The Panel 2008

Profiler · 13-11-2008 11:49pm

Ooohhhh choreographed scripted pretend cat fight rubbish... wow that was like almost halfway funny :rolleyes:

coup1917 · 13-11-2008 11:50pm

Christ I thought that was gonna get serious...........
That was the most uncomfortable b*tch fight to watch

camel toe · 13-11-2008 11:51pm

here andrew maxwell is keeping on the low done tonite...im a fan of him and find his comedy funny.

Toto Wolfcastle · 13-11-2008 11:52pm

He definitely stole that coke joke from boards!

el dude · 13-11-2008 11:52pm

Profiler wrote: »

Ooohhhh choreographed scripted pretend cat fight rubbish... wow that was like almost halfway funny :rolleyes:

Don't know how scripted it was as your one from TodayFM had no comebacks and looked pretty embarrassed.

coup1917 · 13-11-2008 11:53pm

camel toe wrote: »

here andrew maxwell is keeping on the low done tonite...im a fan of him and find his comedy funny.

Think he's been sedated for the RTE 1 audience..........

Profiler · 13-11-2008 11:57pm

el dude wrote: »

Don't know how scripted it was as your one from TodayFM had no comebacks and looked pretty embarrassed.

Yeah that was scripted, there is no way Ne Shiogie (or however you spell it) can think on her feet like that and I think the embarrassment from Ray Darcy lite was that she can't act or deliever a line

camel toe · 13-11-2008 11:59pm

whoever this guy is he's bringing a bit of easyness, lightness and calmness to the show.

Soby · 14-11-2008 12:01am

even though it was scripted that was hilarious

Profiler · 14-11-2008 12:02am

well that was a steaming pile of bovine fertilizer...

The Panel is dead and gone, it's with O'Leary in the Grave

Chong · 14-11-2008 12:02am

Liked it more tonight, Jesus Grainne Seoige is so hot

camel toe · 14-11-2008 12:03am

ok im not being mean, becoz i genuinely like the panel but back in the day ud be laughing through the show, now it just gos over my head.

camel toe · 14-11-2008 12:03am

Chong wrote: »

Liked it more tonight, Jesus Grainne Seoige is so hot

get out bill:)

el dude · 14-11-2008 12:05am

Profiler wrote: »

Yeah that was scripted, there is no way Ne Shiogie (or however you spell it) can think on her feet like that and I think the embarrassment from Ray Darcy lite was that she can't act or deliever a line

No way of knowing really. Could tell Darcy-Lite(i like that) was genuinely pissed off.

Anyway, if Seoige is going to look that good every week she's more than welcome back.

coup1917 · 14-11-2008 12:06am

They wheeled that last guest out fairly quickly........

Show is sinking fast however they managed it......Good old RTE..........:(
The lads look like deer in the headlights for this series.....there's no rapour between them..

Chong · 14-11-2008 12:09am

el dude wrote: »

No way of knowing really. Could tell Darcy-Lite(i like that) was genuinely pissed off.

Anyway, if Seoige is going to look that good every week she's more than welcome back.

HEar Hear.

phenomenon · 14-11-2008 12:14am

Gerry Anderson was on for like only 2 minutes! Do you think his jokes about dwarves were too offensive for RTE1? Gráinne looked disgusted even behind her forced smile.

ednwireland · 14-11-2008 12:15am

I thought it was a million percent better tonight seoige was better by far and eye candy as well at least she let the guys get on with it

dots104 · 14-11-2008 12:17am

Profiler wrote: »

well that was a steaming pile of bovine fertilizer...

The Panel is dead and gone, it's with O'Leary in the Grave

well put. i feared the worst when the show went to rte 1. just like rte to ruin a good irish show

Random · 14-11-2008 12:18am

Right. It's very simple. This is what they need.

Bring back dara.
Gag Mairead.
WHere's Jimmy Carr?
Shoot Maxwell.
Have Grainne get nekid!

The whole bloody thing just seems too rehersed and staged these days

faceman · 14-11-2008 12:19am

God Grainne Seoige looked awful tonight. And Mairead Farrell's hair was a bit, mad. Still tho Mairead is hot. Grainne is not as hot no more!

bumbletumble · 14-11-2008 12:20am

i think they need to start filling those "panel" mugs up wit some JD or ANY drink and they might knowk a bit of craic (not the cork king) outta the panel again!

Shryke · 14-11-2008 12:22am

I thought this one was good. I thought Grainne was very attractive on it.. I actually really liked the panel line-up this week. Thumbs up from me.

lostexpectation · 14-11-2008 12:24am

maxwell was brilliant, two or three fabulous rants he out shone everyone else, and he even went and looked up why the guys were fighting, noone else did, i didn't, thats class. I think they get in earlier this time and planned it more, it was much better.

mairied was only good when she was bitchy otherwise she was a moron as usual.

Saint_Mel · 14-11-2008 11:00am

Overall I though it was rubbish. A few nice rants from Andrew Maxwell but apart from that little else going on.
Mairead Farrell is just not funny or entertaining or decent looking in any way.
As for Grainne Seoige ... stop looking at your lines every 5 seconds! Surely RTE1 could spring for an autocue!

BroomBurner · 14-11-2008 11:26am

I thought it was funny enough this week, a definite improvement on last week. My only complaint is that they cut their last guest really short and he actually sounded like he had some interesting stories to tell.

Delamare has to win the Worst 'Tache Award though. It looks like someone smeared unhealthy excrement over his top lip.

Adamcp898 · 14-11-2008 12:07pm

When is the panel repeated?

illiop · 14-11-2008 12:10pm

I thought that it was quite good this week. Grainne seoige was a great improvement on D'arcy but I don't see why they still insist on bringing Mairead Farrell on, she's only there as a token female and there was already Grainne so?? It was a tad serious at times and overly edited but hey it could have been worse, Ed Byrne could have been on it.
Andrew Maxwell is actually my hero and I loved Colin Murphy's "We love the government bit"

andrewh5 · 14-11-2008 12:12pm

bumbletumble wrote: »

i think they need to start filling those "panel" mugs up wit some JD or ANY drink and they might knowk a bit of craic (not the cork king) outta the panel again!

Having been to a filming of the panel I can reliably inform you they DO have drink in them. Colin Murphy for example has Heineken in his.

NedTermo · 14-11-2008 12:16pm

Thought the show was a massive improvement on last weeks overall. Mainly beacuse Darcy wasnt there and Seoige just let them get on with it. But what is with the guests in this series? I sky plussed it and found myself fast forwarding through the interviews before I nodded off. Soooo boring.
Just give them pieces of randomn news and let them riff, no need for the straight laced "is Irish politics taking a ......" ****e"!
We hear enough about that on the news.
Majorly bad decision to move the shows direction.
Anyone know whose presenting next week?

RubyXI · 14-11-2008 12:17pm

Adamcp898 wrote: »

When is the panel repeated?

Twas repeated Saturday nite at around 11pm last week

Heisenberg. · 14-11-2008 1:23pm

This post has been deleted.

BaZmO* · 14-11-2008 1:30pm

faceman wrote: »

God Grainne Seoige looked awful tonight.

Not awful, but certainly not as good as usual. She's still as wooden as the plank though.

faceman wrote: »

And Mairead Farrell's hair was a bit, mad.

Yes

faceman wrote: »

Still tho Mairead is hot.

No

faceman wrote: »

Grainne is not as hot no more!

Hang your head in shame!

WindSock · 14-11-2008 1:37pm

The English panel shows usually have a token Irish guy. I think ours could do with a token English. A good one, so they have to put more effort into competing for laffs.

Jo Brand, ftw!

hacx · 14-11-2008 2:07pm

Na, Stephen Fry would be better. As a prestenter, prob. Altough I think they should just have Murphy and Delamare presenting.

faceman · 14-11-2008 2:11pm

BaZmO* wrote: »

Not awful, but certainly not as good as usual. She's still as wooden as the plank though.

Yes

No

Hang your head in shame!

Dont get me wrong dude, im not rejecting Grainne's advances, but with her efforts last night, if Mairead approached me on the same night, the Finglas lass would be the one wearing me worn out Partick Thistle jersey the next day!

BaZmO* · 14-11-2008 2:15pm

faceman wrote: »

Dont get me wrong dude, im not rejecting Grainne's advances, but with her efforts last night, if Mairead approached me on the same night, the Finglas lass would be the one wearing me worn out Partick Thistle jersey the next day!

She'd also be responsible for your missing wallet too. Gotta watch those Finglas birds!

Utopia Parkway · 14-11-2008 2:47pm

Yeah the Panel has gone to the dogs alright. What was supposed to be a show with comedians taking the piss out of the week's news and events has now become a show where often half the people on the panel aren't even comedians. Grainne Seoige was better than Ray Darcy anyway who seemed to think he was hosting Questions and Answers and actually shushed the comedians in full flow.

The guest host thing works on shows like Have I Got News For You because their lines are so tightly scripted and genuinely funny that they don't look out of place alongside Merton, Hislop, etc. Darcy last week was just a complete car wreck of a performance. He came across as unfunny and worse, quite unlikeable and it just jars badly with the intended general lighthearted spirit of the show.

Utopia Parkway · 14-11-2008 2:57pm

faceman wrote: »

Dont get me wrong dude, im not rejecting Grainne's advances, but with her efforts last night, if Mairead approached me on the same night, the Finglas lass would be the one wearing me worn out Partick Thistle jersey the next day!

Mairead is a fine thing IMO but not so much last night with that dyed red bouffant. Didn't do anything for her but I have seen her before looking well hot. And of course she has a magnificent rack which helps. Sometimes I do have to mute her though.:D

Grainne is a strange one. I can tell that she's very attractive but she doesn't do much for me. Think she comes across quite cold on the telly. Maybe if you met her in person then you might come away thinking "oh yeah she's the business alright".

Wertz · 14-11-2008 3:19pm

Jesus who the f*ck cares what the women look like on it? If you want eye candy go elsewhere...personally I want comedy from a show like this and neither Seoige or Farrell could deliver that if you paid them.
It was pretty unfunny on the whole and certainly not a patch on what it once was...the only positive I got from the show was the lack of Darcy. I switched off halfways in so didn't see any catfight.
RTÉ seem to be pulling a Bull Island on this show..they've seemingly neutered any edge it had, moved it to the mode adult oriented station and quite frankly made complete and utter sh*te out of it IMO.

[edit] BTW what was going on with the whole tache thing with Murphy and Delamere? They had to be fake...right? Was it a bet or a charity sponsorship or what?

Adamcp898 · 14-11-2008 3:22pm

phi3 wrote: »

Twas repeated Saturday nite at around 11pm last week

Thanks

Saint_Mel · 14-11-2008 3:38pm

Wertz wrote: »

[edit] BTW what was going on with the whole tache thing with Murphy and Delamere? They had to be fake...right? Was it a bet or a charity sponsorship or what?

Movember ... growing moustache during the month of November for charity
http://ie.movember.com/

BaZmO* · 14-11-2008 3:39pm

Wertz wrote: »

Jesus who the f*ck cares what the women look like on it? If you want eye candy go elsewhere...personally I want comedy from a show like this and neither Seoige or Farrell could deliver that if you paid them.

I think the thing about the eye candy thing is that if RTE insist on having a token female on the show each week she needs to be funny, but failing that, which is so often the case, she needs to be at least easy on the eye. Something Fiona Looney fell way short of on both accounts.

Wertz · 14-11-2008 3:46pm

BaZmO* wrote: »

I think the thing about the eye candy thing is that if RTE insist on having a token female on the show each week she needs to be funny, but failing that, which is so often the case, she needs to be at least easy on the eye. Something Fiona Looney fell way short of on both accounts.

Aye that's a fair point. It's funny how the beeb can get away without having to do it on any of their topical/panel/news shows, which can sometimes be devoid of women fullstop, let alone good looking or funny ones.
+1 on Looney...at least we're rid of her...she makes Mairead and Aoibheann (sp?) sound positively Bill Bailey-like

BaZmO* · 14-11-2008 3:50pm

Wertz wrote: »

+1 on Looney...at least we're rid of her...she makes Mairead and Aoibheann (sp?) sound positively Bill Bailey-like

Well in Looney's defence, the others may sound like Bill Bailey but she looks like him!

fonpokno · 14-11-2008 4:12pm

BroomBurner wrote: »

I thought it was funny enough this week, a definite improvement on last week. My only complaint is that they cut their last guest really short and he actually sounded like he had some interesting stories to tell.

No. No no no no NO. Trust me, you were blessed that they cut that guy short. He was mind-numbing. I was at the filming for it and Jebus H. Christ he was dull. I think the entire audience fell asleep. There was not one single funny or even mildly interesting moment during his half hour long interview. He was just talking ****e the whole time. God he was awful...

Sandwich · 14-11-2008 7:34pm

WindSock wrote: »

Jo Brand, ftw!

For the eye candy seat.

faceman · 15-11-2008 1:16pm

Wertz wrote: »

Jesus who the f*ck cares what the women look like on it? If you want eye candy go elsewhere...personally I want comedy from a show like this and neither Seoige or Farrell could deliver that if you paid them.

I dont think Farrell is the worst tbh. Its not many female comedians that make me laugh but she does give it her best. Altho most of the humour on the Panel is no funnier than banter than the pub.

xOxSinéadxOx · 15-11-2008 3:15pm

but why did they change it all, why?????????

hacx · 15-11-2008 4:21pm

Experimenting.

The Panel 2008

Comments