Confirmation of Black Smokes Involvement in Crash?

rip2roar

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjDEU9pcEL0&eurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Elostmysteries%2Ecom%2F1%2Ehtml
Look at the Jet
May be old, but this is the best version I have seen, slowed to perfection and slightly scary,it is obviously the black smoke

monkeyfudge

I've seen a better version of it before.

It really just looks like a bit of debris... it passes a lot closer to the camera than the jet engine as well.

Crucifix

I think in a previous discussion someone said the creators had said that the black smoke isn't in that episode.

stevejazzx

Crucifix wrote:

I think in a previous discussion someone said the creators had said that the black smoke isn't in that episode.

damon and jj won't comment on that but javi who s leaving in a couple of weeks has said:

the monster is not defintely not in the first episode!
is somkey the monster? no/maybe?
I'm pretty sure that smokey was somehow around when the plane crashed, it made sense for there to be a controlling element from the scientists i terms of lostie survival,

rip2roar

It is not debris
It is see-through

Anima

Its definetly the smoke thing in the first ep. Its clearly edited into the frame, its movement is far too smooth to be a real life object.

Its kinda strange that they would say that smokey isn't the monster though. Then again, since when can smoke grab people i.e the pilot. Must be another part to it.

Necronomicon

I got so used to watching the one posted in the other thread that it's weird looking at in realtime! There was a huge debate about whether it is debris or the smoke, I still think smoke.

PullMyFinger!

This is the third thread on this now. Could you merge Steve?