MSU Election thread Read post 72 before posting

Nision · 08-01-2011 5:56pm #1

Too soon?

Nah!

So i hear there will be four sabbats instead of three with the new constitution.

I presume the meaningless/useless exec spots will be done away with.
Eg. Finance.
(Hows that Carbon Neutral SU coming along Declan :P)

So any Rumours/Facts?
Who's running for what?

Nision · 08-01-2011 5:58pm

I love elections more than any other sport! And this is the election equivalent of a world cup year.

Liber8or · 08-01-2011 7:16pm

Anyone willing to take the bet the following changes will be adopted by SU rep candidates?

ATM in the South Campus.
Extended library hours.
Better food services.
And my favourite: campaigning to reduce Student fees.

Same manifestos, year-in, year-out. Just different faces, all trying to 'correct' or 'out-perform' last year's reps.

LeixlipRed · 08-01-2011 7:34pm

I imagine we'll see the Nitelink back too.

banquo · 08-01-2011 7:37pm

You'll never get an ATM on south campus. Not a hope.

A second one on North Campus, I think, *is* possible. Not promising anything though.

Aldebaran · 08-01-2011 7:42pm

I really hope there's a ban on chalk this year.

LeixlipRed · 08-01-2011 7:43pm

Well that wouldn't really be much use considering the campus is pretty small and I've never seen more than 5 people lining up to use it in my 7 and a half years here.

BuroniKiisu · 08-01-2011 7:51pm

Aldebaran wrote: »

I really hope there's a ban on chalk this year.

It was banned for the First Year Representative elections, so almost definitely.

squishykins · 08-01-2011 7:57pm

If they have a beatboxing leprechaun, they'll have my vote. =D

cian1500ww · 08-01-2011 7:57pm

Vending machines in the callan building would be nice

Nision · 08-01-2011 8:13pm

The food thing will be sorted when chill opens,

I'd imagine with the GE in the same month people will be thinking nationally.

Seren_ · 08-01-2011 8:33pm

What's the fourth sabbat's role going to be? I'm thinking possibly Clubs and Socs officer?

Hopefully this year's elections will be as interesting as last year's

Duddy · 08-01-2011 9:07pm

OOOOOOOOH EXCITED.

AdmaialNimitz · 08-01-2011 10:54pm

Your Text Here wrote: »

What's the fourth sabbat's role going to be? I'm thinking possibly Clubs and Socs officer?

Thinking of running of this one actually!

LeixlipRed · 08-01-2011 11:53pm

Are you prepared to sell out? Best do it now, we'll give you more credit for it

banquo · 09-01-2011 3:19pm

LeixlipRed wrote: »

Are you prepared to sell out? Best do it now, we'll give you more credit for it

I'd actually like to know what you mean by this. I work with two full-time people who give far, far more than their job description requires.

I have no intentions in USI. My CV was pretty good coming into this job, it didn't need this extra line on it. I'd like to know exactly how I've 'sold out' if you're going to make that claim. You want a comparison of what I've done and tried to do compared to how things have been done in previous years? Or make a statement about my work ethic while in this job? That's a fight you wanna pick? Really?

Tell you what. We'll swap places for a while. On top of the normal working week + the massives of extra time that all the sabbats (and the exec, in fairness) put in, put in a 60-hour shift every third weekend, because (with Keith Broni's invaluable help) that is the *only* way that one aspect of my job, the paper, is gonna get done in the present circumstances.

So I'd like some specifics if you're going to say that I've sold out. And that goes for Liz too, who I've seen to really, *really* go above and beyond the call of duty this year for no reason other than her commitment to helping the people she works for. I'll stand up for Liz to the ends of the earth because I work 3 feet from her office and I see the hours and labour she puts in. So if you're going to criticise that I'd like some specifics. "If that's ok."

declan06 · 09-01-2011 10:08pm

Nision wrote: »

(Hows that Carbon Neutral SU coming along Declan :P)

Well, we're working on it at the moment, the Union has a very small carbon footprint so I'm quit optimistic. The university has implemented a traffic management plan which is reducing the number of cars with car pooling/cycling etc. They also put recycle bins everywhere, so it's actually coming along quite well.

We has the first meeting of the green working group, and the next meeting will be held in February, which is open to everyone to attend.

Norrdeth · 09-01-2011 10:41pm

declan06 wrote: »

They also put recycle bins everywhere, so it's actually coming along quite well.

Love those bins! So handy, once I saw one of my lecturers coming out after class and throwing their class notes straight in. They were like some sort of super recycling hero or something!

LeixlipRed · 09-01-2011 11:30pm

That's a general statement about all wannabe politicians Rob. Relax.

the_observer · 09-01-2011 11:40pm

Busy season. Oh boy. I'm gonna miss sleep and fun.

PrivateEye · 10-01-2011 1:59am

Something I've seen done by NCAD SU and really like is the idea of mass-meetings, and frequent ones at that. Union Council only really brings out a small grouping, and a certain type of folk at that (Politicos like myself, could name 70% of them) and there is little engagement with the average student. Frequent assemblies, called monthly in a large lecture hall, would allow students to discuss issues in a democratic manner with the union. They're just about that, discussion. That kinda engagement is important, and other campuses have shown it is possible. I see NCAD sometimes do them outdoors too, for example recent assemblies on fighting fees.

Also, if anyone promises they'll build a canteen/ build anything at all actually/ get cheaper booze/ dance naked if the win etc. then I hate them.

the_observer · 10-01-2011 3:43am

PrivateEye wrote: »

Something I've seen done by NCAD SU and really like is the idea of mass-meetings, and frequent ones at that. Union Council only really brings out a small grouping, and a certain type of folk at that (Politicos like myself, could name 70% of them) and there is little engagement with the average student. Frequent assemblies, called monthly in a large lecture hall, would allow students to discuss issues in a democratic manner with the union. They're just about that, discussion. That kinda engagement is important, and other campuses have shown it is possible. I see NCAD sometimes do them outdoors too, for example recent assemblies on fighting fees.

Yeah, I like that idea a lot. I know that not a huge proportion of students actually care about this kind of thing, but maybe this kind of effort to invite them to a very public and open forum might do something.

declan06 · 10-01-2011 1:18pm

PrivateEye wrote: »

Something I've seen done by NCAD SU and really like is the idea of mass-meetings, and frequent ones at that. Union Council only really brings out a small grouping, and a certain type of folk at that (Politicos like myself, could name 70% of them) and there is little engagement with the average student. Frequent assemblies, called monthly in a large lecture hall, would allow students to discuss issues in a democratic manner with the union. They're just about that, discussion. That kinda engagement is important, and other campuses have shown it is possible. I see NCAD sometimes do them outdoors too, for example recent assemblies on fighting fees.

Interesting idea, anyone is entitled to attend UC, but most people wouldn't find it interesting. We can hold a UGM, but I don't think it happened recently. It's something we should look into.

PrivateEye · 10-01-2011 8:15pm

Yeah, I like that idea a lot. I know that not a huge proportion of students actually care about this kind of thing, but maybe this kind of effort to invite them to a very public and open forum might do something.

Yep.

It's working in other colleges, no reason it wouldn't work here. As I said such assemblies would have no voting powers as such, but would no doubt result in greater engagement between the rank and file student body and the SU, not to mention increased debate and discussion among students. Participation and debate has to mean more than an annual vote.

If twenty people show up each month, it's worth doing.

anyone is entitled to attend UC, but most people wouldn't find it interesting

I think posters and an All Students Email for a monthly assembly or 'open meeting to discuss _________' as the need arises would bring interested students out. It would give an idea of feelings on the ground too, on a variety of issues. Around the car parking issues recently for example.

NUIMRO · 10-01-2011 8:34pm

I'll have a natter about it when we start back:)

leopoldbloom · 11-01-2011 1:37am

PrivateEye wrote: »

Yep.
I think posters and an All Students Email for a monthly assembly or 'open meeting to discuss _________' as the need arises would bring interested students out. It would give an idea of feelings on the ground too, on a variety of issues. Around the car parking issues recently for example.

Interesting point, but would this not make Union Council redundant? And purely theoretically would you like to follow the UK model whereby there is no UC, but merely a series of broad public consultations?

UK Sabbats spend approx 70% of their time in mass consultation with students. They do, however have massive staffs in their SUs and the inevitable (and in my experience justified) accusation is that the elected officers have even less power to reform the SUs themselves than in the Irish model. Furthermore, the massive SU staffs make it all the more likely that inconvenient non-SU policies will be be allowed to simply drag on until they expire.

I agree in principle with the main points above, but MSU's president (I have some experience here) is a member of some 30 committees which are all vitally important to ensure the student voice is heard. How could a three-person sabbat team balance time to ensure representative duties are fulfilled while also working to build up attendance at these student assemblies?

More importantly how could anyone ensure these assemblies aren't monopolised by single-interest groups. I have always taken my duties as a representative of every student very seriously, not just those that agree with my personal beliefs.

Ataxia · 11-01-2011 1:55am

leopoldbloom wrote: »

Interesting point, but would this not make Union Council redundant? And purely theoretically would you like to follow the UK model whereby there is no UC, but merely a series of broad public consultations?

Regular Union General Meetings would certainly make UC redundant, and allow greater participation by interested students in the running of their union. All Donal is talking about is regular meeting for discussion/debate that help inform SU policy etc.

Personally I'd be in favour of the former, but would settle for the latter as a decent compromise if needs be.

UK Sabbats spend approx 70% of their time in mass consultation with students. They do, however have massive staffs in their SUs and the inevitable (and in my experience justified) accusation is that the elected officers have even less power to reform the SUs themselves than in the Irish model. Furthermore, the massive SU staffs make it all the more likely that inconvenient non-SU policies will be be allowed to simply drag on until they expire.

Irish Sabbats spend virtually no time in mass consultation with students. I think we should err on the side of greater participation/consultation.

I agree in principle with the main points above, but MSU's president (I have some experience here) is a member of some 30 committees which are all vitally important to ensure the student voice is heard. How could a three-person sabbat team balance time to ensure representative duties are fulfilled while also working to build up attendance at these student assemblies?

I don't understand this argument. You send out an all student email and put up a few posters (like you do for class rep elections, union council, c&s council etc.). Not a huge extra workload, relative to the gain in direct democratic participation.

More importantly how could anyone ensure these assemblies aren't monopolised by single-interest groups. I have always taken my duties as a representative of every student very seriously, not just those that agree with my personal beliefs.

Every student gets a voice. A student's voice is no more or less legitimate because they're part of a political group. This isn't an issue.

In general, I think its quite clear that under the present class rep system there is no real engagement between the SU and the student body. Class reps are almost always already highly politicised people who often use their class rep position to push their own personal views, with little consultation with their classes. Not to mention the fact that there are a lot of students with no rep whatsoever.

I've heard numerous Exec members complaining that students have no loyalty to their SU bar and no real sense that the union has anything to do with them. Student assemblies offer the chance for genuine involvement in their union, in a way that rebranding the bar as 'Your Clubhouse', and similar efforts, never will.

manna · 12-01-2011 12:53am

Ah elections! I'm ready for people to start trying to buy me with empty promises...

Ataxia · 16-01-2011 6:40am

Should this be a sticky?

PrivateEye · 16-01-2011 7:31pm

Should this be a sticky?

No way I'm electing a sticky!
Political joke of the day there....

As for the elections, it'd be super if people could promise not to do this kind of lame CV bandwagoning. Incredibly, it looks like USI won't even fill the position.

"Cónán Ó Broin has resigned from his position as Vice-President in the USI. The organisation is unlikely to hold a by-election to fill the vacancy - O Brion's responsibilities will be distributed amongst current staff. It is believed he decided to resign from the post in favour ...of a position on the Labour party's General Election campaign team."

funky penguin · 16-01-2011 7:35pm

Ataxia wrote: »

Should this be a sticky?

No real need, it'll be busy enough over february.

Plus most people tend to ignore stickies.

declan06 · 16-01-2011 7:43pm

PrivateEye wrote: »

No way I'm electing a sticky!
Political joke of the day there....

As for the elections, it'd be super if people could promise not to do this kind of lame CV bandwagoning. Incredibly, it looks like USI won't even fill the position.

"Cónán Ó Broin has resigned from his position as Vice-President in the USI. The organisation is unlikely to hold a by-election to fill the vacancy - O Brion's responsibilities will be distributed amongst current staff. It is believed he decided to resign from the post in favour ...of a position on the Labour party's General Election campaign team."

Really?
Do you have a link to this?

PrivateEye · 16-01-2011 8:13pm

Really?
Do you have a link to this?

Several student newspapers saying it on Facebook, that comes from The College Tribune. Quite a bit of discussion online around it.

Tragic, as with recent USI statements, this guy deffo doesn't share the ethos of the party in the slightest. Labour should be a bit more selective me thinks, USI types and Mae Sexton are odd inclusions for a social democratic party.

Basically sitting on a student elected position until another wagon came along, disgrace. This kind of thing will be a factor in student elections now with political elections around the corner.

declan06 · 16-01-2011 9:14pm

PrivateEye wrote: »

Several student newspapers saying it on Facebook, that comes from The College Tribune. Quite a bit of discussion online around it.

Tragic, as with recent USI statements, this guy deffo doesn't share the ethos of the party in the slightest. Labour should be a bit more selective me thinks, USI types and Mae Sexton are odd inclusions for a social democratic party.

Basically sitting on a student elected position until another wagon came along, disgrace. This kind of thing will be a factor in student elections now with political elections around the corner.

It hasn't been confirmed, so I won't comment on this case

However I agree with the general point that if you run for something you serve the term unless there's a legitimate reason to step down.

And in terms of attacking Croke park it was voted on at national council, and the majority of Student Unions voted for it, MSU voted against it, and I think it's an awful idea.

BuroniKiisu · 17-01-2011 2:57pm

From Twitter (http://twitter.com/ConanOBroin):

"Just wanted to confirm that I have stepped down as Deputy President of USI and will be going to work for Cllr. Robert Dowds' election team."

funky penguin · 17-01-2011 3:09pm

Grand, sorted, lets talk about SU elections.

banquo · 17-01-2011 4:18pm

I AM NOT RUNNING FOR RE-ELECTION FOR VP COMMS.

Now stop asking me and get back to passing your exams!

funky penguin · 17-01-2011 4:37pm

RoB 4 PrEz!

manna · 17-01-2011 11:18pm

So, apart from Rob's, have any other names been thrown into the ring?

Duddy · 18-01-2011 1:31am

Haven't heard any yet... Rob rerunning might intimidate any other vp comms candidates.

:pac:

Seren_ · 18-01-2011 9:43am

Is there a definitive date for the election yet?

AdmaialNimitz · 18-01-2011 3:56pm

Its odd that my pedanticness has started after the exams...but shouldnt the Thread title be MSU elections?? Schmick'll be getting angry!!

manna · 18-01-2011 6:17pm

Facebook tells me that both Declan and Kyle from the current exec are considering running...

PrivateEye · 18-01-2011 11:42pm

I expect lots of people to run. All motivated by ideals.

irish_goat · 19-01-2011 11:54am

manna wrote: »

Facebook tells me that both Declan and Kyle from the current exec are considering running...

Shock, gasp, horror.

banquo · 19-01-2011 4:49pm

I love how this thread has 1,581 views but only 44 posts. Clearly a few ambitious folk checking back constantly.

:pac:

the_observer · 21-01-2011 10:33pm

banquo wrote: »

I love how this thread has 1,581 views but only 44 posts. Clearly a few ambitious folk checking back constantly.

:pac:

Also me and my trusty F5 button

Nision · 22-01-2011 9:18pm

Ok,
So Fiach has said he will run for VP Welfare and Cathal Og has certainly expressed interest (Strongly). Not sure if he has 100% committed yet but if his sudden HUGE interest in posting welfare related links on Facebook is anything to go by he's cramming hard on the subject.

Both strong candidates but if i'm honest i think Fiach would easily beat Cathal.

Anybody else heard any names being thrown around for this?

I know of two others sniffing around for it but wont name them just yet.

banquo · 22-01-2011 11:02pm

I'm only aware of one other for Welfare?

So I know one for welfare, two for comms, one for what's being referred to as 'clubs and stuff' and three for prez. But I can't really talk about them because I'm obliged to be impartial / can't gossip.

Shame!

manna · 22-01-2011 11:06pm

Damn! I only know one for comms, and haven't heard any for pres yet...

oh Rob, you big tease!

Nision · 23-01-2011 12:23am

Ive heard of two for Clubs, one definiteish.
Another possibly.

MSU Election thread ***Read post 72 before posting***

Comments

MSU Election thread Read post 72 before posting