Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
If we do not hit our goal we will be forced to close the site.

Current status: https://keepboardsalive.com/

Annual subs are best for most impact. If you are still undecided on going Ad Free - you can also donate using the Paypal Donate option. All contribution helps. Thank you.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.

Couple of questions.. Need solving. (Attempts shown)

  • 26-07-2009 02:19PM
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,238 ✭✭✭


    Hi,
    Currently revising for a repeat exam and I am absolutely hopeless. Could somebody here give some help with these? Thanks.

    Question 1:
    Early network communication systems suffered from noise. In a particular system a 1 is
    transmitted onethird
    of the time and a 0 is transmitted twothirds
    of the time. When a 0 is
    sent the probability that it is received correctly is 0.85 and the probability that when a 1 is
    sent it is received correctly is 0.9. Use Bayes' Theorem to find the probability that a 0 was
    transmitted given that a 0 was received.
    
    Attempt:
    P(tran1)=1/3           P(receive1)=0.9
    P(trab0)=2/3 <= [COLOR="Red"]A[/COLOR]   P(receive0)=0.85 <= [COLOR="Red"]B[/COLOR]
    
    Find: P(A|B)     -> Use Bayes Theorem
    
    P(A|B) = [U]            P(B|A) P(B)                  [/U]
                 P(B|A)P(B) + P(A|&#172;B)P(&#172;B)
    
    Sub in values but I can't seem to find P(B|A) at least when I do it equates to .85..
    

    Question 2:
    In October 2007, a sample of 2000 U.S. voters were asked if George W. Bush was doing a
    good job as President of the U.S.A. 725 respondents thought the President was doing a good
    job. From this information, infer the range for the population proportion that think he has
    done a good job.
    

    Attempt:
    2000 Voters
    725 = Good Job
    1,272 = Bad Job
    
    What is [I]Range for the population proportion[/I]?
    

    Any help greatly appreciated.Thanks.


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,595 ✭✭✭MathsManiac


    First one:
    Your problem is with your setting up: 0.85 is not P(received 0), it's P(received 0 | sent 0). Similarly for the 0.9.

    Try that and see you get on.

    Second one:

    Your "point estimate" for the population proportion is the sample proportion: 725/2000, which is 36.25%.

    The quick way to infer an estimated range for the proportion is to use the quick rule that the "margin of error" tion is 1/sqrt(n). In this case, 1/sqrt(2000) is 2.23%, so the estimated range is from 34% to 38.5%.

    A more specific/accurate "inferred range" is to get the 95% confidence interval, which is: the estimate (+/-) 1.96*(standard error)

    The standard error for a population proportion is given by: sqrt[p(1-p)/n].

    If you work that out, you'll get a slightly narrower estimated range than the one given by the quick rule.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,238 ✭✭✭techguy


    Ok,

    I've attempted Bayes Theorem again:
    P(s1) = 1/3 = 0.33
    P(s0) = 2/3 = 0.66
    
    P(r1 | s1) = 0.9                    p(&#172;r1 | s1) = 0.1   ==> p(r0 | s1)
    P(r0 | s0) = 0.85                   p(&#172;r0 | s0) = 0.85  ==> p(r1 | s0)
    
    P(s0 | r0) = [COLOR="Red"]??[/COLOR]
    
    
    P(s0 | r0) = [U]           p(r0 | s0)p(s0)                   [/U]
                     p(r0 | s0)p(s0) + p(r0 | s1)p(s1)
    
    ===>   [U]        0.85(0.66)         [/U]
               0.85(0.66) + 0.1(0.33)
    
    ===> 0.944 ===> P(s0 | r0)
    
    

    Here's my attempt at the second one..:
    P = [U] 725 [/U]  ==> 0.3625
          2000
    
    ??? = 0.3625 +- 1.96 * SQRT(.3625*(1-.3625)/2000)
    
    ??? = 0.3625 +- 0.021068575
    
    36.25 % +- 2.1%
    
    Is this what I am supposed to do??  The values seem slightly off compared to yours?
    


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,238 ✭✭✭techguy


    Here's another Bayes Theorem question:

    Question:
    A company is about to launch a new drink on the market. In the past, 65% of its drinks have successfully launched.
    Before any soft drink is launched, the company conducts research and receives a report predicting favourable or unfavourable sales.
    In the past, 83% of successful drinks and 24% of the unsuccessful ones received favourable reports. What is the probability this new drink will be successful given that it receives a favourable report?


    Answer:
    P(success) = 0.65
    P(fail) = 0.35
    
    P(favourable | success ) = 0.83
    P(favourable | fail ) = .24
    
    P(success | favourable) = ??
    
    P(success | favourable) = [U]            P(fav | sucess) P(success)         [/U]
                               P(fav | success)P(success)+P(fav | fail)P(fail)
    
    ==> [U]0.83(0.65)[/U]
    0.83(0.65) + 0.24(0.35)
    
    ==> 86.52% chance of success given a favourable report.
    

    Another One:

    In a recent poll, 23% of a sample of 500 Irish drivers admit that they sometimes break the speed limit. From this, infer the percentage of the total population of drivers who break the speed limit.

    Answer:
    
    P = 23% N = 500
    
    Pi (What am  I looking for?) = 0.23 +- 1.96 * SQRT(P*(1-P)/N)
    
    ==> 0.23 +- 1.96 * 0.018820201
    ==> 0.23 +- 0.0368876
    
    23% +- 3.% of the total population break the speed limit.
    
    I really appreciate you looking at these.. I have a repeat exam on tuesday, I have nobody else to look at these and I think i'm going to struggle to get 40% (Shame on me in the first place I know :o)
    


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,238 ✭✭✭techguy


    Here are some attempts on Hypothesis Testing.. I am fairly confident that my work is correct I just need some assurance..

    Question 1:

    A train timetable says that the time it takes to travel from Maynooth to Dublin Connolly is 25 minutes. A survey of the arrival times of six trains resulted in a mean of 20 minutes. Assuming that the time is normally distributed, and that the standard deviation is 7 minutes, perform a hypothesis test with a significance level of 0.05 to see if the claim is correct.

    Attempt:
    &#181; = 25                                     Stnd Dev = 7
    Sample Mean &#172;X = 20                 Alpha (Significance) = 0.05
    Number of samples N = 6
    
    Null Hypothesis H0 = &#181; => 25
    Alt Hypothesis H1 = &#181; < 25
    
    Test Stat Z:
    => [U]   &#172;x - &#181;0   [/U]
       StdDev/SQRT(N)
    => [U-5[/U]
         2.8577380
    => [COLOR="Red"]-1.7496[/COLOR]
    
    Rejection Region : Z < - 1.96
    
    Conclusion: Z is not less than -1.96 so the Null hypothesis is accepted. It takes on avg 25 minutes to get to Dublin from Maynooth.
    

    Sorry if that one is a bit all over the place.
    #######################################################
    Question 2:


    A bank bases its sales strategy on the assumption that the mean size of a mortgage taken out by a customer is €300,000. A recent survey of five customers indicates that their mean mortage was €280,000 with a standard deviation of €25,000. Using α=0.05, test if the bank's assumption is correct.

    Attempt:
    &#181; = 300,000                                 Std Dev = 25,000
    Sample Avg &#172;X = 280,000              Significance (Alpha) = 0.05
    Number of samples N = 5
    
    H0 = &#181; => 300,000
    H1 = &#181; < 300,000
    
    Test Statistic Z:
    
    =>[U]  &#172;X - &#181;0[/U]
    StdDev/SQRT(N)
    
    => [U]-20,000[/U]
        11,180
    
    => [COLOR="Red"]-1.78891[/COLOR]
    
    Rejection Region: Z < - 1.96
    
    Conclusion: Test statistic Z is not less than -1.96 (Not in rejection region) so  accpet the null hypothesis. The bank is correct in their assumptions that the mean mortgage is 300,000
    


Advertisement