Whose the right person to go to?

Iano_128 · 18-10-2013 4:42pm #1

Not sure if this is in the right thread so mods feel free to move it..

I've been in the gym the last 2 years and have recently been advised by one of the personal trainers in my new gym that my hips are out of alignment. I was wondering is the best person to go to a Chiropractor, Physiotherapist or who would be the right person to deal with this kind of problem?

Thanks for any info anyone can give!

amazingemmet · 18-10-2013 4:45pm

Physiotherapist would be the best to start with.

roseybear · 18-10-2013 4:48pm

Physio or physical therspist, for this either would do.

roseybear · 18-10-2013 4:48pm

Physio or physical therspist, for this either would do.

Iano_128 · 18-10-2013 4:49pm

Great thanks lads! Have a couple more questions... Does anyone know if this is something thats usually resolved in one session or does it take some repeat sessions (probably depends on the severity of it I suppose) and also, is it something that if I get done I can't go to the gym for a couple weeks?

Transform · 18-10-2013 6:32pm

Iano_128 wrote: »

Great thanks lads! Have a couple more questions... Does anyone know if this is something thats usually resolved in one session or does it take some repeat sessions (probably depends on the severity of it I suppose) and also, is it something that if I get done I can't go to the gym for a couple weeks?

go first and they will let you know from there.

Where are you based? Someone can give you a recommendation

Iano_128 · 18-10-2013 6:33pm

Transform wrote: »

go first and they will let you know from there.

Where are you based? Someone can give you a recommendation

Thanks, based in Clondalkin!

ecoli · 19-10-2013 4:18pm

Ken Lawlor is on your doorstep

http://www.kennethlawlor.ie/home.html

Did the same course as myself and has a good reputation (athough haven't personally been treated by him)

In terms of treatment it would depend on the severity of symptoms and the underlying cause so nigh on impossible to accurately assess over the internet (hence the reasoning behind the medical advice rule here)

calfmuscle · 19-10-2013 4:39pm

Just wondering how this affects you?
Saying your hips are out of alignment is very vague. If it aint broke don't fix it.

discus · 19-10-2013 6:34pm

calfmuscle wrote: »

Just wondering how this affects you?
Saying your hips are out of alignment is very vague. If it aint broke don't fix it.

You only notice the difference once it's sorted, tbh.

Iano_128 · 21-10-2013 8:14am

Thanks for all the replies! Well when I stand up straight my body isn't straight.. So it affects me

Also, I've been told it's harder to make progress in the gym with it the way it is because the weight isn't being distributed evenly..

First Up · 21-10-2013 8:23am

If it's a soft tissue problem a physio should sort it fairly fast but if it's skeletal it is a different matter. More likely the former our you would have known about it before if more serious.

Iano_128 · 21-10-2013 8:29am

First Up wrote: »

If it's a soft tissue problem a physio should sort it fairly fast but if it's skeletal it is a different matter. More likely the former our you would have known about it before if more serious.

Well I'd assume its skeletal? I really don't have a clue though, didn't even think such a thing existed 'til the trainer said it to me. I'd noticed for a while that one side of me (shoulders mainly) was a slight bit bigger than the other but assumed I was just training wrong, but when he got me to stand dead straight I could see it.

First Up · 21-10-2013 9:18am

Iano_128 wrote: »

Well I'd assume its skeletal? I really don't have a clue though, didn't even think such a thing existed 'til the trainer said it to me. I'd noticed for a while that one side of me (shoulders mainly) was a slight bit bigger than the other but assumed I was just training wrong, but when he got me to stand dead straight I could see it.

My physio spotted something that sounds very similar and dealt with it in a few sessions. Mine was all a soft tissue thing so hopefully you will be OK. I would definitely see a proper physio, not a physical therapist.

Iano_128 · 21-10-2013 9:40am

First Up wrote: »

My physio spotted something that sounds very similar and dealt with it in a few sessions. Mine was all a soft tissue thing so hopefully you will be OK. I would definitely see a proper physio, not a physical therapist.

Good stuff, hopefully mines the same thing then! Much rather muscular problems then skeletal! Not sure if you train or do any sports or anything but if you do, when you were getting the treatments were you told not to do any gym/sports or was it ok to keep doing things?

First Up · 21-10-2013 9:55am

Iano_128 wrote: »

Good stuff, hopefully mines the same thing then! Much rather muscular problems then skeletal! Not sure if you train or do any sports or anything but if you do, when you were getting the treatments were you told not to do any gym/sports or was it ok to keep doing things?

I do a fair bit. I went to physio because of some lower back stiffness and she spotted the other matter. Not really inter connected - back sorted itself but I laid off sit ups and the like for a week or so. Physio didn't stop me doing anything - just suggested a few new exercises and stretches.
But every case is different so best get a pro to look at you.

Iano_128 · 21-10-2013 9:59am

First Up wrote: »

I do a fair bit. I went to physio because of some lower back stiffness and she spotted the other matter. Not really inter connected - back sorted itself but I laid off sit ups and the like for a week or so. Physio didn't stop me doing anything - just suggested a few new exercises and stretches.
But every case is different so best get a pro to look at you.

Yeah I made an appointment there with a Physio in my area, he's the only chartered one in Clondalkin apparently so said it'd be best to go with him. 1st appointment is just an initial assessment so should know exactly what it is soon enough

dragonkin · 21-10-2013 11:30am

Curious as to what a physio can actually do about something like this... I doubt a bit of stretching and some foam rolling will sort out a misaligned hip which is generally a systematic problem and probably related to some form of incorrect/repetitive movement or bad body awareness etc. I'm pretty skeptical about most physios tho.

Iano_128 · 21-10-2013 11:35am

dragonkin wrote: »

Curious as to what a physio can actually do about something like this... I doubt a bit of stretching and some foam rolling will sort out a misaligned hip which is generally a systematic problem and probably related to some form of incorrect/repetitive movement or bad body awareness etc. I'm pretty skeptical about most physios tho.

I've been told that's more than likely what caused it yeah.. Do you think I'd be better off going to someone else then? Don't know what it is that Physio's do and don't want to waste money finding out they can't help me..

dragonkin · 21-10-2013 12:50pm

Iano_128 wrote: »

I've been told that's more than likely what caused it yeah.. Do you think I'd be better off going to someone else then? Don't know what it is that Physio's do and don't want to waste money finding out they can't help me..

I'm not too sure myself that is why I asked the question my experience with physios is limited but mostly negative. But I am curious as to what kind of service they could provide that might fix this. My experience with dealing with my own issues is that it is mostly in the head and the way we move that the problem lies. We think we are moving correctly but in reality we are not. Alexander technique and somatics are some modalities that deal with this but they are probably a bit 'woo' for some here. All I know is that stretching a muscle but still moving like crap isn't going to fix anything, Kelly Starrett is another person who explains things quite well but I think his solutions can be a bit limited sometimes. The simple reality is that we are not taught how to use our bodies and the environment we grow up in distorts our natural movement patterns, it is extremely difficult to correct this and my own belief is that the approach favoured by many physios which tends to be very localised does not work.

First Up · 21-10-2013 1:03pm

dragonkin wrote: »

I'm not too sure myself that is why I asked the question my experience with physios is limited but mostly negative. But I am curious as to what kind of service they could provide that might fix this. My experience with dealing with my own issues is that it is mostly in the head and the way we move that the problem lies. We think we are moving correctly but in reality we are not. Alexander technique and somatics are some modalities that deal with this but they are probably a bit 'woo' for some here. All I know is that stretching a muscle but still moving like crap isn't going to fix anything, Kelly Starrett is another person who explains things quite well but I think his solutions can be a bit limited sometimes. The simple reality is that we are not taught how to use our bodies and the environment we grow up in distorts our natural movement patterns, it is extremely difficult to correct this and my own belief is that the approach favoured by many physios which tends to be very localised does not work.

All I can say is that I have had excellent results from two different physios (I changed because the first left Dublin.) The first one sorted out some long standing issues that were the legacy of a rugby career among other things. That took a while - best part of a year - but the results were good and the problems have not returned. That physio was big into sports and sports people and really knew her stuff.

The second physio is also sports aware and sorted what sounds a very similar problem to that described in the OP in a couple of sessions. Other than some specific exercises and stretches and advice on posture, she doesn't see the need for anything else.

I have been very impressed with their knowledge and skill and the results are there to see. I'll be happy to recommend mine if the OP wants to PM me.

calfmuscle · 21-10-2013 4:49pm

First Up wrote: »

All I can say is that I have had excellent results from two different physios (I changed because the first left Dublin.) The first one sorted out some long standing issues that were the legacy of a rugby career among other things. That took a while - best part of a year - but the results were good and the problems have not returned. That physio was big into sports and sports people and really knew her stuff.

The second physio is also sports aware and sorted what sounds a very similar problem to that described in the OP in a couple of sessions. Other than some specific exercises and stretches and advice on posture, she doesn't see the need for anything else.

I have been very impressed with their knowledge and skill and the results are there to see. I'll be happy to recommend mine if the OP wants to PM me.

Just out of curiosity who did you go to?

First Up · 21-10-2013 5:03pm

calfmuscle wrote: »

Just out of curiosity who did you go to?

I'll PM you

Whose the right person to go to?

Comments