Millicent wrote: » But why do you feel the need to comment on your friends' appearances? Genuine question. I've never felt the need to do so outside of telling a friend that they look well on a night out or something.
LexieOnRale wrote: » Oh the irony in that post! you give great advice in the first sentence and then come along and crap all over your own advice in the next sentence. God I love boards!
LexieOnRale wrote: » Why? When she turns around and tells me not to stand under the heater in the beer garden incase I go up in flames from all the hairspray in my hair, I can laugh at that because its funny. But it's still commenting on my appearance. You must have weird friends when you can't give your honest opinion on their appearance
Links234 wrote: » Just to give the benefit of doubt, sometimes friends take the piss, or say something that could be mistaken as cruel if you didn't understand the context between friends. Hell, sometimes some friends have said horrid things about shoes I was wearing. That might not be the case, but you can't always tell.
SparkySpitfire wrote: » Why do you feel the need not to? Do you have to explain every thing you do? Every impulse, every feeling?
Millicent wrote: » You're asking me why I feel the need not to comment on my friends' appearances? Seriously?
cantdecide wrote: » I have found this to be a façade or even a defence mechanism in some. Others just simply lack personality and mimic an older female influence. I've seen a domineering parent figure being at least in part responsible- some parents just want their kids to be clones of themselves.
Candie wrote: » I think this is more like it. Maybe not a lack of personality, but some people are really impressionable and absorb their parents mannerisms and values to a greater extent than most people would. They tend to be really traditional.
LikeClockwork wrote: » So, because she dresses differently, doesn't listen to the same music as you and doesn't get pissed every weekend you take the piss out of her and laugh at her facebook pictures? Christ I weep for humanity sometimes.
SparkySpitfire wrote: » If you can't grasp the concept that some people think differently to you - you are beyond help.
LexieOnRale wrote: » Different reasons. If I felt my friends looked lovely, I'd tell them I thought they looked unreal. If I feel that they don't look good, I'd tell them too, because I wouldn't like them to go out looking crap and having other people laugh at them. I guess the same reason I'd tell someone if they had lipstick on their teeth or if they looked like a poodle after they got too frisky with a curling wand. If I saw a friend of mine wear a pair of Birkenstocks into a nightclub (just an example) you're damn right I'd say ah here jaysus where are ya going with those? And believe it or not, I value friends opinions on my appearance too. "Is my eyemakeup too much?" "Does the blazer look **** with the dress" "which lipstick would look nicer?" And I would certainly hope they'd tell me if I needed to change something. It's different when it's personal preference sure, "your hair is too big" but I like it too big. "Your shoes look like shyte" but they're comfortable. If they're the type of people to go off crying because they're such delicate little flowers then its safe to say we would not be friends
catallus wrote: » "I've always found myself censoring the swear words and adapting a more innocent, slightly more 'country' tone while engaging in conversation with her, as if I was talking to an old-fashioned aunt or grandparents of a friend or something. Even though I'd be talking to a nineteen year old, several years younger than me. " Why is this? Because she's projecting a certain image you calibrate your own behaviour? Do you do this with everyone? I think the answer is no. A few previous posters have brought up the valid point that she may be imprinted with such behaviour from a young age; the question is why do you think it is "middle aged"; I'm not being facetious here when I suggest that your natural disdain for her behaviour/personality may be a sub-conscious reaction to your own insecurities (in the best possible way) about maturing/growing older?
Cydoniac wrote: » What age are you? Genuine question.
catallus wrote: » "I've always found myself censoring the swear words and adapting a more innocent, slightly more 'country' tone while engaging in conversation with her, as if I was talking to an old-fashioned aunt or grandparents of a friend or something. Even though I'd be talking to a nineteen year old, several years younger than me. " Why is this? Because she's projecting a certain image you calibrate your own behaviour? Do you do this with everyone? I think the answer is no.
catallus wrote: » A few previous posters have brought up the valid point that she may be imprinted with such behaviour from a young age; the question is why do you think it is "middle aged"; I'm not being facetious here when I suggest that your natural disdain for her behaviour/personality may be a sub-conscious reaction to your own insecurities (in the best possible way) about maturing/growing older?
Millicent wrote: » No, I'm well aware that people think differently to me, apparently even being shallow enough to give two shits what their friends look like. But yep, I'm definitely beyond help and that's not dramatic at all.
SparkySpitfire wrote: » Curiously, I have a good friend who does this. If you've ever done that enneagram test, it's one of the personality types I think. Some people change their behaviour to gel with their present company and create a less tense environment or whatever. Not saying that's what's happening here but it can happen!
LexieOnRale wrote: » Old enough
catallus wrote: » Everyone does it, apart from sociopaths/psychopaths, but the point is why does beks feel the need to do it to such an extent with a younger person (which is an issue for her specifically).....
SparkySpitfire wrote: » Now you're the one being judgmental after calling someone out on being judgmental... And since you know enough about the group dynamic to judge how comments on appearances are taken and exchanged, I commend your psychic ability. Cos I sure as hell don't, they could be hurtful exchanges, but they could be banter, but I'm not gonna decide which because I'm not in the group.
beks101 wrote: » Interesting. This was what I was getting at - is there something psychological, or some kind of social conditioning at play, that influences this sort of seeming mimicry of an older generation among someone so young? Not - OMG LOLZ LOSER WEARS BIRKENSTOCK SHOES WAT A FREAK LOL WTF, as some people seem to have interpreted it. I've got an array of weird and wacky personalities among my group of friends, varied opinions and tastes, quirky hairstyles, fashion senses, taste in music and politics etc - but all of whom are at or around the same developmental stage in terms of life experience and how they relate to others. I think choosing to dismiss this as "herd mentality" is to cut short a potentially interesting conversation about what influences our personalities and how we come to be the way we are, as per the above posts.
Candie wrote: » I'm starting to get upset because I have Birkenstocks :P