Who faked the crash

whirlwind

If the plane crash has indeed been faked who do you think did it?

Alanstrainor

hasn't that already been explained in one of the episodes, it was Widmore, penny's da. Although knowing lost they might go back on what they've said

whirlwind

Charles Widmore

Alanstrainor wrote: »

hasn't that already been explained in one of the episodes, it was Widmore, penny's da. Although knowing lost they might go back on what they've said

Ya thats what Ben said, but the ship's captain said it was Ben who faked the crash, who do you believe?

Mr E

It was in the most recent episode - Charles Widmore faked the crash (and even dug up bodies from graves to put in the fake plane)

iUseVi

Dharma

Mr E wrote: »

It was in the most recent episode - Charles Widmore faked the crash (and even dug up bodies from graves to put in the fake plane)

Yes, but that information came from one of the others!!

Can you really trust it?

Mr E

Ah good point. Do you think it was the other others?

Sad Professor

Other

As I've said before I think the question is a red herring and neither of them are behind it. The documentation Tom showed Michael in 4x08 was supplied by Ben which should be reason enough not to trust it. And while Widmore is probably a bad guy who wants to exploit the island, I don't think he has the resources or the motivation to fake a plane crash.

I think the plane is real. How? I don't know yet but we've seen weirder things on this show.

whirlwind

Charles Widmore

Just a thougt that might point to Bens/the Others involment in the crash and fake wreak in the ocean. In season 1 claire had a flashback to her time in the other's camp, when she had aaron. I might be mistaken but there was a scene showing aaron in his cot and the mobile over the cot had a model oceanic plane on it. Aaron was seen looking at it. Where did the others get this model? ok perhaps it came from the plane after it crashed. But maybe they had it as part of a wider pack of infomation on the plane , i.e is flight path, passenger list etc. Infomation necessary to fake the wrekage in the ocean and possibly the crash on the island
Also Ben had the capacity to cause Anthony cooper to crash and bring him to the Island after the sub was blown up (although he prob could have been brought earlier)

ArmaniJeanss

Dharma

whirlwind wrote: »

Just a thougt that might point to Bens/the Others involment in the crash. In season 1 claire had a flashback to her time in the other's camp, when she had aaron. I might be mistaken but there was a scene showing aaron in his cot and the mobile over the cot had a model oceanic plane on it. Aaron was seen looking at it. Where did the others get this model? ok perhaps it came from the plane after it crashed. But maybe they had it as part of a wider pack of infomation on the palne, i.e is flight path, passenger list etc. Infomation necessary to cause a plane crash.
Also Ben had the capacity to cause Anthony cooper to crash and bring him to the Island after the sub was blown up (although he prob could have been brought earlier)

Most airlines sell £10 toy models of their planes onboard, so not the most difficult thing to get.
And doesn't your above post confuse the issue, as your poll is asking who faked the wreckage (I think), whereas above you are talking about who caused the original crash. Its plausible say that say Ben caused the crash, but that Widmore faked the wreckage.

whirlwind

Charles Widmore

I am sorry, When i say i think Ben caused the crash i mean he faked the wreckage in the ocean after the real plane crashed on the island due to desmond not pressing the button (or perhaps he had something to do with this). so i mean that Ben possibly had an involment in causing the actual crash, but he also faked the wreckage. I mention the availibilty of the model planes, but why did Ethan/goodwin bring one back? perhaps as part of a plan to fake the wrekage. I recognise the weakness of this argument but its just a hunch. i remember being intrigued by aaron looking at the model plane and feeling it had some significance.

I edited my last post to make it clearer

Stuxnet

It was me

Lawless_Samurai

Charles Widmore

BOBBY wrote: »

It was me

Well I'm glad thats cleared up!