Foxtrol wrote: » Though I agree with the majority of your post I have to disagree with you on the time travel part.
budgemook wrote: » Washed him up a big wall about 30 feet high?
budgemook wrote: » Between different times, no problem. Between being alive and dead?
blandatious wrote: » A query: Claire's baby (aaron) i think was in the church at the end. This would mean Aaron died as a baby i think. During the time when Kate returned to the US Aaron had become a young boy. I think we are working on the theory that they did actually leave the island and return and only the FST scenes did not actually occur. A lot of "i think"'s there but has anyone any opinion on this? Is there an explanation i am overlooking?
Josey Wales wrote: » I'm still confused by the ending. I assume that none of the events shown in seasons 1 - 6 actually happened. It was all just in Jacks imagination as he lay dying after the plane crash. There were no other survivors as they showed the crash site during the credits and there was no people around. Therefore nobody survived the crash.
blandatious wrote: » sorry for reposting but it's bugging me and will get swept away with all the posts. I cant resolve the above in my head
prinz wrote: » There was more than one way in. MIB's body washed out too. In one side, out another.
prinz wrote: » It takes imagination.
mewso wrote: » Wow amazing how different people are. Comparing it to Harry Potter or Star Wars as someone else did is so way off the mark it's unbelievable. Comparing it to wanting a history of Baltimore to enjoy the Wire is even worse.
A Neurotic wrote: » All this craic of Ben and Ana-Lucia and Eloise and Faraday not being ready to move on "yet" is completely at odds with the concept of purgatory/FST being timeless.
Creasy_bear wrote: » Can someone answer this for me .......... Sawyer and the others left on the plane in the end .............did they actually get off the island ? Then Jack dies .........how come everyone was ready to move on at the exact same time re - when Jack is ready
lmaopml wrote: » I think it might be a mistake to call it purgatory? Another poster mentioned a few pages back that the room Jacks fathers coffin was in had various religious symbols in it......It just seems to be a 'middle place' where people either sort out things they obviously regret doing in some instances, and in other instances things they actually never got the chance to do... Have to laugh at Jacks Da's name though, that never struck me before Kate mentioned, 'Your kidding, Christian Sheppard' Little ramble.... In the long run perhaps the Island and it's powers of life, death and re-birth etc. made it possible for them to make the connection again with eachother in the 'middle state' through Desmond as a way of thanking them for the time they had already spent there in order to fulfill Jacobs wish of protecting the Island....Perhaps they got a special 'get out of the middle state early' card once they all died to move on together.... I don't think the middle state was about atonement, I think it was moreso about tying up lose ends...However for Ben who was left behind it was more about 'atonement' because he was aware of his previous life. End of ramble:) and I'd just like to add, I kinda liked Jack boring and all as he was at times, he played the part well........Hurley was a firm favorite of mine though..and I loved Ben too...
jimbling wrote: » I wasn't stuck on David at all. I was just using it to point out that Anthony Cooper didnt matter either. Neither were real. I thought Lockes absolute statement of that was pretty convincing on the matter. But I have been wrong before
jimbling wrote: » I don't think so. The "Purgatory" as we are calling it was created by all the people for whom the island was of ultimate importance. Lockes dad is not really there, he's just filler for Lockes "Purgatory". EDIT: Jack doesn't even have a son!!!!
seadnamac wrote: » Christian says to Jack; "They're all real, everything that ever happened to you is real" How does this tie into what we saw in purgatory? He goes to see his son play piano, he operates on Locke, he flies on a plane, he does everyday mundane stuff. So is Jack to believe that this was all real, even though the consensus is that he was dead? Christian didn't make a distinction between the on island stuff and the FST stuff when he said it was all real. This is the line being used to generally to support the consensus that the island life was real and the FST was purgatory (I'm not neccessarily disagreeing by the way, before someone gets their knickers in a twist), but if everything that happened after Jack was dead was just as real as everything that happened before then, then the line between the two becomes a bit less clear in my opinion.
foxerv1 wrote: » Did anyone catch the segment on the News on RTE2 about it?
Creasy_bear wrote: » I don't get this
Mitch Connor wrote: » No. the age you see people in the FST is not an intimation of when they died. Again, Christian says this - Some died before you, Some died long after you. There is no 'now' here. Time, and the perception of people, is not important in Purgatory.
lmaopml wrote: » I think it might be a mistake to call it purgatory?
CKWPORT wrote: » What they say about it?
When they finally died their “spirits” joined the others who had died before during the course of the series, they were in this type of “purgatory” which in season 6 was the ALT reality.