Just realised something.....*Spoilers for all of season 3*

Enemy Of Fate

*Spoilers*

All of the main 3 ''leaders' of the resistance on New Caprica were actually Cylons (Tigh, Anders, and Tyrol).And Tori was involved with the resitance as well.I wonder was that planned..........

And now that I look through summaries of previous episodes they've been hinting at Tyrol being a cylon since early season 2 (Resistance).Still though I didn't expect him to be a cylon.I mean he wasn't at any of the meetings!!

_CreeD_

Who says any of them really are Cylons, at least in the traditional sense? I don't think the Cylons arranged for the fleet power to fail, Starbuck to do her back from the life trick or have the humans meet the Cylon fleet at that exact turning point. I've posted on this about a year ago but there are forces pulling the strings of the Cylons and Humans alike that have an ability to manifest themselves in the minds of various characters, they're either manipulating these 4 or they are themselves agents of those forces (imho).

Overheal

the 4(5) likely have completely different agenda than the destruction of the human race

Dontico

The Cylons were built by the humans to serve them. They evolved and revolted. Then they mad the "skin-jobs". Maybe the 4(5) are skin jobs that are still loyal to humans, like origionaly intended?

katarin

the producers have said that the 4 of 5 are cylons, but a different kind of cylon and not subject to the same limitations/ programming. i like donticos theory, it makes sense. maybe the 4 of 5 skin jobs are the only editions of their model and maybe they were made by the humans: tigh said he fought in the first cylon war- on the human side. tyroll, anders and tory could've been grown as babies, then given to parents after the war. they all excell in their field: tyroll was given to a religious family who raised him thus - hes knows all about the religous stuff and hes also a first class 'knuckledragger', anders is a professional athlete and tory is a deadly PA. they're all service/ entertainment professions. could be that they were made that way by humans - to serve or entertain humans- and the other seven were made by cylons.

Overheal

Possibly but theres a tiny flaw with that: if the humans created the 4; why don't they anticipate (in any way, at any level of government) that there might be cyclon-human models?

User45701

Dontico wrote:

The Cylons were built by the humans to serve them. They evolved and revolted. Then they mad the "skin-jobs". Maybe the 4(5) are skin jobs that are still loyal to humans, like origionaly intended?

I still think that the final 5 live in peace on earth with humans, i don’t think there loyal to humans i just think they are equal, earth is a place where cylon and human can live together in peace

katarin wrote:

the producers have said that the 4 of 5 are cylons, but a different kind of cylon and not subject to the same limitations/ programming. i like donticos theory, it makes sense. maybe the 4 of 5 skin jobs are the only editions of their model and maybe they were made by the humans: tigh said he fought in the first cylon war- on the human side. tyroll, anders and tory could've been grown as babies, then given to parents after the war. they all excell in their field: tyroll was given to a religious family who raised him thus - hes knows all about the religous stuff and hes also a first class 'knuckledragger', anders is a professional athlete and tory is a deadly PA. they're all service/ entertainment professions. could be that they were made that way by humans - to serve or entertain humans- and the other seven were made by cylons.

Very good reasoning, I don’t know though its BSG its so hard to figure it all out because there is so much to think about but ah i just don’t know my brain is starting to melt