Sweet Science wrote: A MMA fighter wouldnt have once punch KO power with boxing gloves on .
Sweet Science wrote: I know where you are coming from . Once a boxer connects flush with a 4oz glove the fight is over.
walshb wrote: Not even the force of the shot, but the chances of scoring it effectively to get the KO. Boxers specialize in punching/hand striking. Yes, MMA offers differences in how that is implemented, but I still feel that a trained boxer has the better chance to score it in the octagon than the MMA fighter has to score it in the ring...
Brief_Lives wrote: as someone said in the thread previously, it could be the ruining of the UFC (I know, I know, boxing rules)...
vapor trails wrote: » The only reason why I mention this is because everyone is saying what a fighter Floyd is. Possibly the best of all time. What I'm backing here is age. I'm just turning 34 now, I feel old as ****. McGregor is 6 years younger than me and Floyd is 6 years older. If you dissect this purely based on boxing repertoire the conversation will only lead to one conclusion. I want someone to dissect for me the impact of being 40 and getting old as opposed to 28 and coming into prime.
Brief_Lives wrote: » I can?t believe this fight is going ahead... what sort of cash must Conor be getting to take a beating? as someone said in the thread previously, it could be the ruining of the UFC (I know, I know, boxing rules)...
shamrock55 wrote: » Im 40 and feel as strong and fit as i was when i was 30, mayweather is a million times fitter and well maintained then me im sure his age wont be a factor the only thing would maybe it might effect his speed and reactions slightly,his power or stamina i dont think would be effected
Ultimate Seduction wrote: » How though. If Cristiano Ronaldo loses a game of golf to Rory McIlroy, would that be the ruining of soccer?
Je_suis_Jean wrote: » Yeah, because soccer and golf are so similar to MMA and boxing. The reason the FM fight is going ahead is because both codes are perceived as being sufficiently similar that competitors, with some focused training, can step from one code into the other and perform at a similar level to their "home" code so to speak. Same doesn't really apply to soccer and golf now does it?
Brief_Lives wrote: thats a fair enough comment, maybe I was running away with myself. But unlike golf and soccer, MMA and boxing are combat sports.
Je_suis_Jean wrote: Same doesn't really apply to soccer and golf now does it?
realdanbreen wrote: » You may well be feeling strong and fit but there simply is no way that a 41 year old retired boxer should beat a 29 year old professional McGreggor. it's really only a freak show that very few true sporting fans would have any interest in. No doubt a few plane loads of Ole Ole Ole merchants will make the trip.
Donald Trump wrote: » Mellor wrote: » But how it is degrading? You aren't explaining why, just repeating the same thing. It degrades the sport by turning it into a novelty or freakshow rather than necessarily degrading the participants as individuals. Although you could argue that it degrades Mayweather for taking it on in the first place. Let him come back and fight the current top ranked boxer at his weight.
Mellor wrote: » But how it is degrading? You aren't explaining why, just repeating the same thing.
Mellor wrote: I assume you didn't understand the question and are talking about it's impact on boxing - which is irrelevant to MMA
Ultimate Seduction wrote: » Right so, Soccer and GAA would be the best comparison. If a famous GAA player joined Man Utd and was ****, that would not be "the ruining" of GAA
Mellor wrote: » It degrades MMA by turning it into a freakshow? That makes no sense. I assume you didn't understand the question and are talking about it's impact on boxing - which is irrelevant to MMA
Puibo wrote: » I hope there is a lot of opinionated posters in this thread that will end up eating their words!!!
Brief_Lives wrote: » thats a fair enough comment, maybe I was running away with myself. But unlike golf and soccer, MMA and boxing are combat sports.
Mellor wrote: » People are using other sports to make a point. But you don't even need to change the sports. James Toney lost embarrassingly in MMA to a 46 year old, formerly retired, Randy Couture. By your logic, that was embarrassing for boxing, the end of the sport, etc. I find that opinion bizarre. Especially from a boxing fan.
yabadabado wrote: Care to explain ?