What you guys think of her?

Placebo

What do people think of this girls work?
She gets a lot of exposure on flickr, i know shes aiming for fashion photography but her photos are nothing special, very over processed as well. I.E Id rate this guy over her.

Thoughts, views?

LINK


edit: girls GOT skillz ooops

Mellor

I don't think its bad, actually, i'd even say its good.
Its a little over processed for me, like the canvas effect on some shots,

Maybe I was just expecting a low standard, from a good looking girl, who recieve mucho praise and hits (down to looksover ability), I think your post set me up for that.
So when she was ok, I was pleasently surprised


As for that guy, I didn't like the first shot that comes yup, (drum feet)
But the vespa series does it for me

Fajitas!

I'm on my slooooooooooooooooow internet, but from the first page... they're alright. Nothing that goes "sh*te, that's different". Also, they need white - She seems to recover anything on the right side of the 'gram.

Oh noes. Blown Highlights!

Fenster

I like the processing style, but it's really meh for me.

amcinroy

I can't say I like the tone of negativity in this thread or ethics associated with this poll.

The photographer in question has not asked for their photography to be publically rated, graded or critiqued in such a negative manner in an open forum.

This idea that photography is a competition and about status relative to others is completely wrong. This thread says more about the thought processes going on in Placebo's mind than it does about any photography on show by either photographer.

Fajitas!

You're 100% right Amc.

I probably should have said, there's nothing at all wrong with the images. I'm tired and cranky.

Elven... If you want to lock the thread, go for it - You know what I'm like at the mo.