smiley_face wrote: » Doubt Fitz will make the squad so wouldn't waste a match with him at 12.
freyners wrote: » Murray kinsella is reporting a henshaw Fitz midfield with White possibly starting
ionadnapokot wrote: » Nailed on to get into the squad now that he is declared fit. If thats the team it looks 5 others are fighting it out for 3 spots. Guessing JS order at the moment is: 1. Fitz 2. Earls 3. Zebo 4. Kearney 5. McFadden
irishbucsfan wrote: » I'd be absolutely shocked if Earls doesn't make the squad, he's probably the most talented out of all the guys in competition there. I'd be similarly shocked about Fitzgerald, the only justification for him not travelling would be fitness questions. I'd imagine both are on the plane.
freyners wrote: » Thornley is after releasing a team similar to kinsella. Will be interesting to see how close it actually is
total former wrote: » Also says Trimble will be released to play for Ulster.
phog wrote: » How many caps has Earls under Joe? I think it's only two, he like Fitz and Trimble to a lesser degree was injured for most of games that Joe was manager. I doubt Earls has enough caps to be tried in the positions you mention.
smiley_face wrote: » Zebo is clearly the better 11
molloyjh wrote: » Well that's just nonsense. He's clearly better in certain areas and Fitz is clearly better in others. Depending on what you want from a winger you could pick one or the other. I'd put money on Fitz travelling if he's fit. And I don't gamble.
connachta wrote: » With Zebo, Fitz, Bowe, Earls in contention, would anybody here imagine to drop Trimble?
molloyjh wrote: » And I don't gamble.
vienne86 wrote: » He was certainly talked up by Kiss this week - I would be expecting him to play some part on Saturday, regardless of what Thornley says.
total former wrote: » It's not impossible. Dave K is in the mix too. Lots of quality for limited spaces. I don't think Trimble is a definite by any means.
Deleted User wrote: » Too mainstream?
connachta wrote: » IMO Trimble Jones Gilroy D Kearney out, Zebo Fitz Earls Bowe in Sorry, you saw it with Marmion/Boss debate, but I favour beautiful rugby:D
Witheringeye wrote: » That still doesn't make anything I said not true
aimee1 wrote: » If thornley is right about saturdays team with earls (14) and DK (11) thats bad news for trimble and possibly felix jones.
vienne86 wrote: » Thornely saying Fitz will be in the centre - didn't see that coming. He is certainly in the mix for making the cut, and like others, I would be shocked if Earls isn't included as well.
Witheringeye wrote: » All kiss really said was that he was available for selection
total former wrote: » Well, assuming Bowe and Rob K are certainties, that leaves four spots to fill for outside backs. If Earls and Fitz can show they can cover wing and centre, that puts them top of the pile. That leaves two from Trimble/Zebo/D Kearney/Jones/McFadden. If McFadden and Jones aren't named today, they're gone IMO. That means two from the remaining three. If Zebo is the back-up FB, then he goes and it's a straight shoot-out between Kearney and Trimble. I'd say that's 50-50.
molloyjh wrote: » Did he not say he'll definitely play? I'm fairly sure he did, but my memory isn't the most reliable....