Most Overrated Show (Nominees)

Mr E

Please name shows worthy of the Most Overrated Show award.

T&Cs

• Please nominate no more than 3 shows
• The nominated Show(s) must have had a season that aired for the first time, any time, between June 2008 and May 2009.
• Shows still running are permitted
• This category must receive at least 6 valid nominees to be included in the voting stage.
• The show may have aired on US, Irish or UK Television.
• Nominations are open for 1 week (until Saturday 6th June).
• Shows with the most nominations will be included in the voting stage.
• For plot-related categories, please use discretion (spoiler tags if necessary)
  [ spoiler ] Put Spoiler Here [ /spoiler ] (remove spaces in tags)

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Heroes
The X Factor
Big Brother UK

ixoy

Mad Men - Good but not worthy of all the hyperbole
Battlestar Galactica - Not as earth-shattering and clever as it's made out to be
Fringe - Too many people thinking it's amazing and innovative when it's generally (ZFT-heavy episodes aside) just a glossy X-Files clone

Bounty Hunter

ixoy wrote: »

Mad Men - Good but not worthy of all the hyperbole
Battlestar Galactica - Not as earth-shattering and clever as it's made out to be
Fringe - Too many people thinking it's amazing and innovative when it's generally (ZFT-heavy episodes aside) just a glossy X-Files clone

+1 x3

Richard Dower

Grays Anatomy - i just don't get it?
Ugly Betty - nuff said
Desperate Housewives - desperados et al.

JP Liz

Heroes
Lost
Fringe

Xavi6

Lost
Ugly Betty
The Big Bang Theory

tvnutz

CSI
Grey's Anatomy
Two and a Half Men

Overrated based on the large ratings and press coverage they get despite being all $hite.

Tazzer

Battlestar Galactica
Prison Break
Grey's Anatomy

Lost - Completely lost the plot, not that it ever really had any. Entertaining but nowhere near as good as people make it out to be.

Heroes - Just let it die, season 1 reamins fantastic but everything since should be forgotten.

Fringe - Entertaining, but little more than an X-Files redux.

DingDong

Lost
Prison break

DirkVoodoo

Big Bang Theory
Two and a Half Men
Greys Anatomy

Two and a half men gets special mention, why do comedies labelled "america's most popular" never extend beyond potty humor and the same gags week-in, week-out. Give me arrested development any day!

Mr.Nice Guy

The Wire - Controversial maybe but I said it

CSI - Not impressed

The X-Factor - Simon Cowell is evil

Handsome Bob

The X Factor
CSI
Greys Anatomy

Mr E

Nominees:

Heroes
X-Factor
Battlestar Galactica
CSI
Fringe
Lost
Greys Anatomy