Martin or Simon & Patrick Acoustic? Please help

diarmado

I'm stuck on deciding between these two beauties:

1. S&P Flame Maple http://www.simonandpatrick.com/showcaseflamemaple.htm

2. Martin DX1 Tawny satinwood
http://www.guitar-village.co.uk/product-detail.asp?id=5919&catid=4&manid=65&quantity=1&product=Martin+DX+1+Tawny%2C+Natural%2C+New

Both for the same money, both sweet sounding.

I understand the S&P is all solid. I was surprised to discover that the Martin is back and sides laminate, still a beautiful sound though.

Obviously a very personal decision at the end of the day but i am hoping somebody might be able to sway me.

Thank you all

Diarmuid

Dord

I believe Goodwins on Caple St. stock both S&P and Martin? Well, they had some S&P last time I was in there but that was a few years ago. They definitely do stock Martin.

I think with acoustics it's best to try them out before buying.

Eoin Madsen

Last I was acoustic shopping, they stocked S&P in Musicmaker and some Martins in Perfect Pitch. I've had good experiences with Simon & Patrick. For what you pay, they're a better guitar than any of the dominant brands.

paul_allen

Yeah, like the last poster said, the simon and patricks offer better value for money. But the Martin would be easier to sell on, cos of the name and it would hold its value better. Depends if it is a long term guitar you are looking for?