Hyundai Sonata or VW Passat?

BadApple

hi, for a complete novice when it comes to cars, what would people think is better in terms of reliability and "life-span" of either VW 07 FSI passat or an 07 Hyundai Sonata CRDI?
I've narrowed a search down to two cars and would appreciate objective informed opinion, as i havent much of a clue when it comes to cars.

thanks in advance for advice.

colm_mcm

Get an Avensis or something

BadApple

yeah, i know, but i like these two.
VW is 1.6 and Hyundai is 2.0, both have about 25000km on them.

which car is better? price approx 18k

colm_mcm

Both cars have their own issues, but I'd have more confidence in the Sonata, it will also be more economical.

On the other hand the Passat has a nicer interior and generally feels more solid.

colm_mcm

Also bear in mind that you can get a new Passat TFSI for €22,450, doesn't make the 1.6 look great value. You could get a lot better for €18k.

BadApple

thanks for feedback, will try haggle down further, i'm kinda leaning towards the sonata anyway.

colm_mcm

Have you driven either car?

BadApple

yes, i liked both of them, didnt really have a preference on performance, the hyundai looks a bit nicer, in good condition too, dont know much about hyundais but knew vw have good reputation, just wanted to check if hyundai had too.

what would reasonable price be for sonata do you think?

batman2000

BadApple wrote: »

yeah, i know, but i like these two.
VW is 1.6 and Hyundai is 2.0, both have about 25000km on them.

which car is better? price approx 18k

Well the VW 1.6 lacks in power but as colm said the VW will feel more solid. The Hyundai is OK to drive, light steering, the VW has a a heavy (ish) steer but I think you feel in more control of the car. The Hyundai CRDI (diesel) would be a lot more economical and powerful. If they are listed on a carzone or something, copy the links so we can have a look. Aslo compare the specs etc

Anan1

VW had a good reputation for reliability, but that's a good few years in the past now. If reliability's important to you then you'd be better off with a Hyundai. The Passat is a nicer place to sit, though.

BadApple

these are the two cars

http://www.carzone.ie/search/Hyundai/Sonata/2.0-CRDI/200846190854507/advert

http://www.carzone.ie/search/Volkswagen/Passat/AUTO-FSi/200842190465472/advert

is there a big difference between the two?

colm_mcm

Ah, they're automatic.

I wouldn't buy either TBH. but I'd have the Hyundai if it was a straight choice.

VolvoMan

The Passat is far too dear for this climate. If reliability is your main priority it would have to be the Sonata.

BadApple

on another thread a honda accord was recommended to someone, is this a superior car?
what kind of value does this represent?

http://www.carzone.ie/search/Honda/Accord/2.0-i-VT/200840190288452/advert

BadApple

thanks volvoman. i'll rule that one out so, seems the the other gets more positive opinion.

colm_mcm

too expensive IMO.

PM sent.

BadApple

colm_mcm wrote: »

too expensive IMO.

PM sent.

thanks

bf

not wishing to get in trouble, but I am currently seeling a 2007 FSI Comfortline and it is substantially less than the passat you are looking at OP. Feel free to PM if you want details!

colm_mcm

OP is looking at automatics I think

View Profile

Can't go wrong with a Honda.

May be a tad more expensive but will last forever. Holds its value well too.

Luke Crowley

Have you considered a Nissan Maxima? They do everything the Sonata does, but they are a bit less mainstream and there are some serious bargains to be had. Plenty of autos out there too.

As for the Passat, unless you're a fiercely patriotic European with a pathological hatred of anything from Korea, there is no reason to even consider it.