whats your favourite metallica album?

crimsonfire

whats your favourite metallica album?

loismustdie

s & m's mine, you left it out

nesthead

Justice definatley. it just feels like to me all the frustration and anger at what they had gone through during the 3 years after Cliffs death is expressed in the album.

2nd. Puppets

3rd. Kill 'Em All

crimsonfire

i only included studio albums

GiMiC

I gotta go with Master of Puppets.

After that... any of them except St. Anger, which was just utter crap.

UnrealQueen

That was a hard one to answer. I voted Black but i luv Master of Puppets and Load as well.

crimsonfire

i only included it in case theres some nu school metallica fans here who actually like that piece of piss album

Civilian_Target

Ride the Lightning is definitely the best. The last 3 are not up to much TBH, and I can see I'm not alone in that.

snickerpuss

its definately master of puppets. Such class songs. Failing that, ride the lightning.

loismustdie

ok then, master of puppets becasue absence makes the heart grow fonder but black's a classic

tuxy

Originally posted by nesthead
Justice definatley. it just feels like to me all the frustration and anger at what they had gone through during the 3 years after Cliffs death is expressed in the album.

2nd. Puppets

3rd. Kill 'Em All

i agree with that order

loismustdie

Originally posted by crimsonfire
i only included it in case theres some nu school metallica fans here who actually like that piece of piss album

threadstarter, you didn't tell us whic one you prefer

cournioni

Well its between Justice and RTL. I'll have to say Justice. Very good album.

I only really like the first two and AJFA... I just can't listen to MOP apart from the title track.

nosmo

Put the bass back in, and Justice

Dun

AFJA, MOP/RTL in joint second place, and Kill 'em All third.

9lives

I don't like Justice very much. I find it totally bloated in comparison to "RTL" and "MOP". The tunes just don't do as much for me... I'm in a minority. I think it was the beginning of the decline.

- 9L

niallith

AJFA for me this great album
haha dont think st.anger will b gettin many votes :P

9lives

St Anger? Heavens above... here's what I thought
http://www.epinions.com/content_104545488516

- 9L

byte

Master of Puppets, with Ride the Lightning a close second.

Mossy Monk

Originally posted by byte
Master of Puppets

agreed, wonderful album

crimsonfire

my personal favorite in case any of you are wondering is Justice with master of puppets second and reload third. I hate st anger in comparison to their other stuff but on its own its not bad.

Lemming

puppets without a doubt. Superb. Honourable mention to the 'Black' album.

garthv

METALLICA SUCK

Lemming

Originally posted by Garth_Vader
METALLICA SUCK

*sigh*

Devilman

Has to be Puppets.....

followed closely by..Load ( IMHO - awaits the gasps of horror and revulsion )

nadir

1. And Justice for all
2. Master of Pupprets
3. Ride the Lightening

Justice... now thats some raw ****, if Lars drumming wasnt so gay, that would be one of the best albums i have.

The jock

Without a doubt it has to be:
Master of Puppets

_blank_

Deffo

Puppets.

I think if Load/Reload had have been released as a single album with the best tracks from each, it could have made it higher on my list:

1. Puppets
2. Justice
3. Lightening.
4. Kill
5. Black
6. Load
7. ReLoad
8. Anger

bubbles

And justice for all. Such a raw powerfull album, Blackend, And Justice for all, One, Dyers Eve, Harvester of Sorrow. Does it get any better.

Altho, I have to admit I don't listen to the album much - more into Metallica's live music these days - between 99 and 01 their live stuff is increadable esp the justice for all tunes. The albums low production values making it sound flat is a shame. Listen to the live stuff and then decide.

Metallicababe

The black album all the way baby!!!!!!!!!!!

cournioni

Typical women...

Zoton

1. Ride the lightning
2. Master of Puppets
3. Load
4. Metallica
5. St. Anger
6. Kill 'em all
7. ...And justice for all
8. Reload

Brian Houlihan

Justice is my fave with master in a extremely close second

quank

Master of Puppets for me

Is Zoton the only guy here who called it Metallica, and not the Black album?

Googe

1. Kill em All
2. Load
3. Master Of Puppets

Crucifix

I can't believe Reload got a vote and Load didn't.

begbie

Well, i was never that big a Metallica fan. I only have the Black Album, Ride The Lightening and St. Anger. Out of them, i'd pick the Black Album. So thats what i'll vote for!:D

Kersh

Master of puppets.

Souless

Ride the Lightning

ssh

Puppets.

8 songs. All of them distinct, all of them incredibly good and they all sound great back to back.

I think Puppets is probably my favourite album full stop. It's as close to perfect as you are likely to hear.

Heathen

Master of puppets!!!!!!

my first ever met's record .. got it in 86 and a few weeks later cliff died
was a bummer, i was only after getting into them as a kid and i thought that
they were gonna stop after that, but then i remembered the lyrics of whiplash
"we'll never stop we'll never quit.. cos were Metallica!!!"

so i knew it would be ok

later

hostyle

Paster of Muppets!

Why can't I vote? Gives me the results immediately as if I had already voted, instead of the poll.

Petoria

Originally posted by hostyle
Paster of Muppets!

Why can't I vote? Gives me the results immediately as if I had already voted, instead of the poll.

I know. It's really annoying. What's the point in closing the poll? The topic is still open. FFS!

Anywho, Master of Puppets is my fav. My first ever record. Still have it - it's a "Music for the Nations" copy, whatever that means.

OLDYELLAR

gota be kill em all

Heathen

Originally posted by hostyle
Paster of Muppets!

Why can't I vote? Gives me the results immediately as if I had already voted, instead of the poll.

yea i get the same. but who cares!!! puppets won yeeaaaaayyy!!!!!

later
Macker

Marq

st. anger
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahhaahahhah.

the_obsolete

Puppets!!!!!!

DeFIANCE

Kill'em'all is a piece of work those mustane solos are the
coupe'de'grace on horsemen and the power behind whiplash is unrivaled
its awe inspiring, if they play that at the concert ill be well pleased

Fozzy

I had a look at the setlists at their gigs a few days ago, it seems that every concert ends with a different old song, most of them off Kill 'Em All. That's a deadly way to finish.