Waterproof footwear?

fletch · 10-09-2008 10:21am #1

So what do people recommend?
Overshoes? Waterproof shoes? Waterproof socks? Plastic bags over runners?

TinyExplosions · 10-09-2008 10:32am

fletch wrote: »

So what do people recommend?
Overshoes? Waterproof shoes? Waterproof socks? Plastic bags over runners?

Depends on how/where you're cycling. If you have clipless pedals and roadbike shoes, sealskinz socks are probable the best choice. If it's for commuting and you want to wear your normal shoes, BBB waterflex overshoes are what I suggest, and use myself

fletch · 10-09-2008 10:35am

It'll be for commuting....leave my shoes in work and just bring in socks every few days. Would your feet not get very sweaty in those seal skin socks? The overshoes look like the best solution as I don't have pedal clips

TinyExplosions · 10-09-2008 10:38am

fletch wrote: »

It'll be for commuting....leave my shoes in work and just bring in socks every few days. Would your feet not get very sweaty in those seal skin socks? The overshoes look like the best solution as I don't have pedal clips

The seal skinz are supposed to be great (I've not personally tried them), they're breathable and waterproof. For commuting, the overshoes are cheap and effective, so that's what I'd go for. Joe Daly's in Dundrum have them, and I'd say most other shops do too!

neilled · 10-09-2008 10:43am

I've just bought a pair of the Shimano MT90L SPD boots. Very comfy I have to say.

fletch · 10-09-2008 10:43am

Grand....might pick these up so...

Gavin · 10-09-2008 11:16am

fletch wrote: »

Grand....might pick these up so...

I have these and wear them with the same brand SPD shoes. They only work ok, they keep most of the water out but some does get in.

Yesterday for example my shoes were damp and socks wringing. The shoes do dry out quicker alright, as they are less wet, but having a change of socks is a good idea.

How does that compare with the BBB ones Tiny ? Do they keep you completely dry ?

fletch · 10-09-2008 11:20am

Might go for these instead...seem to get a good review.

TinyExplosions · 10-09-2008 11:24am

Verb wrote: »

How does that compare with the BBB ones Tiny ? Do they keep you completely dry ?

The only problem I've had, and you have them with all overshoes is of water getting in the top. For example, I used them on Sat morning (very very wet morning), and went through a fairly deep puddle that threw water up over the top, onto my leg warmers that wicked it down to my shoes. Apart from that, I've been dry in them whenever I've worn them

ruprect · 10-09-2008 11:26am

I got "aquashoes" for €5 in lidl. They look like runners and are made from some quickdrying material. Really meant for the beach. Still take a good while to dry. I just wear them with no socks and plastic bags over them from the meat counter in the supermarket, bigger bags can get caught in cogs. I have very thin silicone tube that I tie at my ankle, this keeps the bag in place and stops most of the rain getting in. A shoelace would do but the silicone keeps it taut.

unionman · 10-09-2008 11:30am

I use these. Seem to work pretty well, even on the wettest days.

Fredo · 10-09-2008 12:56pm

unionman wrote: »

I use these. Seem to work pretty well, even on the wettest days.

I have the same. They are great, keep shoes and foot dry and warm.

Signal_ rabbit · 10-09-2008 3:02pm

fletch wrote: »

Might go for these instead...seem to get a good review.

I have these and think they are excellent. My feet always stay dry. I wear them in the winter with merino wool socks and my feet are toasty warm and dry.

doozerie · 10-09-2008 6:35pm

I have a pair of mid-weight SealSkinz socks that I use only for commuting - my commuting shoes are a larger size than my other road shoes which is about the only reason they can take these socks. I rely on them for warmth mainly, as cycling shoes generally are designed to let air into the shoe which makes winter commuting less fun than it might be. I also wear overshoes for my commute, when the rain is bad, so I haven't really tested how waterproof the SealSkinz really are.

Generally speaking though, I'm not a great fan of waterproof shoes. I've used a few for commuting, and used to use waterproof boots for mountain biking, but in my experience they are never as waterproof as they claim and for those that are the waterproof layer doesn't last very long before water starts to leak in. I find that overshoes are the best bet - most cycling shoes have holes in the soles anyway, to allow cleats to be attached, so water will invariably get in there, but the overshoes keep the wind off (even if they let the water in) so even if your feet get wet they can still remain warm.

fletch · 19-09-2008 10:21am

Are these the same?
Endura Road Overshoe - wiggle
Endura Road Overshoe - chainreactioncycles

The one's on wiggle look shinier and more water resistant...maybe it's just the picture...

Deisetrek · 19-09-2008 10:44am

fletch wrote: »

Are these the same?
Endura Road Overshoe - wiggle
Endura Road Overshoe - chainreactioncycles

The one's on wiggle look shinier and more water resistant...maybe it's just the picture...

I have a pair of the Endura road overshoe from Chain reaction cycles , yeah the picture does not do 'em justice , they are "shiny and water-resistant". If you intend ordering though , go for a size up from your normal shoe size 'cause they are tight fitting.

blorg · 19-09-2008 11:03am

I too have the BBB Waterflex ones and they are very good indeed if they are a good fit. As Tiny says the only potential issue is with water dripping down the top but even this probably won't happen if the fit is right. Fit is important though; water gets in when I have them over my sandals but really does not at all over my shoes, the shoes will stay completely dry. Even with the water in though they keep your feet warm (as I found out climbing in the Pyrenees last week

)

I am considering some Sealskins for use with my sandals but I wouldn't use these with shoes- without overshoes the shoes will still get soaked even if your feet stay dry. A combination could be good if you find water leaking in.

TinyExplosions · 19-09-2008 11:24am

blorg wrote: »

I am considering some Sealskins for use with my sandals but I wouldn't use these with shoes- without overshoes the shoes will still get soaked even if your feet stay dry. A combination could be good if you find water leaking in.

Socks and sandals is only allowed if you're a Franciscan monk mate!

Gavin · 19-09-2008 11:29am

Here, no one told me that overshoes were seriously not cool. After putting mine on, arriving at a friends house and having them fall on the ground laughing at the clog like style, I felt betrayed by boards.ie

Decent: yes. Cool: no.

Luckily no one is looking at anyone in the pissing rain.

Vélo · 19-09-2008 11:58am

Yeah they're not very flattering at all.

fletch · 19-09-2008 12:10pm

Aquinas73 wrote: »

Yeah they're not very flattering at all.

They're not? Damn I was hoping these would double up as shoe protectors for when I go out on a Saturday night and beer gets spilled all over the place...

Vélo · 19-09-2008 12:24pm

fletch wrote: »

They're not? Damn I was hoping these would double up as shoe protectors for when I go out on a Saturday night and beer gets spilled all over the place...

That's only my opinion. By all means you should give it a go, if you do pull and you're asked have you got protection you can always point at your feet.;)

Capt'n Midnight · 20-09-2008 5:21pm

fletch wrote: »

So what do people recommend?
Overshoes? Waterproof shoes? Waterproof socks? Plastic bags over runners?

another option from a long time ago
socks
plastic bag over socks
old pair of runners that you don't mind being destroyed

this way the plastic bags don't rip
your feet do get very cold
or a second pair of socks over the plastic bags to hide them and tuck your leggings into

would gortex socks work ??

Redjeep! · 21-09-2008 9:02pm

I've never understood the fixation that cycling shoe designers have with ventilation holes. I mean in Ireland do we really need them ?

After last Sundays torrential rain I was thinking about fastening my cleats to the sole of my wellies with some self tapping screws....or would that would be too culchie?

kenmc · 22-09-2008 8:03am

The ventilation holes are there to let the water out of course. Ever tried cycling with water sloshing around your shoes?
But in reality, do you really think they can cater for such a small customer base for specific shoes, especially a market which has already been provided for with MTB boots etc?

at1withmyself · 22-09-2008 9:26am

fletch wrote: »

Grand....might pick these up so...

Just on them, I picked up a pair of medium last week but they are too small to fit my shimano 41 shoes, prob need a large or extra large. Always hard to judge the size needed so you might be better off buying them in a shop.

Waterproof footwear?

Comments