Who Should be the new Dr Who?

mike65 · 26-09-2003 9:55pm #1

Well its comming back in 2005 a six part series will see the Doctor
back where he should be - on the Beeb scaring small children!

But who will play the Time Lord? Many Names have already
been mentioned and they're in the poll.

Vote Now!

ixoy · 27-09-2003 1:34am

Paul McGann! He never got a fair chance! And having read the large large majority of the BBC Eight Doctor novels, I've built him up in my head and now want that guy on screen. It must be so.

Or Johnny Depp. Y'know. Whichever.

Gavin W · 27-09-2003 1:38am

Got to be Paul McGann for me, he was the best thing about the '96 TV Movie and I'd love to see him given a proper chance to develop the role on TV.

Though I realise that's probably just wishful thinking from the fan in me, and realistically it's doubtful he's being considered. Richard E. Grant would be wonderful too, and Alan Davies, while not my first choice (he seems too much like the obvious casting choice due to Jonathan Creek) would still be pretty good I reckon.

Hell, I don't care who it is, I'm just ecstatic it's coming back!

Terminator · 27-09-2003 4:31pm

Rachel Griffiths.

Karl Hungus · 28-09-2003 8:50pm

I'll have to go with McGann also, he was brilliant in the movie, and wasn't really given a chance. Although, I would equally like to see Richard E. Grant, and Sean Pertwee in the role.

Shinji · 29-09-2003 11:31pm

Lawrence Llywellen-Bowen. I'm not kidding. He'd be absolutely perfect for the role. Flouncing around like a total fop comes naturally to him

MarVeL · 30-09-2003 9:37pm

How about a time looped Doctor. That way we could could see both Paul McGann (who does deserve a proper run) and Richard E Grant (who could be very, very good). Dr Who and I?

David Stewart · 05-10-2003 9:55am

A bunch of us were sitting in the bar at Phoenix Con last week discussing this very subject. The consensus was that Joannah Lumley - remember her in the Comic Relief special? - would be ideal.

I still would like to see John Cleese as the Dr and Andrew Sachs as the companion.

The Doctor: Manuel. Go outside and look for Daleks.
Manuel (for it is he): Que?

mike65 · 05-10-2003 12:35pm

Originally posted by David Stewart
A bunch of us were sitting in the bar at Phoenix Con last week discussing this very subject. The consensus was that Joannah Lumley - remember her in the Comic Relief special? - would be ideal.

Miss Lumley? A woman as The Doctor? Surely not! I understand Bill Nighy (pic below) who is an exellent character actor in his "middle years" has become the new favourite.

jd · 05-10-2003 12:36pm

Maybe someone like kevin shields (MBV) should do the new theme music..:)

ixoy · 05-10-2003 12:52pm

Originally posted by jd
Maybe someone like kevin shields (MBV) should do the new theme music..:)

I want Orbital's "Doctor Who" mix! It's quite decent and funky....
Also K-9 Mark IV should be the new Doctor...

David Stewart · 05-10-2003 7:02pm

And what's wrong with having a woman as the Doctor?

mike65 · 05-10-2003 9:51pm

Originally posted by David Stewart
And what's wrong with having a woman as the Doctor?

On paper nothing (part from breaking with tradition of course) but
in reality (!) everything 'cos everytime The Doctor encountered
a sqirmy alien enemy she's just scream and hitch up her skirt!

Mike.

Lawdie · 15-10-2003 9:59am

Why don't we make it simple and bring back Tom Baker

shinzon · 15-10-2003 10:02am

have to say i think Patrick Stewart would make an excellent time lord, hed bring gravitas to the role that hasnt been there since Tom Baker

Of course it would all depend on Stewart actually wanting to do another SCI-FI series, but you never know, also didnt i read somewhere that Eddie Izzard is in the running

Shin

superfly · 15-10-2003 10:11am

Tom Baker made a suggestion the other week and i think i would have to agree with him, we need someone that was as zany and brilliant as Baker was and i think the perfect candidate would be Eddie Izzard
you can just imagine him in some tran sexualistic type outfit which he has created for himself and talking about how the Daleks should be pitied because they cant tie their shoelaces or something

ixoy · 15-10-2003 12:31pm

I don't want the new series to be too farcical. Izzard would make it so. I'd like to see it take the approach of the Baker/Davison years where you could get darkness (i.e. "The Talons of Weing-Chang") or the light humour. Don't make the Doctor too sarcastic (O'Neill has that covered in Stargate:SG-1!) but more retain the flippant disregard for authority that he's always had. Hence Johnny Depp.

mike65 · 15-10-2003 12:45pm

Originally posted by ixoy
Hence Johnny Depp.

NO Americans!

Mike

ps I'd like to Tom Baker back as well.....he's still got that slightly mad aspect to his persona.

Lawdie · 25-10-2003 11:59pm

Well I backing Tom Baker, I dont think hes unobtainable. They could easily write him back in. So if theres any producers/casting people out there don't bother with a chancer get Tom.

On Patrick Stewart I say we would all be looking at the screen waiting on him to say "Engage". Then really annoy us by calling all his assistants number one.

Now we got Tom back in the saddle.

Whos going to be his number one. For that I say...K9 (part III)

ixoy · 27-10-2003 3:20am

Originally posted by Lawdie
Now we got Tom back in the saddle.

Whos going to be his number one. For that I say...K9 (part III)

Whaddya mean K9 Part III?

You mean K-9 Mark III?

Lawdie · 27-10-2003 6:41pm

Dead right MKIII

So how old is Tom Baker now anyway, Earth years..not timelord, covering base from all smarty pants

Moriarty · 30-10-2003 3:39pm

Eddie Izzard.

Oh yes.

Lawdie · 31-10-2003 12:09am

This is Izzard who was in the avengers, forget it. The only reasaon he would be good is his inability to get work elsewhere means he would stay a timelord until I'm old.

I know its the new century but nobodies ready for a make up wearing jessy in the tardis yet are they?

What about a female timelord or timelady.... eddie could do both

Who Should be the new Dr Who?

Who Should play the Good Doctor 25 votes

Comments