AR/tist in the spotlight, this week: Tunguska

pconn062 · 13-02-2015 12:25PM #1

So after a bit of a break we are resuming the series. Tunguska has kindly agreed to step up and bare his soul for us all! He will be taking questions for the next week or so so get thinking of anything you want to know about his running background/training.

I'll get us started:

Did you run as a junior?
You were known for your very high mileage training a few years ago, you seem to have changed from that now, can you tell us a little about that?
You have had your issues with injuries over the years, have you managed to get on top of these?
And a bit of fluff....cats or dogs?

Thanks!

walshb · 13-02-2015 12:34PM

Hi Tunguska,

PB over 5k?
Favorite pre race meal/food?
Favourite post race meal/food?
Favorite all time sports personality, and why?

Thanks

13-02-2015 01:21PM

Thoughts on Bressie on the cover of Irish Runner.

Okay, that's not serious

Krusty_Clown · 13-02-2015 01:40PM

Best all-time performance?
Lowest moment in your running history?
If you got a 'do-over' what would you do different?

As someone who has straddled both the 'high mileage/intensity/commitment' and 'less committed' approaches to running (no offence intended), which do you feel is healthier, in terms of mind and body? (think I know the answer to this one!).

Any regrets that you're no longer pushing yourself to the limit, in a running-specific context?

Between the yoga, healthy eating, and positive mental attitude, you've gone a bit California of late. Any guilty pleasures that don't fit in with the lifestyle?

ASIMON0V · 13-02-2015 01:47PM

At your most intense, your most committed - what did you feel you had the potential to run a marathon in?

Your training log, whilst shortlived was definitely one of the most memorable, would you consider running the gauntlet again with another one?

What other running / fitness websites do you visit / use?

christeb · 13-02-2015 01:54PM

great choice!

are you still on the maca (I love it, btw!)? any other weird or wonderful foods that you feel us mortals are missing out on?

what are your go to recipes for healthy, tasty recovery grub? any particular sites / books you recommend?

max weekly mileage logged?

do you see yourself running into your 50s, or will yoga or something else take over?

overpronator · 13-02-2015 02:22PM

Great to see this back and a great candidate.

What are your favourite races domestically and internationally?
Any bucket list races or times to achieve?
What are your favourite and least favourite things about this forum?
What in your opinion is a good indicator workout for marathon shape 4-5 weeks out, provided of course that all other boxes training wise have been ticked.
Favourite tipple?

Finally, cheers for volunteering to reignite this thread.

tunguska · 13-02-2015 02:55PM

pconn062 wrote: »

Did you run as a junior?

I played a lot of sports as a kid, football was my main one though. I was a member of Tallaght ac when I was a child but I couldn't make it work timewise, I was spread too thin and football took priority over anything else. But like I said I played a lot of everything, football, swimming, cycling, GAA, golf, rugger and Tae kwon do. And that was normal, all my friends played sports, its all we did from morning to night and summers even more so.

pconn062 wrote: »

You were known for your very high mileage training a few years ago, you seem to have changed from that now, can you tell us a little about that?

Yeah for me I have to go from one extreme to another in order to find the right balance for myself. When I did my first marathon I was very untrained, I was only running 2 or 3 days a week and the longest run I did was the race series half marathon. I blew up in grand style at around 22 miles and those last few miles were horrendous. I joined a club after that and did some proper training but at the same time I got talking to some of the lads who told me they ran 70 miles a week. This blew my mind as up til that point my weekly mileage was about 20 - 30 miles tops. So literally in the space of a week I went from 20 to 70 miles and then from 70 - 90 and then from 90- 110 or more. I got injured if course and blew myself out with over training so many times. So it was literally one extreme to the other. I learned the lesson eventually though and I became more efficient in what I do. I mean at this stage I'm more concerned with my health than anything else. Some of the **** I did was crazy, like I remember running the rathfarnham 5 k one morning, not feeling right at all, I crossed the finishing line and puked all over the road, thick black stuff at that. And all over some guys shoes who was trying to get me off the road. Now someone with sense would've gone home and lay down but instead I met with my training partner and ran 24 miles. Oh and I had done my Achilles in the 5k race aswell which meant running 24 miles feeling sick and hobbling on what turned out to be a torn Achilles tendon. That was the type of stuff I did all the time and it was silly. So now like I said im more efficient in what I do and im more concerned with my long term health than anything else.

pconn062 wrote: »

You have had your issues with injuries over the years, have you managed to get on top of these?

This is related a lot to what I said above......I got injured initially because I increased my mileage by over 100% in the space of a week and after that it was a catalogue of errors and bad decisions. I think if you're chasing Miles you'll make bad choices, concerning your health anyway. I got orthotics and everything but in the end I just went back to running in very flat shoes and making good decisions and this seemed to do the trick.

pconn062 wrote: »

And a bit of fluff....cats or dogs?

Thanks!

Dogs for sure. Cats......man they're just devious. A dog is always happy to see you no matter what but a cat would stroll over your dead body to go slaughter a blue jay or something like that. I haven't had a dog in years though, we had one when I was 8, he was my dog actually he was got for my birthday. He died 14 years later so he had a good innings but I was devastated, we all were so I haven't had the heart to get another one since.

Timmaay · 13-02-2015 03:07PM

You ran much middle distance? Pbs? Would ya go back to it?

tunguska · 13-02-2015 03:10PM

walshb wrote: »

Hi Tunguska,

PB over 5k?
Favorite pre race meal/food?
Favourite post race meal/food?
Favorite all time sports personality, and why?

Thanks

My PB for 5k is relatively soft, its 15:30 but I definitely felt I could go under 15 mins. That was 2 yrs ago and I actually got injured in that race but I was on a roll at the time and I reckon had I not got injured I would've gone sub 15.

Pre race I just eat granola bars or whatever, its not something I put a lot of thought into.
Post race I'd eat anything, so again its no big deal for me.

My sporting hero is David Purely and this is why.....

He's also my hero in life not just sport.

walshb · 13-02-2015 03:13PM

Soft at 15:30. If I could run that I'd retire from this forum..

Thanks for the replies.

TRR_the_turd · 13-02-2015 03:52PM

walshb wrote: »

Soft at 15:30. If I could run that I'd retire from this forum..

Thanks for the replies.

promise or a threat? We can give you some training guidance if it will help

walshb · 13-02-2015 04:48PM

TRR_the_turd wrote: »

promise or a threat? We can give you some training guidance if it will help

Threat of course.....

tunguska · 13-02-2015 05:48PM

Deleted User wrote: »

Thoughts on Bressie on the cover of Irish Runner.

Okay, that's not serious

Ok I'll bite.........the truth is I Dont care either way. I can see the argument that having someone on the cover who is recognisable will appeal to a broader audience and maybe get them interested in health and fitness. But I can also see the other side of things where people think the Irish runner has sold its soul to the masses in order to make a buck. I don't care enough to get worked up either way though, the only time I ever got pissed off over something like this was when Linda Byrne won the women's mini marathon and all the coverage was focused on that eejit Rosana what's her name. That to me was a joke, giving attention to someone like that over the actual winner of the race........pathetic.
By the way I've met Bressie and he's actually a sound bloke so I've no beef with him either way.

tunguska · 13-02-2015 06:39PM

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

Best all-time performance?

It was probably my first race ever. It was the great Ireland run(10k) and I was completely ignorant. I turned up and ran it like a lunatic. I tore off and was fooked after 5k, I got into a group and i spent the second 5k surging, then bring dropped, getting back in touch, surging ahead again, being reeled in, being dropped again. It was torture and I remember getting to 8k thinking I was gonna die. I held on though and when we got inside the last km I kicked like crazy and outsprinted all the others in the group. I was wearing my Liverpool fc jersey that day and all the other boys In that group were club runners wearing singlets so they were pretty disgusted to be beaten by some clown in a football jersey. It was just a pure out and out race, no Garmin, no clue about pacing, no tactics, just ignorance and the will to hang on. It was perfect.

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

Lowest moment in your running history?

I think the marathon in 2011 was the worst experience I had. I was in great shape that year, me and Phil had really worked hard but 10 days before the race I did my calve on the track, in what was the last rep of the last speed session before the marathon. It was really bad luck, but I got to the start line having not run for 10 days, Hoping the calve would hold up. It did in a way, but I was favoring it and running ass ways and what happened was my hamstring went as a consequence of the altered gait. Had to drop out at hallway and that evening in the boozer surrounded by all the happy people delighted with their races was a low point because for all the work I'd put in it seemed like I got a kick in the balls in return.

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

If you got a 'do-over' what would you do different?

I'm not joking when I say this but I'd become a downhill skier. That and then ski cross.

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

As someone who has straddled both the 'high mileage/intensity/commitment' and 'less committed' approaches to running (no offence intended), which do you feel is healthier, in terms of mind and body? (think I know the answer to this one!).

Gary I think you know what I'm gonna say........to be a healthy person overall, the less obsessed, less committed approach is the way to go, in my opinion anyway.
I'm doing a lot less these days and I can honestly say I'm a lot happier(a lot heavier as well). I just got to the point where I realised in order to go to the next level it was gonna take up even more of my life and it just wasn't worth it, so I made a conscious decision to step away and go live my life a bit more.

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

Any regrets that you're no longer pushing yourself to the limit, in a running-specific context?

A little bit yeah. I mean I'm registered for Berlin in September and there's a part of me that really wants to give it a good whack and go sub 2:30. And that doesn't sound unreasonable, what's one more training cycle?
But whatever is going on with me and my life, one more training Cycle isn't an option. I have some things I need to do and it has to be now, not in a few months or a year or whenever. I can't explain it any better than that, there's just this sense that its time to move on and leave the athletics behind (for now anyway).

Krusty_Clown wrote: »

Between the yoga, healthy eating, and positive mental attitude, you've gone a bit California of late. Any guilty pleasures that don't fit in with the lifestyle?

I've actually always been like that, so its nothing new really. I've always been a bit if a hippy(had long hair and everything) but I try not to turn into one of those new age bores. That's the last thing I want because I hate those guys. I do love yoga and I do meditate, I listen to pink Floyd and I smoked enough dope in my time to probably get myself arrested or at the very least put on some kind of register. So I dunno what all that makes me........guilty pleasures??? Hmmmm I Dont drink and I Dont smoke (not even grass anymore) so there leaves just one thing which I probably shouldn't say on here as it might get me banned.

Dubgal72 · 13-02-2015 07:31PM

Hi, what advice would you give to a juvenile contemplating a career in running?

What's your current average weekly mileage?

Favourite race?

Ps club or solo?

Thanks

Ososlo · 13-02-2015 08:18PM

Great choice and fantastic questions so far with some very insightful and intriguing answers! Can't believe you haven't been "done" already!

Favourite Olympic athletic moment of all time?
Where did your name come from?
What will Mrs. Tunguska get for Valentine's Day?

Favourite Irish athlete of all time?
What do you put your maca powder on/in?

KielyUnusual · 13-02-2015 08:35PM

Ososlo wrote: »

Where did your name come from?

Coincidentally, I was watching a documentary on Asteroids on the BBC last night. Normally I'm out doing much cooler stuff of course. I think the name might have its origins somewhere in an asteroid that decelerated so quickly on entering the Earth's atmosphere that it exploded before impacting the ground and knocked down about a million trees.

The more interesting question might be why he chose that name but then naming himself after an object that went so fast that it spontaneously combusted seems quite apt :P. But hey, it left its mark.

gerard_65 · 13-02-2015 09:42PM

Did you ever drink alcohol?
Favorite food?
What makes you laugh out load?
Apart from Ireland what country would you live in if you had a choice?
Favorite sport (apart from athletics if that is)?
Beach or active holiday?

overpronator · 13-02-2015 09:47PM

Favourite Pink Floyd album?
Watters or Gilmour?

tunguska · 13-02-2015 11:05PM

ASIMON0V wrote: »

At your most intense, your most committed - what did you feel you had the potential to run a marathon in?

Hi Simon
If I had kept going, and been able to string together back to back training plans, uninjured........ I think I could've run under 2:20 at the very least. I did entertain thoughts of Rio at one stage but I got to a point where everything was clear and I saw exactly what it would take to do that and more importantly, the sacrifices I'd need to make. And for me it just wasn't worth the physical toll but also the toll on my over all well being. I mean at my lightest I was 134lbs and I figured id need to be at least 130 to do it right. Now at 5ft 10 134lbs made me look very thin, so to go even thinner was something that didn't sit well with me so I had to make a choice there and then, did I really want to be that skinny? At 134lbs honestly I couldn't look at myself in the mirror, I was disgusted at my appearance, I looked sick, like I'd escaped from a concentration camp or like christian bale in The machinist. I was also getting bouts of light headiness and I'd get colds a lot more easily than ever. So to go down in weight even further was just something that I think would've been a bad decision. Right now I'm 153lbs which is nearly 20lbs heavier than my lightest, and honestly I feel great, everyone is telling me how healthy I look which is probably the death knell for my athletics career. Its the nature of the beast though, if you wanna do well you gotta be underweight.

ASIMON0V wrote: »

Your training log, whilst shortlived was definitely one of the most memorable, would you consider running the gauntlet again with another one?

That log was controversial alright. In fairness I should've been more open to input and less militant about things. And I was a bit of a drama queen the way I ended it.
I wouldn't start another just because there's not a lot of formal work being done at the moment. I'm running a bit, I'm doing lots of yoga, I'm cycling, playing 5 a side football, I'm even dancing. And I Dont think anyone wants read a log of what I do in dance class.

What other running / fitness websites do you visit / use?[/QUOTE]

Nothing really. I used to look at let's run but it all just becomes too argumentitive. I mean there was lads who'd argue with a signpost and I've no time for that crap, it just sucks the life outta you. I did join the runners support page which is, eh, entertaining.

Dubgal72 · 13-02-2015 11:14PM

tunguska wrote: »

And I Dont think anyone wants read a log of what I do in dance class.

Anyone want to start a poll?

tunguska · 13-02-2015 11:24PM

christeb wrote: »

great choice!

are you still on the maca (I love it, btw!)? any other weird or wonderful foods that you feel us mortals are missing out on?

Hey Briano
I do still use it and there are some interesting side effects. Put it this way, if everyone knew about maca then Viagra would be rendered redundant.
Man I take a lot of stuff but if there was one thing I'd recommend it would be chlorella (powder). Actually if I'd recommend one more thing it would that everyone read " No more heart disease " by Dr. Louis ignarro. Its the real deal, this guy won the Nobel prize for what's in that book and I'm amazed its kind of still a secret.

christeb wrote: »

what are your go to recipes for healthy, tasty recovery grub? any particular sites / books you recommend?

I eat very simple, like its stuff you could throw together in 5 mins. It'd as basic as vegetables + sweet potatoes + salmon(probably from a can). I really wanna take a course in healthy cooking, that's something I really need to do. Although I got derval o Rourke's book recently and that is exactly what I was looking for. Food you can cook where you Dont need a load of appliances or a degree in the culinary arts to produce.

christeb wrote: »

max weekly mileage logged?

150 miles. Don't ask me why........

christeb wrote: »

do you see yourself running into your 50s, or will yoga or something else take over?

No I definitely won't be running when I'm in my 50s(or even my 40s). I plan on taking up gymnastics during the summer and I can see myself really getting into that.

tunguska · 13-02-2015 11:59PM

overpronator wrote: »

Great to see this back and a great candidate.

What are your favourite races domestically and internationally?

Hey overpronator

My favorite race that I've done was ballycotton 10 mile. Amazing. Think raheny 5 mile x 1000. Honourable mentions though have got to go to the bohermeen 5k, which is a race I absolutely love. And the craughwell 10 mile because I have never been so well looked after at a race, it was just a great event. That post race spread was epic.....
There is one race that I'm absolutely obsessed by and its the Honolulu marathon. I love Hawaii and this is a race I just have to do, for the sheer enjoyment of it.

overpronator wrote: »

Any bucket list races or times to achieve?

Oops I think I might've answered that in the previous question by mistake.......with regards to times, right now that's all on hold and if I do a race its for the enjoyment of it. That doesn't mean I'd be sandbagging though. I love racing, Jesus I love that last mile where you're in bits but you get to go racing regardless...... No matter what speed I'm going at or where I am in the pecking order, I always race it out.

overpronator wrote: »

What are your favourite and least favourite things about this forum?

That's a good question....... What I like is that if you need to know something you can ask and someone somewhere on here will have an answer. I like discussing races, before and after. Its great to run a race and then to see what everyone else thought of it as well. So there is a good sense if community. I like how bull**** is called out as well. The runners support page is pretty ridiculous, I mean if there's even a hint if disagreement over there the entire thread is deleted and people are banned for voicing opinions that are contrary to the status quo. Its nuts really and not a healthy environment for growth or development.
What I Dont like is the us and them thing that can develop on here. There's no slower runners and there's no fast runners its just one thing overall. The petty arguments as well. Jesus, it goes round in circles and goes nowhere and its the same **** over and over. I Dont mind a good debate but its rare you'll get one, more often than not it descends into petty bickering and name calling and when that happens I just switch off. I don't like people with pet projects either, like a point they'll keep bringing up and dragging into unrelated topics all the time. That's really annoying.

overpronator wrote: »

What in your opinion is a good indicator workout for marathon shape 4-5 weeks out, provided of course that all other boxes training wise have been ticked.
Favourite tipple?

Finally, cheers for volunteering to reignite this thread.

There's a session I would do at that stage but it was unique and I'm not sure I'd recommend it. It was the kind of thing that worked for me but I'm not sure about anyone else. It was on the treadmill, I'd jack the incline up to 8% and do 4 x 20 minute intervals at 13.5 km/ hr with 3 mins recovery between. When I could do that I knew I was in good nick. But if I was coaching someone I'd say a marathon paced run of 13 miles with 3 easy, would do the job. I wouldn't go over 16 miles.

I Dont drink anymore but when I did it was jack Daniels, neat. I was partial to the odd white Russian aswell although that was only because it was The Dude's drink of choice.

tunguska · 14-02-2015 12:02AM

Timmaay wrote: »

You ran much middle distance? Pbs? Would ya go back to it?

No I never did anything under 5k so I'm afraid I haven't got much for you there Tim. I did enjoy the track though and I'd like to do the odd track race here and there.

tunguska · 14-02-2015 12:16AM

Dubgal72 wrote: »

Hi, what advice would you give to a juvenile contemplating a career in running?

Hi dubgal, thanks for letting me go ahead first by the way........if I was advising a juvenile about a sporting career I'd honestly tell them to do what their passionate about. Not what their parents want them to do, bit what their dad did but what they feel is the right thing g fir them. And often that's gonna take experimentation. Trying a lot of different sports, not just falling into one and doing that even though you don't really love it. I guess the bottom line is, try a lot of things before you put your stick into that one sport.

Dubgal72 wrote: »

What's your current average weekly mileage?

At the moment I'm only running every second or third day so its between 20 and 30 miles.....back to where I began.

Dubgal72 wrote: »

Favourite race?

Ballycotton for sure. Amazing experience.

Dubgal72 wrote: »

Ps club or solo?

Thanks

Club. Without a doubt club. Its the kind of thing I could talk about all night but when it comes right down to it you have to find out why for yourself. Put it this way, anyone I know who didn't want to join a club initially, but who then gave it a go invariably said the same thing: I wish I'd joined a club sooner.

tunguska · 14-02-2015 12:44AM

Ososlo wrote: »

Great choice and fantastic questions so far with some very insightful and intriguing answers! Can't believe you haven't been "done" already!

Favourite Olympic athletic moment of all time?

Cheers Aoife, getting "Done" sounds like fun, im up for that, so long as I Dont end up on (another) register.
Favorite Olympic moment was the 1968 200m final. Some people reckon its the greatest 200 in history and I can't argue with that. I watch that race at least 10 times a week, its just this magnificent spectacle and display of raw speed and courage. I know the two lads took centre stage but peter Norman ran an incredible race, he was a hero. And what came after that race is something special too. Love it, I choke up anytime I watch that clip of the three lads on the podium.
Domestically its gotta be john Treacys silver in LA in 1984. I was very young at the time but my mam allowed me and my brother to stay up and watch that race(it was on in the middle of the night over here). That was magic and I"ll never forget the moment he came racing into the Olympic stadium with charlie spedding chasing him down. Amazing night.

Ososlo wrote: »

Where did your name come from?

There was a meteor that crashed in Russia in the 1920s(I think). It was massively powerful and decimated vast stretches of forest land for miles. Only it wasn't a meteor, at least not according to eye witness testimony and conspiracy theorists. They reckon it was a UFO crash landing and the place it crashed was.......Tunguska.

Ososlo wrote: »

What will Mrs. Tunguska get for Valentine's Day?

Ha ha putting me on the spot, that's a devious and loaded question (as you well know). I will be taking Mrs Tunguska to the local picture house where I'll be treating her to a certain romantic film which has been in the news a lot lately and which I know Mrs T will love......American sniper........ Lucky girl.

Ososlo wrote: »

Favourite Irish athlete of all time?

John treacy. He was genuinely brilliant.

Ososlo wrote: »

What do you put your maca powder on/in?

Its nothing exotic I'm afraid, I just throw it into a pint of water and skull it back. Its ferocious stuff though, I really like the taste. But not everyone does, I have a friend who just couldn't hack the stuff and ended up giving bags of the stuff he'd ordered from Peru. Result.

tunguska · 14-02-2015 11:16AM

gerard_65 wrote: »

Did you ever drink alcohol?

My God Ger yes. I was 13 when I first went drinking in a field on halloween night. I had 5 cans of scrumpy jack cider and it blew my head off. I ended up puking in the bath tub when I got home that night. At the height of things I was out boozing friday & saturday nights every week and when it wasnt, it was Thursday, friday and saturday and sometimes it was thursday, friday, saturday & sunday. I drank JD and beer for the most part. Knocked it on the head because I was just done with it, I just didnt feel like drinking anymore thats all it was.

gerard_65 wrote: »

Favorite food?

This is a strange one, but I really love almond butter. I put it on way too many things and overall consume far too much of it to be good for my health.

gerard_65 wrote: »

What makes you laugh out loud?

Im gonna commit sacrilage here and admit I never got Fr. Ted. I was always more of a seinfeld, larry sanders show, kind of person myself. Things that normally crack me up..........mostly unintentional humour, like stuff that was meant to be serious and ends up ridiculous. There was a clip on youtube recently of a road in India which showed some traffic accidents and I was in tears laughing at that. Other people may not have found it funny though

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=588613577922041&pnref=story

And I think The Big Lebowski is the funniest film ever made(that and Robert Altman's MASH)

gerard_65 wrote: »

Apart from Ireland what country would you live in if you had a choice?

Thats a really good question because I was only talking about this with someone recently. Ive always felt like I belong some place else and not here and for whatever reasons, Im drawn to New york. I think me and New york would get along just fine.

gerard_65 wrote: »

Favorite sport (apart from athletics if that is)?

Thats a hard one to answer. Im a sports fanatic and I watch a lot of of different events. I love football obviously, but a lot of the time I find myself weary at the carry on of footballers, theres a dishonesty that has crept into the game which has almost succeeded in turning me off, which I thought would never happen.......I think Rugby is a more pure game. Someone said that Football was a gentlemans game played by thugs and that rugby was a thugs game played by gentlemen, and that kind of sums it up for me. I came across a game of schools Rugby by accident on setanta last sunday, it was St michaels v Clongowes (I think it was the semi finals of the leinster championships) and it was possibly the greatest game of rugger Id ever seen. And that includes senior internationals. It was not only one of the best games of rugger Ive ever seen but it was one of the best spoting spectacles Ive been fortunate enough to witness. It was an aboslute thriller and those lads were amazing athletes, even at such a young age, not just physically though, they all had serious resolve and mental steel. Brilliant.
I love winter sports aswell and Im a massive downhill skiing and ski cross fan. Theyre all lunatics, its such a dangerous sport, I admire their courage and total disregard for their own safety. The women are amazing aswell, their such no nonsense characters whos limbs are literally held together by steel pins. Im kind of in love with Half of them (especially Dominique Gisin) partly for their looks but mostly for their courage.......

gerard_65 wrote: »

Beach or active holiday?

Mix of both Id say. I like to go on adventures and explore new places but If its hot and sunny I like to go swimming and chill out on the beach. My dream holiday is Bora Bora in french polynesia. I even have the place I'll stay picked out:

http://www.stregisborabora.com/

tunguska · 14-02-2015 11:29AM

overpronator wrote: »

Favourite Pink Floyd album?
Watters or Gilmour?

I go through phases where Darkside is my favorite but then a while later it'll be Wish you were here or even Animals. I love the Wall too, but it just was never my favorite, I mean there are some incredible songs on that album but theres some stuff Im not crazy about too(The Vera lynn stuff never did it for me).
Right now Im in an Animals phase, cant stop listening to Dogs. The two solos that bookend the song.......Gilmour magic.

I would be on team Gilmour. He's a proper stand up bloke. He sold his gaff a while ago for 3 million and donated all the money to charity. He's a gentleman and I like his style. Even when he donated that money he kept it quiet and didnt try to draw attention to himself. He's just a classy guy who goes about his business with quiet dignity. One of my favorite songs is his live performance of Hushabye mountain.

Im not anti Roger though, like a lot of people are. I think what he did at the time of the Wall was petty though and the way he treated Rick wright was disgraceful. So I guess he kind of has it coming.

overpronator · 14-02-2015 11:51AM

Great answer, I'd be of a similar mindset to you. Animals would be my favourite followed closely by WYWH. I have a definite soft spot for Meddle too, I've been known to stick Echoes on 4 times one after another on long runs, such an epic tune. The politics of the whole thing is fascinating, Roger was/is a bully and a weaker personality like Rick Wright couldnt handle him. Like you I wouldn't be anti Roger, I think the two of them are infinitely better together than apart, a great balance when it worked. Seeing the Wall at the Aviva last year was a gig ill never forget either even if it was just himself on his own.

tunguska · 14-02-2015 12:16PM

overpronator wrote: »

Great answer, I'd be of a similar mindset to you. Animals would be my favourite followed closely by WYWH. I have a definite soft spot for Meddle too, I've been known to stick Echoes on 4 times one after another on long runs, such an epic tune. The politics of the whole thing is fascinating, Roger was/is a bully and a weaker personality like Rick Wright couldnt handle him. Like you I wouldn't be anti Roger, I think the two of them are infinitely better together than apart, a great balance when it worked. Seeing the Wall at the Aviva last year was a gig ill never forget either even if it was just himself on his own.

I do have a spot for Meddle myself, Echoes is an amazing tune. Some of Gilmours quitar work in that song is off the chart. Insane stuff really when you think about it. When was the last time any band knocked out a 23 minute song? Not even Radiohead(closest thing to modern Floyd) have done something like that. I also have a soft spot for the live in Pompeii gig. Completely bonkers, a live gig, where theres no actual audience(maybe the dead in the ruins of pompeii???). Man that stuff is top class, Saurcerful of secrets is absolutely nuts, I mean a barking mad song but its also genius and seriously brilliant.

AR/tist in the spotlight, this week: Tunguska

Comments