Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Sex stopped? At my age? For the rest of my life?

2

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I'm in almost the same situation except that we still get on and to be honest love each other. Seven years ago we had our second child and that was it. We never made love again. Had sex yes once or twice a year. Not this year though. Like the OP I gave up. She doesn't even respond to cuddles anymore...

    I'm really not sure how much we realise that hormones are pretty much responsible for this in addition to modern lifestyles that enable women to say no more sex. While I applaud the fact that women can be brave enough to admit it and not tolerate unwanted sex with their husbands, it's a pretty messed up scenario that they also see no need to address the matter. I referenced my own experience earlier in the thread and its there to take whatever a man wants to take from it.

    Between the OP and the post above, along with other similar posts, I think this is a thread that can be different to similar threads because actual experiences are being referenced. Not that it solves anything, but it is highlighting a massive issue and discussion can hopefully deliver some conclusions and potential solutions.

    My own solution was to have sex with someone else after my wife said she wouldnt blame me. This lead to jealousy and a very awkward situation when my wife tried to seduce me while I was actively having sex with someone else and I rejected her. It worked for us eventually and thankfully we are on the road to somewhere instead of nowhere. But it did involve a Doctor and lots of treatment, understanding and support. If we take the lack of love and affair scenario out of a womans disinterest in sex, straight out of the equation, we are back to basics. Those basics are hormones and those hormones can be fixed. But the biggest problem is the outright refusal of women to NOT think its a problem. This is wrong on so many levels. It's very prevelant these days hence these threads and posts.

    I have a theory, but I'm not so sure I could express it here without causing chaos.

    Cool thread and sad thread at the same time. Hopefully we can achieve some sort of solution/assurance for contributors.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,608 ✭✭✭✭The Princess Bride


    needsmust wrote: »
    Between the OP and the post above, along with other similar posts, I think this is a thread that can be different to similar threads because actual experiences are being referenced. Not that it solves anything, but it is highlighting a massive issue and discussion can hopefully deliver some conclusions and potential solutions.

    Cool thread and sad thread at the same time. Hopefully we can achieve some sort of solution/assurance for contributors

    This issue is coming up again and again in this forum.
    This particular thread however, seems to be an eye opener for those who've not been in a frustrating sexless relationship to acknowledge just how heart wrenching and emotionally draining it can be.

    You think you're the only one going through it, it's like everyone around you is happily married and sexually fulfilled except you.
    Turns out, there are loads hiding behind a smile.

    I really think this thread should be stickied for a while, because it's only a matter of days before the next spouse comes along to start a new similar one.
    If nothing else, this thread shows that they're not alone out there.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    seenitall wrote: »
    Good question. As far as avoiding it, seems to be the luck of the draw with marriage kind of thing. Awful. (Although I do blame a lot on the subtle, wider-societal brain programming done since childhood, of "sex is baaaaad".)

    The crux of the problem lies with the apparent sanctity of marriage, and the bias of the courts towards the primary carer in case of divorce. Both of these facts mean that, once the ring is on the finger, the woman acquires a huge leverage in the relationship, on the basis of which she is able to indulge any selfish tendencies and suit herself, with little consequence to herself, either socially or financially.

    As a woman, I abhor the fact that these kinds of "marriages"/intimacy-free zones exist out there, they make mockery of what a marriage should be, and give the word "wife" a bad name indeed. But as long as nothing changes, nothing will change... it's a tough one.

    FWIW, I think that the poster who talked about living his own life for himself, getting sexual gratification elsewhere, and thus turning the tables on the wife up to a point, is perhaps the closest to making the best out of a bad situation. The best of luck with it, OP.

    I think it has more to do with motherhood than marriage.

    One, as s mother you are expected to be appropriate all the time. How do you do this and be a sex goddess?

    Two. You're constantly in a state of giving to your kids. How do you reclaim desire? Sometimes there is nothing left to bring to anyone's table.

    Three. Domesticity is a Sex killer.

    Four if you want to be desired you have to be desirable.

    We don't know enough about what OP is presenting or the nature of the relationship to know. It takes two to tango but she's getting all the blame here.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    Emme wrote: »
    He's spoiling her rotten and getting nowhere. If they split he'll be expected to spoil her rotten as well. If she is less financially dependent on him this might not happen. Also if she's getting off her backside and making a financial contribution she might appreciate him more. She is sheltered now, if she were out in the world working and talking to other women she might realise how good her husband is and work harder to hold onto him.

    I notice only the OP went to counselling, not his wife. I suggest they go for marriage counselling together. The OP should let his wife know he is unhappy about their nonexistent sex life and ask is she willing to go to counselling to discuss it. Does she know how important sex is to him?

    Many women get a rude awakening when their marriages end (on their instigation) and they hit the dating scene. More than a few of them would have stayed with their husbands if they knew what was ahead of them. It's too late when they realise that they loved their husbands after all and in many cases the ex-husband is too broken hearted to commit emotionally to a new relationship even though he may have more sexual opportunities than he ever had.

    We don't know anything about their relationship or how good her husband is.

    Alienation has ways of creeping in.

    Your post is more about your own value judgements on women who don't work than it is about how the OP can inspire desire in his wife.

    This is a tale as old as the ages, very common, it's not a moral failure. It's a dynamic and a cycle that needs to be shaken.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 667 ✭✭✭OneOfThem


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    It takes two to tango but she's getting all the blame here.

    Of course she's getting all the blame? He raised it with her explaining how big an issue it was and how it was effecting him and her response was essentially "Right, whatever, here's the deal, we're not having sex anymore, can't be bothered, now let's drop it, I don't see it as a big deal".

    It's the very definition of selfishness.

    "Your problem not mine, I'm perfectly happy with the status quo, go fvck yourself."

    If there is a reason behind it for her, she should use her big girl words and explain what the reason is, so it can be addressed. If she doesn't know the reason, she should be doing everything in her power to discover it.

    "I realise this is making you deeply unhappy. But I'm grand. So this is how thing are now." Is a deeply selfish and self centred and childish response to any issue in a marriage.

    She's 'getting blamed', not for the collapse of thier sex life, but for her ****ty attitude towards her husband's unhappiness.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,882 ✭✭✭Saipanne


    It's quite a predicament, and it seems to be more common these days. Unfortunately, it appears that women have all the power in marriages in the modern world, as divorce courts will almost always favour them. It's because of this I'll never get married. It poses too much of a risk, to the man.

    As for you op, apart from divorcing and taking up hobbies to forget about sex, how would an open marriage go down? If there's no sexual interest there, it might be an option.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Just wanted to add my experience to the thread, although not as relevant as some of the other replies.
    I went through a similar experience to some of the posters during and after my wife’s second pregnancy. For the last 4 months or so of the pregnancy she completely went off sex – that’s probably understandable and I certainly didn’t push things. We has always had quite a good sex life up until then and it had never been a major issue for during the first pregnancy.
    After our child was born I obviously wasn’t pushing for sex and just presumed that things would eventually get back to normal.
    One evening I realised that it had been over a year since we’d had sex and there was still no sign of anything changing. When I would sometimes raise the issue it would get pushed away, I was made to feel I was being unreasonable. I think it had almost become a habit at this stage and I knew I needed to do something. One evening I just sat down with my wife and as calmly as possible talked about it. I said that while I still loved her, I couldn’t continue in a marriage that was lacking all intimacy. I don’t think my wife had even realised up to this point how bad things had gotten. We agreed we’d start trying again.
    It sounds unromantic but we actually agreed set evenings that we called ‘sex-dates’. When the kids were in bed we’d have a nice meal, a couple of glasses of wine, massages, and sex (yeah!).
    We eventually started to reconnect sexually, and our sex lives started to return to normal. Not bragging, but we probably have better sex now than we ever did and we’re married over 11years and together for almost 20.

    I guess my point is that there eventually comes a stage where you need to sit down and address the issue and agree to solve it together – if one of the parties isn’t willing to do this then it’s not going to work.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    We don't know anything about their relationship or how good her husband is.

    Alienation has ways of creeping in.

    Your post is more about your own value judgements on women who don't work than it is about how the OP can inspire desire in his wife.

    This is a tale as old as the ages, very common, it's not a moral failure. It's a dynamic and a cycle that needs to be shaken.

    I am not judging women who don't work. I do however think it is wrong to be in any kind of relationship and make no contribution whatsoever or leave one person to do most of the work. Relationships are a two way street.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    OneOfThem wrote: »
    Of course she's getting all the blame? He raised it with her explaining how big an issue it was and how it was effecting him and her response was essentially "Right, whatever, here's the deal, we're not having sex anymore, can't be bothered, now let's drop it, I don't see it as a big deal".

    It's the very definition of selfishness.

    "Your problem not mine, I'm perfectly happy with the status quo, go fvck yourself."

    If there is a reason behind it for her, she should use her big girl words and explain what the reason is, so it can be addressed. If she doesn't know the reason, she should be doing everything in her power to discover it.

    "I realise this is making you deeply unhappy. But I'm grand. So this is how thing are now." Is a deeply selfish and self centred and childish response to any issue in a marriage.

    She's 'getting blamed', not for the collapse of thier sex life, but for her ****ty attitude towards her husband's unhappiness.

    You are right, that is self centred.

    Number of possibilities:

    1. Pure selfishness....simply not giving a ****.

    2. The difficulty in talking about sex....finding the right language...especially if it hurts someones feelings like "I don't fancy you."

    3. The possibility of feeling exposed and not having the vocabulary to talk about something diffuse...she may not know why... this can be really hard if the person you are talking to as a general rule doesn't listen. "i feel ugly. I am ashamed of my body." These are really really hard things to say.

    4. Is there a possibility of latent utilitarian/Catholic ideas about sex...the procreation is done.... therefore...

    I am not married but I can speak from experience of motherhood, that I felt I lost so much autonomy over my own body, the constant contact with children, touching, hugs, carrying, snussling, etc... the constant outputs of giving... that it can be difficult to feel like a woman when you are a mother all the time. I certainly feel this though I don't have a marriage to manage as well.

    So without much space to feel like a woman, and the loss of autonomy over my body...the last thing I would want is another person needing to touch me because without the space to be autonomous this can feel oppressive.

    Where this leaves a marriage I would imagine is a challenge and how a wife than can reclaim desire....

    Clearly I don't know how OP and his wife communicate outside of this context, are they open and non judgemental...is their mutual scaffolding... are there historical minefields...no one here knows this...

    Or yeah maybe just indifference but how do we know?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    This issue is coming up again and again in this forum.
    This particular thread however, seems to be an eye opener for those who've not been in a frustrating sexless relationship to acknowledge just how heart wrenching and emotionally draining it can be.

    You think you're the only one going through it, it's like everyone around you is happily married and sexually fulfilled except you.
    Turns out, there are loads hiding behind a smile.

    I really think this thread should be stickied for a while, because it's only a matter of days before the next spouse comes along to start a new similar one.
    If nothing else, this thread shows that they're not alone out there.

    I agree with this. Recently a girl posted asking if she should date a guy who was nice and had a good job but she wasn't sure she fancied him. Is this what happens a few years down the line when the girl marries the nice guy with the good job that she doesn't fancy? They set up home, she gets what she wants and stops sleeping with him.

    We agree the OP's wife is a busy(ish) mum. I don't think her problem is exhaustion because she is able to paint and do yoga classes. If she's doing yoga classes she's probably in good shape.

    If she's willing to go to marriage counselling and/or talk to her doctor about hormonal issues relating to desire then the problem isn't selfishness on her part. The OP will have to discuss this with her. If she isn't willing to discuss it he will have to deal with things as he sees fit. Sometimes the threat of another woman can be a wake-up call and a powerful aphrodisiac.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Christ this thread is scary. So many replies of people in the same boat.How does one avoid this?

    I think it is as simple as people falling out of love. In a relationship without children the couple will more than likely split up but it's harder when you have kids.

    The difference between men and women is that women usually won't want sex with their partner or husband if they are no longer in love....whereas men often still will. I don't think that makes the woman the bad guy but it seems many people do seem to think that.

    As for why couples fall out of love well I think a major problem is lack of communication and understanding. I think couples let issues build up without sorting them out properly and this leads to resentment that can be too hard to come back from if left for too long.

    I use another forum and I notice a pattern on there all the time between couples with youn families, now these stories are always told from the womans side but likewise these stories about lack of sex are often told from the mans side.

    Anyway a major issue seems to be about the man not pulling his weight at home....even if his wife or partner is also working. This leads to a lot of resentment and the woman pulling away from the man, he pulls away from her too because he sees her as nagging whereas she sees it as just reminding. I think what people should remember is that as much as men hate being 'nagged' i'm sure the vast majority of women hate having to actually keep going on and on about something, they don't like being turned into a nag!!

    This type of behaviour can be very bad for relationships because I think the man can often feel emasculated because of the way the woman speaks to him but she will often feel very unloved and taken for granted too...very bad combination I think especially if the behaviour goes on for years which it often will when children are young.

    I think if any resentments are left to fester for a long time without being resolved and sex rarely happens as a result then it is often hard for the woman to have sex with her partner as she doesn't see him in that way anymore and it can often feel like a brother/sister relationship. She doesn't desire him in that way...again I don't think that that makes her the bad guy.

    I think another big part of why this kind of thing happens is because we don't really take steps to look after our mental health, if we're stressed we take it out on those closest to us and it takes it's toll on our relationship and while outsiders often see the best version of that person while the closest person to them sees all the bad bits.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I would like to add my experience. We have three young kids. The youngest is nearly three so we are busy. We both work and I do my share. We get on well and are reasonably happy. When it comes to sex it's not happening.

    We have spoke a bit about it, but my wife says she is tired and that we need to spend more time together (I work in the evenings after the kids go to bed). I always initiate sex and most times she will just pretend to be asleep. When she does make an effort (minimal) she is clearly not interested. This is turn just kills my interest. Who wants to force themselves on someone?

    I'm not sure of a solution tbh. I love my kids so divorce is off the cards. Not sure about the whole affair thing. Maybe just to get on with things. Connect with friends.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,775 ✭✭✭✭keane2097


    needsmust wrote: »
    I'm really not sure how much we realise that hormones are pretty much responsible for this in addition to modern lifestyles that enable women to say no more sex. While I applaud the fact that women can be brave enough to admit it and not tolerate unwanted sex with their husbands, it's a pretty messed up scenario that they also see no need to address the matter. I referenced my own experience earlier in the thread and its there to take whatever a man wants to take from it.

    Between the OP and the post above, along with other similar posts, I think this is a thread that can be different to similar threads because actual experiences are being referenced. Not that it solves anything, but it is highlighting a massive issue and discussion can hopefully deliver some conclusions and potential solutions.

    My own solution was to have sex with someone else after my wife said she wouldnt blame me. This lead to jealousy and a very awkward situation when my wife tried to seduce me while I was actively having sex with someone else and I rejected her. It worked for us eventually and thankfully we are on the road to somewhere instead of nowhere. But it did involve a Doctor and lots of treatment, understanding and support. If we take the lack of love and affair scenario out of a womans disinterest in sex, straight out of the equation, we are back to basics. Those basics are hormones and those hormones can be fixed. But the biggest problem is the outright refusal of women to NOT think its a problem. This is wrong on so many levels. It's very prevelant these days hence these threads and posts.

    I have a theory, but I'm not so sure I could express it here without causing chaos.

    Cool thread and sad thread at the same time. Hopefully we can achieve some sort of solution/assurance for contributors.

    Interesting post.

    I would think the advice of investigating possible hormonal issues is far more useful and dare I say grown up than the "she's not giving you the ride so stop giving her money" stuff, which seems pretty creepy at best.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    keane2097 wrote: »
    Interesting post.

    I would think the advice of investigating possible hormonal issues is far more useful and dare I say grown up than the "she's not giving you the ride so stop giving her money" stuff, which seems pretty creepy at best.

    The OP's wife doesn't see any problems with not wanting sex. He will have to convince her to go to the doctor to get her hormones checked. He can't make her go if she doesn't want to. He didn't say anything about his wife's energy levels but she's not doing very much to exert herself. If she was working she might notice a drop in her energy levels which could go unnoticed now. A drop in energy levels could indicate a hormonal/endocrine problem.

    Is she sleeping more? Has she put on weight she can't lose? Is her hair falling out? All of this could indicate a hormonal/endocrine problem as well as a non-existent sex drive.

    Hopefully she will realise how much it matters to him and get herself checked out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,461 ✭✭✭Queen-Mise


    As for getting sex elsewhere. She said go ahead and to be honest if the opportunity arises I'll take it with no sense of betrayal because I feel she is betraying our relationship. I don't want it elsewhere though. She is the woman I love.

    I will never judge a man or woman for that matter who has an affair again.

    I have tears in my eyes as I type this because I've never been able to express it to anyone before.

    It's not even the lack of sex. It's the lack of intimacy. I realise now I shouuld never have married her and if the kids weren't here. I'd be gone.

    The parts I have highlighted are the parts that destroy me. My husband is an absolute gem but the lack of intimacy is soul destroying.

    Do I have to seriously think about having an affair? Is there a website for people in the same boat as me? This is wrecking my head.
    I do not know what the fcuk to do.

    We have spoken about it, made efforts and it has all gone backwards again. What are my options if I don't want to break up my marriage?
    needsmust wrote: »
    I have a theory, but I'm not so sure I could express it here without causing chaos.

    I would love to hear your theory. Just preface the post stating that it is a theory. You may well be partly right or wrong with it. And that you are not stating it as fact.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,368 ✭✭✭Potatoeman


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    And what do you suggest he say, "put out or Im not paying for yoga?"

    LOL...she'll respond with fine. Im on work to rule, take the kids with you to work then.

    The sexual desert is usually created by TWO people.

    No, he can say he is going to get it elsewhere and now that she has so much free time she can get a job and start supporting herself. Take sex out of a relationship and it's a friendship. Would you let a friend spunge off you and insist on celibacy?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    Potatoeman wrote: »
    No, he can say he is going to get it elsewhere and now that she has so much free time she can get a job and start supporting herself. Take sex out of a relationship and it's a friendship. Would you let a friend spunge off you and insist on celibacy?

    Ah ok...then he will mind the kids half the time and do half the house management?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,368 ✭✭✭Potatoeman


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    Ah ok...then he will mind the kids half the time and do half the house management?

    Why not? Many schools offer minding services and many couples both work and manage just fine.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    Potatoeman wrote: »
    Why not? Many schools offer minding services and many couples both work and manage just fine.

    And many don't.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    keane2097 wrote: »
    Interesting post.

    I would think the advice of investigating possible hormonal issues is far more useful and dare I say grown up than the "she's not giving you the ride so stop giving her money" stuff, which seems pretty creepy at best.

    Yes I think some of the responses here are pretty creepy alright. Stop paying for yoga, stop paying for things if she isn't putting out.

    The latent belief system that deep down we are all prostitutes.

    And frankly, if I were in her shoes and I was picking up on that subtext, I would start paying for everything, stop minding the kids, stop doing all the housework, become entirely autonomous and then if he wanted sex hand him the number of a prostitute.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 303 ✭✭Ann84


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    The latent belief system that deep down we are all prostitutes.

    And frankly, if I were in her shoes and I was picking up on that subtext, I would start paying for everything, stop minding the kids, stop doing all the housework, become entirely autonomous and then if he wanted sex hand him the number of a prostitute.

    I don't agree with this! If you give up your financial Independance to rely on someone else stuff gets really complicated!!!
    Can't she just earn her own income and they can seperate happily - problem is that the wife is not financially Independant and the husbands here seem to feel trapped in a relationship with their wives because of this... Putting up with a situation they wouldn't tolerate in another circumstance! I personally think it's pretty awful to expect your partner to go sex free because I don't fancy it for whatever reason, I wouldn't expect him to stay and he would be able to because I don't rely on him!!

    Separating where both parties are financially independent is a lot easier and therefore neither party feels trapped to stay - I see a lot of frustration coming from this on this thread and it's not right, I wouldn't want to stay married to a man if sex was off the table so why should it be different here... Money!!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,516 ✭✭✭zeffabelli


    Ann84 wrote: »
    I don't agree with this! If you give up your financial Independance to rely on someone else stuff gets really complicated!!!
    Can't she just earn her own income and they can seperate happily - problem is that the wife is not financially Independant and the husbands here seem to feel trapped in a relationship with their wives because of this... Putting up with a situation they wouldn't tolerate in another circumstance! I personally think it's pretty awful to expect your partner to go sex free because I don't fancy it for whatever reason, I wouldn't expect him to stay and he would be able to because I don't rely on him!!

    Separating where both parties are financially independent is a lot easier and therefore neither party feels trapped to stay - I see a lot of frustration coming from this on this thread and it's not right, I wouldn't want to stay married to a man if sex was off the table so why should it be different here... Money!!

    I agree with you it is really complicated but if you frame it as Im really sexually frustrated, you owe me, Im not paying for yoga anymore..." your sending the subtext that you see your wife in prostitutional value.

    You then create a paradigm that could easily backfire. We don't even know how OP feels about his wife...does he still love her or is she a nanny and a resource for sex?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,368 ✭✭✭Potatoeman


    zeffabelli wrote: »
    Yes I think some of the responses here are pretty creepy alright. Stop paying for yoga, stop paying for things if she isn't putting out.

    The latent belief system that deep down we are all prostitutes.

    And frankly, if I were in her shoes and I was picking up on that subtext, I would start paying for everything, stop minding the kids, stop doing all the housework, become entirely autonomous and then if he wanted sex hand him the number of a prostitute.


    You have no issue with him being used as an ATM and being deeply unhappy?

    If you only do half of the housework and childminding then you obviously must be paying half of all the bills.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Potatoeman wrote: »
    You have no issue with him being used as an ATM and being deeply unhappy?

    If you only do half of the housework and childminding then you obviously must be paying half of all the bills.


    How do you know the wife isn't deeply unhappy too? Are people assuming that because she has a couple of hobbies that she must be loving her life? The OP's opening line was that he and his wife don't really get on in general. I would imagine the vast majority of people in that situation are deeply unhappy. Who wants to have a relationship like that?

    As for him being used as an ATM, at no point has he said that he has asked her to financially contribute and that she has refused, of course she could offer to try to look for a part time job and maybe she does keep an eye out but she may not be able to find something that suits the hours that the kids are in school.

    He said that she's a good mother, we have no reason to think that she doesn't think that he's also a wonderful father and thinks it's good for the children that they stay in this marriage even if they are both unhappy, we do not know enough about this woman to assume that she is just staying in the marriage because she's financially secure within it.


  • Registered Users Posts: 165 ✭✭Kenny B


    Potatoeman wrote: »
    You have no issue with him being used as an ATM and being deeply unhappy?

    If you only do half of the housework and childminding then you obviously must be paying half of all the bills.

    Many years ago they entered into a contact of sorts, withholding money for a lack of sex is nonsense, withholding money and withdrawing from the relationship is a different thing altogether.


  • Registered Users Posts: 4,591 ✭✭✭blue note


    guest 2015 wrote: »
    It sounds unromantic but we actually agreed set evenings that we called ‘sex-dates’. When the kids were in bed we’d have a nice meal, a couple of glasses of wine, massages, and sex (yeah!).
    We eventually started to reconnect sexually, and our sex lives started to return to normal. Not bragging, but we probably have better sex now than we ever did and we’re married over 11years and together for almost 20.

    I guess my point is that there eventually comes a stage where you need to sit down and address the issue and agree to solve it together – if one of the parties isn’t willing to do this then it’s not going to work.

    This is about the most constructive thing I've read in the thread, but you need the woman to be willing to deal with the issue properly. Very often (including in a relationship I was in) bringing up the issue results in a heavily defensive response - maybe if you did more housework, made more of an effort to be romantic, etc, etc, etc that there would be more sex. A lot of suggestions that take any of the blame off the woman and essentially push dealing with the problem down the road.

    Whereas, what you're suggesting - a date night, starting with a massage or whatever often will result in sex that the woman will enjoy too. In my experience, when we finally did have sex she tended to enjoy it (well she was only human:)). And once you start having sex again it will probably result in a healthier relationship all round.

    However, and it's a big however, she has to be willing to deal with the problem with more than paying it lip service.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 33,518 ✭✭✭✭dudara


    Posters - this is not a forum for you to have a back and forth conversation between yourselves. You can do that via PM. If you are not offering advice to the OP, then please don't post.

    dudara


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    There was a time when my ex could have wrote one of these posts but what he would have left out was that he had an alcohol abuse problem which could see him disappearing for a weekend or else coming back and being verbally abusive or coming back and vomiting and falling asleep on the toilet which was deeply unattractive.

    My anxiety levels were through the roof waiting for him to go missing again. I would dread the weekends or his holidays from work.

    For a long time he had me convinced it was my fault he went out drinking like that due to a lack of a sex life but eventually I realised that that wasn't true because he had abused alcohol even before we were together.

    There were times he would abuse alcohol and I'd make a real effort with sex thinking he'd cop on and we could have great loving sex and then he'd go binge drinking the next day and leave me feeling worthless again.

    Despite those issues we got on great most of the time and I knew the lack of sex affected him and I would desperately want to be close to him at times but I had a big wall up because I would associate getting intimate with him with being more hurt when he would break his promises in relation to alcohol again.

    I actually hated seeing him upset about not having sex and I hated that I felt like I couldn't have it either but as I said his actions in the relationship caused my reaction. It was never about punishing him or withholding it or being selfish, I mentally couldn't put myself in a position to be more hurt and the more intimate we were the more I would be hurt.

    There was a time he was convinced it was all my fault although eventually he realised it wasn't but if he had came on here at the time then people might have made a lot of assumptions about me that simply weren't true. My point is that we just don't know the other side to these stories.

    He told me on 2 different occasions that he'd been with other women which he said he said to try to get me to have sex with him, I do actually believe that he didn't sleep with them.....and then we'd have sex and things would be going great and he'd go on massive benders again, it was very traumatic to be convinced it was all my fault, to believe it, try to take steps to address it and then to have him sabotage it. Anyway that's just a story from the other side.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,368 ✭✭✭Potatoeman


    Her being financially independant might be the best thing for both of you if things get worse. If the marriage fails at least she will have a job and she wont be completely dependant on you.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Potatoeman wrote: »
    Her being financially independant might be the best thing for both of you if things get worse. If the marriage fails at least she will have a job and she wont be completely dependant on you.

    It's definitely a conversation that needs to be had. If ultimatums are going to be issued in regards to sex etc. then I certainly think he should explain to her that he doesn't think the situation is sustainable long term and he will not be able to stay in a sexless mariage long term so she should really start the process of trying to become more financially independent.

    I would imagine the amount of women (in sexless marriages) willing to put up with their husband going out and having sex with another woman would be actually quite small so if he goes down that route the marriage is more than likely going to end anyway.

    Wouldn't she be able to go for divorce on grounds of adultery then? I'm not sure how divorce works in Ireland....would the courts be more likely to be more favourable to her if he committed adultery?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 7 a.non.i.mouse


    Going anon for this reply as I have never told some people the full story behind all this - I was in the same situation for many years.

    With the benefit of hindsight, I got married far to young, I was 23 and so was my wife. The warning signs were there from the beginning but I ignored them as I loved her.

    She was almost afraid of sex, she came from a quite religious family and I think it was this subtle catholic brainwashing that it all came from. There was certainly no sex before we got married – intimacy and affection yes, but no sex.

    I told myself it would get better after we were married. It didn't. I tried patience, I tried talking about it, I tried everything, it never improved. We did have very infrequent sex, and when we did she did say she enjoyed it, but she was always extremely passive. I hoped that one day it would open the floodgates but it never did – she just didn't have a libido that needed satisfying and once our son was born that was pretty much the end of the show.

    Suddenly I realised 10 years had gone by. I was overweight, drinking too much and pretty miserable most of the time. My wife started talking about having another child (would have needed having sex for the first time in years) and I came to a decision – it was not going to improve, I was kidding myself thinking it was. At 33 I was faced with looking elsewhere for sex, putting up with the situation the way it was, or doing something more proactive. I decided I couldn't face a life of pretending everything was ok so I left. We separated.

    A while later I ended up in a relationship with a woman who had no hangups about sex or talking about it. It was like a breath of fresh air. We had/have a great sex life. We are married now and have 3 young kids.

    Do we still have sex? Yes - not as often as before the kids were born but we both want it, need it, realise it is a vitally important part of a healthy relationship. Are there nights when we are just too tired? Of course, but intimacy is still there, and physical contact and affection is sometimes all you need.

    I've never put all this down before but I guess the message I am trying to put out is that you don't have to accept that it's all over. At many times it wasn't an easy road. Leaving my first son was heart wrenching (I still have a very good relationship with him, he sees his 'new' siblings often and gets on well with them despite the age difference).

    I'm not saying this is the solution for you or anyone else, but I cannot say I regret the decision to leave in any way, it was the right solution for me.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,920 ✭✭✭✭Dial Hard


    leafheart wrote:
    Wouldn't she be able to go for divorce on grounds of adultery then? I'm not sure how divorce works in Ireland....would the courts be more likely to be more favourable to her if he committed adultery?

    Nope. All divorces in Ireland are considered "no fault".


  • Registered Users Posts: 87 ✭✭zephyro


    OP I suggest you tell her in a calm manner that if she's not interested, you'll look for someone else who is. Make sure you tell her this first (and note the date in writing) so she can't claim you went behind her back if it comes up later!

    In general, given that the male sex drive is much stronger than the female and also we aren't designed for monogamy anyway, it's pretty strange men don't appreciate that promising long-term monogamy to a woman is very likely a recipe for an infrequent-to-nonexistent sex life.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,269 ✭✭✭✭Sleepy


    OP, unless finances aren't a problem for you at all, I'd suggest addressing the issue of her not pulling her weight financially before making any ultimatums about going elsewhere for sex if she won't join you in counselling / see a doctor about her lack of libido. As it stands, the only input she has on the income side of the income / expenditure breakdown is the children's allowance she receives.

    If you separate, you'll be expected to maintain this situation so you'll be paying all your current bills on top of your new ones (rent / mortgage on a new place, utility bills etc.). Can you afford to do that?

    It may make no sense for her to work full-time if childcare costs come to more than the additional income (less the tax credits you'll lose for no longer being a single-income married couple) but surely she can find some part-time work? My own wife does childminding a few days a week as it's a pretty tax-efficient means of bringing in an extra income that doesn't require us to arrange for childcare for our own kids. Might something like that be an option for her?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Right now I am in a bad phase. She walks in, I walk out. She looks at me, I look away. I have moved into the downstairs room over a year ago, at the time I told her I will not continue with this grotesque Ernie and Bert relationship. I now spend most of my time in my room, I avoid her whenever possible. We have tried to patch this up and everything works great, we go away on weekend breaks, we have fun, we get on, we do things, I put in an effort and then she says "I'm tired, I just want to go to sleep". So afterwards back to my room I go and back to ignoring her.
    I can feel the bitterness and resentment as physical sensations, it feels like my body is being poisoned.
    Why don't I move out? I can't! My salary just about covers the mortgage, the cars, the shopping and maybe going to the beach every now and then with her (grrr) and the dogs (yay!).
    I don't have 8-900 extra a month to also rent an apartment. And however bad things get I will REFUSE to move into some grubby student houseshare or worse even, renting a room of some family, I'll plough my car into a tree before I do that. Besides I can't even afford that.
    We need to sell the house and split the money and go our separate ways. She has already talked about our next house together, I actually feel like strangling the bitch when she says that, has she not listened to what I have been saying to her for the last 10 years? Screaming sometimes? I am living with a demon who is sucking the lifeforce out of me.
    She then says "of course, right so, move out then, but I expect you to call your solicitor and sign the house over to me and by the way, you'll still owe the mortgage". Needless to say I should also cover the legal costs. The absolute screamer and knee-slapper is, I can't even do that! The bank would not allow her to take over the mortgage, because she has no jobs and no means to cover the mortgage.
    I need to talk to a solicitor to force the sale of the house and if anyone has any suggestions who else to talk to, I would be very, very grateful. She has previously mentioned about me abandoning her and how could I do it and do I want her ending up living on the street with the dogs, etc...
    She then says "so you are willing to throw away our relationship over sex". I then simply quote the exact same sentence back to her. Of course then I am selfish and only out for my own gratification.
    What really gets me is the sh*te she looks up on the internet. Alien abduction. The Bilderbergs, the Rothschields, the Illuminati, the grey aliens, the reptilians, the angel cards, the unicorns and all that is just some of the saner stuff, you want to see the really out there, whacked out stuff she looks up.
    And I notice she will let me get away with absolutely anything, she will do anything for me, all because she knows that without me she is utterly screwed. I can ignore her, not talk to her, she will pretend to be happy and that everything is hunky dory. Even when she flips (gives me a tiny bit of grim satisfaction), she will be back to pretend happy and smiling in a short time. I guess to annoy me, to show me that she can get to me but I can't get to her, but I know I can and I do. Soon there will be nothing left in our relationship but spite and malice. In a way it's more honest than what's happening now. Me ignoring her and her pretending all is well.
    I think I should start going out without her, meeting friends and maybe more, any thoughts on that?

    One add on:
    One poster above mentioned the guy having a drinking problem. Of course that doesn't work. If one of the parties in the relationship has a substance abuse problem, it cannot work. But it definitely doesn't apply in my case, I drink little to no alcohol. I don't even smoke.
    So, no sex, no drugs, no alcohol, there are priests that have a more hectic and active social and sex life than me.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,882 ✭✭✭Saipanne


    I can offer one suggestion, which is meetup.com.

    Great way to socialise.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,707 ✭✭✭arayess


    Not Me wrote: »
    She then says "so you are willing to throw away our relationship over sex". I then simply quote the exact same sentence back to her. Of course then I am selfish and only out for my own gratification.

    think you need to be honest with her and say "yes"
    no relationship is worth the feelings you've just put on paper.
    if she isn't willing to make the effort she doesn't love you enough . its' that simple
    I think she is comfortable and has a nice existance and is content in her own selfish behaviour.

    You need for your own sanity to get out of there , let her fend for herself , the judge will make her do this anyway. You will be surprised how much cash you will have paying for 1 rather than 2.
    Or go get sex on the side , go party .


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Op best thing to do would be to talk to a solicitor. Is it just the two of you or do you have kids?


  • Registered Users Posts: 303 ✭✭Ann84


    I have no idea why you'd suggest suicide to being free of your current living arrangement...
    Honestly, I'd rather live in a dingy flat or house share over what you describe any day!
    Why can't she move out? You pay the mortgage - tell her to get a job, your sick of supporting her and your not funding one single non-essential until she gets an income.
    And yes, start going out without her, you are no longer a couple


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,403 ✭✭✭daisybelle2008


    Not Me, I don't understand why you haven't spoke to a solicitor. You have no children, selling the house, splitting the difference and going your separate ways is what will happen.
    Once the assets are split you both fend for yourselves (move back home, get a job whatever). Your relationship has a very strange dynamic, you are only encouraging her dependency. You maybe need to be more honest with yourself, you actually appear to hate her, you say that there is nothing but spite and malice, sex really isn't the issue here, you seem to be totally unsuited at every possible level. Having sex would only be papering over the cracks. Maybe you are holding on to the idea that would fix everything but maybe the level of dysfunction runs a lot deeper than that and you need to let go and make the move to separate.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,723 ✭✭✭seenitall


    The OP does have kids and, like any good father, they are a major consideration for him in this sorry mess of a marriage.
    I feel like I have just accepted defeat - she has everything she wants, I have to accept that a non sexual relationship is beter than one where I am in a flat supporting 2 houses, broke & seeing the kids 1-2 times a week.


    Got a great house, job, wonderful kids and a good mother - I feel like such an asshole thinking of separating, (me going to an apartment, developing arguments about maintenance, kids hearts being broken, both of us being broke, her own great lifestyle of painting classes and yoga while kids are in school - all down the drain) and it could probably all be avoided in my mind with sex once a week or fortnight.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,403 ✭✭✭daisybelle2008


    seenitall wrote: »
    The OP does have kids and, like any good father, they are a major consideration for him in this sorry mess of a marriage.

    I may be wrong but I thought Not Me and the OP are different posters? Not Me only mentions dogs and lists very different circumstances than the OP. :confused: They read like different posters.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,030 ✭✭✭njs030


    I may be wrong but I thought Not Me and the OP are different posters? Not Me only mentions dogs and lists very different circumstances than the OP. :confused: They read like different posters.

    Me too. I thought the most recent post was from someone else. Maybe mods could open a new thread for the new person as it's getting really confusing!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,723 ✭✭✭seenitall


    Ah I see. My mistake then.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    It's getting hard to keep up with who's story is who, but I think it's good to read everyones story anyway (so please don't split the thread mod!!).

    Anyway,kind of same story, nearly.

    Married old enough, lived together long enough, Child one arrived, went relatively ok.
    Child 2 arrived and then the days turned into weeks which turned into months, then we kind of got things a bit more regular, but then child 3 arrived and it's not as bad but still the frustration does eat me up, at this stage though my wife isn;t even concerned with foreplay, just get it over with, and then saying it was fun and we should be doing it every morning and night..

    and here's the thing (and another poster mentioned it earlier)... I can predict down to the day when she'll be interested again. And shock horror folks, it's all just based on her cycle.

    Thinking back on things, she used always loose the nut (like a blind rage) around a certain time of her cycle... (as in jealousy, obsessing about housework, someone out to get her, stupid raging arguments over nothing, threatening to leave with the kids, telling me I should leave).. and then everything would be rosy in a few days time as if it never happened. So eventually she told her doctor about her moods and lack of libido. So as much as we were both hesitant she tried prozac (with regular monitoring by her doctor I must emphasise). When she was on it everything was much calmer and it was actually a very loving house with a lot more patience and less sniping (but of course prozac has it's side effects too).

    So now she's off it and it's going back to that way again. The thing is, we both recognise it and talk about it, I don't want to ever suggest to her that they go 'on medication' as she has a fairly good head on her shoulders and always makes the right decision for us.

    But I hate it, I think people often get the impression that men 'just' want to shoot their load, and initially I thought that this was just my 'hormones' being irrational so I should stop the 'pestering' for sex. But it's just unbearable, loads of teasing/promises/overt suggestions during the day time but when the night time comes I'm just a dirty pervert dog 'looking for sex'. Deep down I want to be wanted too, not because I've done x,y or z in the kitchen, but because I'm me and someone would want me for just being me. If I did just want to 'get off' then I'd be engaging in masturbation very often, but that just depresses me and makes me feel shallow at this stage of my life.

    I'm sick to the back teeth of listening to people who say "oh! just make some more time for romance and the rest will follow" or "buy her flowers" or "help with the housework". This just puts the issue 'solely' back on the man, so invariably it hints at 'buying sex' from your spouse.


    I'd be against criticising your desire 'for sex' by any means necessary (dates and flowers etc), so I think people should go easy a bit on the OP. Your head is all over the place OP and people need to realise that sex for men isn't just about 'knocking one out', it runs just as deep as it does for women, except a lot of us men don't really realise this. Sure, you could go away and have a few affairs and what nots, but deep down you want to be loved, and if you do find love then it's going to be very tricky dealing with that with your wife at home.

    I also think that kids pick up on parents issues/interactions, so the coldness and arguments will become their 'normality' too. Do you want to be teaching them that that is how a normal marriage is? But don't get me wrong, this isn't advice to throw in the towel just yet. I think most marriages go on a roller coaster (despite what your perfect friend's marriages look like!), so there might be hope yet.

    So in the end, I'd take up some other posters advice and consider asking her to see a GP and rule out hormones. Also the fact that she's going deep into conspiracy theories may suggest paranoia (which was a major factor in my wife's imbalance!). I had the bags packed a few times untill I took a stand and said "why the f*ck should I be the one leaving my house and kids".So that's my story OP, I would never want to leave her. But heck I miss the fun we used to enjoy.

    Maybe there's something more going on in society (like hormones in the water kind of thing!) as it seems like a common enough problem on this forum. Or was it always that way and a large portion of couples just grew old and bitter together while it was all apple pie in public.

    Remember OP you've done absolutely nothing wrong, you just want to be wanted. Talk it out, surely ye must have had something worth fighting for before the marriage and kids.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Not me, your problem is very different to the OPs. As another poster said you sound like you hate your wife, you said in your first post that she was an evil bitch, Your problems will not go away if she has sex with you and i'm sure she is aware of how she feel about her so of course she's not going to want to have sex. Your relationship is not going to get better.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    'Not me' your post actually scares me. That level of hate for someone who you you just dont have sex life with is disturbing. You know you are 100% responsible for your own life and happiness right? You're sounding like a sad and bitter man that when presented with solutions or help to a situation that you OBVIOUSLY need to change, you revert to inaction and victim mentality so as not to have to set about the immense work involved in changing your life to achieve the happiness you want or a least a more content situation for yourself. You seem to prefer to sit seething and gathering poisonous resentment, but do nothing. And you actually say you want to have sex with a person you despise? That's dishonest. You don't want a sex life with HER you want a different partner, a different life, everything. Stop the blame game and pinning all the responsibility of YOUR happiness of the shoulders of your wife who you too are treating despicably.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,021 ✭✭✭✭anewme


    Not Me wrote: »
    Right now I am in a bad phase. She walks in, I walk out. She looks at me, I look away. I have moved into the downstairs room over a year ago, at the time I told her I will not continue with this grotesque Ernie and Bert relationship. I now spend most of my time in my room, I avoid her whenever possible. We have tried to patch this up and everything works great, we go away on weekend breaks, we have fun, we get on, we do things, I put in an effort and then she says "I'm tired, I just want to go to sleep". So afterwards back to my room I go and back to ignoring her.
    I can feel the bitterness and resentment as physical sensations, it feels like my body is being poisoned.<SNIP>

    It is clear from this post there is nothing left but spite and malice. Even without the sex, you have nothing in common. You don't even like this person nor she you.

    You say you go to the beach with her (grrr) and the dogs (yay) and that she is driving you bonkers looking up weird stuff about Aliens. And getting satisfaction from seeing her flip. Why do you even want to attempt to have sex with this person you clearly have disdain for.?

    You have no children, nothing to hold you to this person. The posters who who said get your own life back are right. Go to the gym, hill walking, get out of the house, take the dogs out more by yourself. When you start working on yourself, then you will see yourself as a person of value, you are too caught up in it at the moment and can't see the wood for the trees.

    Oh and one thing I don't like from some posts here, is to have an affair. Please don't bring another person into it and use them to make yourself feel better. A friend of mine got caught up with a married guy who was separating. They fell madly in love and were together two years. He pursued her relentlessly, soul mates, his second chance etc. Despite the fact he said solicitors etc were involved, suddenly she was dumped when the wife wanted to try again. She was heartbroken.

    The only one who can change this is you.

    I was in a situation where my partner and I had reached the same situation as you. Lovely house, beautiful couple, but together too young and had grown apart. The sex dried up (on my part) because the relationship was dead. Both of us could have written your post above about the other. One day everything spilled over into violence and I knew there would be a tragedy. So I left the house with 10 pounds to my name and a dog on a lead and started again. We were not married, but engaged which carried the same rights in law.

    You are slowly dying inside living that meagre existence. Get out to preserve your own and your wife's sanity.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,269 ✭✭✭✭Sleepy


    OP, go see a solicitor and tell her to leave your house. You've not mentioned any kids so the worst that can happen you is that she'll get half of whatever equity is in the house after the mortgage is cleared, (possibly) the dogs and some level of alimony (which a decent solicitor will be able to help you minimise).

    As biased as the Irish Courts are against fathers, they're not going to leave you hand over a majority of your income to an ex-wife when there are no children involved. The worst case scenario is that you're left with a lower income but only yourself to support on it and the freedom to enjoy it again. Should she find some other poor gob****e prepared to marry her, the alimony would end and you'd be free and clear.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,030 ✭✭✭njs030


    Sleepy wrote: »
    OP, go see a solicitor and tell her to leave your house. You've not mentioned any kids so the worst that can happen you is that she'll get half of whatever equity is in the house after the mortgage is cleared, (possibly) the dogs and some level of alimony (which a decent solicitor will be able to help you minimise).

    As biased as the Irish Courts are against fathers, they're not going to leave you hand over a majority of your income to an ex-wife when there are no children involved. The worst case scenario is that you're left with a lower income but only yourself to support on it and the freedom to enjoy it again. Should she find some other poor gob****e prepared to marry her, the alimony would end and you'd be free and clear.

    Op does have children, the other poster doesn't. I don't know who we are advising anymore and everyone seem to be just as confused!!


  • Advertisement
Advertisement