chris Cornell's...:pac:

BaZmO*

demanufactured wrote: »

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

So all forward looking bands?

Salvelinus

Liam Gallagher the worlds oldest knacker.

laoisforliam

demanufactured wrote: »

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

You're Kewl

mada999

demanufactured wrote: »

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

i say meh to all these bands... at least you can hear oasis' lyrics.....
i don't like the genre that most of those bands are from, you prob don't like the genre that oasis are from so there's no point giving out...

demanufactured

mada999 wrote: »

i say meh to all these bands... at least you can hear oasis' lyrics.....
i don't like the genre that most of those bands are from, you prob don't like the genre that oasis are from so there's no point giving out...

Aye , were all different at the end of the day

darrenh

demanufactured wrote: »

Ozzy Ozbourne , Slayer , pantera , testement, steve vai, joe satriani, pink floyd , metallica, RATM, soundgarden, Sepultura , iron maiden, killswitchy engage , etc.

Its quite clear you like different music. If any of the above bands who are still together, broke up or died, do you think any oasis fans would be even posting here let alone even care about any of them. I feckin cant stand people like you, who like a certain type of music and think everything else is sh1t. Its close minded.
Me personally I like music of any type. I don't really like many bands but I like lots of songs over a wide spectrum. Jesus, even Take Thats greatest days of our lives is a good song.
Music is for everyone. If young ones get a kick out of westlife or britney and their songs mean something to them should we knock them for that?
On Oasis. They were the greatest Rock'nRoll band of the last 20 years. No one has yet taken over from them and it will be a long time before we are talking about another great band 20 years after they have formed. Concert sales are now what you can base your fan base on and I don't think many would come anywhere close to what Oasis pulled in on a tour.
As well, just because some of the crowd are so called yobs, does that mean they know nothing about music?

ps I like all the bands you have listed above too!!;)

Elliemental

So Noels` left the band...again! I sometimes I have to work hard to remind myself of why I still love this band so much.

Dave Total

Noel will be back, he always is. Not only that if he doesn't rejoin the band, their mum will be upset at christmas dinner!