SGA: Season 2: Episode 13: Critical Mass [SPOILERS]

User45701

Great Episode i loved it
It kept me guesing at 1st i thought that Cathern was the gouauld because it seemed too obvious cause she was the only 1 who stayed behind i thought it might be her cause she was too obvisous and also i thought it was ronin but just because of his stance ye sounds strange but the look on his face and the body launguge as he walked into the room with Cavanagh made me suspect him

also i had a feeling that talas friend would accend

normely sga/sg1 is predictble it could be this new job and lack of sleap thats distracting me or was this epsiode not predictble for all of u 2?

MrPinK

Ok

Aside from a couple of things, I really liked this episode. The ending took me completely by suprise. I started thinking it might have been Novak, the whole nervous hiccuping thing would be a great cover for a spy. I burst out laughing when Teyla starting singing, that was pretty ridiculous. Also thought it was very strange that the wrath cruisers just seemed to disappear at the end. While it was obvious that they would fall for the ruse, a comment from somebody about them having given up their search and gone back on their way would have been nice.

Mantel

Ok

Liked it a lot. Except for the singing. That just sucked.

Catsmokinpot

Bad

Mantel wrote:

Liked it a lot. Except for the singing. That just sucked.

i concur.... good enough episode, nice twist in the end, singing brought the cringe factor up significantly, if i was pacman i would have to eat the people involved in the singing part :v: :v: :v:

Peace

Ok

The singing was extremely ghey...

But all round decent ep i though. Didn't guess Director Skinner was the Gould. Was convinced that it was the female that rodney had in his noggin a few weeks back.

Did i mention the singing was ghey?

ixoy

Good

Soooo the singing... Although Lutrell has a nice voice, it was very much a WTF moment when she began. Quite LOTR... Speaking of which, I loved the way they compared the relay points to the watch towers in the SGC briefing room and all the nerds grin and nod excitedly

I'm always a fan of the "who's the mole" type plots. Not new, but at least here we had seen all the suspects before. I also thought it'd be Casey Novek, with her twitchy nervousness a good cover.

Kavanagh, how much do I love thee? He's such a great a$$hole and his putdown of Weir, basing her actions on emotions and not reason has a large chunk of truth. Definetely need to see more of him - with him, Cadman, Dr. Lee, and Novek this week, we've had perhaps the best ever show of re-occurring characters in SGA yet.

The only bit I didn't care too much for this week was Teyla's singing but even then it wasn't too bad. I'm giving it top marks - it's along the lines of SG1's "Prototype" - a standalone that I really really enjoyed.

jor el

Ok

I thought this was a very good episode, even the singing which I had a good laugh at.

Best bit though was the Asgard on the ship when he said something to Kavanagh like "Dr. Kavanagh, please stop talking now.......... Thank you". That was good.

The nerds talking LOTR in the meeting room was another good bit.

senordingdong

Ok

Wow....that was weird.

I loved the Cluedo type game going on, it was very good.
What I didn't like was the obvious inconsistencies but more importantly was how so many good stories were crammed into one episode, it left little time to explain everything.
Like the ring ceremony and general Athosian goings on could have been a whole episode for example.

Overall though, I thought it was very entertaining and while I didn't like Teyla's singing either, the overall song, was a brilliant soundtrack to the interrogation/torture scene. It was eerily, even suspiciously reminiscent of the action-opera scene from the Fifth Element.

Does anyone know if Caldwell will be back or his he dead/gone for good?

mcgarnicle

senordingdong wrote:

Wow....that was weird.

I loved the Cluedo type game going on, it was very good.
What I didn't like was the obvious inconsistencies but more importantly was how so many good stories were crammed into one episode, it left little time to explain everything.
Like the ring ceremony and general Athosian goings on could have been a whole episode for example.

Overall though, I thought it was very entertaining and while I didn't like Teyla's singing either, the overall song, was a brilliant soundtrack to the interrogation/torture scene. It was eerily, even suspiciously reminiscent of the action-opera scene from the Fifth Element.

Does anyone know if Caldwell will be back or his he dead/gone for good?

He will be back, the asguard beemed the gould out of him

norbert64

the whole singing scene was so cheesy, it was actually quite good.
Although, do we know for sure whether is was actually Rachel singing? :cool:

Edit: Just saw the relevant thread, can't believe it was really her.

@ the ep, was better than average, I was completely surprised by the Caldwell revelation, although I knew for certain it wasn't any of the other suspects. Cadman? things just didn't add up, Novak is just too good & Cavanagh, he just likes to think he's a rebel, lol.
I was xpecting them to find some1 outside the main cast, although I'm glad they kept it in the family in the end.

If there was one negative point I could say, it would be, were all of the SGC scenes really needed.

senordingdong

Ok

mcgarnicle wrote:

He will be back, the asguard beemed the gould out of him

Yeah I got that line but do we know for sure?
Has he been in any of the forthcoming episodes?

mcgarnicle

senordingdong wrote:

Yeah I got that line but do we know for sure?
Has he been in any of the forthcoming episodes?

Yes

Baggly

mcgarnicle wrote:

Yes

pitty